Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The fact is that Israel could single-handedly put an end to all of these boycotts by engaging in those acts & policies that most intelligent people in this world agree are needed for peace.
You know what, I actually doubt they could. The reason is that firstly, a lot of the criticism of Israel is irrational and/or based on ignorance and misunderstandings, and secondly, because it seems Israel's detractors seem hell-bent on disliking her no matter what she does. Just the fact that people actually call the country (and only Israel, mind you, not any of the neighbouring countries) an Apartheid regime speaks novels.

You should perhaps read up on some of the arguments from "Israel's side", rather than only listening to her detractors. A nice place to start would be Israel's withdrawal from Gaza, and what followed.

Did you also condemn folks for boycotting the Apartheid regime and the Soviet Union?
:facepalm:

Well, it's a step up from comparing them to Nazi Germany, at any rate:rolleyes:.
 
I've never really understood this argument.

Does it mean that if Israel said, "Oh sod it, lets just become a totalitarian fascist state!" then people would give the place a break because, well, you don't have the same expectations anymore?

People would still criticize but they wouldn't be able to label them hypocrites. But maybe should ask Steven Hawking, seeing as that's what the thread is about.
 
People would still criticize but they wouldn't be able to label them hypocrites. But maybe should ask Steven Hawking, seeing as that's what the thread is about.

Indeed. I agree with this and would like to know more about Hawking's decision. But instead we have gone back to the usual tedious Israel/Palestine debate whereby Israel is labelled not just wrong but wronger and even more wronger and perhaps even the most wrongest nation on Earth by the "anti-Zionists" and Stephen Hawking is being accused by those on the MEMRI mailing list of either being racist (at best, apparently!) or (worse) an anti-semite or (even worstest) a terrorist sympathizing genocidal Jew-hating hypocrite in a high-tech wheelchair; a grotesque Blofeld and Joseph Mengele hybrid.
 
Indeed. I agree with this and would like to know more about Hawking's decision. But instead we have gone back to the usual tedious Israel/Palestine debate whereby Israel is labelled not just wrong but wronger and even more wronger and perhaps even the most wrongest nation on Earth by the "anti-Zionists" and Stephen Hawking is being accused by those on the MEMRI mailing list of either being racist (at best, apparently!) or (worse) an anti-semite or (even worstest) a terrorist sympathizing genocidal Jew-hating hypocrite in a high-tech wheelchair; a grotesque Blofeld and Joseph Mengele hybrid.

I'm a Zionist and a MEMRI fan and I've never said anything like this. Has someone on JREF said anything even close to this?
 
I'm a Zionist and a MEMRI fan and I've never said anything like this. Has someone on JREF said anything even close to this?

Yes.

Best case scenario the anti-Israel people are racists who think Arabs are unable to be held to the same standard as Jews or Europeans because they're inferior people. Worst case is they're just anti-semites.

So, is Stephen Hawking a racist or an anti-Semite?

Apparently at least racist, since he's not boycotting Palestine. Can't expect Arabs to avoid calls to genocide, can we?
 
I'm a Zionist and a MEMRI fan and I've never said anything like this. Has someone on JREF said anything even close to this?

Indeed. I agree with this and would like to know more about Hawking's decision. But instead we have gone back to the usual tedious Israel/Palestine debate whereby Israel is labelled not just wrong but wronger and even more wronger and perhaps even the most wrongest nation on Earth by the "anti-Zionists" and Stephen Hawking is being accused by those on the MEMRI mailing list of either being racist (at best, apparently!) or (worse) an anti-semite or (even worstest) a terrorist sympathizing genocidal Jew-hating hypocrite in a high-tech wheelchair; a grotesque Blofeld and Joseph Mengele hybrid.

I disagree with Wildcat on that, but his comments don't seem anywhere near the highlighted portion.
 
I disagree with Wildcat on that, but his comments don't seem anywhere near the highlighted portion.

The last bit was a bit of throwaway hyperbole (the clue being my use of ungrammatical phrases such as "even worstest"), which you like to engage in too by the way. Certainly others have found reason to attack him on the grounds that his wheelchair may contain components made in Israel and someone else suggested he get a "Palestinian wheelchair" packed with explosives which others then guffawed merrily over. You must have seen those comments.
 
The last bit was a bit of throwaway hyperbole (the clue being my use of ungrammatical phrases such as "even worstest"), which you like to engage in too by the way.

You bet I do. And I'll remember this comment fondly the next time someone throws the old "strawman" accusation at me for doing so.


Certainly others have found reason to attack him on the grounds that his wheelchair may contain components made in Israel

Seems like a perfectly fair point to me, which is why I commented on it. I'm not remotely suggesting Hawking meticulously avoid all products with even a hint of Zionistic taint. I'm saying using cutting edge, custom made Israeli signature technology while boycotting her science and tech academic community is a pretty fine example of hypocrisy.
 
Back to the OP, why should anyone care what Stephen Hawking thinks about politics?
 
Back to the OP, why should anyone care what Stephen Hawking thinks about politics?

Only because it's an important part of the BDS strategy to convince high profile celebrities to participate in the boycott, and they achieved that in this case.
 
It's rare when a person you hold in such high esteem, can rise even higher. What a great, great man Stephen Hawking is.
 
Someone should have warned Hawking before hand that boycotting Israel would be a grave mistake.

Its ok to boycott China, Venezuela, Cuba, Belorus, Iran, Syria, Bangladesh, Mexico, Nigeria, and Liberia. Those are all fine choices.

But Israel? Oh man, you'll be targeted for destruction by the forces of petty personal attack. Countless waves of accusations of anti-Semitism & Jew-hatred will be thrown at you, day after day, until you are forced to retreat from your unacceptable stance or marginalized as a son of Hitler.


:confused: - Has Hawking been destroyed? Has he retreated? Is he now marginalized?
 
Hawking is a moron because he doesn't understand what the basic premise of a boycott is about, to hurt an institution financially. Have your stupid science conference anywhere, have it in my back yard (no smoking please). Where this stupid science fest is does not hurt or help Israel in the least.

Hey Hawking, if you want to protest the actions of Israel then why not conduct a hunger strike on the steps of the British Embassy? This is nothing other than a Facebook "like this photo if you love your mother".
 
I haven't attacked the boycotting rights of you or Hawking.

Again, there is no "right" to boycott. Either you do it you don't.

I have attacked the BDS organization because it's led by and largely composed of racists, hypocrites and liars whose true goal is to get rid of Israel.

But a super-smart sciencey guy with no background in Middle Eastern politics says that one of those Middle Eastern nations is wrong about something. People, he is super, super smart and he's in a wheelchair! He must be right.
 
To be fair, though, what Hawking seems to be doing isn't "boycotting Israel" as much as saying "I don't feel like visiting this convention, 'cause I'm sorta peeved with you right now. Peace out".

Hawking doesn't care about anything other than promoting himself. His first wife got fed up with constantly having to tell him that he isn't God. His opinion on Israel means nothing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom