Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think I guessed. That post was made while half-asleep, though, so I'm really not sure. Either way, count it as for the lurkers, then.



The US is something of a "bully." The large majority of the time, though, it's more a "bully" like parents or grocery stores are "bullies," though.

Uh?

So, in short, your justification for considering Israel genocidal is that despite Israel not committing genocide in Gaza currently, it wants to? And being awful difficult to hide certainly hasn't stopped... how many actual genocides in the last decade? Either way, I've clarified on that topic before. As things stand, there are a couple accusations that, if true, might be officially be genocide, as relatively weak and likely difficult to as they are to prove. Also with that said, the large majority of people calling Israel genocidal are doing it based on the recent death count in Gaza, where, while Israel may very well be committing very nasty crimes, "genocide" doesn't seem like one of them, based on the actual evidence.


The crime of "genocide" defined in international law:

The international legal definition of the crime of genocide is found in Articles II and III of the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide.

Article II describes two elements of the crime of genocide:

1) the mental element, meaning the "intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such", and

2) the physical element which includes five acts described in sections a, b, c, d and e. A crime must include both elements to be called "genocide."

Article III described five punishable forms of the crime of genocide: genocide; conspiracy, incitement, attempt and complicity.

~~~~~

Excerpt from the Convention on the Prevention and
Punishment of Genocide

"Article II: In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:

(a) Killing members of the group;

(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;

(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;

(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;

(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.


http://www.preventgenocide.org/genocide/officialtext.htm

____________________________________________________________________________________

“Hannibal Protocol”
 
Last edited:
1) the mental element, meaning the "intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such",

Your attempt falls apart here, before anything else. Hamas is none of those. Terrorist organizations in general are none of those.
 
Your attempt falls apart here, before anything else. Hamas is none of those. Terrorist organizations in general are none of those.

Occupations always create resistance.

An ugly occupation produces an ugly resistance.

The vast majority of those slaughtered in Gaza by Israel are civilians. Civilians have been targeted and killed. Civilian infrastructure has been targeted and destroyed. Whole neighborhoods have been reduced to rubble.

Dahiya doctrine

Meanwhile, the people of Gaza are celebrating victory and the ceasefire.

2638953fcedb3a865d.jpg


2638953fcee1727106.jpg
 
Occupations always create resistance.

Tell us all about the German and Japanese resistance to US occupation.

The vast majority of those slaughtered in Gaza by Israel are civilians.

According to who? Oh, that's right: according to Hamas.

Meanwhile, the people of Gaza are celebrating victory and the ceasefire.

So then what are you complaining about? The Palestinians won. Israel was defeated. To the victor go the spoils, and all that.
 
JihadJane said:
Occupations always create resistance.
Resistance which very rarely takes on the form of terrorism against civilians. I know there's no difference to you, but to those affected it's a big deal

ETA:
In their own version of the Ice Bucket Challenge, Palestinians pour rubble taken from Gaza wreckage in attempt to draw attention to their plight.
Yeah, their plight receives very little attention. If only there was some foreign aid, reporters, demonstrations, but no, seems like no one cares, sorry to tell you.
 
Last edited:
Occupations always create resistance.

An ugly occupation produces an ugly resistance.

The vast majority of those slaughtered in Gaza by Israel are civilians. Civilians have been targeted and killed. Civilian infrastructure has been targeted and destroyed. Whole neighborhoods have been reduced to rubble.

In short, you're unable to defend your claim that Israel is trying to destroy the Palestinians in whole or in part, or any other "national, ethnical, racial or religious group," so you retreat to a "Hamas is justified" and the emotional "oh, think of the civilians" position. A lot of civilians in Gaza died, yes. That's directly to blame on Hamas and other terrorist groups there for continually committing war crimes of the sort that directly put those civilians and their property in harm's way, first of all. Israel likely did commit war crimes, yes, but your exceedingly biased arguments don't even try to distinguish what's actually their fault, relying instead on the shared emotional outrage that civilians and non-combatants are being harmed in the first place to try to get your claims and blame accepted without scrutiny.
 
Last edited:
Occupations always create resistance.

An ugly occupation produces an ugly resistance.

The vast majority of those slaughtered in Gaza by Israel are civilians. Civilians have been targeted and killed. Civilian infrastructure has been targeted and destroyed. Whole neighborhoods have been reduced to rubble.

Dahiya doctrine

Meanwhile, the people of Gaza are celebrating victory and the ceasefire.

While I'll agree that Gaza won a victory, I don't think they are on to a winning formula. I mean, just how many more of these victories do you think Gaza can handle? Also...as a result of this victory, how is the Palestinian cause really any stronger - significantly stronger?

I can answer those questions. I think the Palestinian cause is a bit stronger, and I could show it, but the gains are miniscule compared to what could have been and should have been accomplished - and they came at too high a price. The Palestinians still don't have the winning formula....and they are making some horrendous mistakes.

One of the biggest mistakes they are making is worrying too much about killing the enemy. The pals have bought into the Von Clausawitz BS Theory of War where the enemy must be physically anihilated...which might work for them if they had money, industry, tanks, fighter jets, SAMS and plenty of territory from which to fight...but they don't, and as a result the strategy just gets the Pals into more trouble.

Strategically and Tactically, the Pals have learned nothing important about fighting this war since they have started resisting - and firing those stupid rockets the way they do is proof. Worse, they have refused to learn the important lessons of others who have been successful. As a result, they have been on a steady losing streak and even the small wins they obtain are so meager as to be insignificant in the downward trend.

I don't see much hope for them.
 
Jules, Von Calusewitz didn't argue that war involved total destruction of the enemy. He argued that War shouldn't be fought for its own sake, but for clear goals in the country's interests (Hence "War is the continuation of diplomacy by other means")
 
Jules, Von Calusewitz didn't argue that war involved total destruction of the enemy. He argued that War shouldn't be fought for its own sake, but for clear goals in the country's interests (Hence "War is the continuation of diplomacy by other means")

Von Clusewitz was a douchebag who so polluted the realm of military thought that it may take a thousand years to nullify his influence. If you want to know the basis philosophies of Western Armies and the source of their fetish for killing and destruction, all one has to do is read the first few paragraphs of "Von Douchebag" where he writes:

Now, philanthropists may easily imagine there is a skilful method of disarming and overcoming an enemy without causing great bloodshed, and that this is the proper tendency of the art of War. However plausible this may appear, still it is an error which must be extirpated; for in such dangerous things as war, the errors which proceed from a spirit of benevolence are just the worst. As the use of physical power to the utmost extent by no means excludes the co-operation of the intelligence, it follows that he who uses force unsparingly, without reference to the quantity of bloodshed, must obtain a superiority if his adversary does not act likewise.

OMFG! What a wanker...and a sure-fire method to lose a war against an enemy who can actually think!

The most elegant riposte to Von Douchbag's sentiment was realized in 1997 when the winning Army (Ireland's PIRA) performed two things that Winning Armies aren't supposed to do if one thinks like Von Douchebag:

1. Fully Decommission and surrender all arms.
2. Do not contest the other side's declaration of Military Supremacy.

And the British are still so confused about the loss that they don't even know how to ask the right questions. Instead, the British ask questions like: "Was the IRA defeated 'militarily'?" http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/legacy/ni/2008/11/was_the_ira_defeated_militaril_1.html

Silly British. No wonder India's Ghandi kicked their Bee-Hinds.
 
Von Clusewitz was a douchebag who so polluted the realm of military thought that it may take a thousand years to nullify his influence. If you want to know the basis philosophies of Western Armies and the source of their fetish for killing and destruction, all one has to do is read the first few paragraphs of "Von Douchebag" where he writes:



OMFG! What a wanker...and a sure-fire method to lose a war against an enemy who can actually think!

Clausewitz, Maurice de Saxe and Sun Tzu, share the philosophy that in war what is necessary is to destroy the enemies will to resist - Sun Tzu makes it sound so much more poetic, but the intent is the same.

Eastern/Western philosophies of war are much the same - defeat of the enemy by necessary means - and that means that political manouverings and solutions are as valid as military ones.
 
The Double Identity of an "Anti-Semitic" Commenter

Common Dreams said:
Like many other news websites, Common Dreams has been plagued by inflammatory anti-Semitic comments following its stories. But on Common Dreams these posts have been so frequent and intense they have driven away donors from a nonprofit dependent on reader generosity.

A Common Dreams investigation has discovered that more than a thousand of these damaging comments over the past two years were written with a deceptive purpose by a Jewish Harvard graduate in his thirties who was irritated by the website's discussion of issues involving Israel. [...]


Tsk, tsk, tsk...
 
so there's another ceasefire. will it hold for more than a week? assuming it appears to be holding for the short term, what do we think needs to happen for this to be the last major Israel-Palestine military conflict?

Sadly I think there's too much that needs to happen with too much compromise required from both sides - if Israel (and Egypt to an extent) need to start to relax their blockade and border restrictions, Gazans and Hamas (and IJ) needs to stop using what comes into Gaza for offensive purposes (tunnels and rockets etc). The international community needs to get behind this and provide as close to neutral observers as possible.

There's other stuff too but I get the feeling Hamas thinks that they will get another crack at Israel after smuggling in more rockets etc, and Israel under Likud is extremely unlikely to offer any sort of benefit of the doubt to Hamas or Gaza that might lead to further attacks on them.
 
so there's another ceasefire. will it hold for more than a week?

Hopefully, it will end up lasting for a very long time.

assuming it appears to be holding for the short term, what do we think needs to happen for this to be the last major Israel-Palestine military conflict?

For both sides to be willing to cooperate in good faith and compromise much more than they have been. Both the political powers of the Palestinians and the Likud Party, for example, would need to give up on some of the major points in their party platforms. In particular, the ones that mean that the other group will be dispossessed or destroyed.

Sadly I think there's too much that needs to happen with too much compromise required from both sides

And neither side generally being willing to compromise anywhere close to that much, for different reasons.

- if Israel (and Egypt to an extent) need to start to relax their blockade and border restrictions, Gazans and Hamas (and IJ) needs to stop using what comes into Gaza for offensive purposes (tunnels and rockets etc). The international community needs to get behind this and provide as close to neutral observers as possible.

It would be nice.


There's other stuff too but I get the feeling Hamas thinks that they will get another crack at Israel after smuggling in more rockets etc, and Israel under Likud is extremely unlikely to offer any sort of benefit of the doubt to Hamas or Gaza that might lead to further attacks on them.

Sounds about right. As has been noted, Hamas has openly declared that they will take everything that they can get and happily use it to further their efforts to drive out or destroy Israel. That's an incredibly bad background from which to engage in negotiations for any kind of lasting peace.
 
Resistance which very rarely takes on the form of terrorism against civilians.

Not true, unfortunately.

I know there's no difference to you, but to those affected it's a big deal

ETA:
Yeah, their plight receives very little attention. If only there was some foreign aid, reporters, demonstrations, but no, seems like no one cares, sorry to tell you.

2014 Gaza war by numbers:

Palestinians killed: 2,139
Palestinian children killed: 490
Israeli soldiers killed: 64
Israeli civilians killed: 6
Israeli children killed: 1
Palestinians wounded: 11,000
Palestinian children wounded: 3,000
Gaza residents displaced: Up to 500,000
Homes destroyed in Gaza: 20,000

Source: UN

Gaza massacre in numbers: What Israel did in 50 days of brutal bombardment
 
Last edited:
In short, you're unable to defend your claim that Israel is trying to destroy the Palestinians in whole or in part, or any other "national, ethnical, racial or religious group," so you retreat to a "Hamas is justified" and the emotional "oh, think of the civilians" position. A lot of civilians in Gaza died, yes. That's directly to blame on Hamas and other terrorist groups there for continually committing war crimes of the sort that directly put those civilians and their property in harm's way, first of all. Israel likely did commit war crimes, yes, but your exceedingly biased arguments don't even try to distinguish what's actually their fault, relying instead on the shared emotional outrage that civilians and non-combatants are being harmed in the first place to try to get your claims and blame accepted without scrutiny.

I mentioned civilians and civilian infrastructure because, as a way of denying that it was committing genocide, you tried to pretend that Israel was only targeting Hamas, apparently hoping that emotional outrage over terrorism would deflect attention from Israel's long-term, genocidal ambitions.

From its inception to the present, Israel has been a rogue, terrorist state, occupying another people's land.
 
Last edited:
I mentioned civilians and civilian infrastructure because, as a way of denying that it was committing genocide, you tried to pretend that Israel was only targeting Hamas, apparently hoping that emotional outrage over terrorism would deflect attention from Israel's long-term, genocidal ambitions.

From its inception to the present, Israel has been a rogue, terrorist state, occupying another people's land.

Firstly, If it's genocide, it's a poor job at it, because the Palestinian population has increased extensively.

It's Istanbul, not Constantinople. By your logic, REMOVE KEBAB during the 90s was totally justified. Also, EVERY nation has occupied and claimed someone else's clay at some point in history (Where do you think Russia or France got their borders). In Israel's case, its founders had survived an industrial scale extermination attempt and were then kicked around Europe for a few years, leading to Israel being founded (based upon the Balfour declaration). Yet the neighbours decided "we'll finish the job hitler started" and tried 3 times within 25 years to do so, each time they got hammered and can't get over it.

Lastly, tell me, what is the proper solution to the Israel-Palestine conflict?
 
Last edited:
While I'll agree that Gaza won a victory, I don't think they are on to a winning formula. I mean, just how many more of these victories do you think Gaza can handle? Also...as a result of this victory, how is the Palestinian cause really any stronger - significantly stronger?

I can answer those questions. I think the Palestinian cause is a bit stronger, and I could show it, but the gains are miniscule compared to what could have been and should have been accomplished - and they came at too high a price. The Palestinians still don't have the winning formula....and they are making some horrendous mistakes.

One of the biggest mistakes they are making is worrying too much about killing the enemy. The pals have bought into the Von Clausawitz BS Theory of War where the enemy must be physically anihilated...which might work for them if they had money, industry, tanks, fighter jets, SAMS and plenty of territory from which to fight...but they don't, and as a result the strategy just gets the Pals into more trouble.

Strategically and Tactically, the Pals have learned nothing important about fighting this war since they have started resisting - and firing those stupid rockets the way they do is proof. Worse, they have refused to learn the important lessons of others who have been successful.

Who has been successful?

As a result, they have been on a steady losing streak and even the small wins they obtain are so meager as to be insignificant in the downward trend.

I don't see much hope for them.

As with South African apartheid, hope lies with global solidarity and action.
 
Not true, unfortunately.



2014 Gaza war by numbers:

Palestinians killed: 2,139
Palestinian children killed: 490
Israeli soldiers killed: 64
Israeli civilians killed: 6
Israeli children killed: 1
Palestinians wounded: 11,000
Palestinian children wounded: 3,000
Gaza residents displaced: Up to 500,000
Homes destroyed in Gaza: 20,000

Source: UN

Gaza massacre in numbers: What Israel did in 50 days of brutal bombardment

2139 killed (0,15% of population) in 50 days is brutal bombardment? Gazan population grows by about 38 thousand people a year. The "brutal bombardment" is 40% of their population growth.

I'm not sure how you would describe an actual brutal bombardment that kills tens of thousands within hours.

McHrozni
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom