Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm not so sure. Haven't seen the statistics on this, but if I was in Gaza, Israel's attacks would be a deterrent for me, rather than as a provocation. "When we mess with the Israelis, this is what we get in return. 70 years of bloodshed has gained us nothing but lost land, poverty and countless dead. Let us seek a peaceful solution instead".

But what do I know, I don't live in a dictatorship that spoon-feeds me hateful propaganda from the day I enter kindergarden, so what do I know... :boxedin:

If the bombing is intended as a deterrent then you will just have to make up your own mind as to whether or not it is effective. I would suggest that no it is not. And again, if the deterrent effect is the justification, and yet the deterrent effect does not work, then logically speaking is it a justification?

Going back to that review of Overy's book:

And though the devastation left ordinary Germans demoralized, exhausted and frightened, the bombs did not provoke internal collapse or social implosion; the German people were not bombed into revolution. In the cruellest irony, the hardship and terror may even have solidified the Nazis’ grip on the populace: “The effect of the bombing was not, in the end, as the Allies hoped, to drive a wedge between people and regime, but the opposite, to increase dependence on the state and the party.”

That's just one example of a bombing campaign which did not achieve one of its specific goals of having the population overthrow the leadership. If that is the intention here, with the idea being Gazans will overthrow Hamas to end the bombing or to give up firing rockets or digging tunnels then I fear disappointment.
 
If the bombing is intended as a deterrent then you will just have to make up your own mind as to whether or not it is effective.
I doubt it is intended only as a deterrent. The real objective is probably exactly what the Israelis say it is: to take out HAMAS weapons and personell to reduce their ability to terrorize the Israeli civilian population.
 
I doubt it is intended only as a deterrent. The real objective is probably exactly what the Israelis say it is: to take out HAMAS weapons and personell to reduce their ability to terrorize the Israeli civilian population.
I think the "dependence" thing is vital, though. When your neighbourhood is demolished, all your belongings have been bombed to dust and you've got nowhere to go, you become more dependent on the state. I imagine the state scores quite a few brownie points helping those who were left without livelihood by the Israeli assault.
 
I have a question about the "blockade" of Gaza. I have been told that is the justification for Hamas to fire rockets and dig tunnels to grab Israelis. But isn't there a border crossing in Rafah controlled (and currently closed) by Egypt? If so, shouldn't Egypt get some of those rockets and kidnappings? I suspect the answer is that Hamas knows if it started doing those things in Egypt, the Egyptians would show even less restraint than Israel. But I'd be happy to read other explanations.

Yeah, well, somehow the Zionists control Egypt so it's not really their fault. Zionists are very sneaky that way.
 
More than one extremist.

משה פייגלין
August 1 at 3:41pm ·
ב"ה
לכבוד
ראש הממשלה בנימין נתניהו
אדוני ראש הממשלה
זה עתה נודע כי החמאס ניצל את הפסקת האש בכדי לחטוף קצין. מסתבר שהמבצע הזה לא עומד להיגמר כל כך מהר.
הכשלים במבצע היו טמונים בו מתחילתו כי:
א – אין לו מטרה נכונה וברורה.
ב – אין מעטפת מוסרית ראויה התומכת בחיילינו.
מה שנדרש כעת הוא להפנים שאוסלו נגמר, שזו ארצנו – רק ארצנו, כולל עזה!
אין שתי מדינות ואין שני עמים - יש רק מדינה אחת לעם אחד.
בעקבות ההפנמה הזו נדרש שינוי אסטרטגי עמוק ויסודי – הן בהגדרת האויב, הן בהגדרת המשימה, הן בהגדרת היעד האסטרטגי וכמובן - בהגדרת מוסר הלחימה הנכון והנדרש.
1 – הגדרת האוייב
האויב האסטרטגי הוא האסלאם הערבי הקיצוני על כל גרורותיו מאיראן ועד עזה המבקש לחסל את ישראל כולה.
האויב בעין הוא החמאס.
(לא המנהרות, לא הרקטות – החמאס)
2 – הגדרת המשימה:
כיבוש הרצועה כולה וחיסול כל הכוחות הלוחמים ותומכיהם.
3 – הגדרת היעד האסטרטגי:
להפוך את עזה ליפו. עיר ישראלית פורחת עם מינימום אזרחים עוינים.
4 – הגדרת מוסר הלחימה:
"אוי לרשע ואוי לשכנו"

לאור ארבעת הנקודות הללו על ישראל לבצע מיד את הפעולות הבאות:
א - צה"ל יגדיר שטחים פתוחים על גבול סיני ובסמיכות לים בהם תתרכז האוכלוסייה האזרחית- הרחק מהשטח הבנוי ואזורי השיגור והמנהור. באזורים אלו יוקמו מחנות אוהלים עד לאיתור יעדי הגירה רלוונטיים.
אספקת החשמל והמים לאזורים שהיו מאוכלסים – תנותק.
ב – האזורים שהיו מאוכלסים יופגזו בכוח אש מקסימלי. כל מתקני החמאס האזרחיים והצבאיים, אמצעי הקשר והלוגיסטיקה – יחוסלו עד היסוד.
ג – צה"ל יבתר את הרצועה לאורכה ולרחבה, ירחיב מאוד את הצירים, ישתלט על אזורים שולטים וישמיד קיני ההתנגדות במידה וייוותרו כאלה.
ד – ישראל תחל באיתור מדינות ומכסות הגירה לפליטי עזה. המעוניינים להגר יזכו בחבילת סיוע כלכלית נדיבה ויגיעו לארצות הקולטות עם יכולת כלכלית משמעותית.
ה – מי שיתעקש להישאר ויוכח כי אין לו כל קשר לחמאס, יידרש לחתום באופן פומבי על הצהרת נאמנות לישראל ויקבל תעודת זהות כחולה בדומה לזו של ערביי מזרח ירושלים.
ו - עם שוך הקרבות יוחל החוק הישראלי בכל הרצועה, מגורשי גוש קטיף יוזמנו לשוב ליישוביהם והעיר עזה ובנותיה ייבנו כערי תיירות ומסחר ישראליות לכל דבר.
אדוני ראש הממשלה!
זוהי שעת הכרעה גורלית בימיה של מדינת ישראל.
כל גרורות האויב, מאיראן והחיזבאללה ועד דע"ש והאחים המוסלמים – חוככות כעת את ידיהן בהנאה ומכינות עצמן לסבב הבא.
אני מתריע שכל תוצאה שהיא פחות ממה שהוגדר כאן, משמעותה עידוד המשך האופנסיבה נגד ישראל. רק אם יבין החיזבאללא כיצד טופל החמס בדרום, ימנע מלשגר את 100,000 הטילים שלו - מצפון.
אני קורא לך לאמץ את האסטרטגיה המוצעת כאן.
אין לי כל ספק שכמוני, עם ישראל כולו יעמוד ברוב מוחץ לימינך – אם רק תאמצנה.

בכבוד ובהערכה רבה
משה פייגלין
 
More than one extremist.

According to Google translate:

Moshe Feiglin
August 1 at 3:41 pm ·
BH
In honor of
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
Mr. Prime Minister
Just learned that Hamas used the ceasefire to grab an officer. It turns out that this campaign is not going to end so soon.
Failures in the operation were buried in the beginning that:
A - It has no proper purpose and clear.
At Shell no proper moral support our soldiers.
What is needed now is to internalize that Oslo is over, this is our land - only our country, including Gaza!
No two countries and no two peoples - there is only one state for one people.
Following this internalization strategic change required a deep and fundamental - are defining the enemy, both in defining the mission, both in defining the strategic objective, and of course - the definition of morality and right fighting required.
1 - Defining the enemy
Strategic enemy is radical Arab Islam all its derivatives from Iran to Gaza seeking to destroy Israel as a whole.
Hamas is the enemy in the eye.
(Tunnels, rocket - Hamas)
2 - Defining the task:
Conquest of the entire Gaza Strip and elimination of all armed forces and their supporters.
3 - Setting strategic objective:
Turn Gaza and Jaffa. Israeli city booming with a minimum of hostile civilians.
4 - Set the morality of combat:
"Oh wicked and woe to his neighbor"

In light of these four points on Israel immediately execute the following:
A - IDF define open spaces on the Sinai border and in close proximity to the sea which will focus on the civilian population - far from built-up area and launch areas and tunneling. These areas will be set up tent camps to locate relevant immigration goals.
Electricity and water supply to areas that were occupied - clear.
On populated areas were shelled maximum firepower. All facilities Hamas civilian and military, means of communication and logistics - would be eliminated completely.
C - the IDF will break the strap length and width, greatly expand the delegates, will take over areas of control and destroy nests of resistance when these remain.
D - Israel will begin identifying countries and the Gaza refugees quotas. Wishing to emigrate to receive generous financial aid package and will reach the receiving countries with significant financial ability.
The who insists on staying and it is proved that it has no connection to Hamas, will be required to sign a public declaration of loyalty to Israel and gets blue identity card similar to that of the Arabs of East Jerusalem.
And when the fighting ended applied Israeli law throughout the Gaza Strip, Gush Katif expellees will be invited to return to their communities and the city of Gaza and daughters will be built tourist cities and trade Israel for all.
Mr. Prime Minister!
This is a time of fateful decision of Israel's days.
All metastases enemy, Iran and Hezbollah to Da"s and the Muslim Brotherhood - now rubbing their hands in delight and prepare themselves for the next round.
I warned that the result is less than defined here, means encouraging the continued offensive against Israel. Only if you understand how standardized Hhizballa Hamas in the south, will prevent from sending the 100,000 missiles - to the north.
I urge you to adopt the strategy proposed here.
I am sure that like me, the people of Israel will be overwhelmingly on your right - if only to adopt.

Sincerely and with great appreciation
Moshe Feiglin


So basically a junior Israeli politician advocated invading Gaza, disarming Hamas, deporting Hamas and it's supporters, and giving permanent residency to the Arabs who agree not to fight Israel anymore.
 
At least three extremists, oh my. Surely no other country on earth could have that many extremists. It's like an extremist zoo.
 
2638950aa188de303b.jpg

That map is awesome propaganda. It continues to be spread around no matter how much it's debunked.

Let's debunk it again.

The first map works by comparing things that are not really comparable. The white areas are areas privately owned by Jewish people, but all that green "Palestinian Land" isn't land privately owned by Palestinian-Arabs. The majority of it was unused land owned by the government (initially the Ottoman Empire) and much of the remainder was agricultural land leased from the government. Of course, giving these different types of land different colours didn't suit the propaganda purposes

The second map was never a reality. It's the UN partition plan, more or less, which the Palestinian-Arabs rejected.

The third map, if it were labelled accurately, would label Gaza as "Egyptian" and the West Bank as "Jordanian". How, exactly, is it "Palestinian" when it's controlled by these other states? The omission of who really controls these lands eliminates important information about the history of the conflict.

Finally, the fourth map is possibly the most dishonest. These green areas are lands under autonomous control off the Palestine Authority after the Oslo accords, but they're not the only lands owned by or lived on by Palestinians.


"When we have settled the land, all the Arabs will be able to do about it will be to scurry around like drugged cockroaches in a bottle." - Raphael Eitan, Chief of Staff of the Israeli Defence Forces, New York Times, 14 April 1983.

"There was no such thing as Palestinians, they never existed." - Golda Maier Israeli Prime Minister June 15, 1969


"We have to kill all the Palestinians unless they are resigned to live here as slaves." - Chairman Heilbrun of the Committee for the Re-election of General Shlomo Lahat, the mayor of Tel Aviv, October 1983.

"We walked outside, Ben-Gurion accompanying us. Allon repeated his question, What is to be done with the Palestinian population?' Ben-Gurion waved his hand in a gesture which said 'Drive them out!'" - Yitzhak Rabin, leaked censored version of Rabin memoirs, published in the New York Times, 23 October 1979.

David Ben Gurion, future Prime Minister of Israel, 1937, Ben Gurion and the Palestine Arabs, Oxford University Press, 1985: "We must expel Arabs and take their places."

"We'll make a pastrami sandwich of them, ... we'll insert a strip of Jewish settlements in between the Palestinians, and then another strip of Jewish settlements right across the West Bank, so that in 25 years' time, neither the United Nations nor the United States, nobody, will be able to tear it apart."
- (Ariel (Arik) Sharon, 1973)


Yeah, fake Zionist quotes abound on the internet.

http://www.camera.org/index.asp?x_context=7&x_issue=21&x_article=766

http://www.camera.org/index.asp?x_context=7&x_issue=21&x_article=775

http://liberology.wordpress.com/201...es-1-ben-gurion-and-the-german-children-1938/

http://liberology.wordpress.com/category/fake-zionist-quotes/
 
That map is awesome propaganda. It continues to be spread around no matter how much it's debunked.

Let's debunk it again.

The first map works by comparing things that are not really comparable. The white areas are areas privately owned by Jewish people, but all that green "Palestinian Land" isn't land privately owned by Palestinian-Arabs. The majority of it was unused land owned by the government (initially the Ottoman Empire) and much of the remainder was agricultural land leased from the government. Of course, giving these different types of land different colours didn't suit the propaganda purposes

The second map was never a reality. It's the UN partition plan, more or less, which the Palestinian-Arabs rejected.

The third map, if it were labelled accurately, would label Gaza as "Egyptian" and the West Bank as "Jordanian". How, exactly, is it "Palestinian" when it's controlled by these other states? The omission of who really controls these lands eliminates important information about the history of the conflict.

Finally, the fourth map is possibly the most dishonest. These green areas are lands under autonomous control off the Palestine Authority after the Oslo accords, but they're not the only lands owned by or lived on by Palestinians.



Israeli land and property laws
Overview

In 1945, of the 26.4 million dunams (26,400 km²) of land in Mandatory Palestine, 12.8 million was owned by Arabs, 1.5 million by Jews, 1.5 million was public land and 10.6 million constituted the desertic Beersheba district (Negev). Of the 9.2 million dunams of land that was arable, 7.8 million dunams was owned by Arabs, 1.2 million by Jews and 0.2 million was public land.[2][3] By 1949, some 700,000 Palestinians had fled or been expelled from their lands and villages. Israel was now in control of some 20.5 million dunams (approx. 20,500 km²) or 78% of lands in what had been Mandatory Palestine: 8% (approx. 1,650 km²) were privately controlled by Jews, 6% (approx. 1,300 km²) by Arabs, with the remaining 86% being public land.[4] Land laws were passed to legalize changes to land ownership.[5]

As at 2007, the Israel Land Administration (ILA) (established in 1960) manages 93% of Israel's land comprising 19,508 km² under the following laws and land policy. The remaining 7% of land is either privately owned or under the protection of religious authorities. Basic Law: Israel lands (1960) states that all the lands owned by the state of Israel will remain in state ownership, and will not be sold or given to anyone.
Israel Lands Law (1960) details several exceptions to the basic law.
Israel Land Administration Law (1960) describes the details of establishing and operating the Israel Land Administration.[6]
Covenant between the State of Israel and the World Zionist Organization (establishing the Jewish National Fund) (1960).[7]

Thirteen percent of Israel's land belongs to the Jewish National Fund,[8] which is managed by the ILA.

Use of land in Israel usually means leasing rights from the ILA for a period of 49 or 98 years. Under Israeli law, the ILA cannot lease land to foreign nationals, which includes Palestinian residents of Jerusalem who have identity cards but are not citizens of Israel. In practice, foreigners may be allowed to lease if they show that they would qualify as Jewish under the Law of Return.[9]
 
Last edited:
That map is awesome propaganda. It continues to be spread around no matter how much it's debunked.
Pretty telling that JJ posts it, given that as she appears to be highly emotionally invested in this subject, she has to know it's basically a lie (it's been debunked several times on this forum alone). She posts it anyway, presumably in the hope that it will be seen by people who don't know better than to believe it.

I'd like to add to your post that the map also does not show the land gains the Palestinians have made. For a time they didn't control Gaza, for example, so the latest border development in the "Israelis stealing more and more Palestinian territory", to the best of my knowledge, was that Palestine gained land. Which the map conveniently omits.
 
Pretty telling that JJ posts it, given that as she appears to be highly emotionally invested in this subject, she has to know it's basically a lie (it's been debunked several times on this forum alone). She posts it anyway, presumably in the hope that it will be seen by people who don't know better than to believe it.

I'd like to add to your post that the map also does not show the land gains the Palestinians have made. For a time they didn't control Gaza, for example, so the latest border development in the "Israelis stealing more and more Palestinian territory", to the best of my knowledge, was that Palestine gained land. Which the map conveniently omits.



Falsifying history and refusing to acknowledge GLARING facts is nothing but CDAC.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom