Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, but no one has actually made that argument. The argument isn't 'others' are doing worse, but the direct enemy of Israel that they are fighting are doing worse and trying to do worse to them and to their own people. It's that the agency for stopping the violence completely right now rests with Hamas. Israel could (and has several times) stop bombing, but Hamas will not. Israel doesn't target civilians but their direct enemy in this specific fight targets civilians and uses their own as human shield and their deaths propaganda tools. Rewarding such actions encourages more such actions.
I prefer when someone criticizes Israel's action, that that should be addressed instead of a rebuttal of 'the others are doing worse, why are you not criticizing them', and vice versa. The ISIS was brought up to be condemned since Israel is being condemned when it doesn't relate or have anything to do with the criticisms. I believe that both parties have to play a role in ending the violence as the violence stems from Israel's actions (not only the attacks).
Israel can claim and it remains as claims. There is no rewarding/encouraging of Hamas' actions or Israel's actions if a person criticizes one or both. I can criticize the both but a person who supports the IDF will not be able to, neither will a person who supports Hamas.

Then why can't I expect more from the Palestinians who also receive taxpayer money? You don't buy control for security choices because your money went to it.
You can. It's not control but expecting more from what you've invested in. Especially when it is Military aid.
 
Last edited:
What is one to make of the fact that the deputy speaker of the Knesset has called for ethnic cleansing in Gaza?

He’s not an obscure blogger for the Times of Israel. He is a luminary of the Likud – a man who got 23 percent of the vote in a contest for the Likud Party leadership. He was appointed to his current high position by Benjamin Netanyahu. And this is his proposal for Gaza:

a) The IDF [Israeli army] shall designate certain open areas on the Sinai border, adjacent to the sea, in which the civilian population will be concentrated, far from the built-up areas that are used for launches and tunneling. In these areas, tent encampments will be established, until relevant emigration destinations are determined. The supply of electricity and water to the formerly populated areas will be disconnected.

b) The formerly populated areas will be shelled with maximum fire power. The entire civilian and military infrastructure of Hamas, its means of communication and of logistics, will be destroyed entirely, down to their foundations.

c) The IDF will divide the Gaza Strip laterally and crosswise, significantly expand the corridors, occupy commanding positions, and exterminate nests of resistance, in the event that any should remain.

http://dish.andrewsullivan.com/2014/08/05/the-last-and-first-temptation-of-israel/
 
-The action of Israel doesn't support this (though they state it via words).

Yes it does.

The IDF has killed unarmed civilians

That is inevitable, given the way that Hamas fights. But despite the Hamas propaganda, males between the age of 20 and 29 are vastly over-represented among the dead compared to demographics, even if we use Hamas's own figures. If Israel was interested in targeting civilians, then the casualty figures would more closely resemble the demographic mix.

Hamas doesn't position itself as a treat to the regular Palestinian, it position itself as a 'protector'.

A strange protector indeed, which uses them as shields and invites reprisals which kill those Palestinians.

On your last two sentences, I've seen in history the opposite, protesting at the risk of ones life was done.

Maybe Hamas should try that, then.

Life is meaningless with restrictions, etc.

This is nonsense. We all live with restrictions. Perhaps you mean it's meaningless when restrictions pass some unspecified level of intrusiveness and control, but that's not what you said, and you would need to specify what that relevant threshold was in order for the statement to be useful for discussion. You should start saying what you mean, or if you truly meant this as written, stop saying such stupid things.

All a person has is just that and what will there be to lose by standing up to the one who is armed?

One's life, obviously.

Do you understand that having a gun will not mean that intimidation will be successful?

Do you understand that when you're dead, your enemy won't care if they intimidated you, because you're dead?

-It is true on it's own.

No, it isn't.

Also, these infrastructure (schools, hospitals, etc) gives the Palestinians something to hope towards and work towards in comparison to leaving them to live in rubble without basic infrastructure.

They had all these things. Why were they destroyed? Because Hamas used them to attack Israel, and Israel struck back. If you rebuild them again, what will happen? Hamas will use them to attack Israel, and Israel will strike back. And then they will be destroyed again.

Then you're stating that it is not disarming Hamas?

Certainly not of the weaponry needed to control their fellow Palestinians.

Hamas' threat to Israel is less than it was before the conflict? -No.

Yes. Israel destroyed many of Hamas's rockets and tunnels. This reduces the threat Hamas poses to Israel. You have not contested that Hamas rockets were destroyed. You have not contested that Hamas tunnels were destroyed. You have not contested that these actions will reduce the threat to Israel. You have made no argument whatsoever.

Israel doesn't care for Palestinian casualties.

They have no obligation to. That's not their responsibility. It's Hamas's responsibility. Their response must be proportionate, but it has been.

I've not stated that 'Hamas' power is only due to public opinion'. I have stated through out that Hamas' support is important to their 'power'. They need the chaos to have themselves viewed as a necessity.

And yet, you cannot see the logical outcome of that reality: Hamas will act to MAKE chaos. If your rebuilding efforts actually threaten Hamas's powers, then they will simply kill the people doing the rebuilding in order to prevent that from happening. To the extent that they will permit rebuilding, it's precisely because it will NOT threaten their power.

-This is more than the physical attacks on Gaza. There is the issue on building on lands that Palestinians considers their own

Israel has no buildings in Gaza. Israel controls no land in Gaza. This is a patently absurd accusation.

-You assume that they'll bring 'chaos'.

This is not an assumption. It is the logical conclusion of your OWN claims.

Should infrastructure be setup (and it has been) you're stating that Hamas will destroy them because they'll bring stability to Palestine?

If necessary, yes. More likely, in my opinion, is that they'll simply seize control of it, so that most Palestinians see no benefit, and any benefit that they do see will be controlled by Hamas, thus enriching and empowering them.

Within Hamas there will be individuals whose goal is to bring stability.

Sure, sure. Just like there will be individuals whose goal is to bring peace. Yet the organization never acts towards those goals.

How will they explain that to the population when they're now the aggressor?

How do they currently explain to the population that they are the cause of so much of their suffering? Easy: simply lie about it all, and blame the Joos. It's worked so far.

What you state makes no sense, if you think it out. If that was the case then Hamas would've leveled all the buildings as soon as they were built.

Unless the existence of buildings doesn't threaten Hamas.

I didn't state that they were synonymous words (why are you dancing around semantics?

The meaning of words matter. You have a bad habit of not saying what you mean (and that's the charitable interpretation). I want you to be precise. You used the word "justice", I pointed out that this wasn't a relevant criteria because it's subjective, you tried to claim an objective basis for it which still makes no sense.

What will stop a person from stating stealing a woman's purse is justice?

Let's be precise here. Either the law will stop him out of fear of consequences, or his morals will. The former is objective (but not relevant to our discussion, since Israel has obeyed the relevant laws), the latter is not.

The statement that you are discussing is based on your previous statement that the Palestinians faced 'bad treatment' and further stating that you didn't say it was 'unjust' bad treatment.

I have not stated whether or not it was "unjust" because that is not useful here. It is objectively bad (as in harsh, painful, unpleasant to endure). It is seen as unjust by some, and as just by others. But this is not a useful descriptor, since it's so subjective, and there are certainly examples where someone viewed bad treatment of themselves as unjust even though the vast majority would conclude that it was just.

What societal values? I stated very clearly that the the Japanese fought back in WW2 and they would've fought to death had not the Emperor gave the orders. How does this relate to societal values?

The Japanese valued obedience, they valued order, they valued the status of their emperor. Is this not obvious?

Now, what do Palestinians value? They value adherence to Islam, they value hatred towards Jews, and they value a tribal concept of "honor". It's a very different society.

Yes, Japan is not like Gaza. But you seem remarkably ignorant and incurious as to why it's so different.

It is based on your statement that the Palestinians could act the same way the Japanese did (you claim that they didn't fight back or hold animosity after the war) but this situation in Palestine isn't an 'after-war' it is a continuous situation they're facing.

There was no 'after-war' until the Japanese surrendered, and obeyed the terms of their surrender. Hamas could, if it chose, do likewise. They could surrender. And they could get an opportunity to rebuild, just like Japan did.

But they won't.

-Don't move the goal post. You stated that I 'claimed that the Palestinian response to Israel (namely, terrorist attacks) is the result of terrible conditions', I'm stating that I didn't mention 'terrorist' attacks as you claimed I did.

If you weren't talking about terrorist attacks (which is what prompted the Israeli response) then that's even worse: you're ignoring the entire central problem of the conflict. I thought you were talking about that since I didn't think you'd be so dishonest as to ignore the elephant in the room.

I guess I was wrong.

-And how does that change the point that the Palestinians feel animosity to Israel based on how they are treated? Note that this is more than the attacks on Gaza.

It doesn't. I never claimed it does. But even this is short-sighted. The Palestinians hated the Jews and wanted them dead even before they were treated the way they are now treated, even before Israel existed.

-Wars don't break 'animosity cycles'. As can be seen even in this situation.

Wars without victory don't break animosity cycles. Wars with victory are pretty much the only thing that does. History is a cruel teacher in this regard.

-Defeat is what occurs after fighting, stating that if they weren't 'defeated' they would've kept fighting is redundant. The Palestinians don't position themselves as being defeated and don't wish to allow an 'Israel take over'.

Hence their eternal excuse for continued violence that produces nothing for them. So why do they do it?

btw, you think that all will be peaceable between Palestine and Israel if one bombs the other flat and occupy? The occupation by Israel wasn't successful.

It's a little more complicated because Israel cannot easily defeat Hamas's external sponsors such as Qatar (which can then constantly inject resources to prolong the conflict), and because religion and propaganda create a strong belief (in this case, delusion) that the Palestinians will eventually be victorious. But I do think that until the Palestinians believe that they have been defeated, then will not choose peace. And that is the historical norm: wars generally end with defeat for one side or the other.

The US didn't go back.

We didn't need to: Japan didn't attack us again.

They remained and did not put border restrictions

Sure we did, while we occupied them. The restrictions (and the entire occupation) were lifted after it was clear that Japan posed no more threat to the US. But not before then.

If the Palestinians demonstrated they were no threat to Israel, the border restrictions on Gaza would not last. Hell, Israel isn't even responsible for all of them. Egypt controls one of Gaza's borders. Why aren't you bitching about them? Why aren't you blaming them for Gaza's problems? Why isn't Hamas blaming Egypt?

Well, they're not Joos, so it's not as convenient.

neither falsely arrest citizens.

Moved (and unsupported) goalpost.

Is this your proposal for Palestine? It has failed so far in Afghanistan and Iraq but continue. This is your proposal?

No, it is not. I think social values present in Gaza (and Iraq, and Afghanistan) make it less amenable to reformation than Japan. But again, you want to ignore the role these social values play in the conflict, and pretend that it's all due to external pressures. And that's simply absurd.

It was sarcasm

I know that. But it was badly misplaced, since you're still failing to support your own position. You think rebuilding will accomplish something, but you have no idea how much rebuilding, what it will cost, how long it will take, who will do it... but you're still certain that it'll all just work. Somehow. And it's not magic, you swear, even though you don't understand any of it.

to your statement that their plans are 'not top secret' so somehow I should know the scope/scale of their plans.

If you're claiming that their plans match YOUR plans, then yes, you should know at least something about the scale and scope of their plans, otherwise you're just pulling crap out of your ass.

I've not placed them as 'parties who will do what I want'

Yes you have. You specifically referred to them when challenged about who would accomplish your plan.

The past efforts of rebuilding has contributed. Leaving the Palestinians in rubble is a better alternative in what way?

It may make them face the harsh reality of the choice before them: continued war and peace.

The less costly you make the choice of war, the more likely you make their decision to continue it.

An opinion based on logic, evidence and history? You stated that rebuilding the buildings will do nothing for the situation due to looting that took place in the past on a greenhouse building (history), neglecting the fact that hospitals, schools that were built helped the Palestinians towards a seemingly normal life.

Key word. The schools are used for indoctrination by Hamas, the hospitals are used as operations centers, and neither has done anything to loosen the grip that Hamas has on Palestinian society.

You've not backed your opinion with anything of substance, man, be serious.
You've not stated any logical reasons as to why infrastructure will not be a necessary step towards stability in Palestine.

You keep misrepresenting my position. It is a necessary step, but it's a necessary second step. Attempting to accomplish it before the necessary first step (getting rid of Hamas, choosing peace) will accomplish nothing.
 
I prefer when someone criticizes Israel's action, that that should be addressed instead of a rebuttal of 'the others are doing worse, why are you not criticizing them', and vice versa. The ISIS was brought up to be condemned since Israel is being condemned when it doesn't relate or have anything to do with the criticisms. I believe that both parties have to play a role in ending the violence as the violence stems from Israel's actions (not only the attacks).
Israel can claim and it remains as claims. There is no rewarding/encouraging of Hamas' actions or Israel's actions if a person criticizes one or both. I can criticize the both but a person who supports the IDF will not be able to, neither will a person who supports Hamas.


What is your goal in criticism?

If you want things to change, your criticism at least has the goal of giving support to those with the power to change things. Condemning violence from Israel but not from Hamas does in fact reward Hamas. Criticizing Israel for things that are in fact the responsibility of Hamas rewards Hamas. This is in fact why Hamas does many of these things. It is to get international pressure put on Israel, and it's been working. Voicing criticism of Israel without also pointing out any condemnations of Hamas (their direct enemy) can have the effect of punishing Israel and rewarding Hamas.

I don't know what you mean by 'can claim and it remains as claims'.

And no, supporting one side or the other overall does not mean you cannot criticize both. In general and overall I support Israel. I also support the Palestinian people in some of their goals and as people. I oppose Hamas. That does not mean I can't be critical of the IDF, or specific Israelis, or parties in Israel. I voice these criticisms so others know I don't support specific actions or specific groups and am open to more substantial ways to change these things.

While I like comparing and contrasting similar situations and finding consistency in reasoning, I agree that talk of ISIS can be off topic. Sometimes it is just a gotcha, or an attack of the 'appeal to worse problems' sort. But it also can be useful for finding out why there is more international pressure, action, and condemnation on Israel than on other groups. In this way I think the lack of action against Egypt and Assad and others is on topic and illuminating. If you don't want to examine your own motivations personally using these comparisons, I have serious reservations about your motivations overall. That doesn't mean I feel you must discuss them here, but that it would be beneficial for you to use these questions to explore your motivations and consistency for yourself.


You can. It's not control but expecting more from what you've invested in. Especially when it is Military aid.


I would like more, but I'd like more from my own government as well. That doesn't mean I think people are justified in not paying taxes, or shooting at them, or that the police shouldn't arrest such people. Israel hasn't behaved badly enough for me to want less support (although I think a lot of the aid to them is unneeded, I'm open to less material support on other grounds).

Again, what is the goal of your criticism? What do you want it to accomplish? Do you think it adds to the understanding of others to the situation or do you think it reinforces false narratives? I think it reinforces false narratives of the moral equivalency and golden mean sorts.
 
Yes it does.
Within the example there is the incidences of unarmed civilians being killed as well as a disregard for life when targeting UN schools and beaches, etc. So stating something and not acting as it doesn't. More so in the minds of the Palestinians who have to experience it.

That is inevitable, given the way that Hamas fights. But despite the Hamas propaganda, males between the age of 20 and 29 are vastly over-represented among the dead compared to demographics, even if we use Hamas's own figures. If Israel was interested in targeting civilians, then the casualty figures would more closely resemble the demographic mix.
Killing unarmed civilians is inevitable based on how Hamas fights? I was referring to the incidences apart from the bombings. Your conclusion is based on what? The civilian casualties are high, what is your point?

A strange protector indeed, which uses them as shields and invites reprisals which kill those Palestinians.
-Some 'shield'. Did they grab the kids who were playing on the beach and hid behind them on on-coming rockets?

Maybe Hamas should try that, then.
-Maybe Israel should as well. Then both can go about their business.

This is nonsense. We all live with restrictions. Perhaps you mean it's meaningless when restrictions pass some unspecified level of intrusiveness and control, but that's not what you said, and you would need to specify what that relevant threshold was in order for the statement to be useful for discussion. You should start saying what you mean, or if you truly meant this as written, stop saying such stupid things.
You live with restrictions that are placed on the Palestinians? because if you have sense then you'll note that that is the contents of the word 'restrictions'.

One's life, obviously.
Same will be lost if a person allows it.

Do you understand that when you're dead, your enemy won't care if they intimidated you, because you're dead?
You do understand that the gun is used as intimidation in the context you proposed and it doesn't mean that a person will submit to it (dead/alive) that this will not matter to the individual?

No, it isn't.
Yes, it is.

They had all these things. Why were they destroyed? Because Hamas used them to attack Israel, and Israel struck back. If you rebuild them again, what will happen? Hamas will use them to attack Israel, and Israel will strike back. And then they will be destroyed again.
That's what Israel claims. They were used by Palestinians and made proper use of.

Certainly not of the weaponry needed to control their fellow Palestinians.
Israel's action is failing disarming Hamas? -that is the question. You stated that you didn't state that it was disarming Hamas, I'm asking if your view is that it is not 'disarming Hamas'.
You understand the question?

Yes. Israel destroyed many of Hamas's rockets and tunnels. This reduces the threat Hamas poses to Israel. You have not contested that Hamas rockets were destroyed. You have not contested that Hamas tunnels were destroyed. You have not contested that these actions will reduce the threat to Israel. You have made no argument whatsoever.
Israel still views Hamas as a threat as it did in the beginning of the conflict. They don't seem to agree with you.

They have no obligation to. That's not their responsibility. It's Hamas's responsibility. Their response must be proportionate, but it has been.
It is a statement that Israel doesn't care for Palestinians casualties, whether it is their obligation or not. It is their responsibility. Hamas as well.

And yet, you cannot see the logical outcome of that reality: Hamas will act to MAKE chaos. If your rebuilding efforts actually threaten Hamas's powers, then they will simply kill the people doing the rebuilding in order to prevent that from happening. To the extent that they will permit rebuilding, it's precisely because it will NOT threaten their power.
How many builders were killed by Hamas in the past for rebuilding destroyed buildings in Palestine?

Israel has no buildings in Gaza. Israel controls no land in Gaza. This is a patently absurd accusation.
There is the issue of building on land that Palestinians consider their own land, as well as the issue of building on lands that were set under 'negotiation'.
You do know that there is more to 'Palestine' than 'Gaza' and that it is one area?

This is not an assumption. It is the logical conclusion of your OWN claims.
You made the assumption, I didn't. I acknowledge it as your assumption or maybe you'll feel better if I state that I acknowledge that it is your opinion.

If necessary, yes. More likely, in my opinion, is that they'll simply seize control of it, so that most Palestinians see no benefit, and any benefit that they do see will be controlled by Hamas, thus enriching and empowering them
.
More opinions. Good and you know that it will not add to Hamas' image if they destroy all the buildings in Palestine among the Palestinians? It will not 'empower or enrich' them but still loosen their influence.

Sure, sure. Just like there will be individuals whose goal is to bring peace. Yet the organization never acts towards those goals.
How do they currently explain to the population that they are the cause of so much of their suffering? Easy: simply lie about it all, and blame the Joos. It's worked so far.
You've not address what is stated. How will Hamas maintain (or explain their actions) to the Palestinians for their aggression (the aggression that you foretold will take place)? Focus.

Unless the existence of buildings doesn't threaten Hamas.
Leveling the buildings will be a threat to their image.

The meaning of words matter. You have a bad habit of not saying what you mean (and that's the charitable interpretation). I want you to be precise. You used the word "justice", I pointed out that this wasn't a relevant criteria because it's subjective, you tried to claim an objective basis for it which still makes no sense.
YOU stated that the words weren't synonymous as if I said that they were. You created that argument that they're not based on nothing I've stated, yes it is dancing around semantics and creating an argument that was never placed forward. Justice can have an objective basis and be based on the execution of a law (the Justice system), justice can be also based on feelings as 'a person felt that there was an injustice'. There are times when these two incorporate the other. Should the actions on the Palestinians be viewed as perceived injustice based on the viewer or on acknowledging the victim's view?

Let's be precise here. Either the law will stop him out of fear of consequences, or his morals will. The former is objective (but not relevant to our discussion, since Israel has obeyed the relevant laws), the latter is not.
-The law is when something is stated and someone goes against it, the 'justice' is there when the punishment is carried out based on the law/precedent. By relevant laws you mean their own laws or International laws? I figure

I have not stated whether or not it was "unjust" because that is not useful here. It is objectively bad (as in harsh, painful, unpleasant to endure). It is seen as unjust by some, and as just by others. But this is not a useful descriptor, since it's so subjective, and there are certainly examples where someone viewed bad treatment of themselves as unjust even though the vast majority would conclude that it was just.
Do you view is as just/unjust? I've not asked what anyone else see it as, it will remain as your own opinion and I'm not taking you as talking on behalf of anyone else but yourself. You stated that it was 'bad treatment' faced by Palestinian from Israel. I'm asking if you see it as 'just' and if so what is 'just' about it (in your opinion) and if you view it as 'unjust', why so. Simple?

The Japanese valued obedience, they valued order, they valued the status of their emperor. Is this not obvious?


Now, what do Palestinians value? They value adherence to Islam, they value hatred towards Jews, and they value a tribal concept of "honor". It's a very different society.

Yes, Japan is not like Gaza. But you seem remarkably ignorant and incurious as to why it's so different.
You acknowledge that Japan in WW2 is different to Palestine in present times and yet want a similarity to be drawn up as to why one doesn't act as the other. They don't "act" as the other because of their different history, experience and the conditions both were under when in conflict. How is this difficult for you to see -idk.
There is no point in asking why Japanese in WW2 dressed differently to Palestinians in current times, just as there is no point in asking why Japan reacted to the Allies differently than Palestine to Israel. The both don't relate. Should the Palestine react to Israel the way Japan reacted to China during WW2? Or are you going to be selective on that one.
It is as comparing two individuals who grew up in different situations and asking me 'why' they're so different.
Nice summary on what you perceive are the values of Palestinians.

There was no 'after-war' until the Japanese surrendered, and obeyed the terms of their surrender. Hamas could, if it chose, do likewise. They could surrender. And they could get an opportunity to rebuild, just like Japan did.

But they won't.
After war is very simple 'after the war'. You understand that? It is a continuous issue between Palestinians outside of the spike in attacks. Why should Palestine 'surrender' itself to Israel and state that they can occupy with military, carry out arrests on whoever they want? Will Israel do the same? -They won't. The Palestinians have no reason to believe Israel. The Japanese were not given a 'good' deal either.

If you weren't talking about terrorist attacks (which is what prompted the Israeli response) then that's even worse: you're ignoring the entire central problem of the conflict. I thought you were talking about that since I didn't think you'd be so dishonest as to ignore the elephant in the room.

I guess I was wrong.
You seem lost. Maybe you should keep track of the straw-men you create.

You stated: Have the terrorist attacks committed by Palestinians towards the Israelis actually accomplished anything for the Palestinians?
Towards that I stated: I'm not supporting Hamas' attacks neither Israel's actions here (in and out of the spike conflict). I do however acknowledge where the animosity will stem from and how this can be a cycle.
Your response was this: You have claimed that the Palestinian response to Israel (namely, terrorist attacks) is the result of terrible conditions inflicted upon them by Israel.
Which is what I corrected in stated that I've not 'claimed that the Palestinian response to Israel (namely, terrorist attacks) ...'

Hamas' attacks on Israel is based on many things, which they claim but I focused on the Palestinians' view towards Israel's actions. Is this clearer for you?

It doesn't. I never claimed it does. But even this is short-sighted. The Palestinians hated the Jews and wanted them dead even before they were treated the way they are now treated, even before Israel existed.
Good, it doesn't. I asked because your response to the quoted statement had nothing in relation to what was quoted.
Don't hold so tightly to the past. You can continue to hold that view, as others with the same mentality hold the view that 'the Jews are only interested in eradicating all of Palestine off the land that god promised to them.' Same that no progress will be made with fixed mentalities as this.

Wars without victory don't break animosity cycles. Wars with victory are pretty much the only thing that does. History is a cruel teacher in this regard.
Wars with/without victory doesn't break an animosity cycle.

Hence their eternal excuse for continued violence that produces nothing for them. So why do they do it?
You will not understand unless you empathize with a Palestinian. There are people who don't throw in the towel and surrender unconditionally.

It's a little more complicated because Israel cannot easily defeat Hamas's external sponsors such as Qatar (which can then constantly inject resources to prolong the conflict), and because religion and propaganda create a strong belief (in this case, delusion) that the Palestinians will eventually be victorious. But I do think that until the Palestinians believe that they have been defeated, then will not choose peace. And that is the historical norm: wars generally end with defeat for one side or the other.
Why should they? Giving up may not bring them peace, unless you mean submission brings peace. Those held in the concentration camps by the Nazis (JWs, Jews, Gypsies, etc) were submissive, didn't give them peace. The Palestinians don't trust Israel based on Israel's actions (in and out of the conflict).

Sure we did, while we occupied them. The restrictions (and the entire occupation) were lifted after it was clear that Japan posed no more threat to the US. But not before then.


If the Palestinians demonstrated they were no threat to Israel, the border restrictions on Gaza would not last. Hell, Israel isn't even responsible for all of them. Egypt controls one of Gaza's borders. Why aren't you bitching about them? Why aren't you blaming them for Gaza's problems? Why isn't Hamas blaming Egypt?
You realize that I did mention Egypt every time I spoke on the borders ah I forgot you only address things in parts and create straw-men. Hamas states if Israel demonstrates it isn't a threat then it'll stop and vice versa.
Don't go retarded on me.

Well, they're not Joos, so it's not as convenient.
Ah too late...

Moved (and unsupported) goalpost.
There were no cases of falsely arrested civilians?

No, it is not. I think social values present in Gaza (and Iraq, and Afghanistan) make it less amenable to reformation than Japan. But again, you want to ignore the role these social values play in the conflict, and pretend that it's all due to external pressures. And that's simply absurd.
Another strawman. I think that you can hold arguments all by yourself. Failing to see why I should respond anymore.
Then you propose nothing? Afghanistan didn't work, Iraq didn't work. Social values? Since when surrendering is a social value. You are acting as if Japan was pacifist or even an example of 'social behaviour', you do recall their actions on China.

I know that. But it was badly misplaced, since you're still failing to support your own position. You think rebuilding will accomplish something, but you have no idea how much rebuilding, what it will cost, how long it will take, who will do it... but you're still certain that it'll all just work. Somehow. And it's not magic, you swear, even though you don't understand any of it.
It was aptly placed since you asked for information that is not available to the public then state that 'it isn't top secret'. I've stated the parties which stated that they'll do the rebuilding. Simple. How will I know how much it will cost or how long it will take? This is idiotic now. As I said only those who hold the position within those organisations will know. Rebuilding will always accomplish something vs leaving the place in rubble.

If you're claiming that their plans match YOUR plans, then yes, you should know at least something about the scale and scope of their plans, otherwise you're just pulling crap out of your ass.
I didn't claim that their 'plans match mine' because I've not seen their plans. I am contented though that a measure of rebuilding will take place.
Simple things you don't seem to grasp.

Yes you have. You specifically referred to them when challenged about who would accomplish your plan.
No, I didn't refer to them as parties that 'I want to do the work', I referred to them as parties who stated publicly that they will. Simple stuff. Again.

It may make them face the harsh reality of the choice before them: continued war and peace.

The less costly you make the choice of war, the more likely you make their decision to continue it.
Yup, somehow living in rubble will have a positive. I'll bypass this ********.

Key word. The schools are used for indoctrination by Hamas, the hospitals are used as operations centers, and neither has done anything to loosen the grip that Hamas has on Palestinian society.
Yup, all the schools and hospitals serve no purpose to the Palestinians. Man, this is getting dumber and dumber as I scroll down.

You keep misrepresenting my position. It is a necessary step, but it's a necessary second step. Attempting to accomplish it before the necessary first step (getting rid of Hamas, choosing peace) will accomplish nothing.
It is a necessary step. Good. Finally, you admit that it is. I view it as part of that process. To get rid of Hamas they'll need an alternative. By alternative, I mean a group that will a a military protection for Palestine. This I have no suggestion on as yet but I was thinking another country pledging this as it has been done. You see Israel's word that they'll 'be good' doesn't account to much. I know you'll rant on that but it is how they're seen.

I'm leaving now and it has been too pointless going through your statements as the discussion is now at the point where you're forgetting initial statements.
 
Note: The Japanese fought during the war, to death. The attacks stopped after they surrendered. The US did not go back and impose border restrictions or held mass arrest, and so forth. The Japanese were left to rebuild their country and eventually their economy. Even the emperor was not removed. Had they been subjected to continual 'bad' treatment even after the conflict will they not lash back or held marches against it as the blacks in SA?

Sure we did, while we occupied them. The restrictions (and the entire occupation) were lifted after it was clear that Japan posed no more threat to the US. But not before then.

PhilosophicalCaveman said:
The Japanese were not given a 'good' deal either.
Given that you seemed unaware of the 7-year occupation, re-writing of the Constitution, complete disarmament, trial of war criminals, implementation of border controls and other tenets of the end of WWII, just who in the hell are you to comment on this? :confused:
 
Can anyone today sit through Schindler's List, especially the Warsaw Ghetto scenes, without some serious cognitive dissonance? :boxedin:
 
What is your goal in criticism?

If you want things to change, your criticism at least has the goal of giving support to those with the power to change things. Condemning violence from Israel but not from Hamas does in fact reward Hamas. Criticizing Israel for things that are in fact the responsibility of Hamas rewards Hamas. This is in fact why Hamas does many of these things. It is to get international pressure put on Israel, and it's been working. Voicing criticism of Israel without also pointing out any condemnations of Hamas (their direct enemy) can have the effect of punishing Israel and rewarding Hamas.

I've not come across someone who supports Hamas, their actions will continue with or without criticisms towards Israel. I think voicing (as is done in social media) raises the issue and opens it to be discussed. Others might criticize only to voice their concerns without knowing whether it will change or not. I have doubts on if those who have the power to change things will go against their set agenda. Looking back at the demonstrations against certain government activities (as protests against going to war). Without criticizing Israel means that a person is in agreement or looks as if they're in agreement. If there is no one to speak on their actions (in and out of the conflict), Hamas will not stop based on this but Israel will continue and see nothing wrong with bombing market places or UN schools without being accountable. Countries are questioned and Israel is not an exception. The US use of drones for example has been questioned and spoken out against, this was not a 'punishment' to the US but for them to step up. If someone criticizes Hamas, I don't see this as a reward for Israel and a punishment for Palestine. They're directing their view and are free to that. But ideally, yes, both should occur (I've seen that the UN did it by condemning both sides) but criticism shouldn't be refuted with a 'this does this and you say nothing', instead it can just be directly addressed.

I don't know what you mean by 'can claim and it remains as claims'.
I meant that it is a statement by Israel and remains as a statement, than as an action.

While I like comparing and contrasting similar situations and finding consistency in reasoning, I agree that talk of ISIS can be off topic. Sometimes it is just a gotcha, or an attack of the 'appeal to worse problems' sort. But it also can be useful for finding out why there is more international pressure, action, and condemnation on Israel than on other groups. In this way I think the lack of action against Egypt and Assad and others is on topic and illuminating. If you don't want to examine your own motivations personally using these comparisons, I have serious reservations about your motivations overall. That doesn't mean I feel you must discuss them here, but that it would be beneficial for you to use these questions to explore your motivations and consistency for yourself.

That should be raised when ISIS is being discussed unless there is a comparison being made between ISIS and Israel. If a person views Israel as they do ISIS then I can see how that might relate but still there is no room to state that a person must openly condemn the other in order for their argument to be acknowledge. There will be a long list of groups that should be 'condemn'. It is all based on how they'll be related to the topic or what is said. There is more international pressure on Israel because it is seen as part of the West and should be on a different standard than groups as the ISIS. These groups are not easy to get through to as a setup government will be. When on topic on the ISIS, it is usually agreed that no one is in support of their actions, even the regular Muslims are oppose to it.

Again, what is the goal of your criticism? What do you want it to accomplish? Do you think it adds to the understanding of others to the situation or do you think it reinforces false narratives? I think it reinforces false narratives of the moral equivalency and golden mean sorts.
Truth? So far I've been stuck clarifying a point I made some pages back.
I have no online goals other than to hold discussions on and off while at work. If you think about it nothing said in the forum will actually affect the situation but still each person is still free to voice their plight or opinion.
 
Given that you seemed unaware of the 7-year occupation, re-writing of the Constitution, complete disarmament, trial of war criminals, implementation of border controls and other tenets of the end of WWII, just who in the hell are you to comment on this? :confused:

Ah, you're addressing me now or is this another event where you state something and keep silent on the response given? (said in the most kind tone as interwebly as possible)

I am aware of what happened to Japan after WW2 and the deals made among the Allies. After the US left they didn't go back. Israel do influence the Palestinians who haven't agreed to it. It is a continual conflict that the Palestinians face with border restrictions (not on military but on other important items), mass arrests, etc. Even after conflicts unlike Japan who didn't after the departure of the allies. The US left and they didn't go back to harass Japan. The situation of the two can't relate as both cases differ.
I can comment freely, Sir/Ms Aspiring interweb Police. You are free to feel offended or mistreated with tones on it.
 
Can anyone today sit through Schindler's List, especially the Warsaw Ghetto scenes, without some serious cognitive dissonance? :boxedin:
I can do so without any difficulty at all, yes. Why:confused:?

Edit:
PhilosophicalCaveman: sometimes, when you realize you're wrong and that the person you're talking to has a point, it's an idea to simply accept it and move on with your life, rather than backpedalling, moving goalposts or building stramwe; perhaps you could try that?
 
Last edited:
I am aware of what happened to Japan after WW2 and the deals made among the Allies.
Since when? Since 2 days ago when you wrote this?

PhilosophicalCaveman said:
The US did not go back and impose border restrictions or held mass arrest, and so forth. The Japanese were left to rebuild their country and eventually their economy


After the US left they didn't go back.
Yes, after the Japanese fully surrendered, and accepted the terms, and the US occupied Japan and rebuilt its government and infrastructure, and departed 7 years later, leaving forces in several Japanese cities, the US didn't go back." Here is a clue -- we didn't have to "go back" because we never left. Today, there are US troops in Okinawa, Honshu and Kyushu prefectures.

Get your facts straight.
 
Please explain what Jews being systematically murdered and Israel defending itself have in common.
Oh, you know, it's like how apples and space shuttles are the same thing, since they both contain the letter "a". It's not a true Israel-Palestine discussion without completely different scenarios and things being equivocated:o.
 
Killing unarmed civilians is inevitable based on how Hamas fights? I was referring to the incidences apart from the bombings. Your conclusion is based on what?

Based on overwhelming evidence.

-Maybe Israel should as well. Then both can go about their business.

Hamas will not leave Israel alone even if Israel leaves them alone. This is your most insidious lie.

You live with restrictions that are placed on the Palestinians? because if you have sense then you'll note that that is the contents of the word 'restrictions'.

"Context", not "content". And I have no idea which restrictions you think are so terrible that they make life not worth living if you do not specify. And you did not specify. Restrictions on the importation of arms, for example - do they contribute to this alleged meaninglessness of life?

You do understand that the gun is used as intimidation in the context you proposed and it doesn't mean that a person will submit to it (dead/alive) that this will not matter to the individual?

Your grammar is too mangled to make sense of this reply.

That's what Israel claims.

Not just Israel, also independent journalists. See above.

Israel still views Hamas as a threat as it did in the beginning of the conflict. They don't seem to agree with you.

Israel considers the immediate threat to have been reduced. Without rockets or tunnels, Hamas is much less of a threat to Israel. Hamas needs neither of these things to threaten other Palestinians.

It is a statement that Israel doesn't care for Palestinians casualties, whether it is their obligation or not. It is their responsibility. Hamas as well.

No. It is NOT Israel's responsibility. It is Hamas's responsibility. Israel's responsibility towards Palestinians extends no further than the concept of proportionate response.

How many builders were killed by Hamas in the past for rebuilding destroyed buildings in Palestine?

None that I know of. How much influence has Hamas lost in the past because of reconstructed buildings? Also none.

There is the issue of building on land that Palestinians consider their own land

Yeah, well, it's not. Just like Spain no longer belongs to the Caliphate.

You do know that there is more to 'Palestine' than 'Gaza' and that it is one area?

No, it's not one area. There's Gaza, and there's the West Bank. Gaza was formerly part of Egypt. The West Bank was formerly part of Jordan. Hamas is in control of Gaza. It is not in control of the West Bank.

You made the assumption, I didn't. I acknowledge it as your assumption or maybe you'll feel better if I state that I acknowledge that it is your opinion.

Once again, YOU stated that Hamas wants and benefits from chaos. It is not an assumption but a logical conclusion that a party which benefits from a condition will act to perpetuate that condition. You just don't like the results of elementary logic being applied to your own statement.

More opinions. Good and you know that it will not add to Hamas' image if they destroy all the buildings in Palestine among the Palestinians? It will not 'empower or enrich' them but still loosen their influence.

Again with the ridiculous misrepresentations. Hamas doesn't need to destroy buildings, because buildings pose no threat to Hamas's power. They can commandeer any building in Gaza that they want.

Leveling the buildings will be a threat to their image.

According to you, leaving the buildings to stand would be a threat to their image, which logically means that they should not let them stand.

I happen to think your premise is absurd to begin with.

Justice can have an objective basis

But you're appealing to the subjective impression of justice, so whatever objective basis you think it might have is irrelevant. Your argument is that Palestinians feel they have been treated unjustly. This is true, but irrelevant: since their feeling is subjective, they could feel this way whether or not their treatment was objectively justified.

-The law is when something is stated and someone goes against it, the 'justice' is there when the punishment is carried out based on the law/precedent.

No. Plenty of laws and their associated punishments are unjust.

By relevant laws you mean their own laws or International laws? I figure

Both.

Do you view is as just/unjust?

Mostly I view it as an inevitable consequence of Hamas's actions. "Just" or not, there's really no other way that you could expect Israel to respond. It is certainly tragic, but I lay responsibility for that tragedy squarely on Hamas's shoulders, because they were the clear aggressors here.

You acknowledge that Japan in WW2 is different to Palestine in present times and yet want a similarity to be drawn up as to why one doesn't act as the other.

Oh, I know why they're different. I even told you why they are different. I don't think you do, though. You just don't like the comparison because it hurts your argument.

Should the Palestine react to Israel the way Japan reacted to China during WW2? Or are you going to be selective on that one.

That's a stupid question. The Palestinians do not have the physical capability to act towards Israel as Japan acted towards China. You might as well ask if frogs with wings would bump their asses when they jumped.

They do, however, have the physical capability to stop attacking Israel. And I can blame them for the consequences of their failure to do so.

Nice summary on what you perceive are the values of Palestinians.

I note that you cannot dispute the accuracy of that summary.

After war is very simple 'after the war'. You understand that?

I do indeed. And how do we reach the point of 'after the war'? Do you understand that?

It is a continuous issue between Palestinians outside of the spike in attacks.

Without attacks, there is no war! That is what DEFINES war.

Why should Palestine 'surrender' itself to Israel

Because they suffer more than Israel every time there is armed conflict. Because Israel is strong and they are weak. And because that will bring them peace.

But they do not yet want peace. And so they will have war.

The Palestinians have no reason to believe Israel.

And yet, their continuation of war is fruitless. Do they have reason to believe Hamas? No, they don't.

The Japanese were not given a 'good' deal either.

Yet they did not resort to terrorism. Why? Because "good" deal or not, peace was a much better deal than war.

And so it is with the Palestinians as well: peace is a better deal. Yet Hamas continues to refuse it. Therefore Hamas is responsible for the pain and suffering that follow from that refusal.

Wars with/without victory doesn't break an animosity cycle.

This is delusional.

You will not understand unless you empathize with a Palestinian. There are people who don't throw in the towel and surrender unconditionally.

And they will reap the consequences.

Why should they?

Because it is better than the alternative.

Giving up may not bring them peace, unless you mean submission brings peace.

It did for the Japanese and Germans in WW2.

Those held in the concentration camps by the Nazis (JWs, Jews, Gypsies, etc) were submissive, didn't give them peace.

The Israelis are not Nazis. They have no interest in exterminating the Palestinians, especially if the Palestinians stopped attacking.

The Palestinians don't trust Israel based on Israel's actions (in and out of the conflict).

If the Palestinians believe the Israelis will exterminate them if they stop fighting, then they are delusional. There is no reason to bend reality to flatter such a delusion.

You realize that I did mention Egypt every time I spoke on the borders

But you did not blame them, nor did you point out the reasons, implications, and consequences of Hamas not blaming them.

There were no cases of falsely arrested civilians?

You have presented none.

Then you propose nothing?

I propose that Hamas stop attacking Israel.

It was aptly placed since you asked for information that is not available to the public then state that 'it isn't top secret'.

Fundraising objectives are public.

I've stated the parties which stated that they'll do the rebuilding.

But you've got no idea whether or not these efforts would be sufficient, even assuming that your plan could succeed.

How will I know how much it will cost or how long it will take?

If you don't even have order-of-magnitude idea, then you have no plan at all, only a platitude.

Rebuilding will always accomplish something vs leaving the place in rubble.

You didn't claim that rebuilding would accomplish something . You claimed it would accomplish peace.

Yup, somehow living in rubble will have a positive. I'll bypass this ********.

It was a necessary step for both Japan and Germany.

You see Israel's word that they'll 'be good' doesn't account to much. I know you'll rant on that but it is how they're seen.

They're also seen as people who kill non-Jews to use their blood in religious rituals. How they are seen is not an indicator of how they are, nor is it a justification for terrorism.

Israel has demonstrated a willingness for peace. Hamas never has. This is the reality of the situation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom