Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ladies and gentlemen of the Jury, my client had 1000 bullets and he could have killed a 1000 people but he limited himself to only killing 300 of the villagers he attacked. I ask you isn't that a demonstration of his goodness as compared to those heinous villagers who viciously attacked him trying to break his economic and physical stranglehold on their lives. They were intending to kill him and his entire ilk had they just had enough firepower to do it.

How can you condemn a man who only killed 300 people when he could have killed 1000 and feel pity for the vile villagers who were intending to kill him all along had they had the ability to do it.

I call upon you good ladies and gentlemen of the jury, you must acquit my client of all crime he committed because he could have done more but did not while his victims wanted to do more killing than my client did but he stopped them.

I know I have no proof for what the vicious victims would or would not have done, but come on surely their intentions were made clear by them attacking him while he was terrorizing them. If they never intended to kill him why did they not just lie down and take it peacefully.

Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, who do you think is the more heinous, my client who only killed 300 villagers when he could have killed a 1000 had he wanted to, or his violent victims who wanted to kill my client and his entire family if only they could have?

The verdict is in. Hamas is guilty.
 
Ladies and gentlemen of the Jury, my client had 1000 bullets and he could have killed a 1000 people but he limited himself to only killing 300 of the villagers he attacked. I ask you isn't that a demonstration of his goodness as compared to those heinous villagers who viciously attacked him trying to break his economic and physical stranglehold on their lives. They were intending to kill him and his entire ilk had they just had enough firepower to do it.

How can you condemn a man who only killed 300 people when he could have killed 1000 and feel pity for the vile villagers who were intending to kill him all along had they had the ability to do it.

I call upon you good ladies and gentlemen of the jury, you must acquit my client of all crime he committed because he could have done more but did not while his victims wanted to do more killing than my client did but he stopped them.

I know I have no proof for what the vicious victims would or would not have done, but come on surely their intentions were made clear by them attacking him while he was terrorizing them. If they never intended to kill him why did they not just lie down and take it peacefully.

Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, who do you think is the more heinous, my client who only killed 300 villagers when he could have killed a 1000 had he wanted to, or his violent victims who wanted to kill my client and his entire family if only they could have?
Dodge noted:).
 
Oh Leumas, you really do try so hard to take Hamas's side. It's not easy backing those who aspire to actual genocide, is it? But you do put in a good effort.
I do love it when people condemn Israel for killing civilians, while remaining apologists for a regime that actually does intentionally kill as many civilians as they can. Would be cute and funny if there weren't that damned many of them...

Sure, there is room for improvement in Israel and the IDF. How much is open to discussion, but yes, there is. This doesn't, however, mean that you can support terrorist organizations such as HAMAS. Doing so boils down to nothing but a "but, but Israel" defense that every sensible person in here is sick and tired of by now.
 
ANd I notice that in another thread a couple of the more militant Hamas Supporters here seem to be taking the side of ISIS in Iraq now that US Action against ISIS has de facto begun. Why am I not surprised?
 
Last edited:
Kumar may well have been a troll, but he was a very good parody of this -- whenever we talked about Westerners and Israelis killing civilians, he would act all furious and use it as justification to condemn the Western world, but when it was Russians or Palestinians doing something wrong, he would frantically try to justify or excuse them or just change the subject to some random Israeli or American wrongdoing.

I've said it before, but I really, really want to do a blind test someday where I take a lot of people and give them various scenarios to ponder, for then to rank each on a scale of 1-10, from where 1 is utter condemnation and 10 is total support. Only I'll divide the test recipients into groups, with the country changed from group to group (for example Norway, Canada, Russia, and Israel). My hypothesis is that my test subjects will rank the actions as significantly more immoral when they're done by Israelis.

Come to think of it, I don't even need to do blind tests, I can look at the news. When Israel bombs the residential houses of HAMAS' leaders, it's on every Norwegian news channel and condemned by lots of Norwegians. When the Norwegian Air Force did exactly the same thing in Libya, destroying the houses of the Libyan leadership, it was apparently not newsworthy. Then the IDF did the same thing in Gaza in the latest offensive, and all of a sudden it's all over the news again.

Sigh.
 
In every picture I see of a bombed building in Gaza with a bunch of people picking through the rubble, my mind draws a red circle around one of them and labels it "new terrorist".

The problem with this thinking is it presumes that person in your red circle is incapable of abstract reasoning. He can't see the relationship between the rockets Hamas fires, and the incoming Israeli fire that destroyed that building. Instead, he's purely driven by violent emotion.

The truth is he's just as capable of abstract and complex reasoning as anyone else, and you're actually dehumanizing him this way.
 
It's not easy backing those who aspire to actual genocide, is it?


I think you emphasized the wrong word in your post….. here is how it should be

Oh It's not easy backing those who aspire to actual genocide, is it?


A person who ASPIRES to rape is a vile person indeed, regardless of the legal considerations that prohibit the prosecution of his thought crime.

On the other hand, I’m much more inclined to decry the rapist who is actually raping right now after having repeatedly raped in the past. And I am inclined to beseech the lawyers and judges to bring the legal system down upon him with its severest punishments.

But in your vitiated standards you are condemning the intent of a crime while at the same time hailing the action of committing the very same crime.

Well, that is your business but the law is clearly not in agreement with you there.

However I do know of a system that agrees with you wholeheartedly. Judging from the pages of history replete with fascists and oppressors, these systems in fact agree with your topsy turvy illogic of squashing people for their thoughts of revenge against their oppression while self-justifying their own actual crimes as righteously justifiable…. if only those criminals and terrorists just accepted their place.


Oh Leumas, you really do try so hard to take Hamas's side.


A Jew is hardly going to take Hamas' side is he.

A Jew nevertheless, obviously can and should be the first to sympathize and understand why a people might want to fight an oppressor and yes even want to kill the oppressor for the misery and indignity he has put them through.

Moreover a Jew can understand that oppressing people and putting them in what amounts to concentration camps and collectively punishing them for resisting is an anti-Humanistic crime and not just a crime when it is anti-Semitic.

Having suffered anti-Semitism as a child in school a Jew should understand the hatred and desire for revenge one can feel against his TORMENTORS and wanting to pay them back for the humiliation and injuries and loss of property. He should sympathize with the feeling of impotence in not being able to exact retribution.


But you do put in a good effort.


Yes INDEED.... it certainly takes a lot of effort to not wish to punish just anyone for the crimes of the people who tormented one in school just for being a scrawny geeky Jewish boy. (by the way none of them were Palestinians or even Muslim, they were all Christians).

Yes it does take a lot of self-control and a higher level of thought to not beat up on the weaker than oneself just to vent the frustration at not being able to bring to justice the ones who did in fact persecute one.

If you are Jewish, I hope that you can see that
  • Palestinians in refugee camps and Bantustans in the West Bank and Gaza are probably the only human beings on earth that do not have a citizenship of a place on earth.
  • They are being held prisoners behind walls and fences under military occupation being humiliated and oppressed for decades without prospects or dignity in an Apartheid situation much like the South Africans did to the Blacks of South Africa.
  • Their lands are being gradually and irrevocably carved away and their houses demolished to make space for people from other countries to live there, some of whom have dual citizenships of Israel and other countries and can vote in both countries and can travel around the world while the Palestinians are being herded into ever shrinking open air prisons.
  • Every time they boil over and can no longer bear the atrocities that have been dished out to them since 1967 till today they BENIGHTEDLY try (like any human being in the same situation has and will throughout history) to fight back only to get squashed by GOLIATH and regressed even further.
  • The world stopped the White South Africans from continuing to do this to the Blacks of South Africa but no one is rallying to do the same for the Palestinians in Israel.
  • Until this is achieved, if ever, there will continue to be a SHAMEFUL MAJOR HUMAN RIGHTS ATROCITY being committed on a daily basis by a people who ought to be the last to ever commit atrocities on other people because they should know better than most what it is like to be faced by the business end of the rifles and tank cannons of a juggernaut of hateful racist soldiers who regard them as worthless sub-humans who ought to be extirpated to make way for the super race.


If you are just a Zionist-Christian…. oh well
 
Last edited:
The problem with this thinking is it presumes that person in your red circle is incapable of abstract reasoning. He can't see the relationship between the rockets Hamas fires, and the incoming Israeli fire that destroyed that building. Instead, he's purely driven by violent emotion.

The truth is he's just as capable of abstract and complex reasoning as anyone else, and you're actually dehumanizing him this way.



I wish you would exercise those one day!

You have much less of an excuse for not doing so than a shell-shocked almost illiterate victim of war who has just crawled from under the rubble of his entire society.
 
Last edited:
Fairly top notch.

It spun the point of Hamas trying and failing to destroy Israel into someone who merely wants to commit a crime but doesn't.

It managed to bring in the settlement issue, which even Israel's supporters disagree with, even though Hamas is in Gaza where there are no settlements.

It managed to spin killing civilians as a byproduct of fighting an enemy that chose a civilian filled battleground into punishing the civilians instead of the enemy.

And of course, no rant like that is complete without Apartheid and Holocaust comparisons, despite the lack of an actual Apartheid state or genocide.

I'm deducting one for going on about hateful, racist, subhumans enough to get people's mind on the idea that maybe there's something other than fair analysis behind it, but overall, four out of five rocket launchers.



Good Job.
 
Rockets fired from Gaza into Israel. Sure took them long enough:rolleyes:. Anyone else reminded of the Black Knight in that Monty Python sketch who insists on fighting the knights who don't want to fight him, even after his arms and legs have been chopped off?
 
It spun the point of Hamas trying and failing to destroy Israel into someone who merely wants to commit a crime but doesn't.
I was impressed by that, too; that, and so elegantly conflating what HAMAS and the IDF do, albeit in a highly illogical "a stone can't fly, Mother can't fly, thus Mother is a stone" kind of way.
 
Last edited:
I think you emphasized the wrong word in your post…..

You're right. I should have emphasized "genocide".

A person who ASPIRES to rape is a vile person indeed, regardless of the legal considerations that prohibit the prosecution of his thought crime.

Oh, I see. Hamas is merely guilty of thought crimes.

A novel defense of terrorism, no doubt, but not as good as your previous effort.

If you are Jewish, I hope that you can see that

I have never stated whether or not I am Jewish. I am not going to state that. It shouldn't matter, and it's troubling (but not unexpected) that you try to bring up the question.
 
You quoted me. You did not respond to my argument. These are not equivalent.

When I quote your words (as I'm doing now) I address what I'm quoting to show I'm responding. Again, if you are going to claim I ignore anything you said then state exactly what you said which I ignored.

The fact that Hamas has guns, and so will not be driven out of power without a violent fight. You seem to believe that rebuilding will magically remove Hamas's influence, but you have presented no argument for how that can possibly happen without disarming Hamas.
You stated that Hamas has guns mean that they'll not lose power, no? I stated that guns may not intimidate the Palestinian, just as Israel's force/guns did not intimidate them. There is no magic, I stated that rebuilding is one step towards loosening Hamas' influence. I don't know how much I can repeat that. I addressed that many times but you ignore it and state I don't. Israel's attack isn't 'disarming Hamas' it contributes to Hamas' influence.

And you have glossed over Hamas's power over and over as well.
Glossed Hamas' power? I've acknowledged their power, my statements were on ways to reducing it.

You can aim for stability all you want to, Hamas will not let you achieve it.
Apparently neither will Israel.

The only support Hamas needs is money. They can get that from Qatar (and Qatar doesn't give a **** about the Palestinians either). As long as they have money, they can buy guns, and that's all they really need.
Hamas needs the chaotic situation in Gaza.

Indeed it is a necessary step. But you have no idea how to accomplish it.

It is in the sense of whether or not people feel they have been treated justly, which is the relevant sense here. Whether or not you believe in some universal scale of justice doesn't matter for our discussion.
It isn't subjective, it is based on laws and equality, etc.

That you need to be more articulate about exactly what you meant. There were apparently necessary qualifiers that you left out of your statement. Without those qualifiers, your statement was false.
You keep making blank statements without showing what you are referring to.

Of course they could have done something. They could have launched guerilla attacks against our occupying army. They did not.
If you recall in WW2, the Japanese fought back and it is said they would've fought to death, each citizen. The reason they did not is because they got orders from the emperor who was viewed as a God. You comparison to what occurred with the Japanese to Palestine-Israel doesn't relate in anyway. You propose that the Palestinians should be pacifist-like as the Japanese seem to be after the WW but they can't be as it is a constant issue with Israel. Even the Japanese were not, and would've continued had not the emperor stated otherwise.
You keep bringing up Japan vs the Allies without realizing that it has nothing related to this situation.

You have claimed that the Palestinian response to Israel (namely, terrorist attacks) is the result of terrible conditions inflicted upon them by Israel. Yet we inflicted far worse against the Japanese, yet the results are very different. From this we can conclude that the degree of external stress applied to a society is not the only (and maybe not even the primary) determinant of how that society acts. Other factors matter. Yet you don't consider other factors. You dismiss Japan, but you can't even tell me why. You merely declare it irrelevant.
I didn't mention terrorist attacks. The animosity that Palestinians feel towards Israel is a result of the treatment they face. You can speak to some or you can read on their responses to see this for yourself.
What was the different result? Japanese attacked back, they did not respond passively. Japanese faced what in comparison to the Palestinians? -They had strategic bombings on buildings/homes etc in the same way but they did not have constant issues as raids, land-grabbing issues, border restrictions, etc. All the factors imposed on the Palestinians, Japan did not go through during WW2. Comparing the two societies is irrelevant You've not stated how it is relevant other than both were bombed badly and faced a huge lost in civilian life

No, it wouldn't, because that's not how the argument works. Examples don't "cancel".
If you state that Japan's reaction to the US means that Palestine's reaction to Israel should be similar (or out of the norm), then showing another country's reaction that is similar to Palestine's reaction to Israel refutes your point.

Again, you cannot explain why.
I don't care if you want to call it a cycle. Your proposal for how to break the cycle doesn't make sense.
What is your proposal to break the animosity cycle? What I stated makes sense, you can address it and state what you're having trouble with.

I'm not going to make your argument for you.
I'm not arguing that Japan's situation in WW2 is similar to the Israel-Palestine conflict. It you who try to make that a point ignoring the other factors Palestinians have to face which were not experienced by the Japanese, as well as how the situation differ greatly.
Note: The Japanese fought during the war, to death. The attacks stopped after they surrendered. The US did not go back and impose border restrictions or held mass arrest, and so forth. The Japanese were left to rebuild their country and eventually their economy. Even the emperor was not removed. Had they been subjected to continual 'bad' treatment even after the conflict will they not lash back or held marches against it as the blacks in SA?

Then you have no idea of whether or not their efforts will suffice, do you? And if their efforts do not suffice, if a much larger effort would be required, who then shall carry it out?
Their effort may/may not be enough to rebuild all of Palestine. I will not know since they've not stated the full extended of their efforts. Common sense states that with the step on infrastructure, more will be necessary to bring economic-social stability, as opening the restrictions to the outside world and making Palestine more independent than dependent. As well as added thing. The effort is in the right direction and I see nothing to indicate that it will hinder progress. Then again, I don't see why you're concern since you stated that you're indifferent.

Their plans are not top-secret.
Really? You have access to the plans of the UN, you have access to the building blue-print? It is not in the public domain.

Of course they're not in charge of Gaza, because they're not in Gaza. Why would you even put forward such a nonsense response?
To demonstrate that 'guns' doesn't necessarily mean that the population will support under intimidation. Israel has used forced/guns on the Palestinians and it didn't stop the Palestinians from objecting their actions. Same with Hamas if some Palestinians don't see them as a necessity (necessity in protection against Israel). If you read the context that the sentence was said in and the response you gave that it was directed to then you'll understand.

This is incoherent. I have no idea what you even mean here.
Again, see above. Taking a line out of context and quoting, of course wouldn't make you understand what is said.

I have never objected to rebuilding in and of itself, as long as it's not my money. I've only objected to believing that this will solve things. It will not. Just like it hasn't in the past each time it's been tried.
If you believe that it will not be a step to solving anything then that's still your opinion. I've stated how it is a step and I'd like to see more done on the matter (but alas, I have no personal power to). It is an important step in loosing Hamas' support and how it can assess the Palestinians. It is a benefit to them to have a rebuilding and not live among rubble, esp. on the mindset.

Israel's force method throughout the years has not accomplished 'peace' or 'stability', it has fueled the opposite.
 
Last edited:
Should Israel be pardoned from criticism based on 'others are doing worse' or when making criticism on Israel a person must also include criticism on the other to level out the criticism?

Perhaps it can work that way. Maybe persons expect more of Israel since they've invested so much taxpayers money in it.
 
Should Israel be pardoned from criticism based on 'others are doing worse' or when making criticism on Israel a person must also include criticism on the other to level out the criticism?

No, but no one has actually made that argument. The argument isn't 'others' are doing worse, but the direct enemy of Israel that they are fighting are doing worse and trying to do worse to them and to their own people. It's that the agency for stopping the violence completely right now rests with Hamas. Israel could (and has several times) stop bombing, but Hamas will not. Israel doesn't target civilians but their direct enemy in this specific fight targets civilians and uses their own as human shield and their deaths propaganda tools. Rewarding such actions encourages more such actions.

It isn't that criticisms of Israel are not allowed. It is that the criticisms are unfair, unrealistic, and a standard no other country is held to, not just Hamas. I'm critical of the current bombing and occupation, but not because it's inherently wrong to attack cites that are attacking you and who you are at war with, but because going after these, other wise valid, objectives will likely be detrimental to the big picture. Short term goals vs long term goals.

Perhaps it can work that way. Maybe persons expect more of Israel since they've invested so much taxpayers money in it.

Then why can't I expect more from the Palestinians who also receive taxpayer money? You don't buy control for security choices because your money went to it.
 
You stated that Hamas has guns mean that they'll not lose power, no? I stated that guns may not intimidate the Palestinian, just as Israel's force/guns did not intimidate them.

Israelis try not to kill civilians. The Palestinians know that, and exploit that. Hamas is perfectly willing to kill civilians. This the Palestinians know as well. So guns in the hands of Hamas are in fact considerably more intimidating. Furthermore, when your enemy has a gun and you don't, then in a fight you'll be the one who ends up dead. And when you're dead, it kind of doesn't matter if you're not intimidated.

There is no magic, I stated that rebuilding is one step towards loosening Hamas' influence. I don't know how much I can repeat that.

Repeating it won't make it true. And saying that it's not magic isn't an explanation either. Hamas will seize anything valuable for their own purposes. They will do so with guns. Nobody will stop them. So how will this newly rebuilt infrastructure loosen Hamas's influence? You still have no answer.

I addressed that many times but you ignore it and state I don't. Israel's attack isn't 'disarming Hamas' it contributes to Hamas' influence.

I never said that it was disarming Hamas. It is, however, reducing the stockpile of rockets that Hamas has, and destroying the tunnels that Hamas has dug to infiltrate Israel. So it is, in fact, doing something to reduce the threat that Hamas poses to Israel. Yes, it doesn't remove Hamas from power within Gaza, but 1) you don't want Israel to do what it would take to accomplish that, because it would be incredibly brutal to the Palestinian civilians that Hamas hides behind, 2) Israel doesn't really want to do that, because it would be a bloody conflict for their own soldiers, and 3) it's not ultimately Israel's problem that Hamas is oppressing Palestinian civilians.

Glossed Hamas' power? I've acknowledged their power, my statements were on ways to reducing it.

No. You keep pretending that Hamas's power is only due to public opinion. It is not. Therefore it cannot be removed by a mere change in public opinion.

Apparently neither will Israel.

False. If Hamas did not attack Israel, then Israel would not have attacked Gaza. They would permit all the rebuilding that anyone wanted to occur. It is Hamas, and Hamas alone, that is to blame for the infrastructure damage that this conflict has produced.

Hamas needs the chaotic situation in Gaza.

True. But you don't seem to grasp the logical consequence of that. If they need chaos, and you try to bring in order, what exactly do you think will happen? Why, they will produce chaos. How can you stop them? You have no plan, no idea, not even a notion of what would occur.

It isn't subjective, it is based on laws and equality, etc.

No. Justice and law are not synonymous (you are a fool if you think they are), if you meant that the Palestinians had suffered illegally (which laws?) then you should have said so, and equality of what? Different forms of equality are mutually exclusive.

You keep making blank statements without showing what you are referring to.

Follow the thread of quotes and you'll see. But it doesn't matter at this point anyways.

If you recall in WW2, the Japanese fought back and it is said they would've fought to death, each citizen. The reason they did not is because they got orders from the emperor who was viewed as a God.

In other words, internal societal values matter. Now, what are the Palestinian societal values? What role do they play in this conflict?

I didn't mention terrorist attacks.

You cannot evaluate the situation logically, let alone fairly, if you do not consider terrorist attacks against Israel in your analysis. Is this, then, an admission that you are not doing so?

The animosity that Palestinians feel towards Israel is a result of the treatment they face.

Israel didn't attack Gaza because of the way that Palestinians feel. They attacked Gaza because of what Hamas did. And the feelings of Palestinians do not justify those actions.

What is your proposal to break the animosity cycle?

The same thing that breaks most "cycles" (more traditionally known as wars): victory for one side, defeat (and an acknowledgment of that defeat) for the other.

Note: The Japanese fought during the war, to death. The attacks stopped after they surrendered.

Quite so: and we didn't stop attacking Japan until they surrendered. We defeated them, they accepted defeat, and that's how the "cycle of violence" ended. If we had not defeated Japan, then they would have continued to fight us.

The US did not go back and impose border restrictions or held mass arrest, and so forth.

Yes we did. We occupied their country (which includes controlling access to their borders), dictated their laws, rounded up LOTS of their citizens and put them in prison, and executed a fair number of them as well.

The Japanese were left to rebuild their country and eventually their economy.

No, they were not left to do that. They lived under military occupation for years, from 1945 to 1952. During that period, Japan had NO independence. Are you really so ignorant of history that you were unaware of this?

Their effort may/may not be enough to rebuild all of Palestine. I will not know since they've not stated the full extended of their efforts.

In other words, despite having no clue as to whether or not they can do what you want, you're still putting them forward as the parties who will do what you want.

Not terribly convincing stuff there.

Common sense states that with the step on infrastructure, more will be necessary to bring economic-social stability, as opening the restrictions to the outside world and making Palestine more independent than dependent. As well as added thing. The effort is in the right direction and I see nothing to indicate that it will hinder progress. Then again, I don't see why you're concern since you stated that you're indifferent.

Common sense states that this will do no more good than all the past efforts at doing exactly the same thing.

Really? You have access to the plans of the UN, you have access to the building blue-print? It is not in the public domain.

Don't be an idiot. I'm not talking about blueprints. I doubt they have blueprints yet, since they don't know how much money they'll raise and they don't know what exactly will need fixing. But I'm sure they've stated fundraising goals, haven't they? That will give a scale to their plans.

If you believe that it will not be a step to solving anything then that's still your opinion.

And it's an opinion I've backed up with logic, evidence, and history, and you have not countered.
 
Israelis try not to kill civilians. The Palestinians know that, and exploit that. Hamas is perfectly willing to kill civilians. This the Palestinians know as well. So guns in the hands of Hamas are in fact considerably more intimidating. Furthermore, when your enemy has a gun and you don't, then in a fight you'll be the one who ends up dead. And when you're dead, it kind of doesn't matter if you're not intimidated.
-The action of Israel doesn't support this (though they state it via words). The IDF has killed unarmed civilians and used force in and out of the spike in conflict, so yes, the Palestinians can sensibly see a threat to their lives if they march, etc. Force is used on them as well. Hamas doesn't position itself as a treat to the regular Palestinian, it position itself as a 'protector'. Your conclusion that should the Palestinians see Hamas as an aggressor towards them that they'll be intimidated by the guns falls short.
On your last two sentences, I've seen in history the opposite, protesting at the risk of ones life was done. Life is meaningless with restrictions, etc. All a person has is just that and what will there be to lose by standing up to the one who is armed?
Do you understand that having a gun will not mean that intimidation will be successful?

Repeating it won't make it true. And saying that it's not magic isn't an explanation either. Hamas will seize anything valuable for their own purposes. They will do so with guns. Nobody will stop them. So how will this newly rebuilt infrastructure loosen Hamas's influence? You still have no answer.
-It is true on it's own. You stated that it is magic, I've stated that it isn't 'magic', that isn't an explanation but a correction to your statement. I've also explained how it can be a step towards stability. As stated before, stability loosens Hamas' influence on the minds of their supporters because their main argument for being a necessity is to create stability and protect against an oppressor. Also, these infrastructure (schools, hospitals, etc) gives the Palestinians something to hope towards and work towards in comparison to leaving them to live in rubble without basic infrastructure.

I never said that it was disarming Hamas. It is, however, reducing the stockpile of rockets that Hamas has, and destroying the tunnels that Hamas has dug to infiltrate Israel. So it is, in fact, doing something to reduce the threat that Hamas poses to Israel. Yes, it doesn't remove Hamas from power within Gaza, but 1) you don't want Israel to do what it would take to accomplish that, because it would be incredibly brutal to the Palestinian civilians that Hamas hides behind, 2) Israel doesn't really want to do that, because it would be a bloody conflict for their own soldiers, and 3) it's not ultimately Israel's problem that Hamas is oppressing Palestinian civilians.
Then you're stating that it is not disarming Hamas? Hamas' threat to Israel is less than it was before the conflict? -No. Israel doesn't care for Palestinian casualties. Let's not pretend here. Their action through and through on the Palestinians doesn't make them an innocent party.

No. You keep pretending that Hamas's power is only due to public opinion. It is not. Therefore it cannot be removed by a mere change in public opinion.
I've not stated that 'Hamas' power is only due to public opinion'. I have stated through out that Hamas' support is important to their 'power'. They need the chaos to have themselves viewed as a necessity. Also, for recruitment, they need to have support. I've stated that their power can be loosen by removing this.
Is this clear to you or will you make another strawman?

False. If Hamas did not attack Israel, then Israel would not have attacked Gaza. They would permit all the rebuilding that anyone wanted to occur. It is Hamas, and Hamas alone, that is to blame for the infrastructure damage that this conflict has produced.
-This is more than the physical attacks on Gaza. There is the issue on building on lands that Palestinians considers their own, unjust arrests & raids, etc. The issue is much more than the strategic bombings. Israel is not trusted, just as Israel doesn't trust Hamas.

True. But you don't seem to grasp the logical consequence of that. If they need chaos, and you try to bring in order, what exactly do you think will happen? Why, they will produce chaos. How can you stop them? You have no plan, no idea, not even a notion of what would occur.
-You assume that they'll bring 'chaos'. Should infrastructure be setup (and it has been) you're stating that Hamas will destroy them because they'll bring stability to Palestine? Within Hamas there will be individuals whose goal is to bring stability. How will they explain that to the population when they're now the aggressor? What you state makes no sense, if you think it out. If that was the case then Hamas would've leveled all the buildings as soon as they were built.

No. Justice and law are not synonymous (you are a fool if you think they are), if you meant that the Palestinians had suffered illegally (which laws?) then you should have said so, and equality of what? Different forms of equality are mutually exclusive.
I didn't state that they were synonymous words (why are you dancing around semantics? Creating an argument then stating it is foolish to think differently from your created argument). What will stop a person from stating stealing a woman's purse is justice? The statement that you are discussing is based on your previous statement that the Palestinians faced 'bad treatment' and further stating that you didn't say it was 'unjust' bad treatment. So it was 'just' bad treatment? And if so, on what grounds do you view it as 'just'? If not on legislation.

Follow the thread of quotes and you'll see. But it doesn't matter at this point anyways.
I have followed the thread and you do make blank statements while quoting. As that one. Quote and not address what is stated.

In other words, internal societal values matter. Now, what are the Palestinian societal values? What role do they play in this conflict?
What societal values? I stated very clearly that the the Japanese fought back in WW2 and they would've fought to death had not the Emperor gave the orders. How does this relate to societal values? It is based on your statement that the Palestinians could act the same way the Japanese did (you claim that they didn't fight back or hold animosity after the war) but this situation in Palestine isn't an 'after-war' it is a continuous situation they're facing.

You cannot evaluate the situation logically, let alone fairly, if you do not consider terrorist attacks against Israel in your analysis. Is this, then, an admission that you are not doing so?
-Don't move the goal post. You stated that I 'claimed that the Palestinian response to Israel (namely, terrorist attacks) is the result of terrible conditions', I'm stating that I didn't mention 'terrorist' attacks as you claimed I did. If you want to include 'terrorist' attacks by Hamas as having its roots in the way they feel mistreated by Israel then state it as your own point. I'm specific on what I directly say instead of adding on more.

Israel didn't attack Gaza because of the way that Palestinians feel. They attacked Gaza because of what Hamas did. And the feelings of Palestinians do not justify those actions.
-And how does that change the point that the Palestinians feel animosity to Israel based on how they are treated? Note that this is more than the attacks on Gaza.

The same thing that breaks most "cycles" (more traditionally known as wars): victory for one side, defeat (and an acknowledgment of that defeat) for the other.
-Wars don't break 'animosity cycles'. As can be seen even in this situation.

Quite so: and we didn't stop attacking Japan until they surrendered. We defeated them, they accepted defeat, and that's how the "cycle of violence" ended. If we had not defeated Japan, then they would have continued to fight us.
-Defeat is what occurs after fighting, stating that if they weren't 'defeated' they would've kept fighting is redundant. The Palestinians don't position themselves as being defeated and don't wish to allow an 'Israel take over'.
btw, you think that all will be peaceable between Palestine and Israel if one bombs the other flat and occupy? The occupation by Israel wasn't successful.

Yes we did. We occupied their country (which includes controlling access to their borders), dictated their laws, rounded up LOTS of their citizens and put them in prison, and executed a fair number of them as well.
The US didn't go back. They remained and did not put border restrictions, neither falsely arrest citizens. The execution was on military. Palestine has not been 'defeated', it is an area with imposed border restrictions (by Israel & Egypt) and false arrest of its citizens. There was/is no agreement or permission by Palestine for any of those things to take place as it was for Japan.
If your goal is to have Israel bomb Palestine into submission, take over its laws/government, imprison its citizens, etc, then state that this is your wish.

No, they were not left to do that. They lived under military occupation for years, from 1945 to 1952. During that period, Japan had NO independence. Are you really so ignorant of history that you were unaware of this?
Is this your proposal for Palestine? It has failed so far in Afghanistan and Iraq but continue. This is your proposal?

In other words, despite having no clue as to whether or not they can do what you want, you're still putting them forward as the parties who will do what you want.

Not terribly convincing stuff there.
Don't be an idiot. I'm not talking about blueprints. I doubt they have blueprints yet, since they don't know how much money they'll raise and they don't know what exactly will need fixing. But I'm sure they've stated fundraising goals, haven't they? That will give a scale to their plans.
It was sarcasm to your statement that their plans are 'not top secret' so somehow I should know the scope/scale of their plans.

They've stated that they're doing a rebuilding and yes, they are capable of carrying out that pledge, I've not placed them as 'parties who will do what I want', I've placed them as parties who stated publicly that they will be engaging in rebuilding works. I acknowledge that their in-dept plans that you wanted to know was not available to the public but will be known by members within the organisation.

Common sense states that this will do no more good than all the past efforts at doing exactly the same thing.
The past efforts of rebuilding has contributed. Leaving the Palestinians in rubble is a better alternative in what way?

And it's an opinion I've backed up with logic, evidence, and history, and you have not countered.
An opinion based on logic, evidence and history? You stated that rebuilding the buildings will do nothing for the situation due to looting that took place in the past on a greenhouse building (history), neglecting the fact that hospitals, schools that were built helped the Palestinians towards a seemingly normal life. You've not backed your opinion with anything of substance, man, be serious.
You've not stated any logical reasons as to why infrastructure will not be a necessary step towards stability in Palestine.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom