Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Quote from that link:



Now Israel isn't totally blameless in this situation, but when you're dealing with scum like this it's kind of hard to take the higher road.

You'd never hear an Israeli leader utter crap like the above.

If Palestinian leadership would commit to peace for a prolonged period of time and enforced that commitment, they would gain the upper hand, Their complaints about settlements, checkpoints and border closings would gain some traction and win them some sympathy. I never understood why they wouldn't go down this path. It made no sense. Then with further research I realized most of them are more interested in dead Jews than having peace.

When someone in such close proximity to you wants to wipe you off the planet, not sure how you go about resolving that. Especially when it was already attempted not that long ago.

IMO, If that all doesn't take the wind out of the Hamas apologists sails, they don't really care about peace as much as they put on.
 
IMO, If that all doesn't take the wind out of the Hamas apologists sails, they don't really care about peace as much as they put on.

They never have.All they want is the destruction of Israel .Somehow they think that will hurry up the revolution....
 
Quote from that link:



Now Israel isn't totally blameless in this situation, but when you're dealing with scum like this it's kind of hard to take the higher road.

You'd never hear an Israeli leader utter crap like the above.

Well...we know that Terrorism does not promote peace and Hamas should stop it, and it can be done unilaterally. However, would you agree though that more settlements are not the answer to making peace and that Israel should stop this practice unilaterally?
 
Well...we know that Terrorism does not promote peace and Hamas should stop it, and it can be done unilaterally. However, would you agree though that more settlements are not the answer to making peace and that Israel should stop this practice unilaterally?

I don't think that I've actually heard support for Israel's settlement policy in the West Bank from... anyone here. I've heard it argued that Israel has sufficient claim on the land that they can, but that they shouldn't for various reasons as the most "supportive" it's generally been here.

With that said, you look like you're trying to directly link the terrorism practiced by Hamas with the Israeli settlements with the way you said that. Frankly, given the history of the matter, it just looks like the settlements serve as little more than an just another easy excuse for the terrorists among the Palestinians to use to "justify" what they were going to do anyways. That isn't a defense of the settlement policies, for the record, it's simply trying to keep things in perspective. The settlements aren't the root of the problem by a long shot.
 
I'm not talking about "Much" progress here...I'm talking some progress, or just ANY progress: something to keep both sides falling into a permanent cycle of thinking that peace is impossible.

You don't get it, Jules. Hamas doesn't think peace is impossible, Hamas thinks peace is undesirable.
 
However, would you agree though that more settlements are not the answer to making peace
Actually, no, I won't, because any sensible party would recognize that if continuous 'fighting' (or in this case terror) caused nothing but more settlements built and more land lost, the rational thing to do would be to stop fighting. To any rational observer, the fact that every time the Arabs attack Israel, they lose people, land or both, should mean that... maybe it's not such a good idea to do so. Which is another reason why I have never understood the "they are just defending their country" crowd.

Had HAMAS been a moderate party capable of rational thought, they would have signed a peace treaty a long time ago.
 
Actually, no, I won't, because any sensible party would recognize that if continuous 'fighting' (or in this case terror) caused nothing but more settlements built and more land lost, the rational thing to do would be to stop fighting. To any rational observer, the fact that every time the Arabs attack Israel, they lose people, land or both, should mean that... maybe it's not such a good idea to do so. Which is another reason why I have never understood the "they are just defending their country" crowd.

Had HAMAS been a moderate party capable of rational thought, they would have signed a peace treaty a long time ago.

I don't get it. Just because Hamas are a bunch of Creeps, does this mean that Israel must act wrongly, too?

1. We know Hamas can stop terrorism unilaterally and I bet the UN could help pressure them to stop.

2. Israel can also stop taking land unilaterally....if they want.

One of the examples above is not tied to the other, they are just examples and I can think of many more, but they can be preformed unilaterally and they would show good will to the other side and the World Community.

Now, Hamas might be stupid and not stop terror...but they face more than Israel if they do, they also face UN condemnation and a slowing of funds. Israel can stop settlements...and this would do a lot for them. Both are the right things to do and are the moral high road.
 
You don't get it, Jules. Hamas doesn't think peace is impossible, Hamas thinks peace is undesirable.

Sometimes, maybe it's best that Israel doesn't worry about what Creeps like Hamas do and just do the right thing. Just because one is a Creep doesn't give the other a valid reason to become a Creep.
 


You shouldn't get your news from yahoo. ;)

No, Hamas Did Not Take Responsibility For Three Israeli Youths’ Kidnapping And Murder

Mitchell Plitnick said:
[...] What did al-Aruri say? According to reports, he said: “It has been said that it is an Israeli conspiracy, and I say it isn’t…The al-Qassam’s mujahedeen were the ones to carry out [the abduction] in show of support for the prisoners’ hunger strike.”

Now, let’s examine this. Al-Aruri was addressing a very different point than the one being made by the media. He was talking about the belief, held by many, that Israel staged the kidnapping and murders in order to take the actions they subsequently set out upon. It’s an absurd theory, but I’ve seen it quite a bit in the past months. So, al-Aruri wanted to make it clear that this was a Palestinian act.

In fact, we know that the Qawasmeh clan in Hebron carried out the crime. The Qawasmehs are a powerful clan, and have often taken action not just without authorization from Hamas, with which they are strongly affiliated, but sometimes intentionally to foil or change Hamas’ plans and strategy. You can read more about this here. But the Qawasmehs are connected with Hamas’ military wing, the Izz ad-din al-Qassam Brigades. So, all al-Aruri said was what we already knew: the Qawasmehs carried out the act.

If their motivation was, as al-Aruri said, to support the struggle of the Palestinian prisoners held by Israel, their tactics failed miserably. That issue was becoming quite vexing for Israel through non-violent means such as hunger strikes and protests. Since the murders, the issue of the prisoners has fallen off the map completely. Even Hamas ignores it in their demands to Israel, speaking only of the prisoners Israel took during its massive sweep in the West Bank in June. Gaza has completely eclipsed the issue of the prisoners.

Al-Aruri, no doubt, is delighted with this media coverage. Based on his cheerleading when the incident first took place and his words now, he wants Hamas to be “credited” for that despicable act which has also sparked off so much destruction in Gaza. But that doesn’t mean anything has changed. His words do nothing to change the estimate of what happened in June. Unfortunately, the media is making sure it does, and the Israeli government and Hamas, each for their own reasons, are likely to go along with the lie. [...]
 
I don't get it. Just because Hamas are a bunch of Creeps, does this mean that Israel must act wrongly, too?

The next question is... Is Israel necessarily acting in a morally wrong way when it demonstrates the negative consequences of reprehensible actions and makes it as obvious as possible that it's more sensible to make real peace sooner than later?

1. We know Hamas can stop terrorism unilaterally and I bet the UN could help pressure them to stop.

That's actually somewhat questionable. Hamas could certainly take a number of official steps that could change their status away from "terrorist" and put themselves in a position where they could negotiate (not coerce, like they're trying to do now) a lasting peace, but taking those steps would be reasonably likely to very significantly weaken their position, given that a number of those steps would require completely betraying what they stand for or allowing the possibility of real political opposition to exist in the first place. I somewhat doubt that UN pressure would mean much, either, other than cutting the foreign aid that they receive, which, even then, might well just make the martyrdom parts of Palestinian culture more prevalent, which would cause the situation to worsen even more.

2. Israel can also stop taking land unilaterally....if they want.

Incidentally, it's a little hard to "take" what one already has. Frankly, there are valid arguments against the settlements, in which the "stealing land" or "taking land" red herrings play little to no part.

Now, Hamas might be stupid and not stop terror... but they face more than Israel if they do, they also face UN condemnation and a slowing of funds. Israel can stop settlements...and this would do a lot for them. Both are the right things to do and are the moral high road.

The Palestinians not having terrorists as their leaders and representatives would indeed be a huge step forward. Israel not pointedly stirring up the Palestinians would likely be a large step forward, too.
 
I'm no conspiracy theorist, but something in me tells me that there are enough people on both sides of the conflict, who for whatever reasons have no desire for peace and are actively working to make sure there is none, to make peace impossible in that region
 
Last edited:
Hamas has executed 18 Palestinians as informers, and another rocket reaches into Israel.

At least 18 Palestinians accused of spying for Israel were executed Friday in the Gaza Strip on the orders of a self-appointed Palestinian “revolutionary court,” Hamas-linked media and witnesses reported.

Meanwhile, in the southern Israeli city of Ashdod, a rocket fired from Gaza made a direct hit on a synagogue, badly damaging the structure and causing minor injuries to at least two people, Israeli media said.
 
I don't get it. Just because Hamas are a bunch of Creeps, does this mean that Israel must act wrongly, too?
If you stopped putting words in our mouths, maybe that would help. I never said Israel should act wrongly, for any reason.
 
If you stopped putting words in our mouths, maybe that would help. I never said Israel should act wrongly, for any reason.

I did not mean to attribute words to anyone. However, I think we must agree that Israel settling more land is absolutely wrong for any reason: I think we must agree that it is theft.

Can we agree?
 
I did not mean to attribute words to anyone. However, I think we must agree that Israel settling more land is absolutely wrong for any reason: I think we must agree that it is theft.

Can we agree?

If the people of the West Bank hadn't rejected Hamas, and they were the ones firing the thousands of rockets into Israel, or Israel was building settlements in Gaza, you might have a point. However since the People of the West Bank have installed Fatah as their leadership, and Israel pulled their Settlements out of Gaza years ago, what is happening in the West Bank is little more than an excuse that Hamas uses to continue its declared mission.
 
If the people of the West Bank hadn't rejected Hamas, and they were the ones firing the thousands of rockets into Israel, or Israel was building settlements in Gaza, you might have a point. However since the People of the West Bank have installed Fatah as their leadership, and Israel pulled their Settlements out of Gaza years ago, what is happening in the West Bank is little more than an excuse that Hamas uses to continue its declared mission.

Are you saying that it is OK for Israel to take more land for settlements?
 
Last edited:
What would Gaza be like if Hamas hadn't squandered all the money it has received on military equipment and military infrastructure (badly)?
How many schools, hospitals, and housing units could have been built with the supplies used to build their futile tunnel system?
Israel would likely have lifted any embargoes years ago if Hamas would just help their own electorate.
 
Are you saying that it is OK for Israel to take more land for settlements?

I'm saying that regardless of what Israel does in the West Bank, it's nothing to do with Hamas. If Billy punches Bob, that doesn't give you the right to punch Billy, even if Bob is your friend, and when Bob is almost as much of your enemy as Billy, then that certainly doesn't give you that right.
 
I'm saying that regardless of what Israel does in the West Bank, it's nothing to do with Hamas. If Billy punches Bob, that doesn't give you the right to punch Billy, even if Bob is your friend, and when Bob is almost as much of your enemy as Billy, then that certainly doesn't give you that right.

Wolf,

That statement that has nothing to do with my question. But, if you would like to answer my question, then please feel free to do so.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom