Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The New Yorker weighs in with a recap of the ethics of the latest spat:

http://www.newyorker.com/news/john-cassidy/israeli-pullback-wont-quell-questions

"But even if the level of violence does decrease, that won’t put an end to questions about Israel’s conduct of its military campaign, and whether it has committed war crimes in Gaza."

Of course it won't go away. Nothing will put an end to the questions, not even proof to the contrary, because for many, the questions aren't really questions at all, but merely another excuse to justify hatred for Israel. The "questions" won't go away for the same reason that the blood libel won't go away.

Now where's the New Yorker article about the question of Hamas's war crimes?
 
"But even if the level of violence does decrease, that won’t put an end to questions about Israel’s conduct of its military campaign, and whether it has committed war crimes in Gaza."

Of course it won't go away. Nothing will put an end to the questions, not even proof to the contrary, because for many, the questions aren't really questions at all, but merely another excuse to justify hatred for Israel. The "questions" won't go away for the same reason that the blood libel won't go away.

Now where's the New Yorker article about the question of Hamas's war crimes?

If you are speaking of human shields, and rocket attacks on civilians, those are also raised in the same article.
 
Israel is leaving Gaza, according to Norwegian media. So time for HAMAS to start licking its wounds and prepare another batch of rockets, I suppose, then we'll probably see another round in a few years :( .

I don;t think it will take that long.....
 
"But even if the level of violence does decrease, that won’t put an end to questions about Israel’s conduct of its military campaign, and whether it has committed war crimes in Gaza."

Of course it won't go away. Nothing will put an end to the questions, not even proof to the contrary, because for many, the questions aren't really questions at all, but merely another excuse to justify hatred for Israel. The "questions" won't go away for the same reason that the blood libel won't go away.

Now where's the New Yorker article about the question of Hamas's war crimes?



So do you think that because a man was abused as a child he should be allowed to abuse children?

If a man rapes your child and then later in court he cries and screams that he was abused as a child, would you ask the judge to let him go?

What if the Judge happened to be a son or relative of a man who was a child abuser... do you think the man who abused your child has the right to scream that the Judge has no right to sentence him or adjudicate his case?

Do you think the child abuser screaming that all the world is against him and all want to abuse him is grounds for dismissing the case?

Isn't the above behavior of the child abuser an indicator of how mentally disturbed he is and that he needs to be institutionalized?

Don't you think that the Palestinians have been well and truly sacrificed ENOUGH as the sacrificial lamb for the sins of the Europeans who you claim still hate us?
 
If you are speaking of human shields, and rocket attacks on civilians, those are also raised in the same article.

Sure, sure... just not in the headline or the lede. Only Israel gets accused there. The pretense of balance can be maintained, even though it's anything but.
 
So do you think that because a man was abused as a child he should be allowed to abuse children?

Not a logical comparison. The temporal and causal separation of the two crimes in your hypothetical makes it completely unlike the ongoing military conflict between Israel and Hamas.

If a man rapes your child and then later in court he cries and screams that he was abused as a child, would you ask the judge to let him go?

Don't bother compounding your logical flaws with an appeal to emotion. It won't work.

Don't you think that the Palestinians have been well and truly sacrificed ENOUGH as the sacrificial lamb for the sins of the Europeans who you claim still hate us?

I'm not the one sacrificing Palestinians, Hamas is. Go bitch at them.
 
I echo the sentiment from above: that the people with the strongest opinions are most often the least knowledgeable about the issue they're discussing, and that misunderstanding (deliberately?) terms like "genocide" and applying them to the Israel-Palestine conflict pretty clearly communicates that you aren't a serious debater.

"The people that know it the least always know it the loudest!" ;)

I don't know where I first heard this, but it's funny and very often true.
 
It needs to be pointed out that if the death toll is so lopsided, it is not through Lack of trying by HAMAS. It;s just that HAMAS has such lousy hardware with World War 2 era rockets.. SOmething that those who one sidedly condemn Israel while letting HAMAS off the hook forget.
 
Sure, sure... just not in the headline or the lede. Only Israel gets accused there. The pretense of balance can be maintained, even though it's anything but.

Not every article needs to be balanced in every respect, though. It seems perfectly reasonable to write an article about the perceived issues with the way Israel deals with the situation. The article stands or falls on its own merit, even if the context it appears in is biased either way.

The balance of criticism is interesting in some regards, but needs not be invoked in every discussion concerning "war crimes" or undue response by Israel. Hamas and Israel are not identical in every respect, after all, and in a sense, war crimes committed by a western-style democracy are certainly more interesting than ones committed by a terrorist organization.
 
Not every article needs to be balanced in every respect, though.

But it's not just this one article. This is (sadly) the norm across the entire publication, and many other publications.

war crimes committed by a western-style democracy are certainly more interesting than ones committed by a terrorist organization.

Why should that be so? And why to such an overwhelming extent? Do we really do ourselves a service by essentially ignoring Hamas's war crimes, with the rather fatalistic excuse that we simply expect it and so don't bother to note it?

I'm not satisfied by that approach.
 
Essentially, if Israel decides to launch a campagin that results in great colatteral damage, damage to UN facilities, and 1500 deaths, then it better be an effective mean toward a goal. I'm not convinced that the offensive, all-in-all, has been effective in doing much of anything but bolster the support for Hamas.

That's exactly what I commented about earlier, and feared would be the result of this bloody debacle yet again. Furthermore, the UN behaved very naively in this conflict. Letting the IDF know beyond the yin yang the location, on all three accounts, of all UN-school-shelters assembling refugees. What's the point? It's was like painting a big 'bull's eye' on the given buildings.

I tend to agree with Hans Blix (or at least I think it was he, several years ago) who suggested that some kind of non-infested/invested partner should intervene and mediate between the two given parties and force the subsequent resolution thereof for a time henceforth.
 
Last edited:
It needs to be pointed out that if the death toll is so lopsided, it is not through Lack of trying by HAMAS. It;s just that HAMAS has such lousy hardware with World War 2 era rockets.. SOmething that those who one sidedly condemn Israel while letting HAMAS off the hook forget.

As the conflict when the prior to Obama's entry into Office happend, where Hamas sent 650+ missiles into Israel with a death-toll of three (was it?); Now, that's three too many regardless. The ratio does however broker the afterthought of whether Hamas was trying one of three things; 1)rattling the saber for provocative purposes to set the IDF loose on the gazan body, 2) trying to maximize the body-count of israelis but were saddled with 'archaic' artillery, 3) simply showing the world their utter incompetence in handling anything pertaining to precision and accuracy with... well, precision and accuracy.

This conflict is almost of the same ratio per IDF's response toward Hamasian barbarism (whatever their insane motives or inherent qualities may be).
 
Last edited:
But it's not just this one article. This is (sadly) the norm across the entire publication, and many other publications.



Why should that be so? And why to such an overwhelming extent? Do we really do ourselves a service by essentially ignoring Hamas's war crimes, with the rather fatalistic excuse that we simply expect it and so don't bother to note it?

I'm not satisfied by that approach.

Israel is the only reason anyone cares to begin with. The conflict isn't that significant on the world stage; only Israel's involvement and actions make it notable to begin with. They're similar to "us", but they do things that make "us" feel uneasy. Hamas are "others". We dislike them they do not challenge our identity. Us Europeans especially I think are bugged by Israeli jingoism.

Also, Israel have greater immediate impact. And you have to focus on things where there is hope for improvement. Essentially, Israel and Hamas call for different means.

So I think it is a mix of illogical human nature, and rational consideration of how to deal with the situation.
 
That's exactly what I commented about earlier, and feared would be the result of this bloody debacle yet again.

I think you may be confused as to Israel's objective. Their objective was not only to cripple Hamas militarily but, more importantly, to destroy the tunnels Hamas has been building. This in particular was a necessary goal for Israel to achieve, and the application of considerable force was justified in its pursuit. Moreover, an invasion of Gaza (which Hamas could and did guarantee would result in significant civilian casualties) was the only way to achieve that result. It could not be achieved from the air, it could not be achieved from outside Gaza, and Hamas made sure that it cost Palestinian lives. So be it: the Palestinians elected Hamas, and this is the result. Israel has a greater obligation to protect its own citizens than it does to protect Palestinians.

Furthermore, the UN behaved very naively in this conflict. Letting the IDF know beyond the yin yang the location, on all three accounts, of all UN-school-shelters assembling refugees. What's the point? It's was like painting a big 'bull's eye' on the given buildings.

No. Israel did not target those buildings because there were refugees there. That makes no sense. It accomplishes nothing for Israel. Killing more civilians accomplishes nothing for them, they know that, and even if they wanted to do it, they wouldn't need the UN's help to do so. They are able to kill as many Palestinians as they want, and if they had wanted to, far more would be dead. The hard part is NOT killing Palestinians.

The UN was indeed naive, though. They were naive in letting Hamas have access to those buildings. They were naive in letting Hamas use those buildings as arms depots and firing locations. They were naive in turning over weapons found at those buildings to Hamas. They were naive in thinking that Hamas would do anything but put them in the firing line.

I tend to agree with Hans Blix (or at least I think it was he, several years ago) who suggested that some kind of non-infested/invested partner should intervene and mediate between the two given parties and force the subsequent resolution thereof for a time henceforth.

There is no one who wants to do that job. Since Hamas wants to kill Jews, and is willing to kill its own civilians in its efforts to do so, any third party tasked with enforcing "peace" would itself need to fight Hamas militarily.

And who will do that job? UN peacekeepers? Hell no. They have never actually stood up and fought against an armed and determined enemy. They have repeatedly retreated in the face of aggression, leaving those they are supposed to protect at the tender "mercies" of the aggressors. Israel cannot depend upon the UN to protect them, and Hamas would not stop their attacks out of fear of the UN. And what country would possibly want the thankless and bloody task of defending Israel from Hamas (because, face it, that's who the aggressor would be)? As soon as the first body bag returned to whatever country took on that grim watch, there would be cries to leave the dying to the IDF.

Hans Blix is a fool if he thinks his proposal is a realistic option, rather than just some platitude to flatter the sensibilities of whatever audience he was addressing when he said it.
 
Israel is the only reason anyone cares to begin with.

And that itself is a problem. The conflict would likely diminish if the rest of the world simply didn't give a ****. Every condemnation of Israel ends up encouraging and rewarding Hamas, and therefore prolonging the conflict.

Also, Israel have greater immediate impact. And you have to focus on things where there is hope for improvement. Essentially, Israel and Hamas call for different means.

And what means are being used to influence Hamas? None, so far as I can tell.

This approach creates perverse incentives, though many who take it doubtless do not mean to do so. If one side acts like inhuman totalitarian murderers, they become immune to pressure. If the other side acts like a western democracy, then we use its openness and morality to exert pressure against it. Whether or not we mean to do so, we are encouraging groups to act like the former and not like the latter. This may seem rational in the short term, but in the long run it is decidedly not.
 
What you say may very well be correct; it may be wrong. Time may tell, but people will argue themselves blind long after we are both dead about it anyway. I guess I'm cynical enough to feel that prescribing action for the long-term greater good in international relations is essentially futile. It's... too complicated, too chaotic. For my taste, anyway.

I personally mostly find the conflict interesting for exploring pitfalls and difficulties with international law and ethical decisions, the effects of such lopsided conflicts, and the sheer tribalism surrounding it even thousands of miles away.
 
Furthermore, the UN behaved very naively in this conflict. Letting the IDF know beyond the yin yang the location, on all three accounts, of all UN-school-shelters assembling refugees. What's the point? It's was like painting a big 'bull's eye' on the given buildings.
Wow:covereyes. If only we still did stundies.
 
I think you may be confused as to Israel's objective. Their objective was not only to cripple Hamas militarily but, more importantly, to destroy the tunnels Hamas has been building. This in particular was a necessary goal for Israel to achieve, and the application of considerable force was justified in its pursuit. Moreover, an invasion of Gaza (which Hamas could and did guarantee would result in significant civilian casualties) was the only way to achieve that result. It could not be achieved from the air, it could not be achieved from outside Gaza, and Hamas made sure that it cost Palestinian lives. So be it: the Palestinians elected Hamas, and this is the result. Israel has a greater obligation to protect its own citizens than it does to protect Palestinians.

Spokenly, that was at least the plan acted upon from the get-go. But they can't do anything (barely) without turning it into a bloody pig's breakfast, abit like the US ventures during the Vietnam War (not to mention more recent excurcions) in trying to "bomb-out" the holes of Viet-Cong via villages where they didn't really manage to end enough VC's through scorching the earth, but only destroying villages (and the people dwelling there).

Wasn't it even Itzahk Rabin who once mused, something of the order, that one can't succesfully bomb-out a tunneler unless one burns down everything? I might be mistaken, but it was either him or or some affiliate.

No. Israel did not target those buildings because there were refugees there. That makes no sense. It accomplishes nothing for Israel. Killing more civilians accomplishes nothing for them, they know that, and even if they wanted to do it, they wouldn't need the UN's help to do so. They are able to kill as many Palestinians as they want, and if they had wanted to, far more would be dead. The hard part is NOT killing Palestinians.

The UN was indeed naive, though. They were naive in letting Hamas have access to those buildings. They were naive in letting Hamas use those buildings as arms depots and firing locations.

There is no love lost between the UN and Israel. The antimocity is to be assumed from the get-go. I do not believe israeli authorities would purposely seek out UN-shelters to bomb, but they are probably as aware as I am of the noise and disturbance this provides the Hamas, and that nobody will (probably) succesfully hold the IDF et al to legal account for any heat-of-the-moment missed messages. It is, however, becoming their modus operandi that it becomes hard, even for me, not to agree with some of aquaintences in the UN-camp (i.e their habit of doing this very thing as a proverbial chorus-line). And no, Hamas and their dreg of terrorists and blood-hungry madhatters aren't any better. Now, if only Hamas would've been truly hurt by all of this, encumbered by all of this, so that maybe one hundreth of the civilian kills could regarded internationally as "collateral damage" then Israel's execution of the plan might've had some actual windfall (speaking crudely now). But they're not. They've got themselves, most likely, even more waves of willing fighters and sympathetic followers from the aftermath of this constructural, socio-economical and very, very organic 'rubble n death' mayhem.

Now, to your other point. I do not know which of the three UN-schools were harboring Hamas fire-ramps to be destroyed. However, even if they had, without notifying the UN, stored arms underneath those buildings. Bombing them out even after being alerted to the refugee-situation by the UN, several dozen times hours before the subsequent strike, does not deserve your given excuse. It just doesn't. And this has happend (this time around), not that one time but at least three times as of yet.

There is no one who wants to do that job. Since Hamas wants to kill Jews, and is willing to kill its own civilians in its efforts to do so, any third party tasked with enforcing "peace" would itself need to fight Hamas militarily.

Exactly.

And who will do that job? UN peacekeepers? Hell no. They have never actually stood up and fought against an armed and determined enemy. They have repeatedly retreated in the face of aggression, leaving those they are supposed to protect at the tender "mercies" of the aggressors.

Collectively, there is so much red-tape and odd passive-reluctance in their history (and voted mandate) that they're unfortunately nothing more than a 'ghandi'esque' paper-tiger... without much of a bite. They can provide non-military support, by a pseudo-army, but they have not really shown much confidence that they can protect civilians (as mentioned above) or broker peace with much efficiency. That being said, I am a stalwart supporter of the UN as a concept, though very critical of its very selective aggression and at the same time borderline trademarked silk-gloves.

Hans Blix is a fool if he thinks his proposal is a realistic option

Well, hmm... It wasn't a proposal. Not really. A proposal is something entirely different, imo. I think he voiced his view of (at the time) a diplomatic (and potentially escalting to military keeping) necessity. I happen to agree that this route might prove to be one of the best routes to be looked at and expanded upon, all while being too much in its infancy as it is to be regarded as a current viable alternative/option/proposal.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom