Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well...we know that Terrorism does not promote peace and Hamas should stop it, and it can be done unilaterally. However, would you agree though that more settlements are not the answer to making peace and that Israel should stop this practice unilaterally?

Yes, personally I would agree building more settlements doesn't help in the peace process, but the settlements in Gaza are gone yet Hamas is still launching missiles and kidnapping civilians.

Settlements in the West Bank on former Jordanian land don't equate to terrorist activities by a group who has a charter that states this: ""The Day of Judgment will not come until Muslims fight the Jews, when the Jew will hide behind stones and trees. The stones and trees will say, 'O Muslims, O Abdullah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him.'

Until you recognize that, your specious arguments will fall on deaf ears and rightly so.
 
Wolf,

That statement that has nothing to do with my question. But, if you would like to answer my question, then please feel free to do so.

Actually it has everything to do with your question. you asked me if I was saying something that had nothing to do with my statement, so I clarified for you exactly what I was saying.
 
Actually it has everything to do with your question. you asked me if I was saying something that had nothing to do with my statement, so I clarified for you exactly what I was saying.

Yeah...I see now.

And I am beginning to see just how psycopathic Hasbara can be. I swear...hard-core Israeli apologists are a nest of vipers. And, until this moment, I never understood just what it was that made the Palestinians so virulently Anti-Semitic - but now I know. And for some strange reason I am scared...really scared...and I don't even know quite why.

I thank you and ProBonoShill for educating me. I think I will go away and be sick for awhile.
 
Yes, personally I would agree building more settlements doesn't help in the peace process, but the settlements in Gaza are gone yet Hamas is still launching missiles and kidnapping civilians.
Or let's put it this way: there are plenty of places in the world where there is occupied land, settlements and repression, and peace. Examples have been posted in this thread. There is, however, not one place in the world where there is a very real threat of suicide bombing, kidnapping or shooting sprees, constant rocket attacks... and peace.

The settlements are criminal, imperialistic, and tragic to the people they may displace, and yes, they should be torn down and removed, probably every single one. To say they're an "obstacle to peace", though, is just narrow-minded.
 
Incidentally...

However, I think we must agree that Israel settling more land is absolutely wrong for any reason

No. The statement is far too broad to be valid. Adding more settlements in the West Bank is inadvisable and is likely a bit stupid, certainly, and it's far from wrong to put pressure on Israel to cease doing so or for Israel to stop doing so, but "absolutely wrong for any reason" has significant inherent problems when applied to nearly any action, with this case being no exception.

I think we must agree that it is theft.

No. If one already has something, especially something gained legally, it's really not theft to use it. Why is this such a hard concept for people like you to understand? Frankly, if you're trying to accommodate the views of a number of Palestinians with claims like that, every inch of Israel has been stolen from them, which, frankly, is neither a "true" stance nor is it in any way conducive to peace in the region.

Can we agree?

Not when your arguments are that poorly considered.
 
Yeah...I see now.

And I am beginning to see just how psycopathic Hasbara can be. I swear...hard-core Israeli apologists are a nest of vipers. And, until this moment, I never understood just what it was that made the Palestinians so virulently Anti-Semitic - but now I know. And for some strange reason I am scared...really scared...and I don't even know quite why.

I thank you and ProBonoShill for educating me. I think I will go away and be sick for awhile.

You're really scared by what? Reality? Cognitive dissonance? That you're sufficiently emotionally invested in the matter that you have difficulty stomaching disagreement? Or your repeatedly demonstrated inability to make valid counter arguments to nearly anything? Either way, it's your failing, rather completely.

I'm saying that regardless of what Israel does in the West Bank, it's nothing to do with Hamas. If Billy punches Bob, that doesn't give you the right to punch Billy, even if Bob is your friend, and when Bob is almost as much of your enemy as Billy, then that certainly doesn't give you that right.

This actually doesn't work at nearly any level. To list off a few points of great relevance, though...

1) Hamas is not solely active politically in Gaza. They have a real presence in the West Bank, too.

2) The Palestinians of Gaza and West Bank consider themselves to be the same people, even if their different governing bodies have had their differences. It's a bit analogous to Democratic and Republican controlled states in the US. There are definite differences in policy and beliefs, but all consider themselves and the others to be fellow citizens of the US, with very few exceptions. On a personal level, the Republican leadership are my enemies on a number of issues, yet I don't wish to see them suffer.

3) Stepping in to defend others generally isn't wrong. Vengeance could be considered wrong, but that has more to do with cultural beliefs and values and what methods are being employed. Still, for this case, it would be far more accurate to have said, "If Billy punches Bob, that doesn't give you the right to punch Billy's young child, even if Bob is your friend." and end it there, when it comes to Hamas' rockets. That is generally much less controversial and certainly more accurate.


When someone in such close proximity to you wants to wipe you off the planet, not sure how you go about resolving that. Especially when it was already attempted not that long ago.

Multiple times, morelike. Not all Palestinians want to destroy Israel, I'm sure, and many more would be content enough to let the issue rest given the comparative benefits and significant increase in their overall quality of life that would be the results of making and maintaining a long term peaceful solution. Unfortunately, too many of them have bought into the value of terrorism as a means to accomplishing any noble goals that they might have, ignoring that it's been overwhelmingly counterproductive on that front, and the leaders who openly praise terrorism and those who intentionally seek martyrdom aren't even remotely trying to change that.
 
Last edited:
IMO, If that all doesn't take the wind out of the Hamas apologists sails, they don't really care about peace as much as they put on.

True.

They never have.All they want is the destruction of Israel .Somehow they think that will hurry up the revolution....

Also true.

Are you saying that it is OK for Israel to take more land for settlements?

I think you should show us exactly where Israel is taking this land. What I see in the news is every time a new building goes up in Ma'ale Adumim the media squawks "new settlements", but that's land that's been purchased by an Israeli developer, and it's not being appropriated from any Palestinian. I think your question is founded on a premise that's in doubt.
 

What you got there is basically an anti-Israel activist trying to dispute factual evidence with nothing more than his own opinion. Even at that, Plitnick acknowledges Salach al-Aruri has been urging Hamas to conduct such a kidnapping, so claiming what Hamas has been trying to do was in fact done by a "rogue element" is nonsensical.

The kicker is it doesn't matter. Either version, that the kidnappings were orchestrated by Hamas or a rogue element within Hamas, both versions blow a hole in your conspiracy theory about how this latest round of violence started.
 
I think you should show us exactly where Israel is taking this land. What I see in the news is every time a new building goes up in Ma'ale Adumim the media squawks "new settlements", but that's land that's been purchased by an Israeli developer, and it's not being appropriated from any Palestinian. I think your question is founded on a premise that's in doubt.


I am assuming that you are quoting someone, because that is the rationale of a scumbag thief - and I figure you are no scumbag thief.
 
On a stranger note, it looks like the Palestinian Authority may be getting ready to take Israel to the International Criminal Court (ICC) over War Crimes and they are supported by Hamas (very strange). Not only would Israel probably be convicted of war crimes (this is pretty much a slam-dunk case) but Hamas would also be open to being prosecuted for War Crimes, too...or some other Crimes. (I mean, I figure Hamas is guilty of something that the ICC can convict them of)

http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/184331#.U_js-1NqirM

If there is a God with a sense of humor, he'll let the Judge be German. That would make me LMAO!
 
Last edited:
So, let's say a black American buys a house and lot in a white neighborhood. Does defending his purchase make one a scumbag theif? :confused:

OMG! Fish in a Barrel!

No. I mean it would be like a Black Guy bought a ranch just outside of Vicksburg, Mississippi and proclaimed it to be part of the Sovereign African State of Liberia!

LMAO! :roll:
 
Did the Israeli developer in Mycroft's example do such a proclamation?

No...because the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) had already done the nastiest work for him (ya' know....shooting Palestinians and driving them off their land and bulldozing their homes), all the developer has to do is accept stolen property.
 
LSSBB, Safe-Keeper,

You people really need to re-think your concept of morality after insisting that Israel "Buys Land" and trying to equate it with a typical lawful land purchase.

Israel forces Palestinians to sell pieces of Palestine and then declares what they have bought to be Israel. It would be as if the Chinese Government forced the US to sell it parts of New York City and declared them the territory of China and under the control of the Sovereign Chinese Government. It is Land Stealing! It is Immoral! And it is a method whereby Israel is tearing Palestine to pieces and destroying it....bit by bit. And worst of all, Israel is making excuses (Hasbara) and thereby inuring millions to the concept of "Theft being Moral".
 
Last edited:
LSSBB, Safe-Keeper,

You people really need to re-think your concept of morality after insisting that Israel "Buys Land" and trying to equate it with a typical lawful land purchase.

Israel forces Palestinians to sell pieces of Palestine and then declares what they have bought to be Israel. It would be as if the Chinese Government forced the US to sell it parts of New York City and declared them the territory of China and under the control of the Sovereign Chinese Government. It is Land Stealing! It is Immoral! And it is a method whereby Israel is tearing Palestine to pieces and destroying it....bit by bit. And worst of all, Israel is making excuses (Hasbara) and thereby inuring millions to the concept of "Theft being Moral".

Boy, you have totally misread me.

You would have been better off responding to Mycroft with counter-example to prove him wrong. No, you had to attack him as immoral, off of one example he provided. Now you go after me.

For what it's worth, I think the settlements as wrong. I have even said so in this forum, I think in this very thread. However, I have learned here and elsewhere to do my best to listen to what others say, and either counter it or acknowledge and learn from it, respectfully.
 
Boy, you have totally misread me.

You would have been better off responding to Mycroft with counter-example to prove him wrong. No, you had to attack him as immoral, off of one example he provided. Now you go after me.

For what it's worth, I think the settlements as wrong. I have even said so in this forum, I think in this very thread. However, I have learned here and elsewhere to do my best to listen to what others say, and either counter it or acknowledge and learn from it, respectfully.

Maybe I have misread you...but maybe I haven't. We'll soon see, and if I am wrong then I will say so.

So...do you think that Israel is Stealing Land from the Palestinians for these "Settlements"?

It is a Yes/No question.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom