Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why should it be one or the other? The tunnels are used to transport all kinds of goods, including weapons.

Israel controls nearly all sea, land and air entry points to Gaza. The border with Egypt has varied in its porosity according to various factors. Egypt is not actively attacking, brutalizing, beating up, starving, murdering or inflicting collective punishments on the people of Gaza. That is why your rocket question is so ludicrous.


It seems to me you're trying to have it both ways with Egypt. If the Gaza "blockade" is real, it means Egypt is doing the very same thing you criticize Israel for doing. However, in your statement above, you admit the border with Egypt "has varied in its porosity...." That suggests it's not really a "blockade" after all -- it can't be if the Egyptian border is open -- and the justification for attacking Israel falls apart.
 
Last edited:
It seems to me you're trying to have it both ways with Egypt. If the Gaza "blockade" is real, it means Egypt is doing the very same thing you criticize Israel for doing. However, in your statement above, you admit the border with Egypt "has varied in its porosity...." That suggests it's not really a "blockade" after all -- it can't be if the Egyptian border is open -- and the justification for attacking Israel falls apart.

bums not bombs - http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/2013/03/201337135540513860.html
 
It shouldn't be (or at least, Israel shouldn't be regarded as the one who is morally at fault):
----------------------------------------------
"A senior U.N. official who has served in the Gaza Strip and is a longstanding critic of Israeli policies there acknowledged Thursday that Hamas and other terrorist groups were firing weapons “from the vicinity of U.N. facilities” located in the territory."

"three U.N.-run schools have been found with munitions stored in them, as weapons depots.”

"Ging did not mention – and was not asked about – Israeli claims that when the U.N. did find rockets in a U.N. school for the first time earlier this month, it had essentially handed them over to Hamas. UNRWA said at the time it asked “local police,” to remove the rockets."
-------------------------------------------------


If schools get used as munitions depots or launch sites then they become legitimate targets. The folks who are making them legitimate targets are Hamas, who are cynically counting on sentimental unthinking Westerners to hand them a PR victory.

Yes, Giz, and it is Israel who are constantly obliging Hamas by handing them the PR victories on a daily basis. If you knew, as you and others keep saying, that Hamas will reliably be able to use civilians as human shileds in the knowledge that they will be killed and can be displayed on TV, and that furthermore this is the very point of Hamas firing these rockets in the first place then it makes very little sense using a hard-headed coolly rational calculation, to do everything that Hamas wants Israel to do in the first place.

After all, nobody, not you, not the Israelis, not Hamas, think the rockets are an existential threat to Israel. Hamas are not, probably even by your reckoning, trying to destroy Israel with the rocket attacks and cannot do so. What they are trying to do, even by your reckoning, is turn world opinion against them. And not only among those who your slander as "sentimental unthinking Westerners", but, according to Jonathon Freedland, among liberal Zionists too. For example:

For Zionists of the right, repeating these arguments came easily. But liberal Zionists felt conflicted. A death rate that saw civilians account for four out of every five Palestinians killed—and that by July 25, according to the UN, included nearly 200 children—was hard to defend. Earlier this week, the former editor-in-chief of Haaretz, David Landau, wrote that it was no longer good enough to rely on the traditional hasbara sound bite that, while Hamas deliberately targets civilians, Israel only ever kills civilians by accident. Citing halacha, Landau argued that when it’s certain that civilians will die as a result of one’s actions, the distinction between intended and unintended becomes meaningless and is “nullified.” (Landau added that a ground operation was more morally defensible, because it allowed for greater precision.)

Others have not been so specific in their dissent, but they share the sense that it will no longer do simply to trot out the familiar lines. Partly it’s because some of the consequences of the Israeli bombardment have been so hard to stomach: hospitals, schools, and homes battered by shells, with instantly lethal consequences. It requires a special steel, perhaps lacking in some liberal Zionists, to speak up for Israel when the country’s air force has just hit a home for the disabled.

The arguments repeated by the right-wing Zionists, that he mentions, are the ones that you have just made, that when someone stores missiles in a hospital or a school or a home for the disabled, then full moral culpability rests with those who put the missiles there in the first place and with nobody else! And the steeliness with which the arguments are given, as opposed to those wimpy "sentimental" types, usually is couched in bluster and insults and ratcheting up of the rhetoric. Usually when people are forced to defend things that cause them unease, you can often notice how they will do so by increasing their own high dudgeon against those who dare to challenge them. I think it is a defence mechanism and I think even you, Giz, are struggling to align your conscience with these bombings, but perhaps you can reassure me otherwise that you truly don't have any trouble with the bombing of the UN schools and hospitals.

Anyway, I just tried to find out a little more and there is a news story in the Sydney Morning Herald (actually from Reuters) here which says:

The United Nations agency that looks after Palestinian refugees said it had found a cache of rockets at one of its schools in the Gaza Strip and deplored those who had put them there.

United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) spokesman Chris Gunness condemned those responsible for placing civilians in harm's way by storing the rockets at the school but he did not specifically blame any party.

"We condemn the group or groups who endangered civilians by placing these munitions in our school. This is yet another flagrant violation of the neutrality of our premises. We call on all the warring parties to respect the inviolability of UN property," Mr Gunness said.

Now presumably he is asking both the Palestinian militant groups and the Israelis not to allow the schools to become embroiled in this war. But earlier you asked if there was anything that could be done about this. Well, maybe...

Mr Gunness said the agency had called in a UN munitions expert to dispose of the rockets and make the school premises safe, but fighting in the area had so far prevented access to the site.

Okay, earlier you had quotes, with no links, suggesting that the UN were just "essentially" handing back rockets to Hamas whenever they found them, and the quotes seem designed to make the UN some kind of accomplices with Hamas, yet here it is suggested that the UN would have disarmed the munitions if they had been able to get to these schools.

Could you please spell out what you think is going on here without resorting to innuendo?
 
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/2638950aa188de303b.jpg[/qimg]

"When we have settled the land, all the Arabs will be able to do about it will be to scurry around like drugged cockroaches in a bottle." - Raphael Eitan, Chief of Staff of the Israeli Defence Forces, New York Times, 14 April 1983.

"There was no such thing as Palestinians, they never existed." - Golda Maier Israeli Prime Minister June 15, 1969


"We have to kill all the Palestinians unless they are resigned to live here as slaves." - Chairman Heilbrun of the Committee for the Re-election of General Shlomo Lahat, the mayor of Tel Aviv, October 1983.

"We walked outside, Ben-Gurion accompanying us. Allon repeated his question, What is to be done with the Palestinian population?' Ben-Gurion waved his hand in a gesture which said 'Drive them out!'" - Yitzhak Rabin, leaked censored version of Rabin memoirs, published in the New York Times, 23 October 1979.

David Ben Gurion, future Prime Minister of Israel, 1937, Ben Gurion and the Palestine Arabs, Oxford University Press, 1985: "We must expel Arabs and take their places."

"We'll make a pastrami sandwich of them, ... we'll insert a strip of Jewish settlements in between the Palestinians, and then another strip of Jewish settlements right across the West Bank, so that in 25 years' time, neither the United Nations nor the United States, nobody, will be able to tear it apart."
- (Ariel (Arik) Sharon, 1973)


Moshe Dayan: Eulogy for Roi Rotenberg, April 19, 1956
[snip]

Let us not cast the blame on the murderers today. Why should we declare their burning hatred for us? For eight years they have been sitting in the refugee camps in Gaza, and before their eyes we have been transforming the lands and the villages, where they and their fathers dwelt, into our estate.

It is not among the Arabs in Gaza, but in our own midst that we must seek Roi's blood. How did we shut our eyes and refuse to look squarely at our fate, and see, in all its brutality, the destiny of our generation? Have we forgotten that this group of young people dwelling at Nahal Oz is bearing the heavy gates of Gaza on its shoulders?

Beyond the furrow of the border, a sea of hatred and desire for revenge is swelling, awaiting the day when serenity will dull our path, for the day when we will heed the ambassadors of malevolent hypocrisy who call upon us to lay down our arms.

Roi's blood is crying out to us and only to us from his torn body. Although we have sworn a thousandfold that our blood shall not flow in vain, yesterday again we were tempted, we listened, we believed.

We will make our reckoning with ourselves today; we are a generation that settles the land and without the steel helmet and the canon's maw, we will not be able to plant a tree and build a home. Let us not be deterred from seeing the loathing that is inflaming and filling the lives of the hundreds of thousands of Arabs who live around us. Let us not avert our eyes lest our arms weaken.

[snip]
 
After all, nobody, not you, not the Israelis, not Hamas, think the rockets are an existential threat to Israel. Hamas are not, probably even by your reckoning, trying to destroy Israel with the rocket attacks and cannot do so. What they are trying to do, even by your reckoning, is turn world opinion against them. And not only among those who your slander as "sentimental unthinking Westerners", but, according to Jonathon Freedland, among liberal Zionists too. For example:

Was the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor an existential threat to the USA? Things don't have to be existential threat in order to justify a forceful response.


Yes, Giz, and it is Israel who are constantly obliging Hamas by handing them the PR victories on a daily basis. If you knew, as you and others keep saying, that Hamas will reliably be able to use civilians as human shileds in the knowledge that they will be killed and can be displayed on TV, and that furthermore this is the very point of Hamas firing these rockets in the first place then it makes very little sense using a hard-headed coolly rational calculation, to do everything that Hamas wants Israel to do in the first place.

What is your suggestion for a better way? Hamas is committed to killing as many Jews as possible, will not recognize that Israel has any right to survive and seems to be secure from being removed by other Palestinian factions. I fear that the Israeli response may be the least bad option that can realistically be taken.

And as for Hamas gaining PR victories from its cynical use of children as human shields... words fail me for expressing my scorn of Hamas, poor media reporting (preferring emotion rather than logical analysis) and naive western dupes.

The arguments repeated by the right-wing Zionists, that he mentions, are the ones that you have just made, that when someone stores missiles in a hospital or a school or a home for the disabled, then full moral culpability rests with those who put the missiles there in the first place and with nobody else! And the steeliness with which the arguments are given, as opposed to those wimpy "sentimental" types, usually is couched in bluster and insults and ratcheting up of the rhetoric. Usually when people are forced to defend things that cause them unease, you can often notice how they will do so by increasing their own high dudgeon against those who dare to challenge them. I think it is a defence mechanism and I think even you, Giz, are struggling to align your conscience with these bombings, but perhaps you can reassure me otherwise that you truly don't have any trouble with the bombing of the UN schools and hospitals.

I think that you are engaging in projection and it is not me being emotionally manipulated.


Heart-string tugging photos follow of a densely populated area, run by genocidal jew-hating aggressors, that has been the subject of overwhelming land and air assault.

Guess what - totally justified.

Same thing with Gaza.
 

Attachments

  • Berlin-_the_Capture_and_Aftermath_of_War_1945-1947_C5284.jpg
    Berlin-_the_Capture_and_Aftermath_of_War_1945-1947_C5284.jpg
    98.9 KB · Views: 6
It seems to me you're trying to have it both ways with Egypt. If the Gaza "blockade" is real, it means Egypt is doing the very same thing you criticize Israel for doing. However, in your statement above, you admit the border with Egypt "has varied in its porosity...." That suggests it's not really a "blockade" after all -- it can't be if the Egyptian border is open -- and the justification for attacking Israel falls apart.

Find out for yourself what "varied in porosity" means in relation to Egypt's border before indulging in any more cloud-cuckoo-land sophistry
 


Hamas in Their Own Words

Sermon delivered by 'Atallah Abu Al-Subh, former Hamas minister of culture, which aired on Al-Aqsa TV, April 8, 2011, translation by MEMRI
"Whoever is killed by a Jew receives the reward of two martyrs, because the very thing that the Jews did to the prophets was done to him.

"The Jews are the most despicable and contemptible nation to crawl upon the face of the Earth, because they have displayed hostility to Allah.
"Allah will kill the Jews in the hell of the world to come, just like they killed the believers in the hell of this world.
"The Jews kill anyone who believes in Allah. They do not want to see any peace whatsoever on Earth."

Statement from Hamas Ministry of Refugee Affairs on U.N. Relief and Works Agency plan to include Holocaust education in the curriculum taught Palestinian refugees, February 28, 2011

“We cannot agree to a programme that is intended to poison the minds of our children…Holocaust studies in refugee camps is a contemptible plot and serves the Zionist entity with a goal of creating a reality and telling stories in order to justify acts of slaughter against the Palestinian people."

Hamas leader Mahmoud Al-Zahhar, Future News TV, June 15, 2010, Source: MEMRI.org

"We have liberated Gaza, but have we recognized Israel? Have we given up our lands occupied in 1948? We demand the liberation of the West Bank, and the establishment of a state in the West Bank and Gaza, with Jerusalem as its capital – but without recognizing [Israel]. This is the key – without recognizing the Israeli enemy on a single inch of land...

"Our plan for this stage is to liberate any inch of Palestinian land, and to establish a state on it. Our ultimate plan is [to have] Palestine in its entirety. I say this loud and clear so that nobody will accuse me of employing political tactics. We will not recognize the Israeli enemy. "

Dr. Yussuf Al-Sharafi, Hamas representative, April 12, 2007; as reported by Palestinian Media Watch, April 23, 2007
"...the Jewish faith does not wish for peace nor stability, since it is a faith that is based on murder: 'I kill, therefore I am'... Israel is based only on blood and murder in order to exist, and it will disappear, with Allah's will, through blood and Shahids [martyrs]."

Sheikh Dr. Ahmad Bahar, acting Speaker of the Palestinian Legislative Council, April 20, 2007; as reported by Palestinian Media Watch, April 23, 2007
"This is Islam, that was ahead of its time with regards to human rights in the treatment of prisoners, but our nation was tested by the cancerous lump, that is the Jews, in the heart of the Arab nation... Be certain that America is on its way to utter destruction, America is wallowing [in blood] today in Iraq and Afghanistan, America is defeated and Israel is defeated, and was defeated in Lebanon and Palestine... Make us victorious over the community of infidels... Allah, take the Jews and their allies, Allah, take the Americans and their allies... Allah, annihilate them completely and do not leave anyone of them."

Hamas statement in response to criticism by Al-Qaeda's Ayman al-Zawahri, March 12, 2007
"We will not betray promises we made to God to continue the path of Jihad and resistance until the liberation of Palestine, all of Palestine. . . So be assured doctor Ayman, and all those who love Palestine like yourself, that Hamas is still the group you knew when it was founded and it will never abandon its path."
Khaled Mashaal, Hamas leader, February 3, 2006, Al-Hayyat al-Jedida"[Hamas will] never recognize the legitimacy of the Zionist state that was founded on our land."

Mahmoud Zahar, Hamas leader, after casting his vote in the Gaza Strip, January 25, 2006, Ha'aretz
"[Hamas] will not change a single word in its covenant [which is calling for the destruction of Israel]."

Ismail Haniyah, Hamas leader, at an election rally in Gaza, January 20, 2006, Reuters
"They have tried to pressure Hamas to abandon resistance and to abandon arms. They tried to pressure Hamas to abandon its strategic choice in Palestine, all of Palestine. They tried to pressure Hamas to recognize the legitimacy of the occupation. But they failed... We say Hamas will not change its constant principles."

Hamas spokesman, Sami Abu-Zuhri, explains to Al-Sharq al-Awsat that there is no contradiction between Hamas' platform for the election and its charter, which calls for the destruction of Israel, January 13, 2006, BBC Monitoring
"The program [of Hamas-backed list to legislative council] sets out the details and means for its implementation over the next four years, while the [Hamas] charter talks about vision and strategy…The movement is adhering to the constants and strategies outlined in the [Hamas] charter.
"

Sheik Nizar Rayan, Hamas "political" leader, at a rally in Gaza, Al-Jazeera TV on September 16, 2005, MEMRI
"The vanquishing of the enemy in Gaza does not mean that this stage has ended. We still have Jerusalem and the pure West Bank. We will not rest until we liberate all our land, all our Palestine. We do not distinguish between what was occupied in the 1940s and what was occupied in the 1960s. Our Jihad continues, and we still have a long way to go. We will continue until the very last usurper is driven out of our land."


Abdel Aziz Rantisi, Hamas leader, June 10, 2003, interview with Al-Jazeera, Jerusalem Post
"By God, we will not leave one Jew in Palestine. We will fight them with all the strength we have. This is our land, not the Jews..."

"You will have no security except outside the homeland Palestine.... We have Allah on our side, and we have the sons of the Arab and Islamic nation on our side."

Sheik Ahmed Yassin, interview with Australian Muslim youth magazine, Nida'ul Islam, June/ July 2002"
We reject this US domination and this frantic war. From our side, we concentrate on striking blows to it here in Palestine, with the aim of ironing out the Jewish entity in Palestine, which is the cause of trouble in the world..."

"America... always works in favor of the existence of the Israeli entity... This is mainly due to the Zionist-Christian conviction and the 70 million Americans who follow the Protestant creed, which is in favor of Jews against the Muslims. The same applies to most of Britain's population..."
"Because the Israeli and American enemies are ravaging the earth; they do not believe in anything besides power. The Ummah must adopt the principle of Jihad and fighting the enemies."

Hamas communiqué, March 9, 1989, translated and distributed in the U.S. by the Islamic Association for Palestine
"Come to jihad, come to jihad, come to martyrdom..."
"Those thirsty for Jihad all over the world. For the sake of Allah. For liberating the land of Palestine and Jerusalem...."

"We declared and continue to declare now, that a Jew is a Jew... [do not trust them when they say they want peace because they act only] to serve their religion and their people."


Your and my examples, spoken words - who has the obliteration of a nation state written in their charter/constitution?




Israel wants to obliterate Palestine and has been very successful at doing so. Hamas does not have the means to obliterate Israel.

Into the fray: Why Gaza must go

The only durable solution requires dismantling Gaza, humanitarian relocation of the non-belligerent Arab population, and extension of Israeli sovereignty over the region
.

Jerusalem Post, 07/24/2014
 
Some newspaper columnist in the heat of war goes over the top news at 11. If Israel wanted to obliterate Palestine, they're doing a poor job of it. I mean, RWANDA won the 90s Genocide Olympics (though Serbia came a close second thanks to their accordion playing and Tupac) and they had far less military infrastructure than Israel. FFS, ISIS in the middle of a war-torn region is doing a much better effort in genocide than Israel are, and the Mexican Cartels are nothing to sneeze at.
 
Was the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor an existential threat to the USA? Things don't have to be existential threat in order to justify a forceful response.

Okay, let's agree there. It's a good start.

What is your suggestion for a better way? Hamas is committed to killing as many Jews as possible, will not recognize that Israel has any right to survive and seems to be secure from being removed by other Palestinian factions. I fear that the Israeli response may be the least bad option that can realistically be taken.

Well, I have already suggested that if there was a ceasefire that the UN have said that they would dispose of the rockets in the schools.

As for "a better way" I think that really depends upon the outcome that you are after. You would have to tell me what that outcome is and how realistic the chances of that happening under a bombing campaign are likely to be. I have already told you that if it is to see a complete cessation of rocket firing then this is not going to work. We will see a lot of deaths, in the hundreds initially but now it is getting into the thousands, more resentment in Gaza, a few years' lull perhaps and then a resumption of rocket attacks. If that happens will Randi give me a million dollars? No, because every body with a brain knows that will happen and I include you, so you have to tell me what the goal is.

And as for Hamas gaining PR victories from its cynical use of children as human shields... words fail me for expressing my scorn of Hamas, poor media reporting (preferring emotion rather than logical analysis) and naive western dupes.

Well, then, at least we know that you are emotionally invested too. But that's okay, I don't think there is anything wrong with reacting emotionally to these things, only you suggested that there was something suspicious about it.

I think that you are engaging in projection and it is not me being emotionally manipulated.

How do you know you are not being emotionally manipulated? Maybe you are and that is why you support the bombing of Gaza. Most people are not going to admit to being emotionally manipulated, but if they have some kind of affinity for a country or a group of people under attack they may happily cheer on any kind of revenge and rationalize it later. In fact, I think this is something that has been demonstrated by a lot of psychologists to be true, while the subjects obviously believe they are not basing their ideas on emotion or intuition, but always believe themselves to be rational.


Heart-string tugging photos follow of a densely populated area, run by genocidal jew-hating aggressors, that has been the subject of overwhelming land and air assault.

Guess what - totally justified.

Same thing with Gaza.

Coupled with this earlier post of yours...

I imagine that a lot of German cities looked pretty bad in 1945, yet one doesn't tend to hear too much hand wringing over Allied heavy handedness.

When a population votes in a bunch of authoritarian, genocidal, expansionist scumbags who then start shooting at their more powerful neighbors... well, it's not pretty but maybe the neighbors are justified in their response.

...I think I can construct the argument you seem to be making. Please tell me if this is correct, and if not please spell out your argument more clearly to help me understand your point of view:

First, the premises:

1.) Israel's bombing of Gaza, in response to Hamas's rocket attacks, is morally equivalent to Allied bombing, in response to Nazi Germany's invasions of her neighbours.
2.) The Allied bombing campaigns were morally justified in every respect.

The conclusion:

3.) Israel's bombing campaign is justified in every respect.

If the premises are true the conclusion must be as it follows logically from the premises.

In your previous post you even suggested that nobody condemns the Allied bombing of Germany now ("I imagine that a lot of German cities looked pretty bad in 1945, yet one doesn't tend to hear too much hand wringing over Allied heavy handedness.") which only tells me you do not know very much at all about the historiography of bombing campaign, as the moral justification or otherwise of the bombing of civilians in cities in Nazi Germany is a huge topic that goes all the way back to the war itself and has been brought up numerous times since, most recently in a book by Richard Overy called "The Bombers and the Bombed":

Overy explores the full range of European bombing, including the London Blitz, the bombings of Bulgaria, Italy and France, and finally the ferocious Allied assault on Germany that saw Hamburg, Dresden and much of Berlin reduced to charred ruins. Overy’s writing is temperate, but his judgments are devastating, and through it all runs a vein of quiet anger at the sheer profligacy, in squandered blood and treasure, of waging war this way.

One by one, comforting myths are demolished. Long-range bombing by Britain and later by the Allies is usually defended as a valid retaliation in response to the indiscriminate German bombing of civilians. “They sowed the wind, and now they are going to reap the whirlwind,” Bomber Harris is said to have remarked after Luftwaffe bombs rained down on London. (Notions of punishment, revenge and tactics were hopelessly entangled from the start.) Overy demonstrates, however, that the tactic of bombing urban areas had been put into action by the British before the Blitz.

...

Promoters of the bombing campaign insisted that targeting civilians would wear down German morale and economic resilience, leading to the inevitable collapse of the Nazi regime. By 1941, bombs were aimed, as the director of Air Intelligence said, at “the livelihood, the homes, the cooking, heating, lighting and family life of that section of the population which, in any country, is least mobile and most vulnerable to a general air attack — the working class.” Britain had not buckled under the Blitz, but instead of drawing a logical conclusion from this, Harris and his colleagues blithely assumed that Germans lacked the moral fiber to stand up to a concerted air campaign.

In other words, I do not agree with the second premise, that the Allied bombing was morally justified (at least not in every respect). And there was a very clear reason for that; it was ineffective in what it set out to do, just as Israel's attempts at getting the population of Gaza to throw off Hamas has failed by making the lives of civilians there a misery.

So, think about it, if it is not effective and not realistic then why should it be considered the best policy? It seems to succeed in nothing more than steeling the population of Gaza against Israel and in favour of Hamas, while trashing Israel's own reputation amongst normal people in the world.
 
Heart-string tugging photos follow of a densely populated area, run by genocidal jew-hating aggressors, that has been the subject of overwhelming land and air assault.

Guess what - totally justified.

Same thing with Gaza.
It can be debated (and has, on this board alone, numerous times) if the large-scale WWII bombing of Axis cities was justified. Either way, since the Israelis aren't dropping fire bombs from high altitude to pretty much flatten all of Gaza, it's not a very good comparison either way.
 
It seems to me you're trying to have it both ways with Egypt. If the Gaza "blockade" is real, it means Egypt is doing the very same thing you criticize Israel for doing. However, in your statement above, you admit the border with Egypt "has varied in its porosity...." That suggests it's not really a "blockade" after all -- it can't be if the Egyptian border is open -- and the justification for attacking Israel falls apart.
Nah, it's just another "but, but Israel"/moving the goalposts reply. I've seen the same exchange about a million times now.
 
A couple minor interjections.

Coupled with this earlier post of yours...

A bit separately from this and taking it back a step back... It's worth noting that thinking that something is "justified" and agreeing that something is a "legitimate response" are not quite the same as being a proponent of that course of action or thinking that it's the best course of action.

I think that Israel's response is, generally speaking, justified and legitimate. I don't like it much, however, and think that a more directed and judicious response would serve them far better, overall.

So, think about it, if it is not effective and not realistic then why should it be considered the best policy? It seems to succeed in nothing more than steeling the population of Gaza against Israel and in favour of Hamas, while trashing Israel's own reputation amongst normal people in the world.

For the former, at last check, it's been quite steeled against them regardless and that seems highly unlikely to change, given their cultural choices. For that latter, you have something of a point, much as it's saddening that actual genocides receive so much less attention. However, I very highly doubt that your suggested goals quite match the goals of those giving the orders for the bombing.
 
Last edited:
For the former, at last check, it's been quite steeled against them regardless and that seems highly unlikely to change, given their cultural choices. For that latter, you have something of a point, much as it's saddening that actual genocides receive so much less attention. However, I very highly doubt that your suggested goals quite match the goals of those giving the orders for the bombing.

On the subject of support for Hamas, it seems that it had dropped considerably before the rocket attacks and Israel's retaliation.

Support for firing rockets from Gaza into Israel has dropped sharply, from 74% in December 2012, to 38% now, survey conducted by Jerusalem Media and Communications Center shows; 80% back non-violent "resistance" against Israel.

I do not know what it is like now, however, Peter Beinart believes that Hamas may indeed get a pool of new recruits from the relatives of those killed this time:

Israel can destroy Hamas’ rockets, but Hamas will eventually rebuild them bigger and better, as it did after the last war, and the one before that. And in the relatives and friends of the Palestinians killed in Operation Protective Edge, it will find plenty of new recruits willing to fire them.

But I don't know it that is true either. I think only time will tell.
 
On the subject of support for Hamas,

I was more referring to their feelings about Israel than their support of Hamas. Hamas is, after all, quite replaceable. Frankly, I rather hope that the Palestinians learn that violence isn't going to serve their overall interests all the better, though. The 60% is still a bit too low on that front, apparently.
 
Last edited:
Are Israelis and Zionists Really Talking About a Final Solution of the Palestinian Problem?


The Times of Israel published and then removed from its site an essay by Yochanan Gordon that openly called for genocide against the Palestinians of Gaza. A cached version is still on the internet as of Saturday morning.

Gordon’s logic, if one wants to dignify it with that term, is that Hamas calls for the destruction of Israel, and therefore the only way to deal with them is to obliterate them entirely. He used the words “obliterate entirely.”

Hamas is a party-militia of the religious right. It does say it wants to see the Israeli government overthrown. Its leaders don’t, however, speak of committing genocide against Israelis. They say they want to recover their country, which was stolen from them by the Israelis in 1948. Colonial regimes always produce resistance movements.

The fact is that Hamas was supported by Israeli intelligence in the 1980s as a foil to the PLO, so Shin Bet and Mossad don’t seem to have been worried by the party charter.
 
However, I very highly doubt that your suggested goals quite match the goals of those giving the orders for the bombing.

I missed this bit, and I am a little intrigued as to what it means.

Which of my suggested goals of the bombing are you referring to?

And what do you believe are the goals of those ordering the bombing?
 
I missed this bit, and I am a little intrigued as to what it means.

Which of my suggested goals of the bombing are you referring to?

And what do you believe are the goals of those ordering the bombing?

More specifically, I doubt that the goals you named are the only goals, much as I do not and will not pretend to know with any great certainty. The first four other potential goals with what might be mildly positive spin that pop to mind, for example, are effectively hamstringing Hamas for a fair while by destroying most or all of its leadership, making a show of Israel's power to the world and more importantly, its neighbors, pandering to the desires of certain segments of the Israeli population for political reasons, and trying to set the stage for the Palestinians to focus on more immediate domestic concerns for a while. There's a lot of potential goals with negative spins, too, like keeping the barbarians weak and in their place.
 
Last edited:
I'm not so sure. Haven't seen the statistics on this, but if I was in Gaza, Israel's attacks would be a deterrent for me, rather than as a provocation. "When we mess with the Israelis, this is what we get in return. 70 years of bloodshed has gained us nothing but lost land, poverty and countless dead. Let us seek a peaceful solution instead".

But what do I know, I don't live in a dictatorship that spoon-feeds me hateful propaganda from the day I enter kindergarden, so what do I know... :boxedin:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom