Ziggurat, I have addressed your words. You can look back, I have addressed each of your postings by quoting thus far.
You quoted me. You did not respond to my argument. These are not equivalent.
What is it that I am ignoring that you're referring to?
The fact that Hamas has guns, and so will not be driven out of power without a violent fight. You seem to believe that rebuilding will magically remove Hamas's influence, but you have presented no argument for how that can possibly happen without disarming Hamas.
The importance of rebuilding has been placed forward over and over.
And you have glossed over Hamas's power over and over as well.
You've stated that it doesn't matter what gets rebuilt but it does matter if the aim is towards stability.
You can aim for stability all you want to, Hamas will not let you achieve it.
Hamas draws its so-called support from the chaotic situation and the displacement, etc.
The only support Hamas needs is money. They can get that from Qatar (and Qatar doesn't give a **** about the Palestinians either). As long as they have money, they can buy guns, and that's all they really need.
Removing Hamas will not guarantee stability in Gaza, it will however be a necessary step along with rebuilding.
Indeed it is a necessary step. But you have no idea how to accomplish it.
Justice is subjective? -ok.
It is in the sense of whether or not people feel they have been treated justly, which is the relevant sense here. Whether or not you believe in some universal scale of justice doesn't matter for our discussion.
Then what were you trying to say?
That you need to be more articulate about exactly what you meant. There were apparently necessary qualifiers that you left out of your statement. Without those qualifiers, your statement was false.
What they feel is important since actions are based on that. The Japanese could not have done anything
Of course they could have done something. They could have launched guerilla attacks against our occupying army. They did not.
and I see no correlation between the situation the Japanese faced with the US and what the Palestinians face with Israel (or vice versa).
You have claimed that the Palestinian response to Israel (namely, terrorist attacks) is the result of terrible conditions inflicted upon them by Israel. Yet we inflicted far worse against the Japanese, yet the results are very different. From this we can conclude that the degree of external stress applied to a society is not the only (and maybe not even the primary) determinant of how that society acts. Other factors matter. Yet you don't consider other factors. You dismiss Japan, but you can't even tell me why. You merely declare it irrelevant.
Wouldn't an example of two countries that continue a conflict and hold animosity though out cancel off your example?
No, it wouldn't, because that's not how the argument works. Examples don't "cancel".
You're selecting an incident that doesn't stand up
Again, you cannot explain why.
I'm not supporting Hamas' attacks neither Israel's actions here (in and out of the spike conflict). I do however acknowledge where the animosity will stem from and how this can be a cycle.
I don't care if you want to call it a cycle. Your proposal for how to break the cycle doesn't make sense.
Will you be applying your correlation between how the Japanese were attacked with how Israel response? Since you propose it, then let us apply it in that situation.
I'm not going to make your argument for you.
Then you have no idea of whether or not their efforts will suffice, do you? And if their efforts do not suffice, if a much larger effort would be required, who then shall carry it out?
as anyone else who are not in the position within organisation to know the plans set out.
Their plans are not top-secret.
Israel has guns and they're not in-charge
Of course they're not in charge of Gaza, because they're not
in Gaza. Why would you even put forward such a nonsense response?
they've not managed to intimidate the Palestinians into keeping quiet, as you can see, there are incidences with marches etc. It is more than a treat to someone's life.
This is incoherent. I have no idea what you even mean here.
You're free to that opinion. If you're indifferent then I'm guessing that you'll raise no more objections towards a rebuilding.
I have never
objected to rebuilding in and of itself, as long as it's not my money. I've only objected to believing that this will solve things. It will not. Just like it hasn't in the past each time it's been tried.