Mycroft
High Priest of Ed
- Joined
- Sep 10, 2003
- Messages
- 20,501
This seems like a poor rationalisation.
But you're not trolling.

I don't have any need to rationalize anything. I'm not Israeli, I live in Kansas. I'm not part of any decision making process related to this.
Surely we have enough history with this kind of action to know forced relocation like this is a bad idea.
Who is "we", and what other examples are you referring to?
And it seems doubtful that helping them is the idea at all.
Last week I read an article comparing archaeological digs in Jerusalem to the tunnels Hamas dug to infiltrate Israel and kidnap Israelis claiming they were the exact same thing.
Anything that happens in Israel will be used by someone to demonize Israel in regard to the Israel/Arab conflict, but the truth is sometimes an issue is an issue in it's own right.
The poverty and illiteracy rates of these people are not made up. It's one thing to herd goats for a living if that's what you want to do, it's quite another to heard goats for a living because you can't read and that's the only skill your father could pass on to you. If you think you have a better idea, if you know how to get their children into school without putting them into houses, then you need to quit wasting your time on internet message boards and get your ass over to Israel where you can be of help. If you don't like Israel, you can head on over to Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt, or any number of countries that are facing the exact same issues with Bedouin.