Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Apparently, the BBC removed Jeremy Bowen after he found no evidence of Hamas using Gazans as human shields and complaints from Israel. Any evidence for that?
 
Israel is the only reason anyone cares to begin with. The conflict isn't that significant on the world stage; only Israel's involvement and actions make it notable to begin with. They're similar to "us", but they do things that make "us" feel uneasy. Hamas are "others". We dislike them they do not challenge our identity. Us Europeans especially I think are bugged by Israeli jingoism.
Of course it won't go away. Nothing will put an end to the questions, not even proof to the contrary, because for many, the questions aren't really questions at all, but merely another excuse to justify hatred for Israel. The "questions" won't go away for the same reason that the blood libel won't go away.


I am having a hard time understanding which is the case???

Is it what you say above.... or is it what Ziggurat exemplifies???

Have Europeans suddenly turned into Jews now???


However, I have another theory for what you say below. I think it reveals a deeper psychological condition.

Israel is the only reason anyone cares to begin with. The conflict isn't that significant on the world stage; only Israel's involvement and actions make it notable to begin with. They're similar to "us", but they do things that make "us" feel uneasy. Hamas are "others". We dislike them they do not challenge our identity. Us Europeans especially I think are bugged by Israeli jingoism.


Europeans in their infancy were the underdog to Roman Imperialism but they matured into just as equally ruthlessly pitiless colonialist powers.


Could it be that Europeans now, in their hoary (wiser?) stage, see in Israel a reminder of their own bygone(?) days of self-righteous racism and self-attributed sense of superiority combined with unabated exploitation of “lesser humans” and merciless squashing of any that challenged their consumptive manifest destiny?

Maybe what makes people uneasy is watching in Israel a reenactment of the underdog rising up to be a just as ruthless and arrogantly self-righteous exploiter as his previous oppressors and thus realizing the inevitability of the inhumanity of humanity and our utterly impotent insignificance.
 
Last edited:
If Israel was a fraction as cruel as the European colonial powers, they'd be exploiting the Palestinians for Slave labour and cutting their hands off for not meeting quotas. Or feeding them to mastiffs in public as a warning. Or tying them to an artillery gun and dismembering them.
 
If Israel was a fraction as cruel as the European colonial powers, they'd be exploiting the Palestinians for Slave labour and cutting their hands off for not meeting quotas. Or feeding them to mastiffs in public as a warning. Or tying them to an artillery gun and dismembering them.


So what fraction would you give it? 1/10, 1/100?

A rapist who rapes 1 woman is just as much of a rapist as one who rapes 10.

A murderer who murders with a gun is as much a murderer as one who murders with a hammer.

A thief who robs 1 bank is just as much a thief as one who embezzles 1M shareholders.

A child abuser is just as heinous as an animal abuser.
 
Last edited:
So what fraction would you give it? 1/10, 1/100?

A rapist who rapes 1 woman is just as much of a rapist as one who rapes 10.

A murderer who murders with a gun is as much a murderer as one who murders with a hammer.

A thief who robs 1 bank is just as much a thief as one who embezzles 1M shareholders.

A child abuser is just as heinous as an animal abuser.
The point flew by up here ---->






...your head is down here someplace.
 
So do you think that because a man was abused as a child he should be allowed to abuse children?

If a man rapes your child and then later in court he cries and screams that he was abused as a child, would you ask the judge to let him go?

Nothing Zigg said suggests any of that.



Don't you think that the Palestinians have been well and truly sacrificed ENOUGH as the sacrificial lamb for the sins of the Europeans who you claim still hate us?

Wow, what a huge red herring.

They're not sacrificing anything for Europe's sake, they're suffering because they won't end their generational war against a superior foe. This latest incursion into Gaza? Would never have happened if Hamas hadn't started firing off their rockets.
 
Sure, sure... just not in the headline or the lede. Only Israel gets accused there. The pretense of balance can be maintained, even though it's anything but.

When I read the article the words "War Crimes" in the headline were in quotes. The way I read it, the writer was saying they weren't really war crimes.
 
There is no one who wants to do that job. Since Hamas wants to kill Jews, and is willing to kill its own civilians in its efforts to do so...


Just a side note; it's worth pointing out that Hamas kills a lot of Palestinians. All those rockets they were launching? A lot of them fell in Gaza and killed people. Nobody mentions it because nobody cares when Palestinian-Arabs are killed by other Palestinian-Arabs.
 
It needs to be pointed out that if the death toll is so lopsided, it is not through Lack of trying by HAMAS. It;s just that HAMAS has such lousy hardware with World War 2 era rockets.. SOmething that those who one sidedly condemn Israel while letting HAMAS off the hook forget.

We know that Israel could kill many more if they wanted. What should be asked is if Hamas could kill as many Israelis as they wanted, how many would they kill?
 
I get it. You're trying to be clever.

Let me know how that works out for you.


In order to frankly respond to your request I reflected about my many years of striving to be clever. I glanced at my cozy surroundings and ruminated about my humble achievements and as it turned out my efforts to be clever have in fact worked out spiffily well, thanks for asking old chump.

From the looks of it you need to try it sometime, it might afford you a better vantage point on reality and a better grasp of logic.

But I was in fact serious.... your remark was quite anti-Semitic by rational logic standards. I can explain further but it would be an utterly wasted effort from what I have observed around here. So I'd rather use your illogic and leave it up to you to futilely try to show why it is not anti-Semitic or else it stands guilty as charged as you yourself advocated.... after all it is a lot easier to use illogic than to exert an effort at trying to be clever…. I can appreciate your way now that I can afford to be lazy.

If someone can't explain why an idea isn't anti-Semitic, it could be because it is.


However, if you want to try to be clever then rather than uselessly defending your statement against the correct accusation of being anti-Semitic you might want to exert some grey cells at figuring out why it is in fact quite anti-Semitic.

“Let me know how that works out for you”
 
Last edited:
You just wrote an awful lot in order to simply refuse to explain.
 
Maybe I lack right-winged friends, but I can honestly say that don't know any right-winged equivalent of this phenomenon. Nobody is cheering the ground invasion or screaming for Arab blood.

true on this board, but go to CNN or any average news board (not a rational thinking or whatever board) and be prepared for the onslaught...

(but then againw e are speaking of boards where an article on tomatoe sauce leads to a republican-are-bad,democrat-are-worst word war within 5 posts tops, so....)
 
Last edited:
Israel is leaving Gaza, according to Norwegian media. So time for HAMAS to start licking its wounds and prepare another batch of rockets, I suppose, then we'll probably see another round in a few years :( .

Yes, but this was an entirely predictable way in which it would end, is it not? Has anyone seriously suggested there would be a different outcome, and if so what would that be?
 
IBut I was in fact serious.... your remark was quite anti-Semitic by rational logic standards. I can explain further but it would be an utterly wasted effort from what I have observed around here. So I'd rather use your illogic and leave it up to you to futilely try to show why it is not anti-Semitic or else it stands guilty as charged as you yourself advocated.... after all it is a lot easier to use illogic than to exert an effort at trying to be clever…. I can appreciate your way now that I can afford to be lazy.

I also said, "I think normal, reasonable people can decide for themselves if a charge of anti-Semitism is valid or not." At this point I'm pretty comfortable with how normal, reasonable people are likely to judge my statements, so further explanation seems unnecessary.
 
In order to frankly respond to your request I reflected about my many years of striving to be clever. I glanced at my cozy surroundings and ruminated about my humble achievements and as it turned out my efforts to be clever have in fact worked out spiffily well, thanks for asking old chump.

From the looks of it you need to try it sometime, it might afford you a better vantage point on reality and a better grasp of logic.

But I was in fact serious.... your remark was quite anti-Semitic by rational logic standards. I can explain further but it would be an utterly wasted effort from what I have observed around here. So I'd rather use your illogic and leave it up to you to futilely try to show why it is not anti-Semitic or else it stands guilty as charged as you yourself advocated.... after all it is a lot easier to use illogic than to exert an effort at trying to be clever…. I can appreciate your way now that I can afford to be lazy.




However, if you want to try to be clever then rather than uselessly defending your statement against the correct accusation of being anti-Semitic you might want to exert some grey cells at figuring out why it is in fact quite anti-Semitic.

“Let me know how that works out for you”

I can't make it through your posts. They disappear up their own backsides too swiftly
 
Still nobody taking up the claim that the BBC removed a long-standing ME reporter on Israel's request for claiming Hamas hasn't used human shields?
 
Still nobody taking up the claim that the BBC removed a long-standing ME reporter on Israel's request for claiming Hamas hasn't used human shields?

Check the BBC site:

The absence of Jeremy Bowen, the BBC's Middle East editor, from recent news bulletins has spawned a conspiracy theory that has taken on a life of its own on Twitter.

...

Or Bowen's Twitter thingy:

Few spotted Bowen's own explanation, posted on Friday. When asked why he'd stopped tweeting, he replied "because I'm on holiday".

That took about 5 seconds of Googling. How will you repay me!?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom