Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
While it is good to hear, I don't think that it's huge in the way of news. Hamas, other than the recent conflict, has been greatly suppressing the number of rockets fired at Israel for a few years now, which is a fact that shouldn't be forgotten. It's unlikely that their real motives are particularly noble, frankly, but results matter, quite a bit. Either way, at the moment, it would be very, very obviously against their interests for them to break the ceasefire, politically, militarily, economically, and so on.

It is certainly better than some fringe group igniting a shooting war.
 
Hamas arrests Palestinians who launched rocket from Gaza



An important step in the right direction. Perhaps Israel has achieved a significant goal here. At least Hamas seems to have realized the futility of rocket attacks. I doubt they are reformed but maybe they are finally beginning to realize that there is no military solution to their predicament.



Nonsense.

Unlike Israel, Hamas has a very good record of observing and policing ceasefires.

Meanwhile:

Israel’s systematic attacks on civilians to be examined by the Russell Tribunal on Palestine


24-25 September – Brussels – Albert Hall, Brussels

www.russelltribunalonpalestine.com/en/


For immediate release


Wednesday September 17th


The Russell Tribunal’s extraordinary session on Gaza will examine Israeli attacks on civilians and civilian infrastructure during ‘Operation Protective Edge’ in July and August of this year.


Human Rights Watch recently accused Israel of committing war crimes in a report analysing three attacks on schools in Jabalya, Beit Hanoun and Rafah. The attacks killed 45 people, including 17 children.


This is not the first time that a human rights probe has made such claims. United Nations and Amnesty International investigations have also found evidence of war crimes and crimes against humanity.


According to the United Nations, 2,131 Palestinians were killed during Israel’s last 50 day offensive. Of those 501 were children with about 70 percent aged under 12 according to UNICEF.


In the same period, the Ministry of Health in Gaza recorded 10,918 people injured including 3,312 children and 2,120 women. According to the United Nations, 244 schools were shelled and one used as a military base. According to Al Mezan human rights organisation at least 10,920 houses were damaged or destroyed of which 2,853 were completely destroyed. Furthermore 161 mosques, eight hospitals – resulting in six being taken out of service – 46 NGO 50 fishing boats, and 244 vehicles were also hit.


John Dugard, Professor of Interntional Law and former UN Special Rapporteur to the Occupied Palestinian Territories said:


“In its shelling of houses and apartment blocks believed to be occupied by Hamas militants the IDF (Israeli Defence Force) has shown a callous disregard for what it views as collateral damage, but this collateral damage has often taken the form of the killing and injuring of civilians and the destruction of their property. This failure to distinguish between military targets and civilians constitutes a clear war crime.”
 
Last edited:
On 26 August a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas was agreed, bringing a fragile end to a war that killed 2150 Palestinians (mostly civilians) and 73 Israelis (mostly soldiers). Since then Hamas has not fired a single rocket, attacked an Israeli target, or done anything to break the terms of the ceasefire. Israel has done the following:
 
On 26 August a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas was agreed, bringing a fragile end to a war that killed 2150 Palestinians (mostly civilians) and 73 Israelis (mostly soldiers). Since then Hamas has not fired a single rocket, attacked an Israeli target, or done anything to break the terms of the ceasefire. Israel has done the following:

Absolutely, however they did violate the August 19 ceasefire almost immediately with rockets and mortars. And every other ceasefire that had been agreed upon from 2001 on.

Taken as a whole, Hamas' trackrecord for keeping their word is not high.
 
So what is the opposing viewpoint or larger context on this story (not trolling, just can't find much):

At the meetings architect and planner Alon Cohen Lifshitz from the organization Bimkom – Planners for Planning Rights explained all aspects of the relocation plan to the community members (as they were published separately), and created a map.

“From the start we’ve opposed the plan to expel us from the places where we live and settle us unwillingly in one town, but we didn’t know just how bad this plan was until we heard and understood the details,” one participant at the first meeting in Anata told Haaretz. “We decided to express our opposition to the principles of the plan,” he said, “and not this or that aspect of it. We know that we have a tough time ahead of us, and there is a chance that the Civil Administration will exert pressure on us in the form of more demolition orders and attempts to expel us from various places.”

...

The Bedouin representatives’ meetings took place simultaneously in Anata and Jericho, due to the distance between the two places, and also because members of various tribes are embroiled in long-term family or personal disputes. These tensions, according to Cohen Lifshitz, are just a small example of the “great difficulty in gathering together people from various tribes, in close proximity that goes against their way of life.”

...

He also explained that the allocation of lands does not allow each family to build as they wish. “They must submit updated building plans, at their own expense. Speaking with them, I understood that aside from uprooting them, one of the most difficult aspects of the plan is that they are being sent as a group into a single place, without taking into account where they will put their flocks, how they can feed them, how much room they’ll have and where they will keep their livelihood.”

http://www.haaretz.com/news/national/.premium-1.616163
 
So what is the opposing viewpoint or larger context on this story (not trolling, just can't find much):



http://www.haaretz.com/news/national/.premium-1.616163

I'm not sure I understand your question. I don't know that there are different "sides" to these issues, rather they are just very complex. I think what I read in the article sums it up pretty well.

Some contextual things you may or may not be aware of:

Bedouin are traditionally a nomadic people, making a living by herding goats and sheep from place to place.

I'm pretty sure the Bedouin groups discussed in the article are Israelis.

Many Bedouin have settled down in towns, becoming ranchers, laborers, and other things. Some set up Bedouin tents and give camel rides for tourists. Particularly in the North Western area of Israel, Bedouin have done a lot to integrate into Israeli society, many even joining the IDF (they're not required to) and becoming invaluable there.

Some still live as nomads. My understanding is it's a pretty poor life, cut off from running water, electricity, schools and other amenities of the modern world. I'm really not sure how, or even if, they fit into the modern economy. Illiteracy rates are very high.

The idea is to raise their standard of living by integrating them into modern society, giving them water, electricity, access to health care, and most importantly, education. But of course there are complications. Some don't want to settle, others don't know what to do after they settle, others are concerned with settling with families or groups they have conflicts with.
 
The idea is to raise their standard of living by integrating them into modern society, giving them water, electricity, access to health care, and most importantly, education. But of course there are complications. Some don't want to settle, others don't know what to do after they settle, others are concerned with settling with families or groups they have conflicts with.

This seems like a poor rationalisation. Surely we have enough history with this kind of action to know forced relocation like this is a bad idea. And it seems doubtful that helping them is the idea at all. Also, most of the intended are registered Palestinian refugees.

UNRWA added that most of those slated for resettlement to Jericho, in the east of the Palestinian territory, were registered Palestinian refugees.

...

UNRWA said that among those slated for resettlement were people residing "in the E1 and Maale Adumim areas near Jerusalem, which have been slated for new Israeli settlement development."

Israel has been planning construction in the highly contentious area of the West Bank, east of Jerusalem, since the early 1990s.

Plans for building 1,200 settler homes unveiled in December 2012 were quickly put on the back burner after the announcement triggered a major diplomatic backlash.

The Palestinians say construction in E1 would effectively cut the West Bank in two and prevent the creation of any contiguous Palestinian state.

http://news.yahoo.com/un-warns-over-israeli-plan-relocate-west-bank-222039357.html
 
The Palestinians say construction in E1 would effectively cut the West Bank in two and prevent the creation of any contiguous Palestinian state.
Not this old canard again.

Palestine would become 15km at its narrowest, which sounds small until you consider how tiny the region is to begin with. Then you factor in that Irael is already only 15km at its most narrow.

Meanwhile Norway is 6km at the most narrow, but you don't see too many Norwegians complaining their country is cut in two.
 
I wish the media, and people in general, stopped uncritically taking everything "Palestinians said" at face value. They can lie and manipulate like everybody else.
 
Not this old canard again.

Palestine would become 15km at its narrowest, which sounds small until you consider how tiny the region is to begin with. Then you factor in that Irael is already only 15km at its most narrow.

Meanwhile Norway is 6km at the most narrow, but you don't see too many Norwegians complaining their country is cut in two.

That's a ridiculous comparison, Safe-Keeper.

It's a while since Norway was under foreign occupation, though the hatred persists in the hearts of those who remember it.
 
Last edited:
That's a ridiculous comparison, Safe-Keeper.

It's a while since Norway was under foreign occupation, though the hatred persists in the hearts of those who remember it.
"Butbutbut other factors totally unrelated to your point!"

As predictable as it is annoying.
 
"Butbutbut other factors totally unrelated to your point!"

As predictable as it is annoying.

Whatever. Your emotions are your own business. There is a big difference between Palestine and Norway. I suggest you study the two countries further and see if you can discern what it is.

ETA: On second thoughts, perhaps you need some help. Here's a clue: One of them isn't shrinking.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Gaza and the 'crime of crimes'
Russell Tribunal on Palestine finds that Gaza is on the brink of a genocidal apartheid.


by Ronnie Kasrils, South Africa's Deputy Minister of Defence (1994-99); Water & Forestry Minister (1999-2004); and Minister for Intelligence Services (2004-2008). He has retired from government but is active in the Palestine Solidarity Committee. He served in the ANC's armed wing from its inception in 1961.

Nelson Mandela frequently declared that "Palestine was the greatest moral issue of our time". After we toppled the Apartheid regime in 1994, he went further, saying "We South Africans cannot consider ourselves free until the Palestinian People are free".

Millions of us in South Africa collectively recoiled from Israel's gruesome assault on the people of Gaza during those 51 nightmarish days of "Operation Protective Edge" and the attendant ongoing cruelty in the West Bank. As the dust settled, we were left shocked beyond belief as we witnessed a community of 1.8 million in ruins; Khozaa, Shujaiyya, Beit Hanoun, with entire families and neighbourhoods, gone.
 
Last edited:
Which makes 15km not equal to 15km how, exactly?

One of them is a metric kilometer and one of them is a short kilometer? Wait, no... one of them is a Troy kilometer and... no, it's not that either.... Maybe a survey kilometer and an international kilometer? No... how about a nautical kilometer and... damn it, I'm sure I'll figure it out eventually.
 
Did not see that coming.

Indeed, who could have ever guessed that a kangaroo court like that would say something like that? What's more telling is that even they didn't find sufficient justification to actually call what happened there genocide, regardless of how much they wanted to, further demonstrating how incredibly flawed JihadJane's attempts to claim such were.
 
Last edited:
JihadJane said:
There is a big difference between Palestine and Norway.
Another statement, that none of us have contested, that has nothing to do with whether or not a country that is 15km wide is "effectively cut in two".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom