Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
If a two-state solution is actually desired, I'd suggest an explicit reward/punishment system with both sides involved as a way towards it. Good behavior for some set amount of time moves things towards a true two-state solution in a progressive fashion. Bad behavior incurs punishment, which would vary depending on the nature of the bad behavior, but would be explicitly known and agreed on in advance.
To the extent that either side will agree to a third party's idea of "good behavior", "bad behavior", and "punishment", I'm sure this is substantially similar to every single peace proposal that's been attempted since 1948. You don't think the Camp David Accords spelled out exactly this kind of framework?
 
An example of the real difficulty in getting a workable peace (aka both sides must want peace), the "moderate" Palestinian party:

http://www.cnn.com/2015/01/02/world...?iid=ob_articlefooterexpansion&iref=obnetwork

"The political party of Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas posted a drawn image online showing a large pile of skulls and skeletons with Jewish stars on them.

An Israeli government spokesman called it "despicable."

Along with the image, posted Wednesday to the Facebook page of the Fatah party, are the words "lingering on your skulls.""
 
To the extent that either side will agree to a third party's idea of "good behavior", "bad behavior", and "punishment", I'm sure this is substantially similar to every single peace proposal that's been attempted since 1948. You don't think the Camp David Accords spelled out exactly this kind of framework?

I'm not claiming that it hasn't been tried, just that it's one of the parts that matter quite a bit. Agreeing on what and who ends up where seems to be where the major conflicts arise, either way.
 
Squealing about how Israel is the modern Pol Pot yet aspiring to pull a Pol Pot in Israel doesn't do much for PR
 
Last edited:
And another thing: When did Israel become a demonic entity in popular media/culture? Seriously, it's somehow depicted as an evil on the level of Tamerlane.
 
Where have you been?

It's actually a decent question. When did media representation of Israel start getting more and more negative, exactly, who's doing it most, and why are they doing it are all questions that would likely shed a bit of light on the current situation.
 
It's actually a decent question. When did media representation of Israel start getting more and more negative, exactly, who's doing it most, and why are they doing it are all questions that would likely shed a bit of light on the current situation.

I can't remember a time when Israel wasn't routinely demonized in the world press, including some of Israeli media.
 
I'm not claiming that it hasn't been tried, just that it's one of the parts that matter quite a bit. Agreeing on what and who ends up where seems to be where the major conflicts arise, either way.

Those damn Jews, not agreeing to end up at the bottom of the ocean!
 
Tragically, Hamas considers Gazan blight and suffering to be strategic advantages on the world stage. As it does civilian casualties, particularly children. And the current Israeli administration seems intent on helping them out with that.
 
Hi folks, new in this thread, haven't read anything... just throwing in a bit of trivia:

I have an incognito Facebook account which I use to browse, befriend, debate, disrupt conspiracy theorists. One "friend", who is into pretty much every CT there is (particularly chemtrails, 9/11...) also is very much siding with everything Palestinian and reflexively suspects Israeli involvement in every evil on earth. Some days ago, he posted a video that revealed him as a holocaust denier too. One of his friends chimed in, commenting that there is now a "holocaust" going on against the Palestinians. Now while it can't be disputed that Palestinians die at the hands of Israelis, there is obviously an ocean of difference in order of magnitude between the two, and I suspected that this alleged "holocaust" doesn't show in any significant way on Palestian population statistics.

Found some interesting stats:
Wiki: Demographics of the Palestinian territories

  • The Palestinian territories suffer some 14,000 deaths per year, so military conflicts like those in 2014 (ca. 2,200 killed) and 2008/09 (1,200-1,400 killed) do cause a significant proportion of deaths in a year.
  • BUT still the mortality rate, at about 4 deaths / 1000 people (person-years, to be more precise) is lower than that of Israel (a bit over 5) and only half that of the USA (ca. 8)! Sounds surprising, but is explained by the much younger mean and median age of the population - fewer people die of old age in Palestine because fewer are old.
  • Life expectancy is around 75 years according to the CIA World Factbook - about median in the world. Slightly more than Turkey, Brazil, Jordan; about the same as Hungary, China, Mexico; slightly less than Croatia, Morocco, Ecuador.

Obviously, living conditions leave a lot to be desired, and wars with Israel take a real toll; but the situation isn't out-and-out murderous. "Holocaust" comparisons... yikes!

Said FB-"friend" blocked me after I provided those stats. Apparently, facts are not welcome in anti-semitic circles. ;)
 
Tragically, Hamas considers Gazan blight and suffering to be strategic advantages on the world stage. As it does civilian casualties, particularly children. And the current Israeli administration seems intent on helping them out with that.

And dont' get me started on Bibi's decision to dabble in American Partisan Politics.
Bad Move. A number of foreign leaders have tried that, and it has always backfired .
One of the main tenants of Israeli lobbying in the US is that it was non partisan: Democrat or Republican,Liberal or Conservative, if you supported Israel you got the lobbyist support. Now Bibi has thrown that out. Bad move.
 
Hi folks, new in this thread, haven't read anything... just throwing in a bit of trivia:

I have an incognito Facebook account which I use to browse, befriend, debate, disrupt conspiracy theorists. One "friend", who is into pretty much every CT there is (particularly chemtrails, 9/11...) also is very much siding with everything Palestinian and reflexively suspects Israeli involvement in every evil on earth. Some days ago, he posted a video that revealed him as a holocaust denier too. One of his friends chimed in, commenting that there is now a "holocaust" going on against the Palestinians. Now while it can't be disputed that Palestinians die at the hands of Israelis, there is obviously an ocean of difference in order of magnitude between the two, and I suspected that this alleged "holocaust" doesn't show in any significant way on Palestian population statistics.

Found some interesting stats:
Wiki: Demographics of the Palestinian territories

  • The Palestinian territories suffer some 14,000 deaths per year, so military conflicts like those in 2014 (ca. 2,200 killed) and 2008/09 (1,200-1,400 killed) do cause a significant proportion of deaths in a year.
  • BUT still the mortality rate, at about 4 deaths / 1000 people (person-years, to be more precise) is lower than that of Israel (a bit over 5) and only half that of the USA (ca. 8)! Sounds surprising, but is explained by the much younger mean and median age of the population - fewer people die of old age in Palestine because fewer are old.
  • Life expectancy is around 75 years according to the CIA World Factbook - about median in the world. Slightly more than Turkey, Brazil, Jordan; about the same as Hungary, China, Mexico; slightly less than Croatia, Morocco, Ecuador.

Obviously, living conditions leave a lot to be desired, and wars with Israel take a real toll; but the situation isn't out-and-out murderous. "Holocaust" comparisons... yikes!

Said FB-"friend" blocked me after I provided those stats. Apparently, facts are not welcome in anti-semitic circles. ;)

Emotive terms are common among extremists....not much new with that.

Another tactic is to deny problems by selecting the most extreme description of the problem available and pointing out that it is not correct.


Palestinians are not suffering Genocide and Israel will not be "destroyed" if its arab citizens breed too fast.



rinse and repeat...
 
And dont' get me started on Bibi's decision to dabble in American Partisan Politics.
Bad Move. A number of foreign leaders have tried that, and it has always backfired .
One of the main tenants of Israeli lobbying in the US is that it was non partisan: Democrat or Republican,Liberal or Conservative, if you supported Israel you got the lobbyist support. Now Bibi has thrown that out. Bad move.

If we get started on Netanyahu's bad decisions, it may never end.
 
And dont' get me started on Bibi's decision to dabble in American Partisan Politics.
Bad Move. A number of foreign leaders have tried that, and it has always backfired .
One of the main tenants of Israeli lobbying in the US is that it was non partisan: Democrat or Republican,Liberal or Conservative, if you supported Israel you got the lobbyist support. Now Bibi has thrown that out. Bad move.

And to make matters worse, he has an election in 2 months.
 
Tragically, Hamas considers Gazan blight and suffering to be strategic advantages on the world stage. As it does civilian casualties, particularly children. And the current Israeli administration seems intent on helping them out with that.

Yeah, the production of dead Palestinian children is one of the main sources of funding for the Hamas leadership.

I don't think Hamas's sole purpose is to kill kids for money while repressing the rest of the Palestinians in the areas the control, but it certainly is a large portion of it.

I think that is why I don't find that a large portion of the Palestinian supporters actually care at all about the Palestinians themselves. If they did, the very first thing they would do is address this terrible tactic from Hamas. Instead I find that they just want to demonize Israel to make themselves feel better.
 
A confederated solution?

One such effort by the Israel-Palestine Center for Creative Regional Initiatives (IPCRI) (as mentioned in +972’s initial poll report, full disclosure: I participate in it) has tried to break through some of the non-negotiable elements of Israeli and Palestinian two-state demands. IPCRI’s “Two States One Space,” is similar to another initiative called “Two States, One Land,” with Israelis and Palestinians who have been working together for about two years. Both visions involve two separate entities with distinct national identities, based on rough geographic definitions. There would be open borders, high cooperation, and phased but broad freedom of residence. The idea is to avoid uprooting most Israeli settlers, and accept Palestinian refugee return claims in a way that avoids trampling Jewish identity in Israel. Jerusalem is united but shared.

Maybe. I wonder what the response to these poll questions would be in Gaza and the West bank?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom