tyr_13
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Aug 8, 2008
- Messages
- 18,095
I've not come across someone who supports Hamas, their actions will continue with or without criticisms towards Israel.
Some of them yes, others no. Hamas wouldn't use as many human shields if they were not gaining from it. They wouldn't fire from schools and UN buildings if there were more adverser consequences for doing so. Criticizing Israel when these human shields are hit and when UN buildings are used in these ways means that the UN won't change their policy regarding Hamas because the citizens of their countries aren't pressuring for things to be done to stop Hamas from doing so. Instead they will focus on what their citizens are focusing on. That would be criticisms of Israel attacking Hamas sites in this case.
I think voicing (as is done in social media) raises the issue and opens it to be discussed.
Sadly that's not the mainly the case. You and others are not 'starting a discussion' or 'just asking questions'. Much of what I see from my liberal friends (I'm a liberal, ask Zig) is false. This isn't just to say I believe them wrong, but that factual claims are untrue. Straight propaganda and lies, including wrong history and lack of context, is not 'opening a discussion' it is 'advancing a viewpoint' or 'stating a conclusion'.
Others might criticize only to voice their concerns without knowing whether it will change or not. I have doubts on if those who have the power to change things will go against their set agenda. Looking back at the demonstrations against certain government activities (as protests against going to war). Without criticizing Israel means that a person is in agreement or looks as if they're in agreement. If there is no one to speak on their actions (in and out of the conflict), Hamas will not stop based on this but Israel will continue and see nothing wrong with bombing market places or UN schools without being accountable. Countries are questioned and Israel is not an exception. The US use of drones for example has been questioned and spoken out against, this was not a 'punishment' to the US but for them to step up. If someone criticizes Hamas, I don't see this as a reward for Israel and a punishment for Palestine. They're directing their view and are free to that. But ideally, yes, both should occur (I've seen that the UN did it by condemning both sides) but criticism shouldn't be refuted with a 'this does this and you say nothing', instead it can just be directly addressed.
Yes, not every criticism is a punishment or reward. I haven't said that. Some are however, and some lead to punishment or reward. Again, what do you want done about Israel? What measures? Do you seek to persuade them? Do you seek to persuade us so that we support different measures than we currently do? I wish to persuade people into more evidence based measures, and measures that I hope will improve the situation. I hope to persuade them away from actions that will cause more unneeded harm.
I meant that it is a statement by Israel and remains as a statement, than as an action.
What is a statement by Israel? That they have stopped bombing and Hamas keeps attacking them? No, that is action and fact, not just a statement. I hope you meant something else but I can't tell what.
That should be raised when ISIS is being discussed unless there is a comparison being made between ISIS and Israel.
This line here is one of the more telling things about your mindset and you would be well advised to analyze it. Why only Israel? You're shutting out comparisons arbitrarily.
If a person views Israel as they do ISIS then I can see how that might relate but still there is no room to state that a person must openly condemn the other in order for their argument to be acknowledge. There will be a long list of groups that should be 'condemn'. It is all based on how they'll be related to the topic or what is said. There is more international pressure on Israel because it is seen as part of the West and should be on a different standard than groups as the ISIS. These groups are not easy to get through to as a setup government will be. When on topic on the ISIS, it is usually agreed that no one is in support of their actions, even the regular Muslims are oppose to it.
Which are all good reasons why ISIS and Israel don't compare well. But ISIS and Hamas do. But you want to compare only ISIS and Israel because...?
If Israel did as ISIS I'd be for bombing Israel. My position is consistent. Is yours?
Truth? So far I've been stuck clarifying a point I made some pages back.
I have no online goals other than to hold discussions on and off while at work. If you think about it nothing said in the forum will actually affect the situation but still each person is still free to voice their plight or opinion.
What do you mean, 'truth?'? Yes, some things are true and you've said much that is not. Is that what you mean?
Even if these discussions aren't going to change anything, and I've said I want to persuade, they're useful for us to sort out our arguments and conclusions. Or the would be if you're willing to. If this is simply sport to you then people have very, very good reason to dismiss your opinion.