Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
This article (sorry for the mobile link) mentions a "buffer zone" but it has been reduced to 300 feet (100 meters) from 1000 feet it seems. Not 3 kilometers.

http://mobile.businessweek.com/news/2014-08-28/gaza-gets-foreign-aid-israel-widens-buffer-amid-truce


Kucinich's article is from August 5. I found it googling for the 44% number I have heard from other sources. In his article he sources the claim with this link to the Washington Post, which illustrates what he claims.

If this has been temporary and now lifted or eased, that would be great, but frankly I doubt it given their habit of sticking to what they have grabbed. And your article cites "witnesses in Eastern Gaza" as source.
 
"Genocide" is now defined as whatever current Israeli policy happens to be.

"Resistance" is now defined as whatever current Hamas policy happens to be.
I see the last one especially often; terror attacks, murders and kidnappings of civilians is "fighting" and "resistance". The mind boggles.
 
Israeli hospitals treat critical Gazan and West Bank patients:

I ask Omran whether his views have changed since the beginning of the war, and whether he resents Israel. “No,” he answered. “Seventy percent of the people just want to live quietly. The anger is mostly at the governments,” he said.

Both he and his dad are grateful for the help they received. “Doctors here saved my son’s life. I’m forever in their debt.”

And then, Jehad, a man whose very name has become synonymous with “holy war,” says something that lights a tiny spark of hope. “There are good people here on both sides.”

I don't think Israel is attempting anything slightly resembling a genocide.
 
Palestine/Israel

I'm here to learn. From what I understand, Britain had "the land" when Israel was formed. It also seemed the place was indeed called Palestine when the Jewish state was formed in 1948? So aren't the Jews there also "Palestinians"?

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/primary-resources/truman-israel/

In the midst of wanton aggression, we yet call upon the Arab inhabitants of the State of Israel to return to the ways of peace and play their part in the development of the State, with full and equal citizenship and due representation in its bodies and institutions -- provisional or permanent.

Previously... there was a six day war and land was taken over by the Jews.
http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/six_day_war_1967.htm

The war was against Syria, Jordan and Egypt. Israel believed that it was only a matter of time before the three Arab states co-ordinated a massive attack on Israel. After the 1956 Suez Crisis, the United Nations had established a presence in the Middle East, especially at sensitive border areas. The United Nations was only there with the agreement of the nations that acted as a host to it. By May 1967, the Egyptians had made it clear that the United Nations was no longer wanted in the Suez region. Gamal Nasser, leader of Egypt, ordered a concentration of Egyptian military forces in the sensitive Suez zone. This was a highly provocative act and the Israelis only viewed it one way – that Egypt was preparing to attack. The Egyptians had also enforced a naval blockade which closed off the Gulf of Aqaba to Israeli shipping.

Rather than wait to be attacked, the Israelis launched a hugely successful military campaign against its perceived enemies. The air forces of Egypt, Jordan, Syria and Iraq were all but destroyed on June 5th. By June 7th, many Egyptian tanks had been destroyed in the Sinai Desert and Israeli forces reached the Suez Canal. On the same day, the whole of the west bank of the Jordan River had been cleared of Jordanian forces. The Golan Heights were captured from Syria and Israeli forces moved 30 miles into Syria itself.

Six hundred thousands arabs didn't like this though, so some land was giving back: http://www.irish4israel.ie/1967-borders/4581604694

4603457972_818x333.jpg


The PLO was born, and Israel has been a target ever since, no matter how much land is given back.

Now we have people villifying the Israelis for what Hamas is doing there? And saying the "palestinians" (arabs) are being pushed out even though even more land was given up by Israel there in 2011? WTFrac?

What about how Hamas is lobbing weapons at Israel from that land that was given back and spending so many millions on building tunnels to bring weapons in??

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/aug/02/tunnels-hamas-israel-struggle-gaza-war

Why are the Israelis being painted as such bad guys lately, when it's Hamas that hides weapons in civilian areas??

There’s another difference between the two sides. Israel doesn’t want to shed civilian blood. Hamas needs it – especially from its own civilians. That’s one reason why it puts rocket launchers and ammunition dumps in mosques and homes in crowded neighbourhoods. That’s why it told people not to leave northern Gaza this weekend after Israel warned it was going to bomb.
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/human-shields-are-hamass-pr/article19602451/

I see so much crap in places about FB that say the exact opposite of these well known and easy to find facts. What is this insanity??
 
I'm here to learn. From what I understand, Britain had "the land" when Israel was formed. It also seemed the place was indeed called Palestine when the Jewish state was formed in 1948? So aren't the Jews there also "Palestinians"?

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/primary-resources/truman-israel/

In the midst of wanton aggression, we yet call upon the Arab inhabitants of the State of Israel to return to the ways of peace and play their part in the development of the State, with full and equal citizenship and due representation in its bodies and institutions -- provisional or permanent.

Previously... there was a six day war and land was taken over by the Jews.
http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/six_day_war_1967.htm

The war was against Syria, Jordan and Egypt. Israel believed that it was only a matter of time before the three Arab states co-ordinated a massive attack on Israel. After the 1956 Suez Crisis, the United Nations had established a presence in the Middle East, especially at sensitive border areas. The United Nations was only there with the agreement of the nations that acted as a host to it. By May 1967, the Egyptians had made it clear that the United Nations was no longer wanted in the Suez region. Gamal Nasser, leader of Egypt, ordered a concentration of Egyptian military forces in the sensitive Suez zone. This was a highly provocative act and the Israelis only viewed it one way – that Egypt was preparing to attack. The Egyptians had also enforced a naval blockade which closed off the Gulf of Aqaba to Israeli shipping.

Rather than wait to be attacked, the Israelis launched a hugely successful military campaign against its perceived enemies. The air forces of Egypt, Jordan, Syria and Iraq were all but destroyed on June 5th. By June 7th, many Egyptian tanks had been destroyed in the Sinai Desert and Israeli forces reached the Suez Canal. On the same day, the whole of the west bank of the Jordan River had been cleared of Jordanian forces. The Golan Heights were captured from Syria and Israeli forces moved 30 miles into Syria itself.

Six hundred thousands arabs didn't like this though, so some land was given back: http://www.irish4israel.ie/1967-borders/4581604694

4603457972_818x333.jpg


The PLO was born, and Israel has been a target ever since, no matter how much land is given back.

Now we have people villifying the Israelis for what Hamas is doing there? And saying the "palestinians" (arabs) are being pushed out even though even more land was given up by Israel there in 2011? WTFrac?

What about how Hamas is lobbing weapons at Israel from that land that was given back and spending so many millions on building tunnels to bring weapons in??

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/aug/02/tunnels-hamas-israel-struggle-gaza-war

Why are the Israelis being painted as such bad guys lately, when it's Hamas that hides weapons in civilian areas??

There’s another difference between the two sides. Israel doesn’t want to shed civilian blood. Hamas needs it – especially from its own civilians. That’s one reason why it puts rocket launchers and ammunition dumps in mosques and homes in crowded neighbourhoods. That’s why it told people not to leave northern Gaza this weekend after Israel warned it was going to bomb.
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/human-shields-are-hamass-pr/article19602451/

I see so much crap in places about FB that say the exact opposite of these well known and easy to find facts. What is this insanity??
 
Last edited:
Kucinich's article is from August 5. I found it googling for the 44% number I have heard from other sources. In his article he sources the claim with this link to the Washington Post, which illustrates what he claims.

If this has been temporary and now lifted or eased, that would be great, but frankly I doubt it given their habit of sticking to what they have grabbed. And your article cites "witnesses in Eastern Gaza" as source.

Thanks. Here's what it says:

Restricted border zones

A 2km area on the outside of the border fence separating Israel and Gaza is a no-go zone for Israeli civilians. Communities contained in a 3km-deep zone on the inside received evacuation warnings. This area covers 44 percent of the Gaza Strip and contains homes of about 250,000 people.

Gaza City's Shijaiyah neighborhood and the city of Beit Hanoun, which lie inside the 3km zone, have been bombarded heavily.

That was during the conflict though. Presumably those who still have homes in the 3km buffer zone can return to them now. Of course, many of those homes have been destroyed, and many of the people who lived there were probably innocent.

The "land grab" I referred to in the West Bank is supposed to be permanent and used for a new Israeli settlement.

All of this though seems to be a form of collective punishment for the deaths (murders) of the three Israeli teenagers. The land appropriation is framed as a "punishment" specifically for that crime, even though it's not clear to me that the former owners of that land had anything to do with the crime. But they are Palestinians and the people who committed the murder are Palestinians too, so the logic goes.

The bombing of Gaza was not framed as punishment for the murders but as defending against rocket attacks, but the rocket attacks were a response to the operation to find and punish the murderers of the teens. This is what Wikipedia says about how it all started:

The stated aim of the Israeli operation was to stop rocket fire from Gaza into Israel, which non-Hamas factions had begun following an Israeli crackdown on Hamas in the West Bank (sparked by the kidnapping and murder of 3 Israeli teenagers by Hamas members),[29] and which Hamas itself began following an Israeli airstrike on 6 July which killed seven Hamas militants in Khan Yunis.[29][30][31]

So each side can sort of say that the other side "started it".

By the way, did anyone ever figure out exactly who killed the teenagers and whether they were acting on orders from Hamas? My understanding, last I heard was that the leader of Hamas denied responsibility, but at the same time did not condemn the attack but instead indicated his approval of it.

So, as I see it, Hamas is guilty of provoking Israel by expressing approval for the attack, but Israel is also guilty of having a policy of collective punishment, which punishes both the innocent and the guilty on the other side for the crimes of the guilty.
 
From what I understand, that information is convoluted. The zone needed to be cleared to destroy tunnels as well as stop the pot shotting at Israel?

Taking that "new land" is not in dispute at the moment, and is not occupied, and is not being taken as "punishment":
Yair Lapid, Israel’s finance minister, who has spoken out in favour of a new diplomatic process, told reporters Sunday that he “was not aware of the decision” about the land around Gvaot and had instructed his team to look into it. “We are against any swift changes in the West Bank right now because we need to go back to some kind of process there,” he said. He added that the Israeli government was now talking to the Palestinian Authority about the situation in Gaza, “and this is a good thing.”

But Yariv Oppenheimer, general director of Peace Now, said that instead of strengthening the Palestinian moderates, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu “turns his back on the Palestinian Authority and sticks a political knife in the back” of Mr. Abbas, referring to the latest land appropriation. “Since the 1980s, we don’t remember a declaration of such dimensions,” Mr. Oppenheimer told Israel Radio.

Israeli officials said that the land declaration Sunday was open to judicial review and that interested parties had 45 days in which to register objections.
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/world/israel-seizes-land-in-west-bank-block/article20290781/
 
Last edited:
Taking that "new land" is not in dispute at the moment, and is not occupied, and is not being taken as "punishment":

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/world/israel-seizes-land-in-west-bank-block/article20290781/

Well here's what Israeli newspaper Haaretz said:

Israel’s Civil Administration in the West Bank announced the takeover of 988 acres (3,799 dunams) belonging to five Palestinian villages between the Etzion settlement bloc and Jerusalem. The move clears the way for construction of a new settlement named Gvaot.

The announcement follows the cabinet’s decision last week to take over the land in response to the June kidnapping and killing of three teenage Jewish boys by Hamas militants in the area.

Even though they don't use the word "punishment" there, the decision is a "response" to the murders. At best, that seems to be a euphemism for punishment.

ETA: also, your own linked article says it more explicitly:
The timing of the land appropriation suggested that it was meant as a kind of compensation for the settlers and punishment for the Palestinians.
 
Last edited:
I'm here to learn. From what I understand, Britain had "the land" when Israel was formed. It also seemed the place was indeed called Palestine when the Jewish state was formed in 1948? So aren't the Jews there also "Palestinians"?

I'm sure to be wrong, not least because I rarely participate in Israel/Palestine threads because it's bad for my blood pressure.....

Regarding Palestinians vs. palestinians, as I understand it, a large proportion of Jewish Israelis are themselves, or are descended from, people who have moved to Israel from other parts of the world. Palestinians could refer to all people who lived in the British protectorate of Palestine but it has become a shorthand for the non-Jewish inhabitants of the region. It's sloppy in the same way that referring to people who are anti-Jewish as being antisemitic when they may be pro- other Semitic people.

Britain did administer the southern part of the protectorate following the final break up of the Ottoman Empire at the end of the First World War (France administered the Northern part). Britain was administering the protectorate in 1948 when Israel was established. Britain withdrew from the region after sustaining heavy losses from Israeli terrorist operations.

The map showing Israel's land concessions for peace are an interesting counterpoint to the more usual map which shows how Israel has acquired land over the initial 1948 mandate. Israel has returned land from the greatest extent of its invasions but then again retains the Golan Heights and parts of the West Bank.

Personally I think that Israel is walking a tricky tightrope between the ultra-orthodox population who want an Israel corresponding to a notional biblical Israel which includes all of the West Bank (and, IIRC, some of the East Bank) and moderate Israelis who think that the 1967 borders are sufficient. the ultra-orthodox population wield a lot of power and influence. IMO this is always going to cause tension because one group will always be pushing for incremental land grabs (and are indifferent to the feelings and well being of the Palestinians) while the others are uncomfortable with this. I think that in 50 or 100 years time Israel's borders will include the whole of the West Bank (or at least any bits which are of any use).
 
IWhy are the Israelis being painted as such bad guys lately, when it's Hamas that hides weapons in civilian areas??

Partly it's because of the relative sizes of the death tolls. However many Israelis are killed by Hamas, there are orders of magnitudes more Palestinians killed. The proportion of civilians is usually much higher too. This is due to Hamas using the local population as human shields but as Israeli strikes on UN facilities recently show, there may be some indifference from the Israeli side.

Partly it's because Hamas are a terrorist organisation so we expect them to act like *****. Israel on the other hand are a modern democracy. In Northern Ireland there were extra-judicial killings by the security forces (Bloody Sunday being a tragic example), but generally speaking the response to the latest IRA outrage in Derry/Londonderry wasn't the shelling of the Bogside resulting in the deaths of hundreds of women and children. We hold Israel to a much higher standard than Hamas, the same standard we'd hold ourselves to.

Partly it's just because the people in Gaza don't really have any choice. Regardless of how they feel about Hamas, they cannot escape and they cannot ever be truly safe. Living under these conditions it is understandable how extreme views can start to get traction.
 
By the way, did anyone ever figure out exactly who killed the teenagers and whether they were acting on orders from Hamas? My understanding, last I heard was that the leader of Hamas denied responsibility, but at the same time did not condemn the attack but instead indicated his approval of it.

Hamas praised the actions, but supposedly did not order them, at last check. The actions were done by people who were affiliated with Hamas, though, it seems.

So, as I see it, Hamas is guilty of provoking Israel by expressing approval for the attack, but Israel is also guilty of having a policy of collective punishment, which punishes both the innocent and the guilty on the other side for the crimes of the guilty.

Israel is guilty of a number of things in Operation Brother's Keeper which were really not justified by the pretext used, with this latest appropriation of land in the name of the Israeli dead continuing to make their response to that worse. What Hamas is actually guilty of there is their oft stated goal for Israel's destruction, which, while I might consider accepting that as a reason to do some of what they did, hasn't been the justification that they've tried to use. Operation Brother's Keeper warranted a response from the Palestinians and Hamas. The biggest problem with the response that Hamas chose, however, is that they were openly and directly targeting noncombatants who were not involved and had nothing to do with military targets. That, by itself, put their response in the wrong and fully justified Israel counterattacking, before even starting on the rest.

I'm here to learn. From what I understand, Britain had "the land" when Israel was formed. It also seemed the place was indeed called Palestine when the Jewish state was formed in 1948?

That area has a long history of being called Palestine. This has been gone over several time here. It was never an Arab country, though, regardless of the nationalistic desires of a number of Arabs there.

So aren't the Jews there also "Palestinians"?

Some could be considered such. Calling the Arabs who had lived there Palestinians is a matter of convenience more than much else.


Previously... there was a six day war and land was taken over by the Jews.

That was a number of years later, not "previously."


Six hundred thousands arabs didn't like this though, so some land was given back:

More than that. Either way, the Sinai Peninsula was returned to Egypt as part of peace negotiations. Gaza was given to the Palestinian Arabs in an attempt to show good will and move things in the direction of actual peace. Voting Hamas with their explicit anti-peace agenda into power quite defeated that purpose.


The PLO was born, and Israel has been a target ever since, no matter how much land is given back.

Israel was a target before the PLO was formed. Israel was a target before it even existed itself, though.

Now we have people villifying the Israelis for what Hamas is doing there?

No. We have people villifying Israelis because of Israeli actions and actions that they think Israelis have taken and conveniently ignoring or trying to badly justify the actions of Palestinian terrorists that invited or forced actions like that to happen.

And saying the "palestinians" (arabs) are being pushed out even though even more land was given up by Israel there in 2011? WTFrac?

Ignoring the generalized claims that have been as well supported as conspiracy theories in this thread, some evidence has been put forward that Israel increased what they consider the no go part of Gaza for the Palestinians significantly. If they reduce it from what it was before when an actual agreement is reached, as may have happened, it would simply show the weakness in the position of those claiming such, yet again.

I see so much crap in places about FB that say the exact opposite of these well known and easy to find facts. What is this insanity??

Ask them. It usually becomes pretty clear that people are far less interested in truth than in hating on a particular group, though, I suspect.
 
Last edited:
I think that in 50 or 100 years time Israel's borders will include the whole of the West Bank (or at least any bits which are of any use).

The borders do include the West Bank already. It's worth saying, though, that Israel has repeatedly offered to dismantle a number of its settlements in the West Bank as part of what it's brought to the negotiating table.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom