Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Do we actually know why Hawking pulled out of this conference?

Is it not possible, given that he didn't publicize his withdrawal, that he doesn't want to be a part of this debate?

I mean, there are so many foaming one-eyed partisans on both sides that being bullied by either side just might not appeal to him.
 
Just as folks had the right to boycott Apartheid South Africa, folks have the right to boycott Israel.
Of course he has the right. Your comparison to S. African shows you haven't at all read up on the topic, but yes, of course he has the right to boycott any country he wishes, including the one that's probably played a huge part in saving his life. No one has said anything to the contrary.

Just as boycotting Apartheid South Africa wasn't an expression of hatred against Afrikaners and other white South Africans, boycotting Israel isn't an expression of hatred against Jews.
Not directly, no. However, when people spout uninformed nonsense at a specific country, and treat that country based on logic not applied anywhere else ("you don't take as many losses as they do in war, that means you are the bad guys!"), it is an expression of something, and surely that something is not something pretty.

A nicely on topic post, with a bit edited, and I laughed at the part in re wheelchairs.
Me too:D.
 
Last edited:
Of course he has the right. Your comparison to S. African shows you haven't at all read up on the topic, but yes, of course he has the right to boycott any country he wishes, including the one that's probably played a huge part in saving his life. No one has said anything to the contrary.

Not directly, no. However, when people spout uninformed nonsense at a specific country, and treat that country based on logic not applied anywhere else ("you don't take as many losses as they do in war, that means you are the bad guys!"), it is an expression of something, and surely that something is not something pretty.

Good post.

I have no problem with Hawking's decision. I do have a problem with him trying to have his cake and eat it too, in his attempt to lie about the reason for the cancellation. I have a problem with boycotting Israel's "inhumanity" while taking advantage of their technological excellence. And I do wonder if there are any other countries in the world inhumane enough for him to refuse to speak in. Apparently, China makes the cut.
 
And I do wonder if there are any other countries in the world inhumane enough for him to refuse to speak in. Apparently, China makes the cut.

And, there's that comparable China and Tibet thingy as well, which tends to be on fewer peoples' lips these days (understandable but still...)
 
We all must pick our battles.

Some hate Monsanto.

Some hate hydro-fracking.

Hawking has chosen Israel.

More power to him.
 
We all must pick our battles.

Some hate Monsanto.

Some hate hydro-fracking.

Hawking has chosen hates Israel.

More power to him.

I've made some changes that I think better express the conclusion you seem to be reaching for.

Ironically, from my perspective you've listed three targets of irrational hate, and then applauded a supposed intellectual for the target he has chosen for his irrational hate.
 
Last edited:
I've made some changes that I think better express the conclusion you seem to be reaching for.

Ironically, from my perspective you've listed three targets of irrational hate, and then applauded a supposed intellectual for the target he has chosen for his irrational hate.

Hating a maker of pesticides and pesticide-resistant vegetables that may lead to the evolution of pesticide-resistant pests, is irrational?

Hating a method of harvesting fossil fuels that may lead to the contamination of the water supply for tens of millions of people, is irrational?

Interesting perspective you have there. It seems you think hating anything you like, is irrational.
 
Hating a maker of pesticides and pesticide-resistant vegetables that may lead to the evolution of pesticide-resistant pests, is irrational?

Hating a method of harvesting fossil fuels that may lead to the contamination of the water supply for tens of millions of people, is irrational?

Interesting perspective you have there. It seems you think hating anything you like, is irrational.

I think that the pros and cons of these things can be considered rationally. I think that it's possible to reach a rational conclusion about the desirability (or not) of these things. I think it's possible to make rational criticisms, and to propose rational changes and improvements. I think it's possible to do all these rational things, without indulging in ill-informed, knee-jerk, irrational hatred.

If you had said that some people choose to fight for better understanding, and better industry practices, for agricultural pest management, I'd say that was pretty rational. But you didn't say that. You said that some people choose to hate Monsanto. I don't think that's very rational at all.

And then you applauded Hawking for choosing, if I understand you correctly, to hate Israel. What's rational about that?
 
We all must pick our battles.

Some hate Monsanto.

Some hate hydro-fracking.

Hawking has chosen Israel.

More power to him.

With all the world-wide atrocities available for the noble haters to choose from, it's interesting how attracted they are to thezionistentity. I guess priorities must be set.
 
I think that the pros and cons of these things can be considered rationally. I think that it's possible to reach a rational conclusion about the desirability (or not) of these things. I think it's possible to make rational criticisms, and to propose rational changes and improvements. I think it's possible to do all these rational things, without indulging in ill-informed, knee-jerk, irrational hatred.

If you had said that some people choose to fight for better understanding, and better industry practices, for agricultural pest management, I'd say that was pretty rational. But you didn't say that. You said that some people choose to hate Monsanto. I don't think that's very rational at all.

And then you applauded Hawking for choosing, if I understand you correctly, to hate Israel. What's rational about that?

I see no evidence that Hawking "hates" Israel, which is why I didn't claim that he did. I believe that he is very much against the Occupation, the illegal settlement enterprise, and discrimination against Israeli Arabs. These are valid & respectable stands to take.
 
With all the world-wide atrocities available for the noble haters to choose from, it's interesting how attracted they are to thezionistentity. I guess priorities must be set.

Nice strawman.

Did you also condemn folks for boycotting the Apartheid regime and the Soviet Union? Or is only Israel immune from boycotts?
 
Nice strawman.

Did you also condemn folks for boycotting the Apartheid regime and the Soviet Union? Or is only Israel immune from boycotts?

What strawman argument are you referring to?

I'm not "condemning" any boycotters at all. I am commenting on the role fashion and racial politics play in these matters.
 
Last edited:
What strawman argument are you referring to?

I'm not "condemning" any boycotters at all. I am commenting on the role fashion and racial politics play in these matters.

Your use of typical extremist anti-Zionist language such as

"thezionistentity"
 
With all the world-wide atrocities available for the noble haters to choose from, it's interesting how attracted they are to thezionistentity. I guess priorities must be set.

When your governments are involved, it usually does jump up on the list.

But I dislike this line of argument. I call it the "starving children in Africa" argument, but there is probably a proper term.
 
When your governments are involved, it usually does jump up on the list.

But I dislike this line of argument. I call it the "starving children in Africa" argument, but there is probably a proper term.

The fact is that Israel could single-handedly put an end to all of these boycotts by engaging in those acts & policies that most intelligent people in this world agree are needed for peace.
 
When your governments are involved, it usually does jump up on the list.

But I dislike this line of argument. I call it the "starving children in Africa" argument, but there is probably a proper term.

Israel seems to be hated as much or more by the populations of countries not cooperating with her, so I really can't give any weight to the "not in my name" argument.
 
Your use of typical extremist anti-Zionist language such as

"thezionistentity"

You'd have to stretch the definition of the phrase to the point of meaninglessness to even begin to characterize that as a strawman. That's just silly.


The fact is that Israel could single-handedly put an end to all of these boycotts by engaging in those acts & policies that most intelligent people in this world agree are needed for peace.

I basically agree. Much to the chagrin of many, if not most, of the BDS nobility to whom a 2-state agreement would represent a defeat.


Edit: the phrase I'm noting above refers to "strawman", not "thezionistentity".
 
Last edited:
Just wondering when the boycott of Russia, China, Turkey, Algeria, ect is going to start.

Just wondering when people who wage terrorist campaigns against Russia are going to become the poster-boys of the left.

Just wondering when they're going to get their own branch of the UN to make sure they're fed, housed, clothed and kept entertained.

Just wondering when when there's going to be pilgrimages of rich, duped idiots from the West to these places to stand in front of tractors and get in Russian soldier's faces.

Can someone just give me their best-guess timeframe on when that's going to happen? It's just a mystery to me when that's going to happen.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom