Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The people of Palestine's plight seem to only be that they want more freedom and the blockade by Israel & Egypt to end.
What is stopping an independent organisation from rebuilding Palestine and easing on the blockade and the alleged land-grabbing?
The psychological warfare/strategic bombings that Israel is undertaking will result in nothing in the long run, unless the objective is to eradicate Palestine/Gaza (that's another debate that I'll not get into or hold interest in).
Hamas only has power in chaos and the frustration in that area fuels it.
I opine that there are hidden agendas that are not openly stated by the Israeli government & Hamas.
 
On a side note there is 'benefits' to bombing civilian areas and places where civilians might feel safe example the UN school building. That is why it was done in WW2. I'm not stating that that is Israel's intentions (it may/may not be) no one here really knows.
 
The people of Palestine's plight seem to only be that they want more freedom and the blockade by Israel & Egypt to end.
What is stopping an independent organisation from rebuilding Palestine and easing on the blockade and the alleged land-grabbing?

Hamas will not cede control to any independent organization. They could come in and help "rebuild", but Hamas would still be in charge of what got rebuilt. Furthermore, where's the money to do this going to come from? And what's the point, as long as Hamas remains in charge? They'll just use anything you build , so that it will become a target in their next attempt to kill Jews.

The psychological warfare/strategic bombings that Israel is undertaking will result in nothing in the long run, unless the objective is to eradicate Palestine/Gaza (that's another debate that I'll not get into or hold interest in).
Hamas only has power in chaos and the frustration in that area fuels it.
I opine that there are hidden agendas that are not openly stated by the Israeli government & Hamas.

You're overthinking this from Israel's standpoint. They were attacked with rockets, and they struck back. Hamas was building tunnels to infiltrate Israel, and Israel invaded Gaza to shut down those tunnels. Whether or not that will "result in nothing in the long run" isn't really the point, there was still a short-term necessity to do so. No democracy can afford to let its citizens be attacked with impunity.

And Hamas's agenda is pretty openly stated: they want to kill Jews. The more complex motives come from Qatar, their current sugar daddy.
 
Hamas will not cede control to any independent organization. They could come in and help "rebuild", but Hamas would still be in charge of what got rebuilt. Furthermore, where's the money to do this going to come from? And what's the point, as long as Hamas remains in charge? They'll just use anything you build , so that it will become a target in their next attempt to kill Jews.



You're overthinking this from Israel's standpoint. They were attacked with rockets, and they struck back. Hamas was building tunnels to infiltrate Israel, and Israel invaded Gaza to shut down those tunnels. Whether or not that will "result in nothing in the long run" isn't really the point, there was still a short-term necessity to do so. No democracy can afford to let its citizens be attacked with impunity.

And Hamas's agenda is pretty openly stated: they want to kill Jews. The more complex motives come from Qatar, their current sugar daddy.

I gather that you're a pro-Israeli supporter by your comments.
It is not conceding to an independent organisation. Hamas' power/influence in that area is based on one thing only and that is the chaos in that area, it doesn't matter who takes the place of Hamas, once the Palestinians have stability and protection, there is no way an organisation as Hamas can flourish.

I read a poster's comment that the bombing of civilians & the UN building does not have any benefits to Israel, but it actually does have its 'benefits'.
There are no benefits in the long run or the short run should the current patch-work continue. This conflict has been ongoing for many years, this is not a new occurrence. More focus on getting the Palestinian people stable is a good approach. The blockade is an important part of this.
 
Last edited:
Offtopic
On your statement:
"And that itself is a problem. The conflict would likely diminish if the rest of the world simply didn't give a ****. Every condemnation of Israel ends up encouraging and rewarding Hamas, and therefore prolonging the conflict."

I think the opposite. 'The world' can pose as an independent observer looking on. It is important to have a global awareness of all events. I don't know what you place as 'encouraging/rewarding Hamas', since I've not heard 'pro-Hamas' slogans by persons who speak out on the conflict or criticize the Israeli government's actions.
US, Egypt, Israel, Palestine are not independent parties.
 
I gather that you're a pro-Israeli supporter by your comments.
It is not conceding to an independent organisation. Hamas' power/influence in that area is based on one thing only and that is the chaos in that area

No. Hamas rose to power largely because the populace backed its goal (killing Jews). Now that it's in power, however, it can maintain that power based on the fact that they're the ones with the guns. Unless you take those guns away (and good luck with that), then they will remain the ones in power.

it doesn't matter who takes the place of Hamas, once the Palestinians have stability and protection, there is no way an organisation as Hamas can flourish.

And how do you imagine you can accomplish this? Again, Hamas has guns. They are willing to use them, against intruders AND against their fellow Palestinians. How will you provide stability when Hamas is willing to kill to create instability? You cannot, not unless you kill Hamas. Which you aren't willing to do.
 
Hamas' power/influence in that area is based on one thing only and that is the chaos in that area, it doesn't matter who takes the place of Hamas, once the Palestinians have stability and protection, there is no way an organisation as Hamas can flourish.

That's a bit too 'cut n dry' imo. Yes, Hamas influence has been to leech off of the desperation, poverty, frustration and ideological dogmas festering about the palestinian populus. And they've been very effective in using that as leverage, there and abroad. They, or at least their militant branch, didn't (and don't) really do it out of love for their own people, rather they do it on behalf of the idea of triumph through agony. It's almost textbook commonplace when looking at "tribal" conflicts throughout history. And it is always the more passive non-combatants who reap the spoiled "fruits" of onslaught... you know, civilians who just get killed, and whose deaths add to the polarisation of the extremes. I can sympathise with the dynamics that made palestinians think Hamas could be a change for positive, but they weren't really using their heads at all, just ignorance. When you have little else but blood to give, that is exactly what you give and in spades. So, gaining stability and protection might leave Hamasian extremism with a smaller pool to extract support from. As it is though, I wouldn't bet on it. Unfortunately, too many people have too much invested in their ideas and perception of past wrongdoings (which might be appliable on both sides of the sword).
 
Last edited:
No. Hamas rose to power largely because the populace backed its goal (killing Jews). Now that it's in power, however, it can maintain that power based on the fact that they're the ones with the guns. Unless you take those guns away (and good luck with that), then they will remain the ones in power.

Nah, it might be difficult for you to believe that the Palestinians are not a bunch of barbaric Jew-slaughtering Nazis. There are many rational reasons why Hamas came into power and remain in power.
Imagine yourself in that situation, growing up and facing a blockade and other injustices. Israel positions itself as Jewish. Do you think that in that heated scenario you'll distinguish the actions of the Israeli government (a country by itself) and the religion or group of persons who identify themselves as Jews?
Palestinians know what they have to face and what they want. It is stupidity to believe that Hamas can wipe out Israel (or the world jews).


And how do you imagine you can accomplish this? Again, Hamas has guns. They are willing to use them, against intruders AND against their fellow Palestinians. How will you provide stability when Hamas is willing to kill to create instability? You cannot, not unless you kill Hamas. Which you aren't willing to do.

-Who are you referring to as 'intruders'? If you mean outside parties who are independent (non-Israeli/Palestinian) and pose no threat then that is based on what? From what I see independent parties as aid-workers, journalists etc are not targeted.

-Well, is it a case that I'm not willing to do it? idk man, I own no guns and no one offered me a ticket to Gaza. As much as you'd fancy seeing me with a gun and killin' em Hamas.

I'm not a pacifist either but I see that stability and a gradual end to the blockade is a better way for the Palestinians and a way to stifle out Hamas. Who do you think will become part of 'Hamas' in the future or even the present? -Maybe the kid who witness his family being wiped out by a 'Jew bomber' showing disregard for their life. That's just a thought. I wanted you to see that the fuel Hamas gets is not from some irrational 'jew-hate' but they get it from the situation. Similar to Israelis who hate Palestinians due to Hamas and what they face.

Hamas can come to an end and strategic bombing is more a way to keep their influence than to remove it.
 
Jono, there are Palestinians who don't support Hamas, I don't know the percentage but that will be a strong position and an important factor.
I agree it is ignorance, but it is also based on experience and I see that on both sides when reading on the opinions of the Israeli & Palestinian civilians. What other option will a Palestinian have? There is a distrust towards Israel, Egypt & US as well as the PA, etc. Hamas positions itself as 'being against those who pose the restrictions/injustice'. How will they be able to sustain their position in a stable Palestine, with no blockade? That is just my take on how a pro-Hamas Palestinian might reason. I'd like to chat with one to find out instead of having to assume.
You said that 'when you have little else but blood to give, that is exactly what you give', why would it be necessary to sacrifice oneself in a stable environment? There has to be a cause to fight against.
 
I gather that you're a pro-Israeli supporter by your comments.
It is not conceding to an independent organisation. Hamas' power/influence in that area is based on one thing only and that is the chaos in that area, it doesn't matter who takes the place of Hamas, once the Palestinians have stability and protection, there is no way an organisation as Hamas can flourish.

I read a poster's comment that the bombing of civilians & the UN building does not have any benefits to Israel, but it actually does have its 'benefits'.
There are no benefits in the long run or the short run should the current patch-work continue. This conflict has been ongoing for many years, this is not a new occurrence. More focus on getting the Palestinian people stable is a good approach. The blockade is an important part of this.

Maybe you should tell that to Hamas.
 
Nah, it might be difficult for you to believe that the Palestinians are not a bunch of barbaric Jew-slaughtering Nazis.

Hamas is. They make no secret of it. The Palestinians elected Hamas knowing full well their nature. What conclusion do you expect me to draw from that fact?

There are many rational reasons why Hamas came into power and remain in power.

I disagree, but it doesn't even matter. Regardless of how the gained power, they now have it, and they will keep it too, as long as they have the guns. How will you take away their guns? You have suggested no method for doing so.

Imagine yourself in that situation, growing up and facing a blockade and other injustices.

Your justifications for why Hamas wants to kill Jews is irrelevant to me. It's also rather ahistorical, and ignores the fact that such hatred preceded the existence of Israel.

Do you think that in that heated scenario you'll distinguish the actions of the Israeli government (a country by itself) and the religion or group of persons who identify themselves as Jews?

Likewise irrelevant. This has absolutely no bearing on the infeasibility of your proposal.

Palestinians know what they have to face and what they want. It is stupidity to believe that Hamas can wipe out Israel (or the world jews).

And yet, that is what Hamas is determined to do.

-Who are you referring to as 'intruders'? If you mean outside parties who are independent (non-Israeli/Palestinian) and pose no threat then that is based on what? From what I see independent parties as aid-workers, journalists etc are not targeted.

They are not targeted so long as they do nothing to threaten Hamas's dominance. But for your scheme to have any possibility of succeeding, Hamas must be removed from power. Without that precondition, it is doomed to failure. And Hamas will not willingly accept removal from power. So your intruders would indeed need to threaten Hamas, and Hamas would indeed respond with violence.

-Well, is it a case that I'm not willing to do it?

I'm not speaking of you personally going. I know nothing about your situation (maybe you're old, maybe you're infirm, and even if you were personally a coward that wouldn't invalidate your argument). But are you willing to vote to send the armed forces of your country to spend blood and money to secure the removal of Hamas? Because that's what it would take.

I don't think you're willing to do that, but that too doesn't really matter. I know that no other nation is willing to do that.

I'm not a pacifist either but I see that stability and a gradual end to the blockade is a better way for the Palestinians and a way to stifle out Hamas.

You have the sequence of necessary events reversed. Israel's obligation is to its own people first and foremost. As long as Hamas is in power, then Israel will not let Gaza have unrestricted access to the outside world, because that access will simply be used to import weapons to attack Israel. That's unfortunate for the Palestinians, but again, that's not who Israel has an obligation to. Until Hamas is removed, then an end to the "blockade" will simply not happen.

Oh, and don't forget that Egypt is willingly choosing to enforce this same "blockade". Ponder why, and also ponder why they don't get any blame.

Who do you think will become part of 'Hamas' in the future or even the present? -Maybe the kid who witness his family being wiped out by a 'Jew bomber' showing disregard for their life. That's just a thought.

How many Japanese people did American bombers kill? Not just with nuclear bombs, but even worse with the fire bombing of major cities including Tokyo. Did the Japanese become terrorists? No, they did not.

What you describe is not inevitable. It is a choice, a choice with moral significance.

And who do you think will become part of the IDF in the future or even the present? Maybe the kid who has to cower in a bomb shelter because of the katyusha rockets. Even to the extent that we accept your "cycle of violence" logic, why do you apply it in only one direction? Why does only Israel have agency and thus responsibility?

I wanted you to see that the fuel Hamas gets is not from some irrational 'jew-hate' but they get it from the situation.

Except that irrational 'jew-hate' is, in fact, a normal part of Palestinian life now. It is infused in the curriculum of school children. It forms the core of Hamas's very founding charter. To ignore the role of antisemitism in the conflict is to willingly blind yourself to reality.

Hamas can come to an end

But you cannot describe a realistic path towards accomplishing that.

and strategic bombing is more a way to keep their influence than to remove it.

Bombing is a way to protect Israel from an immediate threat. It needs no other justification.
 
In every picture I see of a bombed building in Gaza with a bunch of people picking through the rubble, my mind draws a red circle around one of them and labels it "new terrorist".

I just don't see how bombing Gaza will do anything but perpetuate the cycle.
 
Imagine yourself in that situation, growing up and facing a blockade and other injustices.
Not this again. Firstly, you're getting chronology all wrong; the blockade and the security barrier are results of fanaticism and terror, not the other way around.

Secondly, as you well know, there are lots and lots of people out there living under injustices. Far from all of them respond by taking up arms against innocent people. Most of them will either fight against their oppressors themselves, appeal to the international community for help, or do nothing.

There are exceptions, of course. Bin Laden and Manhattan. HAMAS and Israel. Breivik and Oslo/Utøya. But for the most part, humans are fortunately more peaceful than that. Which is why you don't see Finnish, Ukrainian or Georgian terrorists "defending their country" against the Russian occupiers by lobbing rockets at Russian city blocks, nor do you see Tibetans strapping bombs to their bodies for then to blow themselves up on Chinese school buses.

Most humans in 2014 are more civilized than that.

Israel positions itself as Jewish. Do you think that in that heated scenario you'll distinguish the actions of the Israeli government (a country by itself) and the religion or group of persons who identify themselves as Jews?
Yup.

I wanted you to see that the fuel Hamas gets is not from some irrational 'jew-hate' but they get it from the situation. Similar to Israelis who hate Palestinians due to Hamas and what they face.
If you want us to "see" this, give us some arguments instead of just sitting there going "what would you do".
 
Hamas is. They make no secret of it. The Palestinians elected Hamas knowing full well their nature. What conclusion do you expect me to draw from that fact?
The only conclusion I draw from that is that Hamas is, the Palestinians aren't. The same as say the US government's action in the ME not representing the citizens.

I disagree, but it doesn't even matter. Regardless of how the gained power, they now have it, and they will keep it too, as long as they have the guns. How will you take away their guns? You have suggested no method for doing so.

You can disagree but it's very one-sided to not consider that there are reasons why Hamas was elected and why they have the support of some Palestinians. I think that is one of the most important things to assess in cutting Hamas' power. Guns doesn't mean they'll maintain power or that it keeps them 'in power', they need recruits and support.

Your justifications for why Hamas wants to kill Jews is irrelevant to me. It's also rather ahistorical, and ignores the fact that such hatred preceded the existence of Israel.

It is not 'justifications' but for you to empathize or understand the view of the Palestinians. It is not a 'want to kill the jews' but they see Israel as jews and an oppressor. It is not hatred that stemmed from some mystical hate for jews. If you view it as irrelevant then what is the point of discussing anything further? Your inability to separate Palestinians from Hamas is the same as some Palestinians have of separating Jews from Israel.

They are not targeted so long as they do nothing to threaten Hamas's dominance. But for your scheme to have any possibility of succeeding, Hamas must be removed from power. Without that precondition, it is doomed to failure. And Hamas will not willingly accept removal from power. So your intruders would indeed need to threaten Hamas, and Hamas would indeed respond with violence.
My intruders are who? Fixing another government in lieu of Hamas isn't what I proposed. I stated that an independent body can come in to rebuild Palestine and the plight of the Palestinians should be considered (that of wanting stability, 'land-grabbing' and a gradual end to the blockade).

I'm not speaking of you personally going. I know nothing about your situation (maybe you're old, maybe you're infirm, and even if you were personally a coward that wouldn't invalidate your argument). But are you willing to vote to send the armed forces of your country to spend blood and money to secure the removal of Hamas? Because that's what it would take. I don't think you're willing to do that, but that too doesn't really matter. I know that no other nation is willing to do that.

You directed your statement towards me, so I supposed that you were referring to me as a person. Why will I have to vote for my armed forces to invade another place and remove a group there? And that is what it will take for what? I see no relevance in this statement.

You have the sequence of necessary events reversed. Israel's obligation is to its own people first and foremost. As long as Hamas is in power, then Israel will not let Gaza have unrestricted access to the outside world, because that access will simply be used to import weapons to attack Israel. That's unfortunate for the Palestinians, but again, that's not who Israel has an obligation to. Until Hamas is removed, then an end to the "blockade" will simply not happen.

Oh, and don't forget that Egypt is willingly choosing to enforce this same "blockade". Ponder why, and also ponder why they don't get any blame.

I actually mentioned Egypt in other postings. Israel can be obligated to its citizens but its actions are moving outside of that and affecting the Palestinians, so yes, they do have a part to play in the matter. It is much more than 'accessing the outside world', it is viewed as a prison.


How many Japanese people did American bombers kill? Not just with nuclear bombs, but even worse with the fire bombing of major cities including Tokyo. Did the Japanese become terrorists? No, they did not.

What you describe is not inevitable. It is a choice, a choice with moral significance.

And who do you think will become part of the IDF in the future or even the present? Maybe the kid who has to cower in a bomb shelter because of the katyusha rockets. Even to the extent that we accept your "cycle of violence" logic, why do you apply it in only one direction? Why does only Israel have agency and thus responsibility?

The Japanese & American situation is no comparison to the Israel & Palestine situation and history. You understand this, right? I'll disregard that point.
Do you really think that these events will have no effect on the kids that has to view it? I didn't 'apply it in one direction' either, I was responding to your statement on Hamas. Your call to 'kill Hamas'. Mentioning the cycle is to show you that you can't 'kill Hamas' when there are others who can take its place. The way is to get at the root and cut it. I proposed that stability is how you cut it. Simple. I don't know where you got ideas of WW2 & IDF.

Except that irrational 'jew-hate' is, in fact, a normal part of Palestinian life now. It is infused in the curriculum of school children. It forms the core of Hamas's very founding charter. To ignore the role of antisemitism in the conflict is to willingly blind yourself to reality.
rhetorical question: Why do you think that is so?
You expressed that it is irrelevant to discuss or consider the reasons for that. It is a cycle and based on what the children has to experience and deduce even on their own.

But you cannot describe a realistic path towards accomplishing that.
I've already stated an idea on how Hamas can come to an end, it is stability and providing an alternative that the Palestinians will accept. I don't see this happening at the moment as each party has their own agenda at hand.

Bombing is a way to protect Palestine Israel from an immediate threat. It needs no other justification.
If that line of reasoning helps you so be it.
 
Not this again. Firstly, you're getting chronology all wrong; the blockade and the security barrier are results of fanaticism and terror, not the other way around.

I suggest that you follow the order I was responding to the poster. It was not a chronological representation of events.

Secondly, as you well know, there are lots and lots of people out there living under injustices. Far from all of them respond by taking up arms against innocent people. Most of them will either fight against their oppressors themselves, appeal to the international community for help, or do nothing.
There are also examples of groups who do not. Are we going to go through who does what and who doesn't?... I see no point in your statement.

There are exceptions, of course. Bin Laden and Manhattan. HAMAS and Israel. Breivik and Oslo/Utøya. But for the most part, humans are fortunately more peaceful than that. Which is why you don't see Finnish, Ukrainian or Georgian terrorists "defending their country" against the Russian occupiers by lobbing rockets at Russian city blocks, nor do you see Tibetans strapping bombs to their bodies for then to blow themselves up on Chinese school buses.
The situation with Israel & Palestine is unique to themselves, comparing it to other situations would leave out a lot of parts that made that situation the way it is. I also don't see any relevance to your statement but feel free to expand on it and tell me how it relates.

Most humans in 2014 are more civilized than that.

Yup.
Ah, depends on what you label as civilized. I can't recall any pacifist country. One without a military, etc.

If you want us to "see" this, give us some arguments instead of just sitting there going "what would you do".
Again, there is no 'us', my post was directed to a discussion. I was demonstrating a point. What arguments are you hoping for?
 
Global revulsion at the mind-numbing carnage of Israel’s onslaught on Gaza seems finally to have spurred some of the western political class to speak out. The resignation of Sayeeda Warsi, Britain’s first Muslim cabinet minister, in protest against her government’s “morally indefensible” stance, emboldened Nick Clegg, the deputy prime minister, to demand the suspension of arms export licences to Israel....

Global public opinion has shifted decisively in favour of justice for the Palestinians. What’s needed is to turn that into unrelenting pressure for an end to support for occupation, an arms embargo and sanctions, from above and below. The horror of Gaza is a crime made in Washington and London, as well as Jerusalem.

Gaza is a crime made in Washington as well as Jerusalem
The carnage unleashed on the Palestinians is part of a decades-old routine that depends on western support

http://www.theguardian.com/commenti...-washington-jerusalem-carnage-western-support
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom