Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
By the way, did anyone ever figure out exactly who killed the teenagers and whether they were acting on orders from Hamas? My understanding, last I heard was that the leader of Hamas denied responsibility, but at the same time did not condemn the attack but instead indicated his approval of it.


Yes, their corpses were found on property of those who were the main suspects from the beginning: Marwan Qawasmeh and Amer Abu Eishe. Members of the Hebron-based Qawasmeh clan, affiliated with Hamas but known for acting on their own/against Hamas "party line". Their houses were raided and destroyed in the very beginning. I don't know if they were actually arrested or if they are still on the run.

You can find the details in this extremely important article I have linked already a couple of times. Notice the date. And the main point: Netanyahoo and his criminal friends knew the whole time they were mass-raiding "searching for the kids" that they were almost certainly dead, and who murdered them.

Max Blumenthal said:
From the moment three Israeli teens were reported missing last month, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and the country’s military-intelligence apparatus suppressed the flow of information to the general public. Through a toxic blend of propaganda, subterfuge and incitement, they inflamed a precarious situation, manipulating Israelis into supporting their agenda until they made an utterly avoidable nightmare inevitable.

Israeli police, intelligence officials and Netanyahu knew within hours of the kidnapping and murder of the three teens that they had been killed. And they knew who the prime suspects were less than a day after the kidnapping was reported.

Rather than reveal these details to the public, Israel’s Shin Bet intelligence agency imposed a gag order on the national media, barring news outlets from reporting that the teens had almost certainly been killed, and forbidding them from revealing the identities of their suspected killers. The Shin Bet even lied to the parents of the kidnapped teens, deceiving them into believing their sons were alive.

Instead of mounting a limited action to capture the suspected perpetrators and retrieve the teens’ bodies, Netanyahu staged an aggressive international public relations campaign, demanding sympathy and outrage from world leaders, who were also given the impression that the missing teens were still alive. [...]


Make sure to read the full article.
 
Last edited:
Bully! Now that a drug addled old rock star is on the case, how can a complete resolution not be far away?
 
Still seeing no evidence of isralis partying around thousands of impaled Palestinians or pyramids of skulls where Gaza used to stand.

Neither of which are needed for genocide to have happened. Of more importance is the lack of evidence that the Israelis were trying to destroy a racial, ethnic, religious, or national group in whole or in part. They were certainly trying to destroy in whole or in part a political group that's been formally classified as a terrorist group, yes, as well as responding to military attacks that were based in civilian areas and attacking military targets that were hidden in civilian areas with the intent of using the presence of civilians as deterrents. Neither of these count as acts of genocide, which rather destroys the case that the Israel haters want to make. There may be a case or two on a very small scale that individual or relatively small groups of Israeli soldiers could be accused of genocide, but that's immensely weaker than the claims that the Israel haters have kept making. Frankly, Hamas should be under a lot of scrutiny for whether it committed genocide against the Palestinians, too, if that's the level of the claim.

Going further, that a trial run by an organization that I've never heard of before is likely to happen in the future is not evidence, in itself, that genocide did occur, regardless of how much JihadJane seems to wish otherwise. If it rules that the Israelis were committing genocide, the reasoning for why may be worth looking at, though.

Taking a look at the description, though, suggests fairly strongly that it's a kangaroo court. Looking further, it looks like it has a history of being that.
 
Last edited:
My point about impalement and skull pyramids was about how Israel would have to be actively malicious to commit genocide.
 
My point about impalement and skull pyramids was about how Israel would have to be actively malicious to commit genocide.

And part of mine was that hyperbole doesn't really help any side in this, especially given how easily a lot of people have taken a break from being at all objective.
 
And part of mine was that hyperbole doesn't really help any side in this, especially given how easily a lot of people have taken a break from being at all objective.

Not hyperbole as much as satire.
 
Neither of which are needed for genocide to have happened. Of more importance is the lack of evidence that the Israelis were trying to destroy a racial, ethnic, religious, or national group in whole or in part. They were certainly trying to destroy in whole or in part a political group that's been formally classified as a terrorist group, yes, as well as responding to military attacks that were based in civilian areas and attacking military targets that were hidden in civilian areas with the intent of using the presence of civilians as deterrents. Neither of these count as acts of genocide, which rather destroys the case that the Israel haters want to make. There may be a case or two on a very small scale that individual or relatively small groups of Israeli soldiers could be accused of genocide, but that's immensely weaker than the claims that the Israel haters have kept making. Frankly, Hamas should be under a lot of scrutiny for whether it committed genocide against the Palestinians, too, if that's the level of the claim.

Going further, that a trial run by an organization that I've never heard of before is likely to happen in the future is not evidence, in itself, that genocide did occur, regardless of how much JihadJane seems to wish otherwise. If it rules that the Israelis were committing genocide, the reasoning for why may be worth looking at, though.

Taking a look at the description, though, suggests fairly strongly that it's a kangaroo court. Looking further, it looks like it has a history of being that.
How small a part constitutes genocide and who makes the decision?
 
How small a part constitutes genocide and who makes the decision?

That's actually one of the questions that doesn't have a clear answer yet, apparently. To take from the relevant wikipedia article,

The phrase "in whole or in part" has been subject to much discussion by scholars of international humanitarian law.[2] The International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia found in Prosecutor v. Radislav Krstic – Trial Chamber I – Judgment – IT-98-33 (2001) ICTY8 (2 August 2001)[27] that Genocide had been committed. In Prosecutor v. Radislav Krstic – Appeals Chamber – Judgment – IT-98-33 (2004) ICTY 7 (19 April 2004)[28] paragraphs 8, 9, 10, and 11 addressed the issue of in part and found that "the part must be a substantial part of that group. The aim of the Genocide Convention is to prevent the intentional destruction of entire human groups, and the part targeted must be significant enough to have an impact on the group as a whole." The Appeals Chamber goes into details of other cases and the opinions of respected commentators on the Genocide Convention to explain how they came to this conclusion.

The judges continue in paragraph 12, "The determination of when the targeted part is substantial enough to meet this requirement may involve a number of considerations. The numeric size of the targeted part of the group is the necessary and important starting point, though not in all cases the ending point of the inquiry. The number of individuals targeted should be evaluated not only in absolute terms, but also in relation to the overall size of the entire group. In addition to the numeric size of the targeted portion, its prominence within the group can be a useful consideration. If a specific part of the group is emblematic of the overall group, or is essential to its survival, that may support a finding that the part qualifies as substantial within the meaning of Article 4 [of the Tribunal's Statute]."[29][30]

In paragraph 13 the judges raise the issue of the perpetrators' access to the victims: "The historical examples of genocide also suggest that the area of the perpetrators’ activity and control, as well as the possible extent of their reach, should be considered. ... The intent to destroy formed by a perpetrator of genocide will always be limited by the opportunity presented to him. While this factor alone will not indicate whether the targeted group is substantial, it can—in combination with other factors—inform the analysis."[28]

As it stands, if one just takes the intent to destroy compared to how much they take advantage of the opportunities presented to them, Hamas very likely is guilty of genocide, while Israel notably is not, for example. Israel's removed nearly all opportunity, though, so because of raw numbers, it's a bit pointless to prosecute Hamas for genocide.
 
Last edited:
Message of support from Eve Ensler
On September 15, 2014:



For the Russell Tribunal

"This a wail, a scream on paper. There are no more words. Only this moment where we rise against the illegal and deathly occupation of Palestine, against mass slaughter of the defenseless, against the complicit silence of the international community, against the military might and arrogance of the Israeli and the U.S. governments who choose annihilation over justice and love."

Eve Ensler

http://www.russelltribunalonpalestine.com/en/4246/message-of-support-from-eve-ensler
 
Message of support from Eve Ensler
On September 15, 2014:



For the Russell Tribunal

"This a wail, a scream on paper. There are no more words. Only this moment where we rise against the illegal and deathly occupation of Palestine, against mass slaughter of the defenseless, against the complicit silence of the international community, against the military might and arrogance of the Israeli and the U.S. governments who choose annihilation over justice and love."

Eve Ensler

http://www.russelltribunalonpalestine.com/en/4246/message-of-support-from-eve-ensler

How does this support your cause? Seems she's quite aware that it's a kangaroo court, by the sound of it, and makes it fairly clear that she's laboring under numerous misconceptions, to be very kind.

Well, it's probably quite safe to conclude that you're a secret Hasbara shill, trying to discredit Israel's critics, now. It's either that, or some quite unflattering things about you, yourself, at least.
 
Message of support from Eve Ensler
On September 15, 2014:



For the Russell Tribunal

"This a wail, a scream on paper. There are no more words. Only this moment where we rise against the illegal and deathly occupation of Palestine, against mass slaughter of the defenseless, against the complicit silence of the international community, against the military might and arrogance of the Israeli and the U.S. governments who choose annihilation over justice and love."

Eve Ensler

http://www.russelltribunalonpalestine.com/en/4246/message-of-support-from-eve-ensler

Compared to what the Spanish did in the New World (Benchmark for causing an outright apocalypse), there wasn't anything resembling "annihilation" or "mass slaughter" in Gaza. And "Justice" is in the eye of the beholder.
 
Message of support from Eve Ensler
On September 15, 2014:



For the Russell Tribunal

"This a wail, a scream on paper. There are no more words. Only this moment where we rise against the illegal and deathly occupation of Palestine, against mass slaughter of the defenseless, against the complicit silence of the international community, against the military might and arrogance of the Israeli and the U.S. governments who choose annihilation over justice and love."

Eve Ensler

http://www.russelltribunalonpalestine.com/en/4246/message-of-support-from-eve-ensler


And who is Eve Ensler?

A playwright.

Establishing I was correct when I called it theatre.
 
Hamas arrests Palestinians who launched rocket from Gaza

Hamas authorities in the Gaza Strip arrested the militants who launched a rocket at southern Israel on Tuesday evening, Israel Radio quoted a senior defense official as saying.

Israel made clear to Hamas that if it did not take swift action against those responsible for firing the rocket, the IDF would need to take action, according to Israel Radio.

Hamas told mediators that it was interested in preserving the cease-fire and that it apprehended those responsible for the rocket.

An important step in the right direction. Perhaps Israel has achieved a significant goal here. At least Hamas seems to have realized the futility of rocket attacks. I doubt they are reformed but maybe they are finally beginning to realize that there is no military solution to their predicament.
 
Hamas arrests Palestinians who launched rocket from Gaza



An important step in the right direction. Perhaps Israel has achieved a significant goal here. At least Hamas seems to have realized the futility of rocket attacks. I doubt they are reformed but maybe they are finally beginning to realize that there is no military solution to their predicament.

While it is good to hear, I don't think that it's huge in the way of news. Hamas, other than the recent conflict, has been greatly suppressing the number of rockets fired at Israel for a few years now, which is a fact that shouldn't be forgotten. It's unlikely that their real motives are particularly noble, frankly, but results matter, quite a bit. Either way, at the moment, it would be very, very obviously against their interests for them to break the ceasefire, politically, militarily, economically, and so on.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom