Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I mentioned civilians and civilian infrastructure because, as a way of denying that it was committing genocide, you tried to pretend that Israel was only targeting Hamas, apparently hoping that emotional outrage over terrorism would deflect attention from Israel's long-term, genocidal ambitions.

Heh. Emotional outrage has nothing to do with the positions that I've put forth, and has been extremely evident in your arguments. Projection will get you nowhere. As it stands, I've repeatedly pointed agreed that Israel likely committed war crimes in their attack on Gaza, just that "genocide" is not really in evidence as one of them in the recent conflict. As for "long-term, genocidal ambitions," that would have been much more supportable if you had tried to argue that in 1947. Yes, 1947. Since then, it's become increasingly untenable.

So, why are you so emotionally fixated on "genocide" to the point where you're trying to draw attention away from what crimes Israel likely did commit? You're a secret Hasbara shill trying to make everyone think that those who have problems with Israel's conduct are crazy people without a real case, right?:rolleyes:

From its inception to the present, Israel has been a rogue, terrorist state, occupying another people's land.

Not according to nearly every other country in the world. This description is incredibly inaccurate, on every level, though. Exactly the kind of thing that a secret Hasbara shill trying to make everyone think that those who have problems with Israel's conduct are crazy people without a real case would say.
 
2139 killed (0,15% of population) in 50 days is brutal bombardment? Gazan population grows by about 38 thousand people a year. The "brutal bombardment" is 40% of their population growth.

I'm not sure how you would describe an actual brutal bombardment that kills tens of thousands within hours.

McHrozni

To clarify for him, that's about 40% of the population growth during the bombing itself. Once again, Israel was doing an incredibly pathetic job of it if they were actually trying to reduce the number of people in Gaza.
 
Not true, unfortunately.



2014 Gaza war by numbers:

Palestinians killed: 2,139Palestinian children killed: 490Israeli soldiers killed: 64
Israeli civilians killed: 6
Israeli children killed: 1
Palestinians wounded: 11,000
Palestinian children wounded: 3,000
Gaza residents displaced: Up to 500,000
Homes destroyed in Gaza: 20,000

Source: UN
Would you be kind enough to post a UN source, other than:
Palestinian health officials say 2,139 people, most of them civilians, including more than 490 children, have been killed in Gaza since Israel launched Operation Protective Edge on 8 July.
 
Who has been successful?



As with South African apartheid, hope lies with global solidarity and action.

Let_8bea3c_1486839.gif


Israel isn't Apartheid South Africa, not by a long stretch. Besides, people will forget about it within a week anyway.
 
There are no other sources. The only source for that total is Hamas itself.

I don't think that I've heard of Israel challenging the base Palestinian killed numbers, though. What has been challenged is how many of those deaths were noncombatants. A Palestinian pointing a gun at Israelis is a combatant, frankly, regardless of gender or age, for example. At last check, they were claiming that roughly half the Palestinians who have died were definitely combatants, for example.
 
Last edited:
I don't think that I've heard of Israel challenging the base Palestinian killed numbers, though. What has been challenged is how many of those deaths were noncombatants. A Palestinian pointing a gun at Israelis is a combatant, frankly, regardless of gender or age, for example. At last check, they were claiming that roughly half the Palestinians who have died were definitely combatants, for example.

So Hamas claims are (rightfully) subjected to scrutiny but Israeli claims are taken at face value.
 
So Hamas claims are (rightfully) subjected to scrutiny but Israeli claims are taken at face value.

More specifically, the Israelis are the one with the most vested interest in disputing the number of dead Palestinians and were in the best position to keep track of the numbers independent of the Palestinians. If they and the Palestinians working for the UN agree with the number of Palestinians dead, there's not much reason to simply dismiss that number without being about to back up the dismissal solidly.

Of more interest to anyone with even a little bit of impartiality is how many non-combatants died and why they died. Frankly, Israel deserves no condemnation for destroying or killing military targets in response to military actions taken against Israeli citizens. Under more civilized circumstances, Israel would deserve the full brunt of the blame and condemnation for the dead noncombatants and destroyed civilian property. However, given Hamas' systematic violations of the laws of war that put them in danger in the first place, it's much more difficult to determine where the condemnation should go. Unfortunately for the haters of Israel, the default is Hamas, in this case, because of their tactics. Either way, as I've also noted repeatedly before, I have little doubt that Israel did commit war crimes and is feeding some extent of disinformation to the rest of the world. So, no, taken in context, Israeli claims should not just be taken at face value. When they're pointing towards the actually important issues, rather than at something of a red herring, however, they're well worth pointing out.
 
Last edited:
2139 killed (0,15% of population) in 50 days is brutal bombardment? Gazan population grows by about 38 thousand people a year. The "brutal bombardment" is 40% of their population growth.

I'm not sure how you would describe an actual brutal bombardment that kills tens of thousands within hours.

McHrozni

2139/38000 = .056289.

To clarify for him, that's about 40% of the population growth during the bombing itself. Once again, Israel was doing an incredibly pathetic job of it if they were actually trying to reduce the number of people in Gaza.

Oh, then it's...

(50/365) x 38000 = 5205.47

2139/5205 = 41%

Okay, now I follow it.

/math nerd
 
I mentioned civilians and civilian infrastructure because, as a way of denying that it was committing genocide, you tried to pretend that Israel was only targeting Hamas, apparently hoping that emotional outrage over terrorism would deflect attention from Israel's long-term, genocidal ambitions.

This is ironic, chiding Aridas for relying on "emotional outrage" when it's you who's desperately trying to generate emotional outrage by rationalizing using the word "genocide" and quoting websites that call Israel "barbaric". Compared to you, Aridas has been positively vulcanesque in avoiding emotionalism.

The anti-Israel arguments depend heavily on changing word definitions. "Genocide" is no longer attempting to exterminate a population, but now it's whatever it needs to be to accused Israel of doing it. Same with "occupation", "refugee", "piracy" and many other terms.

To the people who haven't drunk your kool-aid, the attempted deceptions are both obvious and pathetic. There are always the kooks who will nod their heads to anything you accuse the evil "zionists" of doing, but they're the same ones who spray vinegar in the air to protect themselves from "chemtrails" and swallow colloidal silver to prevent a common cold.
 
The anti-Israel arguments depend heavily on changing word definitions. "Genocide" is no longer attempting to exterminate a population, but now it's whatever it needs to be to accused Israel of doing it. Same with "occupation", "refugee", "piracy" and many other terms.

"Genocide" is now defined as whatever current Israeli policy happens to be.

"Resistance" is now defined as whatever current Hamas policy happens to be.
 
This is ironic, chiding Aridas for relying on "emotional outrage" when it's you who's desperately trying to generate emotional outrage by rationalizing using the word "genocide" and quoting websites that call Israel "barbaric". Compared to you, Aridas has been positively vulcanesque in avoiding emotionalism.

Thank you.

The anti-Israel arguments depend heavily on changing word definitions.

Frequently not, though. Ignorance, willful and otherwise, has been a much larger issue with the anti-Israel arguments in this thread. This is not to detract from the valid criticisms of Israeli doings, of course, but it's sad when, like with 9/11, the real issues receive so much less attention than the conspiracy theories and the like.
 
Israel's "precision" strikes:

See for yourself: Aerial and panoramic views show devastation in Gaza

http://electronicintifada.net/blogs...ial-and-panoramic-views-show-devastation-gaza

Wow, that's awful. That really puts things in perspective.

All that human suffering just because Hamas wouldn't honor agreements Fatah previously made with Israel, diverts precious resources to build even more rockets, and uses building materials to build hardened bunkers and tunnels to protect high ranking Hamas members and to kidnap Israelis rather than building preciously needed infrastructure.

To my mind, Hamas has 1.8 million very good reasons to make peace with Israel. It's a pity you don't put the same value on those human lives; that you're okay with keeping them in suffering because you would rather Hamas win their war, even if it takes decades or even generations longer, than to compromise and let their people live in peace and get on with their lives.
 
Last edited:
Glad that the disgusting massacre is over for now, in addition to the obvious reasons because I had decided to not change my signature before it ends, and got a bit tired of it already. For posterity here, if you didn't check it out, it's good stuff. The film is a must-watch.

If Americans knew | Occupation 101
 
Last edited:
Seems the latest round of this conflict has reached at least a temporary lull as both sides count their losses.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/israel...efire-holds-both-sides-mull-who-won-1.2749270

Who "won"? Hard to say. Hamas is still there, but most or many of their tunnels were destroyed and their supply of rockets depleted. Nonetheless, they claim they won.

Casualties according to Wikipedia were, on the Israel side, 66 soldiers and 6 civilians dead, 450 soldiers and 80 civilians wounded. On the Gaza side there are various estimates around 2,100 dead, 70% of those civilians according to the Gaza Health Ministry and 11,000 wounded. The IDF estimates that 1000 of those killed were militants, so about half. Also 250 were captured.

The cost in money for Israel is about $2.5 billion. For Gaza the damage is estimated at around $4-6 billion and rebuilding may take 20 years.

Just yesterday Israel announced they would appropriate some more land in the West Bank:
U.S.: Israel's West Bank land grab 'counterproductive' to two-state solution

The United States sees Israel's announcement on Sunday of a land appropriation for possible settlement construction in the West Bank as "counterproductive" to peace efforts and urges the Israeli government to reverse the decision, a State Department official said.

Israel’s Civil Administration in the West Bank announced the takeover of 988 acres (3,799 dunams) belonging to five Palestinian villages between the Etzion settlement bloc and Jerusalem. The move clears the way for construction of a new settlement named Gvaot.

The announcement follows the cabinet’s decision last week to take over the land in response to the June kidnapping and killing of three teenage Jewish boys by Hamas militants in the area.
 
Last edited:
Btw, for perspective the GDP of Israel is about $250 billion while that of the Palestinian Territories is about $10 billion, again according to Wikipedia. So the cost to Israel was about 1$ of GDP and that for Gaza is about 60% of the the entire Palestinian GDP. I'm guessing that other countries probably including the US will foot the bill for rebuilding Gaza. Maybe even Israel itself will pitch in?
 
Who "won"?


Those with genocidal intentions won. More important than the next "land grab" in West Bank you mentioned is this:

Dennis Kuchinich said:
[...] There is a land grab going on. The Israeli prime minister, Binjamin Netanyahu, has shrunk Gaza’s habitable land mass by 44%, with an edict establishing a 3km (1.8-mile) buffer zone, a “no-go” zone for Palestinians – and that’s quite significant, because a good part of Gaza is only 3 to 4 miles wide. Over 250,000 Palestinians within this zone must leave their homes, or be bombed. As their territorial space collapses, 1.8m Gazans now living in 147 square miles will be compressed into 82 square miles.

Gaza’s entire social and physical infrastructure of housing, hospitals, places of worship, more than 130 of its schools, plus markets, water systems, sewer systems and roads are being destroyed. Under constant attack, without access to water, sanitary facilities, food and medical care, Gazans face an IDF-scripted apocalypse.

With Gaza’s land mass shrinking due to Israeli military action, it’s about time someone asked: What is the end game? Three weeks ago, Moshe Feiglin, deputy speaker of the Knesset, called for Gaza to “become part of sovereign Israel and will be populated by Jews. This will also serve to ease the housing crisis in Israel.”

Israel has a housing crisis? After the “no-go” buffer zone is evacuated, there will be 21,951 Palestinians per square mile in Gaza, while Israel’s population density stands at 964 persons per square mile.

Deputy Speaker Feiglin wants the Palestinians in Gaza to lose all of their land. One must not assume that Mr Feiglin or his Likud faction speak for the main government actors like Prime Minister Netanyahu. After all, Knesset politics are complex and divergent. But since Gaza has just lost control of that 44% of its land, it may also be time to ask: does the establishment of that 3km zone represent the unfolding of a larger plan? Is that the end game? [...]


Talking about driving someone into the sea...
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom