Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
:rolleyes:


You can't even let the outrageous claims of "counterpunch" stand; you have to embellish them? Your spam sucks.

ETA - "The cold and wet of winter are approaching" -- In Gaza, the cold and wet are what, 50 or 60 degrees? Give me a break.
God, that person is trying to make the approaching winter in Gaza seem like the approaching Winter in Westros....
 
Where else in the world apart from the Palestinian territories would the international community stand by idly as so many people suffer
:violin:

The Palestinians receive far, far, far more attention and humanitarian aid than you would expect for a people their size, and in their situation. There are so many other people in the world who have it far worse, and yet are just about completely ignored.

Sometimes I wonder if we're even on the same planet.

ETA:
"
Palestine Human Development Report (2004), 113. According to certain analyses, Palestinians are the largest per capita recipients of international development assistance in the world (Lasensky [2004])".
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_aid_to_Palestinians

So... according to JJ, giving the Palestinians more aid per capita than any other nationality on Earth is "standing idly by".
ETA2: plus media attention, boycotts, trendy youth movements, attention from high-level politicians, and the list goes on.
Again, are we even discussing the same conflict?
 
Last edited:
So... according to JJ,

Does just spamming biased articles like that even qualify as that? Doing so just makes me less sympathetic to the Palestinian cause, regardless, even if I do keep reminding myself that JihadJane is almost certainly trolling for the Jews to counter that.

Again, are we even discussing the same conflict?

It's all about the PR, apparently.
 
Then shouldn't the headline be Palestinian Militants Accused of War Crimes by Amnesty International?
 
Hamas fires rockets at Israeli civilians, and as a result, Israel loses credibility?

It goes both ways

This certainly is not a form of "defense"

_67255958_009839494-1.jpg

article-1105127-02F27F36000005DC-677_468x286.jpg

1788214-5.jpg


Such munitions are designed to wreak as much havoc and destruction as possible, without any regard to civilian life even after a conflict is over. Back when Israel was hit with multiple suicide bomb incidents (which also wreak havoc without regard to civilian life), such actions were rightfully condemned. Israel is accountable to the same standard.

If Israel gave a **** to distinguish militants from civilians, they would use coordinated munitions (air/artillery). Instead, during Operation Cast Lead and subsequent strikes before and after, they've used munitions like that which blatantly disregard anything in their path to maximize damage (including a UN building that was burned down as a result).
 

Yeah. That reminded me of an article repeatedly referred to by a friend that apparently made a big deal out of something like two Republicans convicted of corruption, and had a one liner about around 12 Democrats also being convicted of corruption. No spin there at all.
 
It goes both ways

This certainly is not a form of "defense"

[qimg]http://news.bbcimg.co.uk/media/images/67255000/jpg/_67255958_009839494-1.jpg[/qimg]
[qimg]http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/01/04/article-1105127-02F27F36000005DC-677_468x286.jpg[/qimg]
[qimg]http://msc.wcdn.co.il/w/w-635/1788214-5.jpg[/qimg]

Such munitions are designed to wreak as much havoc and destruction as possible, without any regard to civilian life even after a conflict is over. Back when Israel was hit with multiple suicide bomb incidents (which also wreak havoc without regard to civilian life), such actions were rightfully condemned. Israel is accountable to the same standard.

If Israel gave a **** to distinguish militants from civilians, they would use coordinated munitions (air/artillery). Instead, during Operation Cast Lead and subsequent strikes before and after, they've used munitions like that which blatantly disregard anything in their path to maximize damage (including a UN building that was burned down as a result).

I agree. The tactic is tit for tat, and it ends up supplying Hamas with exactly what it wants... maximal Palestinian civilian deaths, particularly children. The primary utility of launching missiles from Gaza is to provoke massive retaliation in order to produce horrible images of Palestinian children suffering and dying.
 
It goes both ways

This certainly is not a form of "defense"

[qimg]http://news.bbcimg.co.uk/media/images/67255000/jpg/_67255958_009839494-1.jpg[/qimg]
[qimg]http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/01/04/article-1105127-02F27F36000005DC-677_468x286.jpg[/qimg]
[qimg]http://msc.wcdn.co.il/w/w-635/1788214-5.jpg[/qimg]

Such munitions are designed to wreak as much havoc and destruction as possible, without any regard to civilian life even after a conflict is over. Back when Israel was hit with multiple suicide bomb incidents (which also wreak havoc without regard to civilian life), such actions were rightfully condemned. Israel is accountable to the same standard.

If Israel gave a **** to distinguish militants from civilians, they would use coordinated munitions (air/artillery). Instead, during Operation Cast Lead and subsequent strikes before and after, they've used munitions like that which blatantly disregard anything in their path to maximize damage (including a UN building that was burned down as a result).
Why mix in that last picture which was from Lebanon?

Israel does use coordinated air/artillery. GPS guided munitions are also on the horizon, just like the US's Paladin system. IDF/IAF strikes against urban military targets are not akin to suicide bombers strikes. That's a fallacy within itself.

First couple of pictures are phosphorus airburst munitions primarily used to cover friendly troop movements and/or blind enemy troops. These are not used to 'maximize damage' as you've stated. The Goldstone report did not find anything illegal of its use and its application during the previous Gaza war. No reason for it to be illegal now. A few dramatic pictures of its use and a burned down building that might have resulted in the use of these munitions doesn't make it illegal either.
 
Last edited:
By the look of it, they were going to significant lengths to get their military forces to be passed off as civilians, for that matter.

No question, that's SOP. But the most effective result, from the Hamas pov, is graphic images of Palestinian children being torn apart by Israeli weapons. Which is one of the reasons they use child labor in tunnel construction (along with their ability to work in small spaces.)
 
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/w...-berlin-wall-9849899.html?cmpid=facebook-post

Palestinians knocked a hole into a wall yesterday ahead of the 25th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall to remind the world of their struggles.

A group of Palestinian activists armed with sledgehammers smashed a hole in the brick barrier that crosses the West Bank village of Bir Nabala situated between Jerusalem and Ramallah amid tight Israeli security.

"It doesn't matter how high the barriers will be, they will fall. Like the Berlin Wall fell - The Palestinian wall will fall," the Palestinian activists who organised the event wrote in a statement according to Al Jazeera via the Palestinian Ma'an News Agency.

In footage filmed by Palestinian TV, the activists said that the aim was to show that Israel's barrier will not prevent them from reaching Jerusalem and the al-Aqsa mosque, which is considered to be one of the holiest in Islam.
 
This certainly is not a form of "defense"

What, exactly, is "this", and why is it not a valid form of defense? Your pictures do not in fact speak for themselves.


I'm at a loss as to why you think these pictures are worse than conventional munitions.


It took me a while to find a link that actually describes what's in the picture. Is it in Palestinian territory? No, it is not.

Such munitions are designed to wreak as much havoc and destruction as possible, without any regard to civilian life even after a conflict is over.

The first two pictures are white phosphorus shells. They are not designed "to wreak as much havoc and destruction as possible". Your pictures don't show them causing any more havoc and destruction than ordinary munitions, or for that matter even as much havoc and destruction. What those shells are designed for, and what Israel used them for, is to create smokescreens, something conventional munitions do not do nearly as well.

Your last picture is of something else entirely, and wasn't even involved with the Israel-Palestinian conflict.

Nice try, but ultimately a fail.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom