Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Madness of Israel

Israel has gone barking mad. An elegant demonstration of its madness - of Israel's vicious self-pity - is on display in an article recently published in an Israeli Paper comparing the Palestinians in Gaza to the Nazis.

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4554583,00.html

It was written by a former Israeli General who seems to actually believe Israel's own Black Propaganda. It's Amazing..how Israel is so quickly becoming that which it professes to fear and despise.
 
The Madness of Israel

Israel has gone barking mad. An elegant demonstration of its madness - of Israel's vicious self-pity - is on display in an article recently published in an Israeli Paper comparing the Palestinians in Gaza to the Nazis.

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4554583,00.html

It was written by a former Israeli General who seems to actually believe Israel's own Black Propaganda. It's Amazing..how Israel is so quickly becoming that which it professes to fear and despise.

First of all, your reading comprehension is terrible. The author compares the Palestinian people to the German people, not to the Nazis. The two groups are distinct and, frankly, the comparison is fairly accurate in context. Separate from that, quite frankly, the Palestinians leadership have repeatedly demonstrated that they're far, far closer to the ideology of the Nazis than Israel's leaders, with the general populace of Palestinians having repeatedly been polled as largely supporting that ideology. Neither the Palestinian people nor the Israeli people are Nazis, regardless, and the author doesn't imply that they are.

Second, the man largely makes valid points, as far as he takes them. There are indeed other considerations than military strategy in play, though, which the Israeli leaders have found compelling enough to overrule causing much more death and destruction than they have. Do you have any indication at all that the Palestinians would extend even a fraction of the consideration that Israel has extended to them despite the conflict, were the situation reversed?

ETA: It's worth noting that "self-pity" has nothing to do with the article that you linked. That you're trying to claim that it somehow is a display of "self-pity" shows nothing more than that you have bias that's heavily interfering with your rationality.
 
Last edited:
The Madness of Israel

Israel has gone barking mad. An elegant demonstration of its madness - of Israel's vicious self-pity - is on display in an article recently published in an Israeli Paper comparing the Palestinians in Gaza to the Nazis.

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4554583,00.html

It was written by a former Israeli General who seems to actually believe Israel's own Black Propaganda. It's Amazing..how Israel is so quickly becoming that which it professes to fear and despise.
...and the topic changes yet again.
 
I am assuming that you are quoting someone, because that is the rationale of a scumbag thief - and I figure you are no scumbag thief.

Yawn.

If there is a God with a sense of humor, he'll let the Judge be German. That would make me LMAO!

That would be funny, why?

No...because the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) had already done the nastiest work for him (ya' know....shooting Palestinians and driving them off their land and bulldozing their homes), all the developer has to do is accept stolen property.

Yeah, that's the claim, isn't it? The anti-Israel narrative relies heavily on this idea of "displacement". Supposedly, every Zionist that fled Russian pogroms or rising anti-Semitism in Europe had to boot some Arab family out of their home to do it.

Except why would we believe that? That's not the way immigration works any other place in the world, so why would it happen that way in Palestine? Anywhere else in the world where people immigrate to a place, they don't displace the population already there, the overall population density increases. Nobody needs to be kicked out, some people purchase places from existing homeowners, others rent, and overall new residences are built to accommodate everyone.

Similar myths are spread about the West Bank. Supposedly, every new residence built must inherently bump Palestinian-Arabs off that land. No wonder they're so angry, they say, if someone can just come along and swipe whatever they want. But does it really work that way?

"Peace Now initially claimed that 86.4% of Ma'ale Adumim was privately owned Palestinian land, basing the figure on data leaked from a government report.[14][15] After Peace Now petitioned the Israeli courts to have the official data released, the group revised the figure to 0.5 percent of the settlement is built on private land. Israel maintains that Maale Adumin was built on "state lands," or areas not registered in anyone's name, and that no private property was being seized for building.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ma'ale_Adumim#Land_ownership

This is typical of the conflict. Initially outrageous claims are made, but then the claims are drastically altered in the face of actual evidence. Years later, people are still arguing the initial claim, it's still all over the internet.

And to be clear, .5% is too much. It's still an injustice to somebody, and I'm all in favor of doing what's right by those land-owners. At the same time, claiming that any new building in Ma'al Adumim is "expanding the settlements" and "driving Palestinians off their lands" is just not true. Further, claiming it's the reason behind Palestinian intransigence is nothing short of ignorance. Probably unintentional ignorance by most who push that myth, but certainly not by all.
 
This is typical of the conflict. Initially outrageous claims are made, but then the claims are drastically altered in the face of actual evidence. Years later, people are still arguing the initial claim, it's still all over the internet.
Yup, that's pretty much the problem exactly.
 
The Madness of Israel

Israel has gone barking mad. An elegant demonstration of its madness - of Israel's vicious self-pity - is on display in an article recently published in an Israeli Paper comparing the Palestinians in Gaza to the Nazis.

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4554583,00.html

It was written by a former Israeli General who seems to actually believe Israel's own Black Propaganda. It's Amazing..how Israel is so quickly becoming that which it professes to fear and despise.


Holocaust survivors condemn Israel for 'Gaza massacre,' call for boycott

In response to Elie Wiesel advertisement comparing Hamas to Nazis, 327 Jewish Holocaust survivors and descendants publish New York Times ad accusing Israel of 'ongoing massacre of the Palestinian people.'

"…we are disgusted and outraged by Elie Wiesel’s abuse of our history in these pages to justify the unjustifiable: Israel’s wholesale effort to destroy Gaza and the murder of more than 2,000 Palestinians, including many hundreds of children. Nothing can justify bombing UN shelters, homes, hospitals and universities. Nothing can justify depriving people of electricity and water."
 
In response to Elie Wiesel advertisement comparing Hamas to Nazis, 327 Jewish Holocaust survivors and descendants publish New York Times ad accusing Israel of 'ongoing massacre of the Palestinian people.'

The Germans used the "Big Lie" on order to discredit the Jews and launch a campaign of terror against them. So...you would think that as someone who had been persecuted by the Nazis and their lies, Elie Wiesel would have been inoculated from ever using something as horrible as "The Big Lie" in an effort to persecute others. At least that is what I thought as a younger man. I mean, the thought of Israel using the "Big Lie" to harm others was just incomprehensible to me and I just wouldn't believe it for the longest time. In fact, I used to get into long arguments with my father about the subject and I began to believe that the man was an anti-semite.

Yeah...I really began to believe my own father was an anti-semite: a man whose whole life exemplified a tolerance of others of different cultures and races - and the bravest and kindest man I ever knew. But, as the years went on and the evidence piled up before my eyes, I realized my father was right: Israel is incredibly disfunctional. And while horrors of "The Big Lie' used by the Germans had inoculated many Jews against ever using or being fooled by such a technique - it only gave other Jews a template for the destruction of a people.

The spectacle of Israel believing the "Big Lie" amazes me...and horrifies me. However, I am thankful that we have enough cameras, video equipment and communication networks to insure that Israel can't commit a fast genocide and wipe out the Palestinians before the world could react. Instead, the Israelis will keep holding the Palestinians in great open-air prisons until a resolution can be reached. And while that may not be much consolation to the misery of the Palestinians, at least they'll be alive and there may be hope that things will change one day.
 
However, I am thankful that we have enough cameras, video equipment and communication networks to insure that Israel can't commit a fast genocide and wipe out the Palestinians before the world could react.
Speaking of 'big lies'...
 
Jules Galen,

You've never heard of EMPs, right?

And JihadJane,

If Israel were out to murder gazans, the death toll would be 2,000 in the first hour and you'd have thousands impaled vlad style on the walls of Jerusalem.
 
Or they would simply drop an atomic bomb, and good night Gaza.

No. Israel will not use an Atomic Bomb. One, there are too many Israelis (and others) who would oppose it. Two, even if the Israeli government went rogue and were to use an atomic bomb on the Palestinians, they would become International Pariahs on a scale they had never imagined - and I am sure that Israeli Government knows that. So...let's not even discuss such silliness...even as silliness.

Also, Iran is going to use an Atomic Bomb either. Forget it. The Iranian government can be nasty, but they are not utter fools. If Iran used an Atomic Bomb, the reprecusions for them would even be worse than what Israel would face. Unlike what many Hasbara Puppets would have me believe, I do not believe Iran is suicidal.

In fact, Iran has had 35 years to provoke the US to strike and the US has never really found a reason - because Iran has not given them one. That's a pretty good indicator that despite Iran's "Crazy Talk" their government is a bit more concerned with survival than given credit.
 
Or they would simply drop an atomic bomb, and good night Gaza.

I'm going to agree with Jules here, actually, in disagreement. Gaza is simply not enough of a military target to justify nukes, nor would their use actually improve Israel's security.

As it stands, though, the Israelis have been keeping the death count exceedingly low compared to what they could have done. All they would need to do is stop giving multiple forms of warning and the death toll would be overwhelmingly higher, before getting to choosing targets that would have overwhelmingly more potential when it comes to killed Palestinians.
 
I'm going to agree with Jules here, actually, in disagreement. Gaza is simply not enough of a military target to justify nukes, nor would their use actually improve Israel's security.
You realize I was not being serious, right? I meant, "if Israel was the genocidal maniac Jules pretends they are".
 
You realize I was not being serious, right? I meant, "if Israel was the genocidal maniac Jules pretends they are".

You seem to have a very confused conception of the nature of "Genocide as a Weapon" and the types of people who wield it. Very few nations I know of won't use the Genocide Weapon if given the chance - it's cheap and effective and usually takes the form of famine. Only the truly crazy nations insist that the Genocide Weapon be one of outright murder.

Anyways, the US, UK, USSR, Turkey, Mexico, Germany, Argentina, Qing Empire...etc., etc. have used the Genocide Weapon. Hell...Spain once used the weapon accidentley against the Aztecs by introducing Small Pox and then losing control of their Indian Allies (who literally butchered the Aztecs for food) and who outnumbered the Spanish by 50-to-1 (my WAG).

But...the Genocide Weapon is awfully difficult to use nowadays as ya' can't "hide it" like in the old days, so I don't think Israel will use it. I don't think it's a question of Israel's morals - just that they won't have the opportunity to "get away with it". This observation doesn't imply that Israel is any more, or any less, blood-thirsty than any other nation. Israel is just like any other colonial power - and colonialism is a dirty, nasty business no matter how "We are Moral" BS a country spews (just read some British history - they murdered them by the 10's of Millions - even more than the USSR and Germany combined).
 
You realize I was not being serious, right? I meant, "if Israel was the genocidal maniac Jules pretends they are".

I think I guessed. That post was made while half-asleep, though, so I'm really not sure. Either way, count it as for the lurkers, then.

The British film-maker wants an ‘absolute boycott of all the cultural happenings supported by the Israeli state’ and has labelled the US a ‘bully’ at the Sarajevo film festival

The US is something of a "bully." The large majority of the time, though, it's more a "bully" like parents or grocery stores are "bullies," though.

You seem to have a very confused conception of the nature of "Genocide as a Weapon" and the types of people who wield it. Very few nations I know of won't use the Genocide Weapon if given the chance - it's cheap and effective and usually takes the form of famine. Only the truly crazy nations insist that the Genocide Weapon be one of outright murder.

Anyways, the US, UK, USSR, Turkey, Mexico, Germany, Argentina, Qing Empire...etc., etc. have used the Genocide Weapon. Hell...Spain once used the weapon accidentley against the Aztecs by introducing Small Pox and then losing control of their Indian Allies (who literally butchered the Aztecs for food) and who outnumbered the Spanish by 50-to-1 (my WAG).

But...the Genocide Weapon is awfully difficult to use nowadays as ya' can't "hide it" like in the old days, so I don't think Israel will use it. I don't think it's a question of Israel's morals - just that they won't have the opportunity to "get away with it". This observation doesn't imply that Israel is any more, or any less, blood-thirsty than any other nation. Israel is just like any other colonial power - and colonialism is a dirty, nasty business no matter how "We are Moral" BS a country spews (just read some British history - they murdered them by the 10's of Millions - even more than the USSR and Germany combined).

So, in short, your justification for considering Israel genocidal is that despite Israel not committing genocide in Gaza currently, it wants to? And being awful difficult to hide certainly hasn't stopped... how many actual genocides in the last decade? Either way, I've clarified on that topic before. As things stand, there are a couple accusations that, if true, might be officially be genocide, as relatively weak and likely difficult to as they are to prove. Also with that said, the large majority of people calling Israel genocidal are doing it based on the recent death count in Gaza, where, while Israel may very well be committing very nasty crimes, "genocide" doesn't seem like one of them, based on the actual evidence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom