Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Fixed that last line for you. Unlike Holocaust Denial, I have seen no evidence that people who criticize Israeli policy, on the whole, are anti-Semites or self-hating Jews (the other favorite description).

I say, "Good for Hawking!"

No good scientist is anti-Semitic, as Jews have contributed greatly to the sciences. Especially Hawking's field.
 
No good scientist is anti-Semitic, as Jews have contributed greatly to the sciences. Especially Hawking's field.
There's a difference between being anti-Semitic and disagreeing with the policies of the current government of Israel.

Or there should be, anyway.
 
I bet there are some guys right now trying to find the specifications to Hawkings' wheelchair and computer-generated voice technology to find out how many parts were made or invented in Israel and then declaring, "Ah ha! If your boycott is real, you'll stop using your hi-tech wheelchair!"

They see Hawkings rollin', they be hatin'
 
Fixed that last line for you. Unlike Holocaust Denial, I have seen no evidence that people who criticize Israeli policy, on the whole, are anti-Semites or self-hating Jews (the other favorite description).

I say, "Good for Hawking!"

They may not be anti all Jews but they are certainly engaging in blaming the victim.
 

I like Chinese culture and Chinese women too.

Actually, it is difficult to know why Hawking made this decision given that he has visited Israel four times in the past.

I think academic boycotts are a bad idea even to places such as China and Iran. I would happily go to any of those countries to deliver a lecture. Not sure whether anyone would listen, though. :(
 
Any word on when Hawking will be attending a scientific conference in Palestine? I mean, well, if they have them and all.
 
At this point even I feel that Israel should be boycotted, mostly because I don't know how to only boycott the Orthodox there.

Look, the whole county is being held hostage by the Orthodox right now. They don't work, they don't fight and yet they have constitutionally mandated seats in parliament and living stipends. They have large, state subsidized families who are the exact same people who are invading the Palestinian lands and stealing their property.

The hardworking Non-Orthodox citizens of Israel are being forced by these brutes to do their bidding. They need to be encouraged to rise up against their religious extremist captors and rewrite their constitution to no longer give such ridiculous treatment to the Orthodox.

I stand in support of the Israeli people in their fight to regain their own country from religious zealots.
 
Not the only hypocracy in this situation:

From: http://www.irishtimes.com/news/worl...residential-conference-in-jerusalem-1.1386618
Nitsana Darshan-Leitner, director of the Israel Law Centre, criticised Hawking’s decision, noting that the cosmologist uses Israeli-developed technology to cope with his motor neurone illnesse.

Perhaps Hawking should give up all Israeli technology and see if there is a Palestinian-version of a wheelchair that he could use.

I expect AMD would be happy to supply him with any hardware requirements.

It might not come with a speech synthesizer

Telesensory Systems isn't Isreali (in fact what remains of the company is owned by a company based in Singapore).
 
I bet there are some guys right now trying to find the specifications to Hawkings' wheelchair and computer-generated voice technology to find out how many parts were made or invented in Israel and then declaring, "Ah ha! If your boycott is real, you'll stop using your hi-tech wheelchair!"

http://www.jpost.com/Diplomacy-and-...ng-reaffirms-support-of-Israel-boycott-312505

Nitsana Darshan-Leitner, director of Shurat HaDin – Israel Law Center, called Hawking’s boycott hypocritical.

“His whole computer-based communication system runs on a chip designed by Israel’s Intel team. I suggest that if he truly wants to pull out of Israel, he should also pull out his Intel Core i7 from his tablet.”

She suggested that he should also consult his academic contacts and the Intel engineers in Israel before deciding to boycott.

“He seems to have no understanding of this world.”

Since 1997, Hawking’s computer- based system has been sponsored and provided by Intel.

Any word on when Hawking will be attending a scientific conference in Palestine? I mean, well, if they have them and all.

http://www.jpost.com/Diplomacy-and-...ng-reaffirms-support-of-Israel-boycott-312505

Hawking, 71, has visited Israel four times, most recently in 2006, when he lectured at Israeli and Palestinian universities.
 
Just as folks had the right to boycott Apartheid South Africa, folks have the right to boycott Israel.

Just as boycotting Apartheid South Africa wasn't an expression of hatred against Afrikaners and other white South Africans, boycotting Israel isn't an expression of hatred against Jews.
 
Last edited:
If "The Palestinians" accept a 2-state solution, why did the residents of the Gaza strip (an area composed of over a million Palestinians) vote for a party that has a charter that indicates they want to eliminate all jews in palestine?

Is there some new definition of "2 state solution" that would allow killing of all Jews in Israel?


Not the only hypocracy in this situation:

From: http://www.irishtimes.com/news/worl...residential-conference-in-jerusalem-1.1386618
Nitsana Darshan-Leitner, director of the Israel Law Centre, criticised Hawking’s decision, noting that the cosmologist uses Israeli-developed technology to cope with his motor neurone illnesse.

Perhaps Hawking should give up all Israeli technology and see if there is a Palestinian-version of a wheelchair that he could use. It might not come with a speech synthesizer or breathing assistance, but I'm sure it can pack a heck of a lot of explosives for any wheelchair bound suicide bombers.


According to an interview I heard with a british journalist who was involved in breaking the story (sorry don't have any references right now), in the past he went to Israel but only on condition that we would be allowed to speak at Palestinian universities as well. I guess what has changed is that Palestinian academics have communicated to him that a boycott is the "best" option now.


Here's the problem...

Yes, there are things that Israel does wrong. However, its hard to see how someone is supportive of "the Jews" or of Israel, when they get criticism that is far out of proportion to what they have actually done. Palestine votes in a party that wants to "kill all Jews", and regularly fires rockets into Israel? Who cares, we need to discuss the "evils of zionism". Islamic cultures regularly supress and even kill homosexuals and women? Who cares as long as Isreal is doing something wrong!

It would be a little easier to accept criticism of Israel as legitimate (and not anti-semetic) if it were a bit more evenly balanced.

As for Hawkings, he has every right to express his political views. However, his expertise is in theoretical physics. When it comes to issues of politics and national self defense, his "expertise" is no greater than my car mechanic or greeter at the local wal-mart.

Why is it so hard for you and others to simply admit & accept that BOTH sides have done some ********** up things? Why is this always a competition of who has done worse?
 
Why is it so hard for you and others to simply admit & accept that BOTH sides have done some ********** up things? Why is this always a competition of who has done worse?

Because Hawking is boycotting Israel, rather than the Palestinians (or both).
 
Because Hawking is boycotting Israel, rather than the Palestinians (or both).

Indeed. A charitable interpretation of this disparity is that the Israelis might modify their behavior in response to such pressures, but the Palestinians almost certainly won't. But regardless of why this disparity of effort exists, it still ends up as perverse, in the sense that the better-behaved party is still the party that the most external pressure is being applied to, and that's perverse.
 
Indeed. A charitable interpretation of this disparity is that the Israelis might modify their behavior in response to such pressures, but the Palestinians almost certainly won't. But regardless of why this disparity of effort exists, it still ends up as perverse, in the sense that the better-behaved party is still the party that the most external pressure is being applied to, and that's perverse.

It's even worse, as it implies that concessions from the Israelis will be appreciated by the Palestinians who will then become more peaceful and conciliatory themselves. This appears to be a dangerous misconception (where progressive westerners assume that their morals and world view will be shared by Hamas, honor-shame cultures, etc). What if no concessions, save complete abasement and surrender, will be enough?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom