Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Israeli Settlements were incredibly stupid. And this is from somebody who is a generally a supporter of Israel.

Agreed.

What amuses me is how many Euros demand that the US take a more "balanced and even handed" approach to the Israeli Palestinian problem. My answer is "We Will If You Will", given how hostile Euro opinion generally is to Israel. And I am cynical enough to think
that it has less to do with humanitarian concern for the Palestinians and more with thirst of Arab Oil.

I am cynical enough to think it is due to European neuroses rather than realpolitik over oil.
 
Let us know when Hawking attends a scientific forum in Gaza.

He has contact with Palestinian academics (from the NYT article: “based on advice from Palestinian academics that he should respect the boycott,”) but he doesn't want to have any contact with Israeli academics.

Do you not see a difference in how he treats each side? And that his decision (shunning the more moral side) is morally perverse?
 
Just as folks had the right to boycott Apartheid South Africa, folks have the right to boycott Israel.
Yes they do.

And we have the right to point out whether someone boycotting Israel is an idiot/patsy/hypocrite for doing so.
Just as boycotting Apartheid South Africa wasn't an expression of hatred against Afrikaners and other white South Africans, boycotting Israel isn't an expression of hatred against Jews.
As far as I know, there were no widespread South African political organizations (supported by blacks) that were calling for the extermination of all white people.
 
He has contact with Palestinian academics (from the NYT article: “based on advice from Palestinian academics that he should respect the boycott,”) but he doesn't want to have any contact with Israeli academics.

Do you not see a difference in how he treats each side? And that his decision (shunning the more moral side) is morally perverse?

That's even more of a stretch than "pressured by activists".
 
Bingo!

Best case scenario the anti-Israel people are racists who think Arabs are unable to be held to the same standard as Jews or Europeans because they're inferior people. Worst case is they're just anti-semites.

So, is Stephen Hawking a racist or an anti-Semite?
 
Say what one will about Hawking, his ditching his wife for his nursemaid. Nonetheless, politically, he's always been a principled man. No one can match Bertrand Russell, but the UK certainly has an admirable tradition.

Bertrand Russell was a philanderer! No doubt he was wrong about everything else too!
 
Bertrand Russell was a philanderer! No doubt he was wrong about everything else too!

Well...
Pacifist in WW1 who publicly agitated against the USA getting involved
Opposed rearmament in WW2 (I think he finally changed his mind in 1943)
Thought that Oswald (the JFK assassin) was innocent (compared it to the Dreyfus case!)
Supported CND
 
United Nations resolution 181 calls for a Jewish and Arab state in Palestine.

The Jews accepted this resolution. It is the basis for the UN's recognition of the State of Israel.

If the Arab state in Palestine is abandoned, so must the Jewish state.
 
Well...
Pacifist in WW1 who publicly agitated against the USA getting involved
Opposed rearmament in WW2 (I think he finally changed his mind in 1943)
Thought that Oswald (the JFK assassin) was innocent (compared it to the Dreyfus case!)
Supported CND

Bertrand Russell was, of course, wrong about many things. He was essentially a pacifist for almost all of his life on almost everything, but he did change his mind on WWII. I have read somewhere that he also supported nuking the Soviet Union. I certainly see nothing obviously wrong about his pacifism over WWI, though. In fact, I see very little that is obviously right about belligerentismTM in that one.

And he certainly went doolaly on the JFK thing.
 
Nothing is wrong with having an affair. Obviously. Everyone is comfortable with that.:boggled:

I do not think it is so so bad.. ;)

A survey shows the following results of married men and women who want to have hanky panky with somebody other than their partner.

Married men who want to be unfaithful - 58%
Unmarried men who want to be unfaithful - 41%
Married women who want to be unfaithful - 23%
Unmarried women who want to be unfaithful - 19%

http://www.dannychoo.com/post/en/1453/Adultery+in+Japan.html


Here (in Japanese) it says that 40%~55% of Japanese married men betray

http://okwave.jp/qa/q562218.html
 
Last edited:
I do not think it is so so bad.. ;)

A survey shows the following results of married men and women who want to have hanky panky with somebody other than their partner.

Married men who want to be unfaithful - 58%
Unmarried men who want to be unfaithful - 41%
Married women who want to be unfaithful - 23%
Unmarried women who want to be unfaithful - 19%

http://www.dannychoo.com/post/en/1453/Adultery+in+Japan.html

And how many of those people's partners wanted their spouse to be unfaithful?

Anyway, this is silly. Don't bother answering that because we know the approximate answer and this is not the thread for that. Feel free to start one, though.
 
I care about Israel exactly as much as I care about Stephen Hawking. Which is to say, I don't wish either specific harm, but it's not like I actually know them or care about them. Their states of being are neither my responsibility nor my concern, so I don't know why I would have, advertise, or expect anyone else to take seriously my opinions of them. And I believe the world would be a better place if more people felt the same lack of feeling on the matter.

Why "mind your own business" didn't make it into the Ten Commandments I can't imagine.
 
The Arabs rejected it, not Israel. They chose to try to destroy Israel and genocide the Jews instead. They failed, and as it turns out there's consequences for launching a war of genocide and then losing. Sucks to be them.

And this thread is the first time in your life you've been exposed to the Hamas Covenant and the PLO Charter, yes?

Hawking has decided to boycott Israel, due to Israel's racist & inhumane actions.

Sucks to be Israel. :)
 
Hawking has decided to boycott Israel, due to Israel's racist & inhumane actions.

Sucks to be Israel. :)

It doesn't suck to be Israel whether Hawking shows or not.

Would have been a little classier if he or his representatives had just been honest from the start, instead of lying that the cancellation had been due to health reasons.
 
It doesn't suck to be Israel whether Hawking shows or not.

Would have been a little classier if he or his representatives had just been honest from the start, instead of lying that the cancellation had been due to health reasons.

That's both cowardly and stupid. The entire point of a boycott is to influence behavior, but if you don't let the target of the boycott know the reason for your boycott, how can it influence them?

Hawking is brilliant, but he's apparently also an ass.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom