Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
On another note, though, good to finally see some serious discussion in this thread, what with Kumar getting kicked out and all :) .
 
Those who are anti-semitic obviously will condemn Israel no matter what, and those people cannot be reasoned with, but there are plenty of perfectly normal people including sympathizers with Israel for whom the bombing of UN schools and hospitals is too much.

I certainly struggle to see the point of such actions. Maybe they have as purpose obscure to me, but it seems Israel would win a lot from showing a little restraint.

At this point it almost seems to me that Israel is far more motivated by internal political concerns than the external threat of Hamas.
 
The tunnels are used primarily to circumvent the illegal blockade and bring in essential supplies.

I'm sure these essentials include irrigation pipe, sugar and nitrogen fertilizer, from reports of rockets leaving white smoke trails. Shutting down the tunnels will reduce availability of resources for the Gaza High Power Rocketry Club (masked, because they don't have Tripoli numbers, armed because Israel won't clear the range) to build their own hardware, forcing them to rely on commercially made military rockets for their Club activities.
 
Those who are anti-semitic obviously will condemn Israel no matter what, and those people cannot be reasoned with, but there are plenty of perfectly normal people including sympathizers with Israel for whom the bombing of UN schools and hospitals is too much.

It shouldn't be (or at least, Israel shouldn't be regarded as the one who is morally at fault):
----------------------------------------------
"A senior U.N. official who has served in the Gaza Strip and is a longstanding critic of Israeli policies there acknowledged Thursday that Hamas and other terrorist groups were firing weapons “from the vicinity of U.N. facilities” located in the territory."

"three U.N.-run schools have been found with munitions stored in them, as weapons depots.”

"Ging did not mention – and was not asked about – Israeli claims that when the U.N. did find rockets in a U.N. school for the first time earlier this month, it had essentially handed them over to Hamas. UNRWA said at the time it asked “local police,” to remove the rockets."
-------------------------------------------------


If schools get used as munitions depots or launch sites then they become legitimate targets. The folks who are making them legitimate targets are Hamas, who are cynically counting on sentimental unthinking Westerners to hand them a PR victory.
 
I certainly struggle to see the point of such actions. Maybe they have as purpose obscure to me, but it seems Israel would win a lot from showing a little restraint.

At this point it almost seems to me that Israel is far more motivated by internal political concerns than the external threat of Hamas.

I disagree - if the preamble in the Hamas charter is still applicable i.e.

The Preamble to the Charter states: ″Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it″.


Then Israel has every right to be concerned. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamas_Covenant#Statements_about_Israel


Imagine an neighbour moving in next to your domicile telling you that their intention is to kill you. What would you do?


These ARE the fundamentals, other nations have also espoused the wish to obliterate Israel.


Again, now you have more neighbours who want to obliterate you. Who are you going to call? What would you do?
 
Last edited:
Even assuming the "essential supplies" are not actually weapons used to attack Israel,

Why should it be one or the other? The tunnels are used to transport all kinds of goods, including weapons.


how is Israel responsible for a "blockade" which includes a border under Egyptian control?

Israel controls nearly all sea, land and air entry points to Gaza. The border with Egypt has varied in its porosity according to various factors. Egypt is not actively attacking, brutalizing, beating up, starving, murdering or inflicting collective punishments on the people of Gaza. That is why your rocket question is so ludicrous.
 
I disagree - if the preamble in the Hamas charter is still applicable i.e.

The Preamble to the Charter states: ″Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it″.


Then Israel has every right to be concerned. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamas_Covenant#Statements_about_Israel


Imagine an neighbour moving in next to your domicile telling you that their intention is to kill you. What would you do?


These ARE the fundamentals, other nations have also espoused the wish to obliterate Israel.


Again, now you have more neighbours who want to obliterate you. Who are you going to call? What would you do?

Hamas might want to obliterate Israel, though it has repeatedly stated that it will accept a withdrawal to pre-1967 borders. Israel, on the other hand is actively, progressively and successfully obliterating Palestine. Can you spot the difference?
 
Hamas might want to obliterate Israel, though it has repeatedly stated that it will accept a withdrawal to pre-1967 borders. Israel, on the other hand is actively, progressively and successfully obliterating Palestine. Can you spot the difference?

With only ~1.5k dead within 3 weeks that's a poor job in "obliterating" a people. Seriously, the Hutus in Rwanda had far less developed infrastructure yet they wiped out 1/10 Rwandans within 3 months with only Machetes and small arms. Israel really needs to step up their game if it's wanting to win the Genocide Olympics.
 
Hamas might want to obliterate Israel, though it has repeatedly stated that it will accept a withdrawal to pre-1967 borders. Israel, on the other hand is actively, progressively and successfully obliterating Palestine. Can you spot the difference?

Slowest obliteration EVAH!
 
I disagree - if the preamble in the Hamas charter is still applicable i.e.

The Preamble to the Charter states: ″Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it″.


Then Israel has every right to be concerned. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamas_Covenant#Statements_about_Israel


Imagine an neighbour moving in next to your domicile telling you that their intention is to kill you. What would you do?


These ARE the fundamentals, other nations have also espoused the wish to obliterate Israel.


Again, now you have more neighbours who want to obliterate you. Who are you going to call? What would you do?

Like with Giz, I essentially agree with you. But when Israel decides to launch an offensive, it seems nothing short of prudent to consider the immediate and long-term threat posed by Hamas vs. the lives of civilians.

Essentially, if Israel decides to launch a campagin that results in great colatteral damage, damage to UN facilities, and 1500 deaths, then it better be an effective mean toward a goal. I'm not convinced that the offensive, all-in-all, has been effective in doing much of anything but bolster the support for Hamas.
 
Hamas might want to obliterate Israel, though it has repeatedly stated that it will accept a withdrawal to pre-1967 borders. Israel, on the other hand is actively, progressively and successfully obliterating Palestine. Can you spot the difference?
Not you too. We've just kicked out Kumar, and you immediately take over.

Of course HAMAS would "accept an Israeli withdrawal to pre-1967 borders". Any losing side in a war would accept the enemy falling back to give up large areas of land:rolleyes:. When they simultaneously have as their goal that they want the whole cake for themselves, though, and when they consistently turn down peace offerings that could indeed give them virtually all of the occupied land... colour me unimpressed.
 
Like with Giz, I essentially agree with you. But when Israel decides to launch an offensive, it seems nothing short of prudent to consider the immediate and long-term threat posed by Hamas vs. the lives of civilians.

Essentially, if Israel decides to launch a campagin that results in great colatteral damage, damage to UN facilities, and 1500 deaths, then it better be an effective mean toward a goal. I'm not convinced that the offensive, all-in-all, has been effective in doing much of anything but bolster the support for Hamas.
Depends. If it is an all-out move to take out HAMAS and replace it with a more civilized and down-to-earth leadership, leading to peace in and around Gaza, it will be more than worth it in the long run.
 
When they simultaneously have as their goal that they want the whole cake for themselves, though, and when they consistently turn down peace offerings that could indeed give them virtually all of the occupied land... colour me unimpressed.

This sounds like it could be useful; do you have any good sources on said peace offerrings?
 
Hamas might want to obliterate Israel, though it has repeatedly stated that it will accept a withdrawal to pre-1967 borders. Israel, on the other hand is actively, progressively and successfully obliterating Palestine. Can you spot the difference?

Yes - it appears you cannot.

Your first two statements do not follow. e.g. pre-1967 borders could be applied, but still the wish to obliterate Israel would remain in the charter.

Israel is not obliterating Palestine, nor does it say it wants to in its charter/constitution.

See the difference?
 
Yes - it appears you cannot.

Your first two statements do not follow. e.g. pre-1967 borders could be applied, but still the wish to obliterate Israel would remain in the charter.

Israel is not obliterating Palestine, nor does it say it wants to in its charter/constitution.

See the difference?

2638950aa188de303b.jpg


"When we have settled the land, all the Arabs will be able to do about it will be to scurry around like drugged cockroaches in a bottle." - Raphael Eitan, Chief of Staff of the Israeli Defence Forces, New York Times, 14 April 1983.

"There was no such thing as Palestinians, they never existed." - Golda Maier Israeli Prime Minister June 15, 1969


"We have to kill all the Palestinians unless they are resigned to live here as slaves." - Chairman Heilbrun of the Committee for the Re-election of General Shlomo Lahat, the mayor of Tel Aviv, October 1983.

"We walked outside, Ben-Gurion accompanying us. Allon repeated his question, What is to be done with the Palestinian population?' Ben-Gurion waved his hand in a gesture which said 'Drive them out!'" - Yitzhak Rabin, leaked censored version of Rabin memoirs, published in the New York Times, 23 October 1979.

David Ben Gurion, future Prime Minister of Israel, 1937, Ben Gurion and the Palestine Arabs, Oxford University Press, 1985: "We must expel Arabs and take their places."

"We'll make a pastrami sandwich of them, ... we'll insert a strip of Jewish settlements in between the Palestinians, and then another strip of Jewish settlements right across the West Bank, so that in 25 years' time, neither the United Nations nor the United States, nobody, will be able to tear it apart."
- (Ariel (Arik) Sharon, 1973)
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/2638950aa188de303b.jpg

"When we have settled the land, all the Arabs will be able to do about it will be to scurry around like drugged cockroaches in a bottle." - Raphael Eitan, Chief of Staff of the Israeli Defence Forces, New York Times, 14 April 1983.

"There was no such thing as Palestinians, they never existed." - Golda Maier Israeli Prime Minister June 15, 1969


"We have to kill all the Palestinians unless they are resigned to live here as slaves." - Chairman Heilbrun of the Committee for the Re-election of General Shlomo Lahat, the mayor of Tel Aviv, October 1983.

"We walked outside, Ben-Gurion accompanying us. Allon repeated his question, What is to be done with the Palestinian population?' Ben-Gurion waved his hand in a gesture which said 'Drive them out!'" - Yitzhak Rabin, leaked censored version of Rabin memoirs, published in the New York Times, 23 October 1979.

David Ben Gurion, future Prime Minister of Israel, 1937, Ben Gurion and the Palestine Arabs, Oxford University Press, 1985: "We must expel Arabs and take their places."

"We'll make a pastrami sandwich of them, ... we'll insert a strip of Jewish settlements in between the Palestinians, and then another strip of Jewish settlements right across the West Bank, so that in 25 years' time, neither the United Nations nor the United States, nobody, will be able to tear it apart."
- (Ariel (Arik) Sharon, 1973)

Hamas in Their Own Words

Sermon delivered by 'Atallah Abu Al-Subh, former Hamas minister of culture, which aired on Al-Aqsa TV, April 8, 2011, translation by MEMRI
"Whoever is killed by a Jew receives the reward of two martyrs, because the very thing that the Jews did to the prophets was done to him.

"The Jews are the most despicable and contemptible nation to crawl upon the face of the Earth, because they have displayed hostility to Allah.
"Allah will kill the Jews in the hell of the world to come, just like they killed the believers in the hell of this world.
"The Jews kill anyone who believes in Allah. They do not want to see any peace whatsoever on Earth."

Statement from Hamas Ministry of Refugee Affairs on U.N. Relief and Works Agency plan to include Holocaust education in the curriculum taught Palestinian refugees, February 28, 2011

“We cannot agree to a programme that is intended to poison the minds of our children…Holocaust studies in refugee camps is a contemptible plot and serves the Zionist entity with a goal of creating a reality and telling stories in order to justify acts of slaughter against the Palestinian people."

Hamas leader Mahmoud Al-Zahhar, Future News TV, June 15, 2010, Source: MEMRI.org

"We have liberated Gaza, but have we recognized Israel? Have we given up our lands occupied in 1948? We demand the liberation of the West Bank, and the establishment of a state in the West Bank and Gaza, with Jerusalem as its capital – but without recognizing [Israel]. This is the key – without recognizing the Israeli enemy on a single inch of land...

"Our plan for this stage is to liberate any inch of Palestinian land, and to establish a state on it. Our ultimate plan is [to have] Palestine in its entirety. I say this loud and clear so that nobody will accuse me of employing political tactics. We will not recognize the Israeli enemy. "

Dr. Yussuf Al-Sharafi, Hamas representative, April 12, 2007; as reported by Palestinian Media Watch, April 23, 2007
"...the Jewish faith does not wish for peace nor stability, since it is a faith that is based on murder: 'I kill, therefore I am'... Israel is based only on blood and murder in order to exist, and it will disappear, with Allah's will, through blood and Shahids [martyrs]."

Sheikh Dr. Ahmad Bahar, acting Speaker of the Palestinian Legislative Council, April 20, 2007; as reported by Palestinian Media Watch, April 23, 2007
"This is Islam, that was ahead of its time with regards to human rights in the treatment of prisoners, but our nation was tested by the cancerous lump, that is the Jews, in the heart of the Arab nation... Be certain that America is on its way to utter destruction, America is wallowing [in blood] today in Iraq and Afghanistan, America is defeated and Israel is defeated, and was defeated in Lebanon and Palestine... Make us victorious over the community of infidels... Allah, take the Jews and their allies, Allah, take the Americans and their allies... Allah, annihilate them completely and do not leave anyone of them."

Hamas statement in response to criticism by Al-Qaeda's Ayman al-Zawahri, March 12, 2007
"We will not betray promises we made to God to continue the path of Jihad and resistance until the liberation of Palestine, all of Palestine. . . So be assured doctor Ayman, and all those who love Palestine like yourself, that Hamas is still the group you knew when it was founded and it will never abandon its path."
Khaled Mashaal, Hamas leader, February 3, 2006, Al-Hayyat al-Jedida"[Hamas will] never recognize the legitimacy of the Zionist state that was founded on our land."

Mahmoud Zahar, Hamas leader, after casting his vote in the Gaza Strip, January 25, 2006, Ha'aretz
"[Hamas] will not change a single word in its covenant [which is calling for the destruction of Israel]."

Ismail Haniyah, Hamas leader, at an election rally in Gaza, January 20, 2006, Reuters
"They have tried to pressure Hamas to abandon resistance and to abandon arms. They tried to pressure Hamas to abandon its strategic choice in Palestine, all of Palestine. They tried to pressure Hamas to recognize the legitimacy of the occupation. But they failed... We say Hamas will not change its constant principles."

Hamas spokesman, Sami Abu-Zuhri, explains to Al-Sharq al-Awsat that there is no contradiction between Hamas' platform for the election and its charter, which calls for the destruction of Israel, January 13, 2006, BBC Monitoring
"The program [of Hamas-backed list to legislative council] sets out the details and means for its implementation over the next four years, while the [Hamas] charter talks about vision and strategy…The movement is adhering to the constants and strategies outlined in the [Hamas] charter.
"

Sheik Nizar Rayan, Hamas "political" leader, at a rally in Gaza, Al-Jazeera TV on September 16, 2005, MEMRI
"The vanquishing of the enemy in Gaza does not mean that this stage has ended. We still have Jerusalem and the pure West Bank. We will not rest until we liberate all our land, all our Palestine. We do not distinguish between what was occupied in the 1940s and what was occupied in the 1960s. Our Jihad continues, and we still have a long way to go. We will continue until the very last usurper is driven out of our land."


Abdel Aziz Rantisi, Hamas leader, June 10, 2003, interview with Al-Jazeera, Jerusalem Post
"By God, we will not leave one Jew in Palestine. We will fight them with all the strength we have. This is our land, not the Jews..."

"You will have no security except outside the homeland Palestine.... We have Allah on our side, and we have the sons of the Arab and Islamic nation on our side."

Sheik Ahmed Yassin, interview with Australian Muslim youth magazine, Nida'ul Islam, June/ July 2002"
We reject this US domination and this frantic war. From our side, we concentrate on striking blows to it here in Palestine, with the aim of ironing out the Jewish entity in Palestine, which is the cause of trouble in the world..."

"America... always works in favor of the existence of the Israeli entity... This is mainly due to the Zionist-Christian conviction and the 70 million Americans who follow the Protestant creed, which is in favor of Jews against the Muslims. The same applies to most of Britain's population..."
"Because the Israeli and American enemies are ravaging the earth; they do not believe in anything besides power. The Ummah must adopt the principle of Jihad and fighting the enemies."

Hamas communiqué, March 9, 1989, translated and distributed in the U.S. by the Islamic Association for Palestine
"Come to jihad, come to jihad, come to martyrdom..."
"Those thirsty for Jihad all over the world. For the sake of Allah. For liberating the land of Palestine and Jerusalem...."

"We declared and continue to declare now, that a Jew is a Jew... [do not trust them when they say they want peace because they act only] to serve their religion and their people."


Your and my examples, spoken words - who has the obliteration of a nation state written in their charter/constitution?



 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom