Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ah Seumas Milne, who didn't grow out of sixth form politics. The problem with the "treat israel like apartheid south africa!" lot is that they cannot into context. ISIS are right next door and if Israel is gutted as they wish, Jews will be exterminated (Then again, I'm pretty sure the "boycott Israel" lot think ISIS are glorious people's resistance against Imperialism). Israel, along with Turkey and Iran, are the only sane men in the Middle East. Israel has been threatened with extinction three times within living memory (1948, 1967, 1973).

And it's typical for socialists to describe what's going on as "mind-numbing carnage" when it's NOTHING compared to what ISIS and Assad are up to.
 
Ah Seumas Milne, who didn't grow out of sixth form politics. The problem with the "treat israel like apartheid south africa!" lot is that they cannot into context. ISIS are right next door and if Israel is gutted as they wish, Jews will be exterminated (Then again, I'm pretty sure the "boycott Israel" lot think ISIS are glorious people's resistance against Imperialism). Israel, along with Turkey and Iran, are the only sane men in the Middle East. Israel has been threatened with extinction three times within living memory (1948, 1967, 1973).

And it's typical for socialists to describe what's going on as "mind-numbing carnage" when it's NOTHING compared to what ISIS and Assad are up to.
The current conflict is not with ISIS or whatever they are calling themselves this week. It is with Hamas and, by default (due to popular support, intimidation, or just geographic proximity), the Palestinian population. There is also an asymmetrical comparison of weaponry, the Hamas fighters are armed with rifles, machine guns, IEDs and free-flight rockets. They have caused a tiny number of civilian casualties. The IDF have modern armour, artillery, aircraft and naval vessels.

Hamas, despite their rhetoric, are in no position to threaten the existence of the Israeli state. Their reaction at the moment is highly disproportionate contrary to the present laws of armed conflict. More Israeli citizens have died from the Israeli response than have died from Hamas actions.

Gaza has a population density equivalent to the suburbs in Greater London. The chances to fire out of such an area and not be close to civilians is negligible when the returning fire is 155mm artillery or 500lb, or larger, bombs. Even the 155mm rounds have more explosive power than the rockets fired by Hamas.

The IDF have really shot themselves and the government in the foot internationally. It's totally out of hand.

The only resolution will be to knock both of their ears, apply sanctions to both sides and force them to the negotiating table. Israel will need to acknowledge that the Palestinians will need full equal rights to such details as land, water and power supply rights. Until they address those issues Hamas will always have recruiting potential.
 
There are 21 countries with no! or extremely limited militarists.
With the exception of Iceland the rest amount to an combined area less than the United Kingdom and are generally surrounded by, or are protectorates from, countries with armed forces.
 
My intruders are who?

You never said. Which is one of the problems with your proposal: nobody is interested in the job.

Fixing another government in lieu of Hamas isn't what I proposed. I stated that an independent body can come in to rebuild Palestine and the plight of the Palestinians should be considered (that of wanting stability, 'land-grabbing' and a gradual end to the blockade).

It doesn't matter what gets rebuilt, it will be looted and ruined by Hamas. Just look what happened to the greenhouses left behind when Israel pulled back its settlers.

The Japanese & American situation is no comparison to the Israel & Palestine situation and history. You understand this, right? I'll disregard that point.

Yes, it is different. But that's also part of my point: the fact that Israel is bombing Gaza and cutting off access (we did that to Japan too) is only part of the story. Yet it's the only part you're focusing on. We treated Japan far worse than Israel has treated Gaza. So what's different? And why should that matter? There are indeed answers to these questions, they aren't rhetorical, but they don't point in the direction you suggest, and they can't be ignored.

Do you really think that these events will have no effect on the kids that has to view it?

I never said anything of the sort. But 1) that goes both ways, Hamas is breeding hostility among Israelis, and 2) that does not obviate Israel's immediate responsibility to protect its citizens, for which you have offered no alternative course of action and for which there IS no alternative course of action other than to strike at Hamas.

Your call to 'kill Hamas'. Mentioning the cycle is to show you that you can't 'kill Hamas' when there are others who can take its place.

And you can't kill the Nazis (as in the actual Germans in WW2) when there are others who can take its place. Except, of course, you can. Do it enough and they'll run out of people willing to take their place. Wars are indeed won by killing enough of the enemy. Happens all the time.

The way is to get at the root and cut it. I proposed that stability is how you cut it. Simple. I don't know where you got ideas of WW2 & IDF.

You propose a platitude, not a plan. How can this stability be achieved, when Hamas will fight to undermine it? You cannot, not without fighting Hamas. And that is precisely what you think should not be done.

rhetorical question: Why do you think that is so?

It's not rhetorical. And there are multiple reasons, some of them religious (the Koran and the Hadith are full of anti-Jewish statements), some of them historical.

You expressed that it is irrelevant to discuss or consider the reasons for that. It is a cycle and based on what the children has to experience and deduce even on their own.

What children experience. Indeed.

I've already stated an idea on how Hamas can come to an end

But it's a wholly unrealistic idea. You have no idea how it can actually be achieved, or even who can do it.

If that line of reasoning helps you so be it.

Your equivalence is false, and transparently so. Hamas's rocket attacks did nothing to protect Palestinians. Its tunnels did nothing to prevent Israeli attacks. These were purely offensive acts, acts which directly triggered retaliations and directly endangered Palestinian lives. Hamas doesn't even try to protect its own civilians, they want Palestinian civilians dead, whereas the IDF strives to protect Israeli citizens. There is absolutely no moral or logical equivalence between these actions.
 
Gaza has a population density equivalent to the suburbs in Greater London. The chances to fire out of such an area and not be close to civilians is negligible when the returning fire is 155mm artillery or 500lb, or larger, bombs.

Alternatively; Gaza has a similar population density to Berlin in 1945. And as we all know, no one would have dreamed of it being OK to attack Berlin in order to strike at the depraved, genocidal bunch of extremists who were in charge.
 
Crimes against Humanity. Israel’s “Own Words”: “We Must Expel Arabs…We Struck Civilians Because They Deserved It”

Well, if it was printed at globalresearchdotca.... :oldroll:
I checked a couple of his sources, and the quotes he mined seem to be accurate. Of course, "college student strings together out-of-context, quote-mined statements against the Palestinians" doesn't have the same ring to it.
 
Last edited:
You never said. Which is one of the problems with your proposal: nobody is interested in the job.

No, you said that there will be intruders.

It doesn't matter what gets rebuilt, it will be looted and ruined by Hamas. Just look what happened to the greenhouses left behind when Israel pulled back its settlers.
Your assumption isn't founded since there were buildings that were built and not looked or ruined by Hamas/ the Palestinians. I'll disregard that remark.

Yes, it is different. But that's also part of my point: the fact that Israel is bombing Gaza and cutting off access (we did that to Japan too) is only part of the story. Yet it's the only part you're focusing on. We treated Japan far worse than Israel has treated Gaza. So what's different? And why should that matter? There are indeed answers to these questions, they aren't rhetorical, but they don't point in the direction you suggest, and they can't be ignored.
It is very different. I focused on many parts, not on the bombing to 'cut off access'. Are you forgetting your points? You brought up the WW2 Japan-US bombings to state that the Japanese didn't turn 'terrorists', aiming to state that the Palestinians would be unaffected by the situation. It is incorrect as it is not only the strategic bombings of parts of Palestine that can cause the 'hate' but also the other actions of Israel and Egypt which the Japanese didn't have to face. That is why I state that they're different situations and different people. I don't know who you are stating as 'we', the statement that Japan was 'treated worse' than Palestine is stupid. How will you compare the two is beyond me. The Palestinians' plight should be undermined by what the Japanese faced? These people are in a situation that is continual and has been going through for years. I will dismiss this ****** comment of yours and not bother further with it.

I never said anything of the sort. But 1) that goes both ways, Hamas is breeding hostility among Israelis, and 2) that does not obviate Israel's immediate responsibility to protect its citizens, for which you have offered no alternative course of action and for which there IS no alternative course of action other than to strike at Hamas.
1) Hamas doesn't need to breed hostility, that is my point, the actions of Israel speaks for itself to the regular Palestinian.
2) A country can 'protect its citizens' but not at the expense of wiping out another group of people. No disregard for life is what is being addressed. The continual attacks that show no regard for Palestinian life can't be accepted as a norm and I personally wouldn't.

And you can't kill the Nazis (as in the actual Germans in WW2) when there are others who can take its place. Except, of course, you can. Do it enough and they'll run out of people willing to take their place. Wars are indeed won by killing enough of the enemy. Happens all the time.
Nazis are here today, you've not wiped out that ideology. Do it enough and you'll can wipe out an entire population, is that what you mean? You have a warp view of modern war and how it is 'won'. Death-tolls wouldn't bring success to anyone. To eradicate Hamas it'll take more than mass killings.

You propose a platitude, not a plan. How can this stability be achieved, when Hamas will fight to undermine it? You cannot, not without fighting Hamas. And that is precisely what you think should not be done.
How do you know Hamas will fight to undermine it? Stability can be achieved by rebuilding Palestinian and moving it to be more independent and open to the rest of the world.

It's not rhetorical. And there are multiple reasons, some of them religious (the Koran and the Hadith are full of anti-Jewish statements), some of them historical.

-The reasons that are given by Palestinians are less religious and more on the actions that they have to face.


Your equivalence is false, and transparently so. Hamas's rocket attacks did nothing to protect Palestinians. Its tunnels did nothing to prevent Israeli attacks. These were purely offensive acts, acts which directly triggered retaliations and directly endangered Palestinian lives. Hamas doesn't even try to protect its own civilians, they want Palestinian civilians dead, whereas the IDF strives to protect Israeli citizens. There is absolutely no moral or logical equivalence between these actions.

My equivalence to what? That Israel's actions make it look as an aggressor?
The Palestinians can go where to protect themselves? Idiotic, there is no safe place for them to turn when attacks are done not even in buildings that are said to be safe. I wouldn't bother with your position. It seems all to comfort yourself.
 
How do you know Hamas will fight to undermine it? Stability can be achieved by rebuilding Palestinian and moving it to be more independent and open to the rest of the world.
Who will be doing this rebuilding? Who will govern during this period of increased independence and openness?
 
Who will be doing this rebuilding? Who will govern during this period of increased independence and openness?

I've read that Norway is organizing a donor conference, as well as the UN. Do you think that a rebuilding should be done or not? It is difficult to imagine Palestine reaching a stable position with rubles and lack of important infrastructure.
How will I foresee who will govern? For one thing I don't see Hamas as a suitable government but whoever takes the mantle should focus on the Palestinians and nothing else.
 
I don't understand very much of your response; I'm sorry about that.

I googled "Norway Palestine donor conference," and found this article from the Associated Press.

GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip | The outlines of a solution for battered, blockaded Gaza are emerging after Tuesday's tentative Israel-Hamas cease-fire: Norway is organizing a donor conference and Western-backed Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas aims to oversee rebuilding and reassert his authority in the territory, lost to Hamas in 2007.

Forces loyal to Abbas would be deployed at Gaza's crossings to encourage Israel and Egypt to lift the closure they imposed after the Hamas takeover.

Abbas is someone that the world community thinks they can work with. Unfortunately, as another poster rightly told you, Hamas has guns and will not be giving them up without a fight:

Hamas, in turn, has signaled flexibility on ceding some authority to Abbas in Gaza, but insists on having a say on reconstruction and that it will not disarm.

Izzat Rishq, a senior Hamas official, said disarming isn't up for discussion.

"We'd take the life of anyone who tries to take the weapons of resistance," he told The Associated Press.

Egypt's closure of the tunnels and Israel's recent offensive have Hamas as weak as ever, so let's hope that their talk is just talk. Maybe this pounding will knock some sense into them; maybe not.
 
Norway is hosting a donor conference, and the UN...something? Who is going to physically enter Gaza (with permission from Egypt, Abbas and Israel), tell Hamas to **** off and actually re-build stuff?
 
Norway is hosting a donor conference, and the UN...something? Who is going to physically enter Gaza (with permission from Egypt, Abbas and Israel), tell Hamas to **** off and actually re-build stuff?

Rebuilding isn't even sufficient. What then? Whatever gets rebuilt will either be seized for use by Hamas or looted. When Israel left Gaza, they left a bunch of fully functioning, fully equipped greenhouses which were capable of generating a significant amount of income. This was a gift that was given to the Palestinian Authority. What happened to those greenhouses? They were basically destroyed. By the Palestinians.
 
Norway is hosting a donor conference, and the UN...something? Who is going to physically enter Gaza (with permission from Egypt, Abbas and Israel), tell Hamas to **** off and actually re-build stuff?
Ok, we'll go through this slowly.
-You asked who will do the rebuilding?
I stated some current news that I read Norway is hosting a donor conference to accumulate funds to help rebuild Palestine. I believe that it is noted in the article you read.
Now on the comment on the UN, I stated that I've read that they (the UN) stated (or pledged) that they will.

Which part are you have difficulty with so far?
 
Rebuilding isn't even sufficient. What then? Whatever gets rebuilt will either be seized for use by Hamas or looted. When Israel left Gaza, they left a bunch of fully functioning, fully equipped greenhouses which were capable of generating a significant amount of income. This was a gift that was given to the Palestinian Authority. What happened to those greenhouses? They were basically destroyed. By the Palestinians.

They looted, and? You will move on or stick on the past? Rebuilding is sufficient and why shouldn't it be rebuilt or infrastructure be placed for the Palestinians? They're as anyone else. This isn't even debatable.
 
They looted, and? You will move on or stick on the past? Rebuilding is sufficient

You keep saying that, but that doesn't make it true. I have provided an argument for why it is not true. You have provided no counter-argument for why it is true. You merely declare it to be so, but your declarations are unsupported and unconvincing.

and why shouldn't it be rebuilt or infrastructure be placed for the Palestinians?

You still won't say by whom.

They're as anyone else. This isn't even debatable.

You can't actually defend your position, so you just move the goalpost and claim that there is no debate.
 
Ok, we'll go through this slowly.
-You asked who will do the rebuilding?
I stated some current news that I read Norway is hosting a donor conference to accumulate funds to help rebuild Palestine. I believe that it is noted in the article you read.
Now on the comment on the UN, I stated that I've read that they (the UN) stated (or pledged) that they will.

Which part are you have difficulty with so far?

They've been doing this for years and years and year now. If you think the goal is to create peace, then we must conclude that these efforts are a failure. Why would we expect the same thing to suddenly succeed now? That disjunction between repeated past experience and future expectation is often put forth as the definition of insanity.
 
You keep saying that, but that doesn't make it true. I have provided an argument for why it is not true. You have provided no counter-argument for why it is true. You merely declare it to be so, but your declarations are unsupported and unconvincing.

Stating you've 'provided an argument' doesn't mean you have provided anything. Rebuilding is a step towards stability in Palestine, it is not that complicated. How can life continue when most of the buildings are destroyed and proper infrastructure is not present?

You still won't say by whom.
Look at the comment left above.

You can't actually defend your position, so you just move the goalpost and claim that there is no debate.
My position that Palestine should be rebuilt? There is no other 'goalpost' than this. If you don't want any rebuilding that's your position. It is not debate on this as it is necessary for the Palestinians to have these basic things.
 
They've been doing this for years and years and year now. If you think the goal is to create peace, then we must conclude that these efforts are a failure. Why would we expect the same thing to suddenly succeed now? That disjunction between repeated past experience and future expectation is often put forth as the definition of insanity.

I answered a question that was very simple. There was no comment on 'their goal' and rephrase a quote doesn't bring any sustenance to your position that there shouldn't be a rebuilding.
Palestinians have benefited from infrastructure, now that some are destroyed they will benefit again once it is rebuilt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom