Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Those damn Jews are at it again, repressing the Palestinians by... wait for it...it's really bad... oh my...attending a service! Those pesky Jews always looking for trouble:


http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-30092720

Four Israelis have been killed and eight injured as two men armed with a pistol and meat cleavers attacked a West Jerusalem synagogue.
 
Those damn Jews are at it again, repressing the Palestinians by... wait for it...it's really bad... oh my...attending a service! Those pesky Jews always looking for trouble:


http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-30092720

Four Israelis have been killed and eight injured as two men armed with a pistol and meat cleavers attacked a West Jerusalem synagogue.


And some people are passing out candy

according to CNN
 
If the Berlin Wall had been built to counter constant attacks from West Germany, then it might have been a decent PR awareness stunt. As it is, they have no more in common than both being "walls". What a dumb stunt.
They prey on the ignorant. Unfortunately, it works.
 
This time the Palestinian uprising is different: it's happening inside Israel

This uprising, if it is the third intifada, will be fought by Palestinians inside the walls of Israel itself, says David Hearst.


Just a few hundred meters away from al-Aqsa, the crowded and poor Palestinian neighbourhood of Silwan is in the first stages of Judaisation. It is now referred to as the City of David. Just after settlers took over 23 more apartments in Silwan at the end of September, and violent clashes ensued, an advert appeared congratulating the settlers on their Zionist endeavour. "The strengthening of Jewish presence in Jerusalem is our common challenge," went the ad. "With your settlement act, you make us proud."

Who put their names on the front page ad? Nobel Laureate Eli Wiesel; Shlomo Aharonishky, ex-chief of staff of the Israeli Police; and retired general Amos Yadlin, former head of intelligence in the Israeli Defense Forces and a possible contender for the leadership of the Labor Party. As MEE contributor Meron Rapoport noted: "In short, not a bunch of right-wing lunatics, but the flesh and bone of the Israeli establishment."
 
Well, it's been over a month since JJ's last post and longer since there was noteworthy news posted here. On a very, very quick search, I'm not seeing anything since the day JJ posted about the rebuilding effort. Anyone else happen across anything?
 
I for one stopped posting because I grew tired of the quality of the discussion, primarily the constant drive-by posting of news links. I would rather have deep, interesting, naunced discussion. That's what we all learn from.
 
In which case, I'd say that the best way to convince Israel to the table is to point out that the wars for survival are long gone (1973 was over 40 years ago), and that most of the Arab states have learned that a military campaign against you is futile. Also, get to work fixing their electoral system so that minority parties can't sink coalitions.
 
It was humbling to learn that Gaza is not even a quarter of the size of the county I grew up in yet has a population of nearly 2 millions whereas my county has less than 20K.
 
The population would be higher but the leadership feels it necessary to lob rockets at Israel.
 
The population would be higher but the leadership feels it necessary to lob rockets at Israel.

Rather than investing in infrastructure. The actual hostilities themselves don't seem to have much of a demographic impact. The embargo may or may not, but I doubt it.
 
In which case, I'd say that the best way to convince Israel to the table is to point out that the wars for survival are long gone (1973 was over 40 years ago), and that most of the Arab states have learned that a military campaign against you is futile. Also, get to work fixing their electoral system so that minority parties can't sink coalitions.

Yup.
 
I for one stopped posting because I grew tired of the quality of the discussion, primarily the constant drive-by posting of news links. I would rather have deep, interesting, naunced discussion. That's what we all learn from.

I'm new to the party and not sure I have much to add, but I've got what I think is a good question worth discussing (maybe worthy of its own thread?):

One-state or two-state solution? I always hear people arguing about a two-state solution but I've never heard justification as to why. Usually the discussion is about where to draw the borders.

Thoughts, anyone?
 
I'm new to the party and not sure I have much to add, but I've got what I think is a good question worth discussing (maybe worthy of its own thread?):

One-state or two-state solution? I always hear people arguing about a two-state solution but I've never heard justification as to why. Usually the discussion is about where to draw the borders.

Thoughts, anyone?

By "one state solution" are you referring to annexations?

I could not support annexation because it would impose enforced citizenship of a non democratic state. I would not be a supporter of black people being made citizens of a state that defines inself as the home of white people either.
 
I'm new to the party and not sure I have much to add, but I've got what I think is a good question worth discussing (maybe worthy of its own thread?):

One-state or two-state solution? I always hear people arguing about a two-state solution but I've never heard justification as to why. Usually the discussion is about where to draw the borders.

Thoughts, anyone?

Well... The bit of an assessment here is -

One-state: Much of the Jewish part of Israel opposes this, given that they would effectively lose their Jewish state to the much larger number of Arabs. Incidentally, the Arabs have frequently been proponents of this for the exact same reason and an Arab-dominated one-state solution has been the obvious end goal of more than a few of their proposals.

Two-state: Much of the Arab population of the area oppose this as a final state, but would be happy to accept it as a stepping stone towards their final goal of a one-state solution. They frequently don't do much to mask that, which makes the Jewish population rather wary of actually going through with it, though they have tried to make large gestures to at least test the waters. Gaza, for example. Gaza is internally under Arab control, with Israel having refused to give up the safeguards it has in place because of the open aggression that the Arabs have continuously shown in various ways. Israel would likely be willing to give up those safeguards eventually, if the Arabs finally showed a long-term commitment to playing nice, but there are a lot of factors interfering with that, not least being Israel's own misdeeds, regardless of whether most of the current misdeeds have their direct roots in Arab misdeeds.

One state is, frankly, as good as off the table as a reasonable solution, unless you want Israel to fail at the reason why it exists in the first place. A true two state isn't completely off, but simply isn't very workable with the level of hostility present.
 
Last edited:
By "one state solution" are you referring to annexations?

I could not support annexation because it would impose enforced citizenship of a non democratic state. I would not be a supporter of black people being made citizens of a state that defines inself as the home of white people either.
I mean a shared state including all of the land by all of the people. I see the concern, now.
Well... The bit of an assessment here is -

One-state: Much of the Jewish part of Israel opposes this, given that they would effectively lose their Jewish state to the much larger number of Arabs. Incidentally, the Arabs have frequently been proponents of this for the exact same reason and an Arab-dominated one-state solution has been the obvious end goal of more than a few of their proposals.

Two-state: Much of the Arab population of the area oppose this as a final state, but would be happy to accept it as a stepping stone towards their final goal of a one-state solution. They frequently don't do much to mask that, which makes the Jewish population rather wary of actually going through with it, though they have tried to make large gestures to at least test the waters. Gaza, for example. Gaza is internally under Arab control, with Israel having refused to give up the safeguards it has in place because of the open aggression that the Arabs have continuously shown in various ways. Israel would likely be willing to give up those safeguards eventually, if the Arabs finally showed a long-term commitment to playing nice, but there are a lot of factors interfering with that, not least being Israel's own misdeeds, regardless of whether most of the current misdeeds have their direct roots in Arab misdeeds.

One state is, frankly, as good as off the table as a reasonable solution, unless you want Israel to fail at the reason why it exists in the first place. A true two state isn't completely off, but simply isn't very workable with the level of hostility present.

Hm

I wonder if there could be a system that is representative or that takes awhile (like one generation - step by step) to alleviate some of those worries and issues. I guess that would have to be more dictatorial than democratic, though, which I don't think I could be in favor of
 
One-state or two-state solution? I always hear people arguing about a two-state solution but I've never heard justification as to why. Usually the discussion is about where to draw the borders.

Thoughts, anyone?

Why would the people and government of Zionist Israel agree to the complete surrender of every thing they've fought for for 70 years?
 
Why would the people and government of Zionist Israel agree to the complete surrender of every thing they've fought for for 70 years?

I guess I see it differently as it not being "surrender" (imo a kind of compromise) but *shrug* I don't know a great deal about the topic
 
I mean a shared state including all of the land by all of the people. I see the concern, now.


Hm

I wonder if there could be a system that is representative or that takes awhile (like one generation - step by step) to alleviate some of those worries and issues. I guess that would have to be more dictatorial than democratic, though, which I don't think I could be in favor of

If a two-state solution is actually desired, I'd suggest an explicit reward/punishment system with both sides involved as a way towards it. Good behavior for some set amount of time moves things towards a true two-state solution in a progressive fashion. Bad behavior incurs punishment, which would vary depending on the nature of the bad behavior, but would be explicitly known and agreed on in advance.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom