Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hawking doesn't care about anything other than promoting himself. His first wife got fed up with constantly having to tell him that he isn't God. His opinion on Israel means nothing.

Refreshing to see a post related to the OP, and I had no idea what was behind his divorce. Thanks. :)
 
Hawking is a moron because he doesn't understand what the basic premise of a boycott is about, to hurt an institution financially. Have your stupid science conference anywhere, have it in my back yard (no smoking please). Where this stupid science fest is does not hurt or help Israel in the least.

Hey Hawking, if you want to protest the actions of Israel then why not conduct a hunger strike on the steps of the British Embassy? This is nothing other than a Facebook "like this photo if you love your mother".

A boycott need not cost its target a dime.

Moral pressure is good enough.
 
Again, there is no "right" to boycott. Either you do it you don't.

But a super-smart sciencey guy with no background in Middle Eastern politics says that one of those Middle Eastern nations is wrong about something. People, he is super, super smart and he's in a wheelchair! He must be right.

Interesting strawman and red-herring.

Him being in a wheelchair is irrelevent to this discussion.

But it is tasteless for you to bring it up as a way to attack him.
 
Morality can't be pressed. It is there or it is not. A boycott will never change anyone's morality. Morality comes from within.

If enough nations boycotted Israel they would listen and adjust their policies.

Israelis are stubborn but not stupid.
 
Him being in a wheelchair is irrelevent to this discussion.

He is totally irrelevant to any serious conversation about Middle Eastern politics.

But it is tasteless for you to bring it up as a way to attack him.

He has used his disability to make millions. I just post my thoughts on an Internet forum.
 
He is totally irrelevant to any serious conversation about Middle Eastern politics.

He has used his disability to make millions. I just post my thoughts on an Internet forum.

Ironic how you accuse others of profiting off of their own suffering.
 
If enough nations boycotted Israel they would listen and adjust their policies.

Doubtful. Israel is a small nation that does not have large international trade. If every nation in the world decided to boycott all Israeli products, those nations could find the same products and services somewhere else. Israel's economy is small enough to support itself.
 
Since we mods didn't get to this soon enough, there will be no yellows handed out for this batch of off-topic posts. However, going forth, please remember that this thread is about Stephan Hawking and his recent boycott of Israel. Refrain from discussing Israel/Palestine, each other, the US or other off-topic things.

And as always, keep it civil; because the topic is also not the other posters.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis
 
Academic boycott of Israel is a good thing. But a more productive boycott would be one that sees tourists stay away. There are much lovelier & safer nations in the Mediteranean to visit than Israel.

If European and American tourists started going to Greece, Cyprus, Italy, and Croatia instead of Israel, it would have a huge impact on Israel's economy and make them think about their policies.
 
Last edited:
Academic boycott of Israel is a good thing.
It would seem mr. Hawking declined for health reasons, making whatever arguments in favour of his absence moot.
 
It would seem mr. Hawking declined for health reasons, making whatever arguments in favour of his absence moot.

Maybe so, but the idea of boycotting Israel has its merits. It sends a strong message to the govt. and its people that "we don't support what you do and we will do our best to avoid your products & services until you change your behavior".
 
Maybe so, but the idea of boycotting Israel has its merits.
You keep saying so, but given that the topic isn't about Israel or boycotts in general, I'm guessing we're done here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom