Israelis try not to kill civilians. The Palestinians know that, and exploit that. Hamas is perfectly willing to kill civilians. This the Palestinians know as well. So guns in the hands of Hamas are in fact considerably more intimidating. Furthermore, when your enemy has a gun and you don't, then in a fight you'll be the one who ends up dead. And when you're dead, it kind of doesn't matter if you're not intimidated.
-The action of Israel doesn't support this (though they state it via words). The IDF has killed unarmed civilians and used force in and out of the spike in conflict, so yes, the Palestinians can sensibly see a threat to their lives if they march, etc. Force is used on them as well. Hamas doesn't position itself as a treat to the regular Palestinian, it position itself as a 'protector'. Your conclusion that should the Palestinians see Hamas as an aggressor towards them that they'll be intimidated by the guns falls short.
On your last two sentences, I've seen in history the opposite, protesting at the risk of ones life was done. Life is meaningless with restrictions, etc. All a person has is just that and what will there be to lose by standing up to the one who is armed?
Do you understand that having a gun will not mean that intimidation will be successful?
Repeating it won't make it true. And saying that it's not magic isn't an explanation either. Hamas will seize anything valuable for their own purposes. They will do so with guns. Nobody will stop them. So how will this newly rebuilt infrastructure loosen Hamas's influence? You still have no answer.
-It is true on it's own. You stated that it is magic, I've stated that it isn't 'magic', that isn't an explanation but a correction to your statement. I've also explained how it can be a step towards stability. As stated before, stability loosens Hamas' influence on the minds of their supporters because their main argument for being a necessity is to create stability and protect against an oppressor. Also, these infrastructure (schools, hospitals, etc) gives the Palestinians something to hope towards and work towards in comparison to leaving them to live in rubble without basic infrastructure.
I never said that it was disarming Hamas. It is, however, reducing the stockpile of rockets that Hamas has, and destroying the tunnels that Hamas has dug to infiltrate Israel. So it is, in fact, doing something to reduce the threat that Hamas poses to Israel. Yes, it doesn't remove Hamas from power within Gaza, but 1) you don't want Israel to do what it would take to accomplish that, because it would be incredibly brutal to the Palestinian civilians that Hamas hides behind, 2) Israel doesn't really want to do that, because it would be a bloody conflict for their own soldiers, and 3) it's not ultimately Israel's problem that Hamas is oppressing Palestinian civilians.
Then you're stating that it is not disarming Hamas? Hamas' threat to Israel is less than it was before the conflict? -No. Israel doesn't care for Palestinian casualties. Let's not pretend here. Their action through and through on the Palestinians doesn't make them an innocent party.
No. You keep pretending that Hamas's power is only due to public opinion. It is not. Therefore it cannot be removed by a mere change in public opinion.
I've not stated that 'Hamas' power is only due to public opinion'. I have stated through out that Hamas' support is important to their 'power'. They need the chaos to have themselves viewed as a necessity. Also, for recruitment, they need to have support. I've stated that their power can be loosen by removing this.
Is this clear to you or will you make another strawman?
False. If Hamas did not attack Israel, then Israel would not have attacked Gaza. They would permit all the rebuilding that anyone wanted to occur. It is Hamas, and Hamas alone, that is to blame for the infrastructure damage that this conflict has produced.
-This is more than the physical attacks on Gaza. There is the issue on building on lands that Palestinians considers their own, unjust arrests & raids, etc. The issue is much more than the strategic bombings. Israel is not trusted, just as Israel doesn't trust Hamas.
True. But you don't seem to grasp the logical consequence of that. If they need chaos, and you try to bring in order, what exactly do you think will happen? Why, they will produce chaos. How can you stop them? You have no plan, no idea, not even a notion of what would occur.
-You assume that they'll bring 'chaos'. Should infrastructure be setup (and it has been) you're stating that Hamas will destroy them because they'll bring stability to Palestine? Within Hamas there will be individuals whose goal is to bring stability. How will they explain that to the population when they're now the aggressor? What you state makes no sense, if you think it out. If that was the case then Hamas would've leveled all the buildings as soon as they were built.
No. Justice and law are not synonymous (you are a fool if you think they are), if you meant that the Palestinians had suffered illegally (which laws?) then you should have said so, and equality of what? Different forms of equality are mutually exclusive.
I didn't state that they were synonymous words (why are you dancing around semantics? Creating an argument then stating it is foolish to think differently from your created argument). What will stop a person from stating stealing a woman's purse is justice? The statement that you are discussing is based on your previous statement that the Palestinians faced 'bad treatment' and further stating that you didn't say it was 'unjust' bad treatment. So it was 'just' bad treatment? And if so, on what grounds do you view it as 'just'? If not on legislation.
Follow the thread of quotes and you'll see. But it doesn't matter at this point anyways.
I have followed the thread and you do make blank statements while quoting. As that one. Quote and not address what is stated.
In other words, internal societal values matter. Now, what are the Palestinian societal values? What role do they play in this conflict?
What societal values? I stated very clearly that the the Japanese fought back in WW2 and they would've fought to death had not the Emperor gave the orders. How does this relate to societal values? It is based on your statement that the Palestinians could act the same way the Japanese did (you claim that they didn't fight back or hold animosity after the war) but this situation in Palestine isn't an 'after-war' it is a continuous situation they're facing.
You cannot evaluate the situation logically, let alone fairly, if you do not consider terrorist attacks against Israel in your analysis. Is this, then, an admission that you are not doing so?
-Don't move the goal post. You stated that I 'claimed that the Palestinian response to Israel (namely, terrorist attacks) is the result of terrible conditions', I'm stating that I didn't mention 'terrorist' attacks as you claimed I did. If you want to include 'terrorist' attacks by Hamas as having its roots in the way they feel mistreated by Israel then state it as your own point. I'm specific on what I directly say instead of adding on more.
Israel didn't attack Gaza because of the way that Palestinians feel. They attacked Gaza because of what Hamas did. And the feelings of Palestinians do not justify those actions.
-And how does that change the point that the Palestinians feel animosity to Israel based on how they are treated? Note that this is more than the attacks on Gaza.
The same thing that breaks most "cycles" (more traditionally known as wars): victory for one side, defeat (and an acknowledgment of that defeat) for the other.
-Wars don't break 'animosity cycles'. As can be seen even in this situation.
Quite so: and we didn't stop attacking Japan until they surrendered. We defeated them, they accepted defeat, and that's how the "cycle of violence" ended. If we had not defeated Japan, then they would have continued to fight us.
-Defeat is what occurs after fighting, stating that if they weren't 'defeated' they would've kept fighting is redundant. The Palestinians don't position themselves as being defeated and don't wish to allow an 'Israel take over'.
btw, you think that all will be peaceable between Palestine and Israel if one bombs the other flat and occupy? The occupation by Israel wasn't successful.
Yes we did. We occupied their country (which includes controlling access to their borders), dictated their laws, rounded up LOTS of their citizens and put them in prison, and executed a fair number of them as well.
The US didn't go back. They remained and did not put border restrictions, neither falsely arrest citizens. The execution was on military. Palestine has not been 'defeated', it is an area with imposed border restrictions (by Israel & Egypt) and false arrest of its citizens. There was/is no agreement or permission by Palestine for any of those things to take place as it was for Japan.
If your goal is to have Israel bomb Palestine into submission, take over its laws/government, imprison its citizens, etc, then state that this is your wish.
No, they were not left to do that. They lived under military occupation for years, from 1945 to 1952. During that period, Japan had NO independence. Are you really so ignorant of history that you were unaware of this?
Is this your proposal for Palestine? It has failed so far in Afghanistan and Iraq but continue. This is your proposal?
In other words, despite having no clue as to whether or not they can do what you want, you're still putting them forward as the parties who will do what you want.
Not terribly convincing stuff there.
Don't be an idiot. I'm not talking about blueprints. I doubt they have blueprints yet, since they don't know how much money they'll raise and they don't know what exactly will need fixing. But I'm sure they've stated fundraising goals, haven't they? That will give a scale to their plans.
It was sarcasm to your statement that their plans are 'not top secret' so somehow I should know the scope/scale of their plans.
They've stated that they're doing a rebuilding and yes, they are capable of carrying out that pledge, I've not placed them as 'parties who will do what I want', I've placed them as parties who stated publicly that they will be engaging in rebuilding works. I acknowledge that their in-dept plans that you wanted to know was not available to the public but will be known by members within the organisation.
Common sense states that this will do no more good than all the past efforts at doing exactly the same thing.
The past efforts of rebuilding has contributed. Leaving the Palestinians in rubble is a better alternative in what way?
And it's an opinion I've backed up with logic, evidence, and history, and you have not countered.
An opinion based on logic, evidence and history? You stated that rebuilding the buildings will do nothing for the situation due to looting that took place in the past on a greenhouse building (history), neglecting the fact that hospitals, schools that were built helped the Palestinians towards a seemingly normal life. You've not backed your opinion with anything of substance, man, be serious.
You've not stated any logical reasons as to why infrastructure will not be a necessary step towards stability in Palestine.