Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I doubt it is intended only as a deterrent. The real objective is probably exactly what the Israelis say it is: to take out HAMAS weapons and personell to reduce their ability to terrorize the Israeli civilian population.

Well, maybe that is so, but it was you who brought up the possibility that the effect, if not the aim, was one of deterrent...

I'm not so sure. Haven't seen the statistics on this, but if I was in Gaza, Israel's attacks would be a deterrent for me, rather than as a provocation. "When we mess with the Israelis, this is what we get in return. 70 years of bloodshed has gained us nothing but lost land, poverty and countless dead. Let us seek a peaceful solution instead".

...and I was the one who suggested that the stated aims are the true aims, and for that I was told that there may be other aims that we don't know about.

More specifically, I doubt that the goals you named are the only goals, much as I do not and will not pretend to know with any great certainty. The first four other potential goals with what might be mildly positive spin that pop to mind, for example, are effectively hamstringing Hamas for a fair while by destroying most or all of its leadership, making a show of Israel's power to the world and more importantly, its neighbors, pandering to the desires of certain segments of the Israeli population for political reasons, and trying to set the stage for the Palestinians to focus on more immediate domestic concerns for a while. There's a lot of potential goals with negative spins, too, like keeping the barbarians weak and in their place.

However, all I have said so far is that if the stated aims are the true aims then they may not be successful, and if the aims are consistent with the effects (i.e the bombing of civilian infrastructure) then there are two further problems, namely that...

1.) as with the Blitz, and as with Allied bombing of Germany, and as with UN bombing of Korea, or US bombing of Cambodia, the population does not turn on the people in charge, but rather turns to them for help.

and

2.) the bombing generates extremely bad PR and even condemnation from allies, which brings us to the next point...
 
The U.S. criticized the latest school-vicinity shelling:

U.S. calls shelling outside U.N. school in Gaza 'disgraceful

Does this mean that now that the anti-western crowd will start defending Israel, or that they will continue an 'anti-zionist' stand and now warm up to the U.S.?:confused:

Such a quandary!

Indeed, those who hate the West often get themselves into a pickle trying to denounce everything the West ever does when two of the standard bearers of the West criticize each other. Another favourite of mine is when one of their anti-western heroes joins forces with the West (Nixon meets Mao!).

However these quandaries also presumably occur to those of the My Country Right or Wrong persuasion who back any and every warlike action, including the bombing of civilians, with increasingly dubious rationales.

I certainly would not feel comfortable with the record of having consistently rationalized bombing UN schools. Presumably if I did have such a record, I would be unmoved by words from the UN Secretary General:

U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon described the attack as a "moral outrage and a criminal act" and called for those responsible for the "gross violation of international humanitarian law" to be held accountable.

...especially if I had based much of my case on the innuendo that the UN was in league with Hamas. However, if the US suddenly came out with this:

The United States was "appalled by today's disgraceful shelling" and urged Israel to do more to prevent civilian casualties, according to a statement by State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki. She also called for an investigation into recent attacks on U.N. schools.

then I may have to be forced to call the United States government

sentimental unthinking Westerners

who are

naive western dupes

being emotionally manipulated.

What a quandary, as you say. What to do? Maybe, it will be necessary to turn up the rhetoric a bit more.
 
The whole Jon Voight/Penelope Cruz/Javier Bardem flap shows why I have a huge mistrust of show biz celebs making political statments: Both responses are over the top, one sided, and I suspect, concerned more with image then making a actual point.Cruz Bardem want to look good to the trendy Lefty crowd in Europe;Voight has sort of declared himself the spokesman for the Hollywood Right. I will get my information elsewhere, thank you.
 
According to Norwegian media, IDF just reported they are done destroying HAMAS tunnels, but that they will remain on the Gaza strip until all their objectives are complete.
 
Falsifying history and refusing to acknowledge GLARING facts is nothing but CDAC.

If you can't make your point without using ALLCAPS and making up acronyms, you probably don't have a point. Try posting in standard English.
 
Indeed. Leumas, if someone is wrong, point out how they're wrong. When I write "to the best of my knowledge", it means I'm unsure and open to being corrected. So again, if I'm mistaken, tell me how instead of accusing me of cognitive dissonance.
 
Another 72 hour cease fire. Get you bets down as to how long this one will hold, but get them down quick.....
 

Yeah, check out the footnotes on that article and you will see that information comes from pro-Palestinian organizations. Paissadotorg and Palestineremembereddotcom. It doesn't refute my assertion that it's misleading to label everything not directly owned by a Jew as "Palestinian", and the "facts" it does present are questionable.
 
Yeah, check out the footnotes on that article and you will see that information comes from pro-Palestinian organizations. Paissadotorg and Palestineremembereddotcom. It doesn't refute my assertion that it's misleading to label everything not directly owned by a Jew as "Palestinian", and the "facts" it does present are questionable.



This is an egregiously anti-Semitic remark.
 
Last edited:
Israel is leaving Gaza, according to Norwegian media. So time for HAMAS to start licking its wounds and prepare another batch of rockets, I suppose, then we'll probably see another round in a few years :( .
 
Last edited:
I suspect ISIS recent expansion into Lebanon is the reason for the ceasefire as Israel and Hamas recognise they are a far bigger threat
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom