Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
This seems like a poor rationalisation.

But you're not trolling. :oldroll:

I don't have any need to rationalize anything. I'm not Israeli, I live in Kansas. I'm not part of any decision making process related to this.

Surely we have enough history with this kind of action to know forced relocation like this is a bad idea.

Who is "we", and what other examples are you referring to?

And it seems doubtful that helping them is the idea at all.

Last week I read an article comparing archaeological digs in Jerusalem to the tunnels Hamas dug to infiltrate Israel and kidnap Israelis claiming they were the exact same thing.

Anything that happens in Israel will be used by someone to demonize Israel in regard to the Israel/Arab conflict, but the truth is sometimes an issue is an issue in it's own right.

The poverty and illiteracy rates of these people are not made up. It's one thing to herd goats for a living if that's what you want to do, it's quite another to heard goats for a living because you can't read and that's the only skill your father could pass on to you. If you think you have a better idea, if you know how to get their children into school without putting them into houses, then you need to quit wasting your time on internet message boards and get your ass over to Israel where you can be of help. If you don't like Israel, you can head on over to Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt, or any number of countries that are facing the exact same issues with Bedouin.
 
That's a ridiculous comparison, Safe-Keeper.

It's a while since Norway was under foreign occupation, though the hatred persists in the hearts of those who remember it.

When Norway was under occupation, how wide it was at its narrowest point was irrelevant. Just like in the disputed territories.

Whatever. Your emotions are your own business. There is a big difference between Palestine and Norway. I suggest you study the two countries further and see if you can discern what it is.

Which is basically a catch-all that works (in your mind, anyway) to invalidate any comparison you don't like.

ETA: On second thoughts, perhaps you need some help. Here's a clue: One of them isn't shrinking.

I'll just take this opportunity to remind you that "Palestine" as a nation does not exist and so can't said to be "shrinking".
 
In New Orleans, 109 police officers were killed in the line of duty in 2012 alone.

As far as I can tell this is a serious misreading of that link. The deaths go back to 1856. This link was posted in 2013 and I'm just reading it now. OT but I felt it was worth correcting. In one year 109 would be insane.
 
Another statement, that none of us have contested, that has nothing to do with whether or not a country that is 15km wide is "effectively cut in two".

Keep arguing about how many angels fit on the head of a pin. Enlightenment is sure to follow! There is no high-tech army blockading Noway's borders.

Meanwhile, in the real world:

Israel Was Tried For War Crimes Today, The Testimony Will Break Your Heart

“16 yr old boy stripped naked and used as human shield by Israel for 5 days. He was denied food, water and sleep – and mentally and physically abused, including lashed with a wire across his back. Israeli army stopped a family car near a West Bank protest over Gaza. Positioned their weapons in the windows of back doors, where toddlers were sitting and began to fire on protest. This is not an isolated incident. There is a clear, recorded pattern of Israel using Palestinian children as human shields during attacks on Gaza.”

“We found one of 89 families completely liquidated during Operation Protective Edge so badly burned/destroyed they had to be buried in a mass grave by a bulldozer – evoking memories of the darkest times in European history. On outskirts of Rafah, I heard testimony from 19 yr old Mohammed Abu Said of how Israeli soldiers stripped him naked and sniped at neighbours, then set the dogs on him in between shooting rounds. In Khuza’a – a man left a group of <resistance> fighters in his home. He returned to find their throats had been cut, their bodies piled in a corner and burnt with grenades. A clear pattern of executions has been established. Israeli soldiers gather civilians in an open area, asks if anyone speaks Hebrew. When people step forward, they shoot them dead. Four brothers of one man were taken into garden and shot dead, one of them was mentally disabled and had little idea he was being killed.”

more testimony
 
Tried? You surely mean condemned by a powerless, non-sanctioned body with zero legitimacy and a predetermined conclusion.
 
More testimony:

“More than 90% of Gaza’s agricultural output destroyed by Israel over summer, almost all farms destroyed. Israel destroyed 220 factories in Gaza, this constitutes around 70% of Gaza’s industrial output gone.There was no military justification for the destruction of these factories whatsoever. I stayed in Gaza for one month in a house with 72 Palestinian civilians, 60 of whom had been displaced. It was overcrowded, tap water wasn’t working anymore, we had to buy fuel, we had to bake our own bread as none available in shops. 220 factories were completely destroyed during the 7 weeks of Israel’s Operation Protective Edge. Israel has succeeded in turning a functional economy in Gaza into a third world territory in just 8 years, through the blockade and four large scale military assaults. Israel is not only attacking systematically civilians in their homes, but systematically destroying the economy of Gaza to make people dependent on aid.”
 
More testimony:

“Israeli army routinely defecate in Palestinian homes and buildings they occupy, leaving behind racist and violent graffiti together with piles of ****.

The Imam in Gaza was held for days by Israeli troops who ordered him at gunpoint to use mosque tannoy to call on community to come to the mosque. As young people gathered they were surrounded by Israeli troops, stripped naked at gunpoint and tortured/killed for sport.

The Imam was used as human shield by Israeli troops. He was stripped naked at gunpoint in front of men, women and children of the neighborhood.”
 

If true, that would indeed be quite horrible. I'm not convinced of the trustworthiness of the source, though, to be completely honest. Given the stated claimant, though, he should have plenty of photographic evidence, right? Any chance that you would happen to have it available? That, at least, would be a start.
 
Last edited:

More testimony:
One of the earliest studied cases happened in Brazil when a farmer in the 1950s claimed a spacecraft emitting a very bright light landed on his family’s farm. He continued to see the strange object until one night, when it took him and left some disturbing evidence of alien experimentation. The farmer claimed the alien beings brought him on their ship to impregnate a rather fetching-looking female and described everything from the ship to his “suitor” in great detail.
 
Max Blumenthal: The interview

"If people really want to know what motivates me and the position I've taken, it shouldn't require some rich explanation or ideology. It's not about having 'Jewish issues' with the way I was raised, or even necessarily deep identification with Palestinian culture. All you need to feel is disgust with unfairness: it's just not fair the way Palestinians are being treated."

As someone familiar with the region myself from a number of visits over the last decade, I ask if during the course of his research there were any particular moments that stand out – that shocked him.

"The violence you witness, the physical destruction, becomes normalised", Blumenthal reflects. "It's the psychological violence, the daily acts of dehumanisation which are really shocking. There is a video I saw over the summer, after the discovery of the bodies of the teens when Jewish Israeli society became overwhelmed with a desire for revenge, a video of a Jewish woman who pushes a Palestinian woman into a lake. She did it because she could."

This, for Max, scares him "more than a bomb falling on a residential tower". Why? "Because it shows how the dehumanisation of a people who are occupied and racially outcasted has seeped into the core of common people and give them carte blanche to just humiliate them."

This, he says, "reminds me of the dark days in Europe". He continues: "There's no way I can't be reminded of the photos I saw as part of the moral formation I had as a child, of Jews having their beards cut in public by regular people, or people being humiliated for relations with Jews in 1930s Europe." Palestinian citizens of Israel, Max comments, have "the feeling of being under siege but in a more subtle way than in the West Bank – under siege from a population who are your neighbours.
 
Israel is incrementally destroying the Palestinians: is it time to use the g-word?

Last month a “jury” featuring international law experts at a people’s court, known as the Russell Tribunal, into Israel’s recent attack on Gaza concluded that Israel was guilty of “incitement to genocide”. The panel argued that Israel’s long-term collective punishment of Palestinians was designed to “inflict conditions of life calculated to bring about the incremental destruction of the Palestinians as a group”.

The tribunal’s language intentionally echoed that of Raphael Lemkin, a Polish Jew and lawyer who after fleeing Nazi Europe succeeded in introducing the term “genocide” into international law.

Lemkin and the UN convention’s drafters understood that genocide did not require death camps; it could also be achieved gradually through intentional and systematic abuse and neglect. Their definition raises troubling questions about Israel’s treatment of Gaza, aside from military attacks. Does, for example, forcing the enclave’s two million inhabitants to depend on acquifers polluted with seawater constitute genocide?

Israel’s occupation is more complex than a genocide
 
Israel is incrementally destroying the Palestinians: is it time to use the g-word?

No. Even your own attempts to make an argument in support of your claim have contradicted you on that. Repeatedly. One would think that when both dictionary and kangaroo court agree that what happened was not genocide, you should rethink your position.




...If your point is basically that calling the situation "genocide" is inaccurate, but that it's still a nasty situation, sure, I'll agree with you. If it's nothing more than yet another attempt to justify your false claims of genocide, you seriously need to change your tune to something more accurate, unless your goal continues to be to make fun of those who hate Israel and to make them look like idiots.

Either way, any chance that you found those pictures yet?
 
Israel is incrementally destroying the Palestinians: is it time to use the g-word?

So basically you've just given up on making any rational argument of your own and have become nothing more than a spam bot.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom