Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Stating you've 'provided an argument' doesn't mean you have provided anything.

True. But the argument has still been provided, multiple times, in multiple posts. Ignoring it won't make it go away.

Rebuilding is a step towards stability in Palestine, it is not that complicated.

Yet it is not sufficient, not even close. But you pretend that it is.

How can life continue when most of the buildings are destroyed and proper infrastructure is not present?

Obviously life does continue, because this is not a new situation, and the Palestinians are not all dead. Furthermore, many groups have been subjected to much harsher conditions without turning towards terrorism. Terrorism is not the inevitable result of being treated badly.

Look at the comment left above.

That doesn't answer my question. Who will do the rebuilding? Will Norway do the rebuilding? Will the UN do the rebuilding? Why is this such a hard question to answer directly? Why can you not simply say, "X will do the rebuilding", where X is the party of your choice?

My position that Palestine should be rebuilt?

No, your position that this will bring peace and disempower Hamas.

If you don't want any rebuilding that's your position.

It is not my position. I have never expressed that position.
 
They've been doing this for years and years and year now. If you think the goal is to create peace, then we must conclude that these efforts are a failure. Why would we expect the same thing to suddenly succeed now? That disjunction between repeated past experience and future expectation is often put forth as the definition of insanity.

Even Ban Ki Moon seems to have gotten the message.

"We will build again, but this must be the last time to rebuild," Ban told the UN assembly in New York. "This must stop now. They must go back to the negotiating table. We must spare no effort to turn the current calm into a durable cease-fire that addresses the underlying issues of the conflict: ending rocket fire from Gaza, weapons smuggling, opening the (Gaza) crossings, lifting the blockade and bringing Gaza back under one Palestinian government that accepts and adheres to the PLO commitments."

Meanwhile ... Hamas Holds "Victory Rally" in Gaza.
 
True. But the argument has still been provided, multiple times, in multiple posts. Ignoring it won't make it go away.
I've addressed everything you've stated via quoting.

Yet it is not sufficient, not even close. But you pretend that it is.
I ask again, how isn't a rebuilding of Palestine (infrastructure, homes, etc) that where destroyed not a move towards stability?

Obviously life does continue, because this is not a new situation, and the Palestinians are not all dead. Furthermore, many groups have been subjected to much harsher conditions without turning towards terrorism. Terrorism is not the inevitable result of being treated badly.
Ah, you acknowledge that there is unjust 'bad' treatment. Let me gather what you're trying to say here, and be open and correct me if I'm understanding you wrongly. 'Life' goes on because not all the Palestinians are dead even when surrounded by rubles they should be capable of maintaining a normal or functioning life and that should be sufficient. No rebuilding, etc. Due to other groups (who ever they are) being in 'harsher conditions' and not retaliating or feeling anger to the ones who they view as the oppressor, the Palestinians should move on (even though said circumstances continue).

?

That doesn't answer my question. Who will do the rebuilding? Will Norway do the rebuilding? Will the UN do the rebuilding? Why is this such a hard question to answer directly? Why can you not simply say, "X will do the rebuilding", where X is the party of your choice?
They are the two parties in recent news who stated their willingness (or pledge) to rebuild. I don't need to makeup a party to rebuild. I am stating who has positioned themselves to do it.

No, your position that this will bring peace and disempower Hamas.
My position is that it will be a step towards stability and loosen Hamas' power on the minds of Palestinians. I've stated other factors that will work with this one.

It is not my position. I have never expressed that position.
Then you'll want a rebuilding to occur? I only assumed that you didn't based on your arguments against rebuilding. But if you think that rebuilding should occur then you hold that there is a measure of importance to it. What will that importance be? (Unless you don't, in which case, clearly state it)
 
We treated Japan far worse than Israel has treated Gaza.

I've generally heard the example of the US-Vietnam conflict more often in this context, on making that point (well, within swedish discourse that is). E.g, bombing out a village or area of 200 people just to get half a dozen potentially/somewhat confirmed Viet Cong combatants or storage thereof. Of course, many times it can be a bit shifty and shakey when using cross-world conflicts into context of local ones.
 
Jono, there are Palestinians who don't support Hamas, I don't know the percentage but that will be a strong position and an important factor.
I agree it is ignorance, but it is also based on experience and I see that on both sides when reading on the opinions of the Israeli & Palestinian civilians. What other option will a Palestinian have? There is a distrust towards Israel, Egypt & US as well as the PA, etc. Hamas positions itself as 'being against those who pose the restrictions/injustice'. How will they be able to sustain their position in a stable Palestine, with no blockade? That is just my take on how a pro-Hamas Palestinian might reason. I'd like to chat with one to find out instead of having to assume.
You said that 'when you have little else but blood to give, that is exactly what you give', why would it be necessary to sacrifice oneself in a stable environment? There has to be a cause to fight against.

Sure but as true as "you can't bomb Hamas out of Gaza" is, the same accuracy probably rests in the prediciton; "you can't rebuild Hamas out of Gaza". Look at Saudi Arabia. It's a conglomerate of western engineering and brilliance, soaked up into a deserty archaic theocracy pulled at times by the horses of war for money, other times for religion (sounds familiar?). That socio-economical (et al) stability is a general benefit for, and a required part of, peaceful relations is not really debatable. But I find myself very hesitant to believe it would perform the round-about change you hope/believe it would.

I work with several people who hail from Palestine. Now, the reasons for this escapes me, none of them support Hamas (for one, it was partly why he had to get away) yet all of them (as near as I can tell) have little but contempt for Israel due to the clinging idea/memory of past offences. And it is exactly that I was referring to earlier; the idea of victimhood and how it fills one's identity (something both sides of the conflict excel at ad naseum), regardless of how 'good' or 'bad' one really has it.
 
Sure but as true as "you can't bomb Hamas out of Gaza" is, the same accuracy probably rests in the prediciton; "you can't rebuild Hamas out of Gaza". Look at Saudi Arabia. It's a conglomerate of western engineering and brilliance, soaked up into a deserty archaic theocracy pulled at times by the horses of war for money, other times for religion (sounds familiar?). That socio-economical (et al) stability is a general benefit for, and a required part of, peaceful relations is not really debatable. But I find myself very hesitant to believe it would perform the round-about change you hope/believe it would.

I work with several people who hail from Palestine. Now, the reasons for this escapes me, none of them support Hamas (for one, it was partly why he had to get away) yet all of them (as near as I can tell) have little but contempt for Israel due to the clinging idea/memory of past offences. And it is exactly that I was referring to earlier; the idea of victimhood and how it fills one's identity (something both sides of the conflict excel at ad naseum), regardless of how 'good' or 'bad' one really has it.

I believe that that stability is one step and an important one as it will have an effect on the mentality of the Palestinians and lessen some of the points Hamas drive across as 'justification' for attacks. It will not be an overnight change but one important factor towards an overall stability/ self-sustaining Palestine.
I have in my mind that infrastructure as schools, etc and a socio-economical stability will affect a citizen's mindset, esp in the minds of the younger ones. The contempt is based on the past and current actions by Israel/Hamas but wouldn't a stability bring a cutting point? Victimhood can only go so far back.
 
Your tone isn't really encouraging me to want to engage you, no. And you're welcome for the correction.

You shouldn't focus on perceived tones but only on what is stated and address points. Just a recommendation for online/offline debating/discussing since 'tones' are only based on personal perception and has a high chance of being wrong esp online. I don't recall swearing at you or attacking you on a personal level. I admit my points can come off as strong since I focus on what is said. You're welcome for the advice/tip.
 
I've addressed everything you've stated via quoting.

Nope. Not once have you put forth any coherent argument for how Hamas can be removed from power.

I ask again, how isn't a rebuilding of Palestine (infrastructure, homes, etc) that where destroyed not a move towards stability?

Because it will not actually do anything to remove Hamas from power.

Ah, you acknowledge that there is unjust 'bad' treatment.

I said nothing about "unjust", which is a subjective opinion anyways.

Let me gather what you're trying to say here, and be open and correct me if I'm understanding you wrongly. 'Life' goes on because not all the Palestinians are dead even when surrounded by rubles they should be capable of maintaining a normal or functioning life and that should be sufficient.

You said nothing about "normal" or "functioning". And neither did I.

Due to other groups (who ever they are) being in 'harsher conditions' and not retaliating or feeling anger to the ones who they view as the oppressor, the Palestinians should move on (even though said circumstances continue).

What they feel is not the problem. What they do is the problem. I'm sure plenty of Japanese felt considerable anger towards the US in the wake of WW2. But it is what they did that mattered.

Have the terrorist attacks committed by Palestinians towards the Israelis actually accomplished anything for the Palestinians? Has it in any way lessened or relieved their plight? No, it has not. Therefore, why should it continue? Why does it continue?

They are the two parties in recent news who stated their willingness (or pledge) to rebuild. I don't need to makeup a party to rebuild. I am stating who has positioned themselves to do it.

And what is the scale of their proposed effort? Is it sufficient to meet what you expect are the needs?

You don't actually have any idea, do you?

My position is that it will be a step towards stability and loosen Hamas' power on the minds of Palestinians.

The people with the guns will always be the ones in charge. Will your proposed efforts do anything to change who has the guns?

No, it will not.

Then you'll want a rebuilding to occur?

I am not opposed to or in favor of rebuilding right now, I am indifferent to it. If you want to spend YOUR money on rebuilding Gaza while Hamas is in charge, go ahead. I don't want to spend any of mine on that doomed project, because it's a waste. It's futile. It will accomplish nothing so long as Hamas is in charge. But I won't try to stop you.
 
Carlitos, if you want a response or feedback, it'll be best you speak up and expand on your points. Also, hint if you'll be responding back or it'll be bypassed again.
[I hope that you didn't read that in a a harsh tone.]
 
I am waiting for all the people condemning Israel to also condemn the actions of ISIS in what amounts to genocide againsts infidels in Iraq. I am not holding my breath, though.
 
Nope. Not once have you put forth any coherent argument for how Hamas can be removed from power.
Ziggurat, I have addressed your words. You can look back, I have addressed each of your postings by quoting thus far. What is it that I am ignoring that you're referring to? The importance of rebuilding has been placed forward over and over. You've stated that it doesn't matter what gets rebuilt but it does matter if the aim is towards stability. It is an important factor to have the Palestinians in a close to 'comfortable' position and have access to basic infrastructure.

Because it will not actually do anything to remove Hamas from power.
Hamas draws its so-called support from the chaotic situation and the displacement, etc. It will be important to consider to reducing Hamas' power.
Removing Hamas will not guarantee stability in Gaza, it will however be a necessary step along with rebuilding.

I said nothing about "unjust", which is a subjective opinion anyways.
Justice is subjective? -ok. Then it is a just bad treatment. -Understood.

You said nothing about "normal" or "functioning". And neither did I.
Then what were you trying to say? That is my point.

What they feel is not the problem. What they do is the problem. I'm sure plenty of Japanese felt considerable anger towards the US in the wake of WW2. But it is what they did that mattered. Have the terrorist attacks committed by Palestinians towards the Israelis actually accomplished anything for the Palestinians? Has it in any way lessened or relieved their plight? No, it has not. Therefore, why should it continue? Why does it continue?
What they feel is important since actions are based on that. The Japanese could not have done anything and I see no correlation between the situation the Japanese faced with the US and what the Palestinians face with Israel (or vice versa). Wouldn't an example of two countries that continue a conflict and hold animosity though out cancel off your example? You're selecting an incident that doesn't stand up against this one being discussed. I'm not supporting Hamas' attacks neither Israel's actions here (in and out of the spike conflict). I do however acknowledge where the animosity will stem from and how this can be a cycle.
Will you be applying your correlation between how the Japanese were attacked with how Israel response? Since you propose it, then let us apply it in that situation.

And what is the scale of their proposed effort? Is it sufficient to meet what you expect are the needs?

You don't actually have any idea, do you?
I'll not know the scale, as anyone else who are not in the position within organisation to know the plans set out. I do know however what they've stated which is setting out plans to rebuild, no doubt the UN will be rebuilding their buildings that Israel destroyed, apart from that more might be stated on the matter later on since this is the early stages.

The people with the guns will always be the ones in charge. Will your proposed efforts do anything to change who has the guns?

No, it will not.
Israel has guns and they're not in-charge, they've not managed to intimidate the Palestinians into keeping quiet, as you can see, there are incidences with marches etc. It is more than a treat to someone's life. It will loosen Hamas' power on the minds of the Palestinians (those who support them or deem them a necessity).

I am not opposed to or in favor of rebuilding right now, I am indifferent to it. If you want to spend YOUR money on rebuilding Gaza while Hamas is in charge, go ahead. I don't want to spend any of mine on that doomed project, because it's a waste. It's futile. It will accomplish nothing so long as Hamas is in charge. But I won't try to stop you.
You're free to that opinion. If you're indifferent then I'm guessing that you'll raise no more objections towards a rebuilding.
 
Ziggurat, I have addressed your words. You can look back, I have addressed each of your postings by quoting thus far.

You quoted me. You did not respond to my argument. These are not equivalent.

What is it that I am ignoring that you're referring to?

The fact that Hamas has guns, and so will not be driven out of power without a violent fight. You seem to believe that rebuilding will magically remove Hamas's influence, but you have presented no argument for how that can possibly happen without disarming Hamas.

The importance of rebuilding has been placed forward over and over.

And you have glossed over Hamas's power over and over as well.

You've stated that it doesn't matter what gets rebuilt but it does matter if the aim is towards stability.

You can aim for stability all you want to, Hamas will not let you achieve it.

Hamas draws its so-called support from the chaotic situation and the displacement, etc.

The only support Hamas needs is money. They can get that from Qatar (and Qatar doesn't give a **** about the Palestinians either). As long as they have money, they can buy guns, and that's all they really need.

Removing Hamas will not guarantee stability in Gaza, it will however be a necessary step along with rebuilding.

Indeed it is a necessary step. But you have no idea how to accomplish it.

Justice is subjective? -ok.

It is in the sense of whether or not people feel they have been treated justly, which is the relevant sense here. Whether or not you believe in some universal scale of justice doesn't matter for our discussion.

Then what were you trying to say?

That you need to be more articulate about exactly what you meant. There were apparently necessary qualifiers that you left out of your statement. Without those qualifiers, your statement was false.

What they feel is important since actions are based on that. The Japanese could not have done anything

Of course they could have done something. They could have launched guerilla attacks against our occupying army. They did not.

and I see no correlation between the situation the Japanese faced with the US and what the Palestinians face with Israel (or vice versa).

You have claimed that the Palestinian response to Israel (namely, terrorist attacks) is the result of terrible conditions inflicted upon them by Israel. Yet we inflicted far worse against the Japanese, yet the results are very different. From this we can conclude that the degree of external stress applied to a society is not the only (and maybe not even the primary) determinant of how that society acts. Other factors matter. Yet you don't consider other factors. You dismiss Japan, but you can't even tell me why. You merely declare it irrelevant.

Wouldn't an example of two countries that continue a conflict and hold animosity though out cancel off your example?

No, it wouldn't, because that's not how the argument works. Examples don't "cancel".

You're selecting an incident that doesn't stand up

Again, you cannot explain why.

I'm not supporting Hamas' attacks neither Israel's actions here (in and out of the spike conflict). I do however acknowledge where the animosity will stem from and how this can be a cycle.

I don't care if you want to call it a cycle. Your proposal for how to break the cycle doesn't make sense.

Will you be applying your correlation between how the Japanese were attacked with how Israel response? Since you propose it, then let us apply it in that situation.

I'm not going to make your argument for you.

I'll not know the scale

Then you have no idea of whether or not their efforts will suffice, do you? And if their efforts do not suffice, if a much larger effort would be required, who then shall carry it out?

as anyone else who are not in the position within organisation to know the plans set out.

Their plans are not top-secret.

Israel has guns and they're not in-charge

Of course they're not in charge of Gaza, because they're not in Gaza. Why would you even put forward such a nonsense response?

they've not managed to intimidate the Palestinians into keeping quiet, as you can see, there are incidences with marches etc. It is more than a treat to someone's life.

This is incoherent. I have no idea what you even mean here.

You're free to that opinion. If you're indifferent then I'm guessing that you'll raise no more objections towards a rebuilding.

I have never objected to rebuilding in and of itself, as long as it's not my money. I've only objected to believing that this will solve things. It will not. Just like it hasn't in the past each time it's been tried.
 
We know that Israel could kill many more if they wanted. What should be asked is if Hamas could kill as many Israelis as they wanted, how many would they kill?


Ladies and gentlemen of the Jury, my client had 1000 bullets and he could have killed a 1000 people but he limited himself to only killing 300 of the villagers he attacked. I ask you isn't that a demonstration of his goodness as compared to those heinous villagers who viciously attacked him trying to break his economic and physical stranglehold on their lives. They were intending to kill him and his entire ilk had they just had enough firepower to do it.

How can you condemn a man who only killed 300 people when he could have killed 1000 and feel pity for the vile villagers who were intending to kill him all along had they had the ability to do it.

I call upon you good ladies and gentlemen of the jury, you must acquit my client of all crime he committed because he could have done more but did not while his victims wanted to do more killing than my client did but he stopped them.

I know I have no proof for what the vicious victims would or would not have done, but come on surely their intentions were made clear by them attacking him while he was terrorizing them. If they never intended to kill him why did they not just lie down and take it peacefully.

Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, who do you think is the more heinous, my client who only killed 300 villagers when he could have killed a 1000 had he wanted to, or his violent victims who wanted to kill my client and his entire family if only they could have?
 
Oh Leumas, you really do try so hard to take Hamas's side. It's not easy backing those who aspire to actual genocide, is it? But you do put in a good effort.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom