Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've not come across someone who supports Hamas, their actions will continue with or without criticisms towards Israel.

Some of them yes, others no. Hamas wouldn't use as many human shields if they were not gaining from it. They wouldn't fire from schools and UN buildings if there were more adverser consequences for doing so. Criticizing Israel when these human shields are hit and when UN buildings are used in these ways means that the UN won't change their policy regarding Hamas because the citizens of their countries aren't pressuring for things to be done to stop Hamas from doing so. Instead they will focus on what their citizens are focusing on. That would be criticisms of Israel attacking Hamas sites in this case.


I think voicing (as is done in social media) raises the issue and opens it to be discussed.

Sadly that's not the mainly the case. You and others are not 'starting a discussion' or 'just asking questions'. Much of what I see from my liberal friends (I'm a liberal, ask Zig) is false. This isn't just to say I believe them wrong, but that factual claims are untrue. Straight propaganda and lies, including wrong history and lack of context, is not 'opening a discussion' it is 'advancing a viewpoint' or 'stating a conclusion'.

Others might criticize only to voice their concerns without knowing whether it will change or not. I have doubts on if those who have the power to change things will go against their set agenda. Looking back at the demonstrations against certain government activities (as protests against going to war). Without criticizing Israel means that a person is in agreement or looks as if they're in agreement. If there is no one to speak on their actions (in and out of the conflict), Hamas will not stop based on this but Israel will continue and see nothing wrong with bombing market places or UN schools without being accountable. Countries are questioned and Israel is not an exception. The US use of drones for example has been questioned and spoken out against, this was not a 'punishment' to the US but for them to step up. If someone criticizes Hamas, I don't see this as a reward for Israel and a punishment for Palestine. They're directing their view and are free to that. But ideally, yes, both should occur (I've seen that the UN did it by condemning both sides) but criticism shouldn't be refuted with a 'this does this and you say nothing', instead it can just be directly addressed.


Yes, not every criticism is a punishment or reward. I haven't said that. Some are however, and some lead to punishment or reward. Again, what do you want done about Israel? What measures? Do you seek to persuade them? Do you seek to persuade us so that we support different measures than we currently do? I wish to persuade people into more evidence based measures, and measures that I hope will improve the situation. I hope to persuade them away from actions that will cause more unneeded harm.


I meant that it is a statement by Israel and remains as a statement, than as an action.


What is a statement by Israel? That they have stopped bombing and Hamas keeps attacking them? No, that is action and fact, not just a statement. I hope you meant something else but I can't tell what.



That should be raised when ISIS is being discussed unless there is a comparison being made between ISIS and Israel.


This line here is one of the more telling things about your mindset and you would be well advised to analyze it. Why only Israel? You're shutting out comparisons arbitrarily.


If a person views Israel as they do ISIS then I can see how that might relate but still there is no room to state that a person must openly condemn the other in order for their argument to be acknowledge. There will be a long list of groups that should be 'condemn'. It is all based on how they'll be related to the topic or what is said. There is more international pressure on Israel because it is seen as part of the West and should be on a different standard than groups as the ISIS. These groups are not easy to get through to as a setup government will be. When on topic on the ISIS, it is usually agreed that no one is in support of their actions, even the regular Muslims are oppose to it.


Which are all good reasons why ISIS and Israel don't compare well. But ISIS and Hamas do. But you want to compare only ISIS and Israel because...?

If Israel did as ISIS I'd be for bombing Israel. My position is consistent. Is yours?


Truth? So far I've been stuck clarifying a point I made some pages back.
I have no online goals other than to hold discussions on and off while at work. If you think about it nothing said in the forum will actually affect the situation but still each person is still free to voice their plight or opinion.


What do you mean, 'truth?'? Yes, some things are true and you've said much that is not. Is that what you mean?

Even if these discussions aren't going to change anything, and I've said I want to persuade, they're useful for us to sort out our arguments and conclusions. Or the would be if you're willing to. If this is simply sport to you then people have very, very good reason to dismiss your opinion.
 
Yes, after the Japanese fully surrendered, and accepted the terms, and the US occupied Japan and rebuilt its government and infrastructure, and departed 7 years later, leaving forces in several Japanese cities, the US didn't go back." Here is a clue -- we didn't have to "go back" because we never left. Today, there are US troops in Okinawa, Honshu and Kyushu prefectures.

Get your facts straight.

You seem heated on something. I stated that the US didn't go back to show that it was not an ongoing issue that the Japanese had to face as the Palestinians have to at present. After conflicts they still have Israel's 'presence' or influence to deal with and thus maintain that 'animosity', which was that other person's reason for comparing Japan to Palestine (even though there isn't any comparison).
No need to get snippy. Breathe.
 
I don't recall there being Palestinian skin lampshades or palestinian fat used in soap

As if those were the salient issues depicted in the film. There's probably not a complete working piano in all of Gaza either. :rolleyes:

What about occupation, apartheid, limiting supplies to a large dense population?
 
As if those were the salient issues depicted in the film. There's probably not a complete working piano in all of Gaza either. :rolleyes:

What about occupation, apartheid, limiting supplies to a large dense population?

There was an attempt at comparing Israel and Nazi Germany and I was pointing out how absurd it was. When someone uses the word "Apartheid" it generally is more of a soundbite than an accurate description. And last I checked, Israel had withdrawn all settlements from Gaza
 
There was an attempt at comparing Israel and Nazi Germany and I was pointing out how absurd it was. When someone uses the word "Apartheid" it generally is more of a soundbite than an accurate description. And last I checked, Israel had withdrawn all settlements from Gaza

Like many analogies, it falls apart if you try to take it literally.

My juxtaposition of the depiction of the Warsaw Ghetto vis a vis the current Israel situation is food for thought. Some may find it useful; others perhaps more interested in Gish Galloping it around the arena a dozen different ways.
 
Some of them yes, others no. Hamas wouldn't use as many human shields if they were not gaining from it. They wouldn't fire from schools and UN buildings if there were more adverser consequences for doing so. Criticizing Israel when these human shields are hit and when UN buildings are used in these ways means that the UN won't change their policy regarding Hamas because the citizens of their countries aren't pressuring for things to be done to stop Hamas from doing so. Instead they will focus on what their citizens are focusing on. That would be criticisms of Israel attacking Hamas sites in this case.
Hamas will continue as they please, they will fire from the places they fire from and Palestinians will have to go to the schools, the market places and other places. Criticizing Israel for showing disregard for civilians as well as Hamas is what I'll prefer than cheering on the event or accepting it as necessary. The 'human shield' accusation is also one that is debated. Can't stop persons from objecting to what they see as an injustice, not only the casualties but also the effect on the border restriction and other events that take place when there is no mass bombing taking place. I think that the pressure placed on Israel has had some positives.

Sadly that's not the mainly the case. You and others are not 'starting a discussion' or 'just asking questions'. Much of what I see from my liberal friends (I'm a liberal, ask Zig) is false. This isn't just to say I believe them wrong, but that factual claims are untrue. Straight propaganda and lies, including wrong history and lack of context, is not 'opening a discussion' it is 'advancing a viewpoint' or 'stating a conclusion'.
If you oppose something I stated, then it is best to state what it is than lump me with 'your liberal friends'. I've seen that demonstrated on both sides of the field but raising the issue is how both are voiced and in some cases clarified.

Yes, not every criticism is a punishment or reward. I haven't said that. Some are however, and some lead to punishment or reward. Again, what do you want done about Israel? What measures? Do you seek to persuade them? Do you seek to persuade us so that we support different measures than we currently do? I wish to persuade people into more evidence based measures, and measures that I hope will improve the situation. I hope to persuade them away from actions that will cause more unneeded harm.
You can't persuade someone who has emotional attachment to the situation. I've seen that much online. I wouldn't aim to persuade someone into a different view. I will prefer though to allow them to see/empathise with the other side. That is stronger than instilling an ideology or an opinion.

What is a statement by Israel? That they have stopped bombing and Hamas keeps attacking them? No, that is action and fact, not just a statement. I hope you meant something else but I can't tell what.
A statement by Israel refers to announcements made by Israel to the public.

This line here is one of the more telling things about your mindset and you would be well advised to analyze it. Why only Israel? You're shutting out comparisons arbitrarily.
There is nothing to analyse. When I speak about ISIS it is in that setting and Israel in another. If someone states that ISIS is not being criticized when the current topic is on Israel being criticized then it means that there is some relationship between the two. Example if I am stating that Bush is dumb president and someone states 'why are you not criticising Francisco Franco', it means that there is some relations between the two and the person is proposing that one can't be criticised without the other. If a person is bringing another group into the discussion then it has to have some relevance.

Which are all good reasons why ISIS and Israel don't compare well. But ISIS and Hamas do. But you want to compare only ISIS and Israel because...?
I've not compared ISIS and Israel. You should reread the statement.

If Israel did as ISIS I'd be for bombing Israel. My position is consistent. Is yours?
Your position will be to bomb Israel? haa is that your solution to all situations? "what? they did what!? -BOMB them!"
My position will be based on the situation. If there is an alternative, example, the US disarming their Israeli ally. It's good to have different options available as 'bomb them' don't seem to eradicate the problem in modern times.

What do you mean, 'truth?'? Yes, some things are true and you've said much that is not. Is that what you mean?

Even if these discussions aren't going to change anything, and I've said I want to persuade, they're useful for us to sort out our arguments and conclusions. Or the would be if you're willing to. If this is simply sport to you then people have very, very good reason to dismiss your opinion.

'Truth?' is similar to stating 'Honestly?'. I guess what I said will depend on what a person cancels as 'propaganda' or 'truth'. The discussion was very opinion based since it is on future events (example stating that rebuilding will be a step towards stability, as well as stating that Hamas' power on the minds of some of their Palestinian supporters can be loosen)

Your goal is to persuade or to have others take your view and that is the position of the others. Everyone wants their view to be accepted. I don't aim towards it as I figure that the users should be adult enough to assess the situation and they'll come to their views based on many things.
I'm not so bored to view chatting in a forum as a sport. I'm open to discussion and I accept that persons will have a different view/opinion. If mine is dismissed or someone thinks I'm being aggressive towards them, what effect should it have on myself or on the overall issue? I enjoy more reading the experiences and views that both sides hold on on. I've read excuses being made by both sides and that lack of empathy or understanding the positions taken by the other is lost when a person's goal is to 'persuade' or have their view accepted. If this is your purpose for engaging in any discussion then good luck with that. May you have all the followers you desire. I'm out for the weekend, enjoy yours.
 
Last edited:
There was an attempt at comparing Israel and Nazi Germany and I was pointing out how absurd it was.
I'm sure a lot of people who use the Nazi comparison do so out of convenience, since WWII is something we all are emotionally invested in and have a decent deal of knowledge about. Still a tasteless comparison, though. It's like saying the Nazi bombing of the Netherlands in 1940 and NATO's bombing of Libya in 2011 are the same, because they were both bombings, and they both led to a nation's surrender. Can I be opposed to Germany's invasion and bombing of the Netherlands, and in support of NATO's bombing of Libya, without experiencing cognitive dissonance? Of course I can. Apples and oranges.

Sure, you're not meant to take analogies too litterally, but the Warsawa Ghetto analogy, coupled with a question about cognitive dissonance? ...no. Just no.
 
Hamas will continue as they please, they will fire from the places they fire from and Palestinians will have to go to the schools, the market places and other places. Criticizing Israel for showing disregard for civilians as well as Hamas is what I'll prefer than cheering on the event or accepting it as necessary.


Expect for the very important part where Israel doesn't show disregard for civilians, and even if you hold they do (because your definition of 'disregard' is different than mine) to hold present them as some sort of equivalency is false, and perpetuating a false narrative.


The 'human shield' accusation is also one that is debated.


It's not only an accusation, it is the objective truth. That people 'debate' it matters nothing to if it's true or not. Hamas uses human shields. They tell people to stay in buildings and GO TO buildings that they know are going to be bombed because Israel has told them they are going to be bombed. This is contrary to your accusation of 'disregard' Israel has for civilians.


Can't stop persons from objecting to what they see as an injustice, not only the casualties but also the effect on the border restriction and other events that take place when there is no mass bombing taking place. I think that the pressure placed on Israel has had some positives.


I can certainly try to get them to explain why they see it as injustice, how they think it can change, who they blame, and why they don't apply that view consistently. Getting people to examine what is injustice, what can be done about it, and the drawbacks certainly has benefits.


If you oppose something I stated, then it is best to state what it is than lump me with 'your liberal friends'. I've seen that demonstrated on both sides of the field but raising the issue is how both are voiced and in some cases clarified.


Not everything is about your arguments. However as you're using many of the same arguments and saying many of the same false things I will point that out. See the above specific things I've called out from you.

Basically if the shoe fits it's pointless to complain about the size.


You can't persuade someone who has emotional attachment to the situation. I've seen that much online.


That's nice, but why not engage in the rational arguments then? You cannot believe that everyone is simply emotionally attached to this. Or rather you mean that everyone who disagrees with you does?


I wouldn't aim to persuade someone into a different view. I will prefer though to allow them to see/empathise with the other side. That is stronger than instilling an ideology or an opinion.


These sentences contradict each other. What you describe is persuading them, so you do seek to persuade, but with emotion rather than reason.

Dismissing what I'm saying as ideology and opinion is unfounded.


A statement by Israel refers to announcements made by Israel to the public.


Which statement are you talking about?


There is nothing to analyse.


Of course there is.


When I speak about ISIS it is in that setting and Israel in another. If someone states that ISIS is not being criticized when the current topic is on Israel being criticized then it means that there is some relationship between the two. Example if I am stating that Bush is dumb president and someone states 'why are you not criticising Francisco Franco', it means that there is some relations between the two and the person is proposing that one can't be criticised without the other. If a person is bringing another group into the discussion then it has to have some relevance.


Yes, that is sometimes the case as I already said, but also isn't always the case as I already said as well.


I've not compared ISIS and Israel. You should reread the statement.


You said that it was the only comparison that should be made though. Your sentences are difficult to comprehend. Is English not your first language?


Your position will be to bomb Israel? haa is that your solution to all situations? "what? they did what!? -BOMB them!"


No. Reread what I said.


My position will be based on the situation. If there is an alternative, example, the US disarming their Israeli ally. It's good to have different options available as 'bomb them' don't seem to eradicate the problem in modern times.


That would never be an option and it's naive in the extreme to even use that as an example. The situations under comparison don't allow for that at all. I said 'bomb them' because under the ISIS situation and the hypothetical 'Israel is doing what ISIS is', those are the only viable options.

You're reading into my comments what you want to read and not what they say.



'Truth?' is similar to stating 'Honestly?'. I guess what I said will depend on what a person cancels as 'propaganda' or 'truth'. The discussion was very opinion based since it is on future events (example stating that rebuilding will be a step towards stability, as well as stating that Hamas' power on the minds of some of their Palestinian supporters can be loosen)


While there is ideology, opinion, and non-objective things involved, there are still objective facts as well. For those it matters not what someone 'considers' truth. It exists whether or not you believe it.


Your goal is to persuade or to have others take your view and that is the position of the others. Everyone wants their view to be accepted. I don't aim towards it as I figure that the users should be adult enough to assess the situation and they'll come to their views based on many things.
I'm not so bored to view chatting in a forum as a sport. I'm open to discussion and I accept that persons will have a different view/opinion. If mine is dismissed or someone thinks I'm being aggressive towards them, what effect should it have on myself or on the overall issue? I enjoy more reading the experiences and views that both sides hold on on. I've read excuses being made by both sides and that lack of empathy or understanding the positions taken by the other is lost when a person's goal is to 'persuade' or have their view accepted. If this is your purpose for engaging in any discussion then good luck with that. May you have all the followers you desire. I'm out for the weekend, enjoy yours.


I don't desire followers. You must mean followers in a none traditional way.

I'm not dismissing you for being 'aggressive' but said that if this is just sport for you then you should be dismissed. If it is just sport then you're not discussing in good faith. You do seem to buy into the 'golden mean' too much.

Having empathy is great, but that doesn't mean that because you hold one party at fault for a specific something doesn't mean you don't have empathy for them. I have empathy for many criminals for example, but still want the punished and reformed. I have empathy for Hamas, but their actions leave little recourse but to eliminate them if they don't stop being Hamas. I have empathy for Israel, but I still hold them responsible some of the settlements and I hold those making horrendous and evil statements responsible for them, and hope they get punished for that as well. Yes, many people on both sides lack empathy but that does not mean they are only on the side they are or hold the belief that the do because of that lack of empathy. It certainly doesn't mean that those who do have empathy don't just because some people who agree with them don't.

Have fun.
 
Like many analogies, it falls apart if you try to take it literally.

My juxtaposition of the depiction of the Warsaw Ghetto vis a vis the current Israel situation is food for thought makes no sense whatsoever.

Some may find it useful; others perhaps more interested in Gish Galloping it around the arena a dozen different ways.

FYP and I don't think the bolded means what you think it means.
 
I wish you would exercise those one day!

Zing!

If someone were handing out points for clever insults, that may well have earned you one.

You have much less of an excuse for not doing so than a shell-shocked almost illiterate victim of war who has just crawled from under the rubble of his entire society.

Palestinians are almost illiterate now?

Truth is the literacy rate in the Gaza Strip is 96.3%, only a little less than Israel's 97.1%.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_literacy_rate

I really don't think you know anything about Palestinians. You just make assertions that they're whatever you need them to be, but you make no effort to check to see if those assertions are true.
 
A person who ASPIRES to rape is a vile person indeed, regardless of the legal considerations that prohibit the prosecution of his thought crime.

You don't seem to know what a "thought crime" is. A hint: stockpiling 30,000 missiles takes more than just thoughts. Shooting them at civilians is an actual crime, not just a thought crime.

On the other hand, I’m much more inclined to decry the rapist who is actually raping right now after having repeatedly raped in the past. And I am inclined to beseech the lawyers and judges to bring the legal system down upon him with its severest punishments.

...and destroying the weapons your enemy plans to use against you is not "rape", or any other crime. Even if in doing so you cause hardship for your enemy.

Well, that is your business but the law is clearly not in agreement with you there.

Except it is. In real life, if not in your flawed analogy.

A Jew is hardly going to take Hamas' side is he.

Oddly enough, some do.

A Jew nevertheless, blah, blah, blah...

You know, if you're Jewish and speaking as a Jew to other Jews, this might make sense. If you're not Jewish and are trying to tell Jewish people how they should feel, it's hard to see this as anything but offensive.

If you are just a Zionist-Christian…. oh well

What if you just believe Palestinians are also responsible for their part in the conflict and need to take an equal share of the responsibility for ending the conflict?
 
Last edited:
You stated that Hamas has guns mean that they'll not lose power, no? I stated that guns may not intimidate the Palestinian, just as Israel's force/guns did not intimidate them.

The average Palestinian on the street has no choice. They don't endure because they have any super-human lack of fear, they endure because their leadership offers no other way.

Hamas, on the other hand, builds these massive underground complexes in part to keep their leadership safe.

-The action of Israel doesn't support this (though they state it via words).

Actually, they do. Dropping leaflets, giving advanced notice by text messages and phone calls, even the warning explosion on top of buildings are all measures Israel takes to reduce civilian casualties. Further, the separation barrier put an amazing amount of resources into enacting a non-violent solution to suicide-terror. They even pioneered the development and use of rubber bullets.

Who has done more, in the middle of a way, to reduce civilian casualties?


Hamas doesn't position itself as a treat to the regular Palestinian, it position itself as a 'protector'.

This is positively orwellian.

Hamas doesn't position themselves as any kind of protector. They position themselves as being religious fanatics who will never give up, regardless of the suffering it brings down on their people. Once, years ago, that was enough to get them elected into power because Gaza citizens thought they were less corrupt than Fatah, and the first thing Hamas did upon being elected into power was to go on a shooting rampage where they killed all their rivals; that is other Palestinians who supported Fatah.


Within the example there is the incidences of unarmed civilians being killed as well as a disregard for life when targeting UN schools and beaches, etc. So stating something and not acting as it doesn't. More so in the minds of the Palestinians who have to experience it.

Incidents such as these do not invalidate the measures Israel takes to reduce civilian casualties. Nobody is claiming Israel is perfect in its efforts to minimize civilian casualties, and perfection in these efforts is an unreasonable standard to hold them to.

After war is very simple 'after the war'. You understand that? It is a continuous issue between Palestinians outside of the spike in attacks. Why should Palestine 'surrender' itself to Israel and state that they can occupy with military, carry out arrests on whoever they want? Will Israel do the same? -They won't. The Palestinians have no reason to believe Israel. The Japanese were not given a 'good' deal either.

The Japanese got a pretty good deal. Their economy has been rebuilt, their government is a stable democracy that protects the rights of its citizens, and they now have good relations with the people who once conquered them.

You ask why the Palestinians should surrender? Why shouldn't they? If their surrender is what it takes to stop the fighting, then that's what they should do. If they can stop the fighting through other means, like through negotiations, then they can do that instead, but the important thing is the fighting cannot stop unless they agree to stop it.
 
After war is very simple 'after the war'. You understand that? It is a continuous issue between Palestinians outside of the spike in attacks. Why should Palestine 'surrender' itself to Israel and state that they can occupy with military, carry out arrests on whoever they want? Will Israel do the same? -They won't. The Palestinians have no reason to believe Israel. The Japanese were not given a 'good' deal either.
Another one of those arguments I hear only about the Israel/Palestine crisis and honestly completely fail to get.

Calling it quits and asking for negotiations is what you do when you have clearly lost a war. It is how war works, and has always worked. If you're losing, you stop fighting and come to the negotation table, and hope for as good a deal as possible.

What HAMAS is doing is basically what the Black Knight did in Monthy Python's Holy Grail film. He stands there with his arms and legs chopped off and wants to "bite the head off" of an adversary that does not even want to fight him. The Palestinians have lost pretty much all their lands and countless people -- and HAMAS still insists on the victim narrative, all the while lobbing rockets, sending suicide bombers, and plotting genocide.

And whenever we point this pretty massive elephant in the room out to people, all they say is butbutsettlements!!!.
 
Yes, after the Japanese fully surrendered, and accepted the terms, and the US occupied Japan and rebuilt its government and infrastructure, and departed 7 years later, leaving forces in several Japanese cities, the US didn't go back." Here is a clue -- we didn't have to "go back" because we never left. Today, there are US troops in Okinawa, Honshu and Kyushu prefectures.

Get your facts straight.


A very small point. While Okinawa is an island and a prefecture, Honshu and Kyushu are islands. There are many prefectures on the islands of Honshu and Kyushu.

However, you are absolutely correct that the United States never left Japan and still has military bases from Okinawa up through Honshu. PhilosophicalCaveman is incorrect in his statement that the US "presence"or "influence" is not an ongoing issue that the Japanese have to face. American military presence is a constant theme in Japanese politics.
 
I do love it when people condemn Israel for killing civilians, while remaining apologists for a regime that actually does intentionally kill as many civilians as they can. Would be cute and funny if there weren't that damned many of them...

Sure, there is room for improvement in Israel and the IDF. How much is open to discussion, but yes, there is. This doesn't, however, mean that you can support terrorist organizations such as HAMAS. Doing so boils down to nothing but a "but, but Israel" defense that every sensible person in here is sick and tired of by now.

It's an odd touchstone, where sometimes the otherwise liberal/human-rights/anti-racist crowd change places with their opposition (a bit like the issue of whether or not homosexuality is genetic, hereditary or socially constructed/learned). People (here in Sweden) who generally purport the increased awareness of islamic fundamentalism, related extremism and the more observed cultural clashes of their beliefs with the climate of Europe, are for some reason the first ones to argue that Hamas, Hezbollah et al are more like "freedom fighters" than terrorists and mainly/chiefly hold Israel accountable for any subsequent mayhem thereof. At least, if this observation of mine is somewhat correct it might explain why I never feel these debates offer a good fit of position for me, since I am not a 'philo-hamas' or 'philo-Israel'.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom