Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I echo the sentiment from above: that the people with the strongest opinions are most often the least knowledgeable about the issue they're discussing, and that misunderstanding (deliberately?) terms like "genocide" and applying them to the Israel-Palestine conflict pretty clearly communicates that you aren't a serious debater.
 
There also seems to be a conflating of the terms "War Crimes" and "Genocide". There are War Crimes other then Genocide......
 
And I see that it is fine for Javier Badier and Penelope Cruz to accuse Israel of Genocide,but for Gal Gadot (the new movie Wonder Woman) to defend Israel is outrageous.
 
And a lot of Antisemitic diatribes can get a free pass when they say "Anti-zionist". Seriously, someone could replace the word "Jew" for "Zionist" from Sturmer articles and would still be quoted wholesale.
 
Yeah, it really is looking pretty bad. I know the goal is the destruction of the tunnels, which certainly seems like a legitimate objective, but still... It's heavy-handed.

I suppose the reason for the heavy-handedness is minimizing the risk of Israeli casualties, yet the cost is pretty high.

I imagine that a lot of German cities looked pretty bad in 1945, yet one doesn't tend to hear too much hand wringing over Allied heavy handedness.

When a population votes in a bunch of authoritarian, genocidal, expansionist scumbags who then start shooting at their more powerful neighbors... well, it's not pretty but maybe the neighbors are justified in their response.

As it happens there are plenty of good arguments for saying that the bombing of civilians in World War Two was indeed Allied heavy-handedness. And the same goes for some of the Israeli bombings now. And as far as limiting Israeli casualties is concerned, they could have limited those casualties far more by not sending in a ground invasion of Gaza.

For me the question is whether or not the bombing and the invasion of Gaza is going to be effective, and I don't really think that it is. It's certainly been successful from Hamas's perspective as they have been able to parade dead babies to the TV cameras.
 
I have a question about the "blockade" of Gaza. I have been told that is the justification for Hamas to fire rockets and dig tunnels to grab Israelis. But isn't there a border crossing in Rafah controlled (and currently closed) by Egypt? If so, shouldn't Egypt get some of those rockets and kidnappings? I suspect the answer is that Hamas knows if it started doing those things in Egypt, the Egyptians would show even less restraint than Israel. But I'd be happy to read other explanations.
 
Last edited:
I have a question about the "blockade" of Gaza. I have been told that is the justification for Hamas to fire rockets and dig tunnels to grab Israelis. But isn't there a border crossing in Rafah controlled (and currently closed) by Egypt? If so, shouldn't Egypt get some of those rockets and kidnappings? I suspect the answer is that Hamas knows if it started doing those things in Egypt, the Egyptians would show even less restraint than Israel. But I'd be happy to read other explanations.

You might be right. We certainly saw that the military dictatorship was not averse to shooting thousands of protesters and sentencing hundreds more to death. Given that Hamas is an offshoot of the Muslim Brotherhood, I would imagine Egypt would quite happily unleash a fierce bombing campaign if they thought they could get away with it. Similarly Assad senior and Assad junior killed ten times as many in Hama in military campaigns of their own and did not get many people protesting outside the Syrian embassies of the world with placards reading "No More Hamas!"

On the other hand, Egypt apparently has been destroying tunnels from Sinai in to Gaza, and apparently has been subject to attacks from either Hamas or other militant groups:

Cairo (AFP) - Egypt's army said Sunday it has destroyed 13 more tunnels connecting the Sinai Peninsula to the Gaza Strip, taking to 1,639 the overall number it has laid waste to.

...

Cairo also accuses of Hamas of being involved in militant attacks inside Egypt, which have multiplied since Morsi was toppled.

Militant groups say their attacks are in retaliation for a police crackdown on Morsi's supporters. The crackdown has seen more than 1,400 people killed in street clashes.

http://news.yahoo.com/egypt-army-destroys-13-more-gaza-tunnels-093712884.html
 
As it happens there are plenty of good arguments for saying that the bombing of civilians in World War Two was indeed Allied heavy-handedness. And the same goes for some of the Israeli bombings now. And as far as limiting Israeli casualties is concerned, they could have limited those casualties far more by not sending in a ground invasion of Gaza.

For me the question is whether or not the bombing and the invasion of Gaza is going to be effective, and I don't really think that it is. It's certainly been successful from Hamas's perspective as they have been able to parade dead babies to the TV cameras.


But,frankly, expecting the Israelis to stand around doing nother while being attacked is completely unrealistic.

And the tunnels are changing the dynamics. Pretty apparent HAMAS is using those as a response to Iron Dome. The IDF was genuinely shocked by the extent of the tunnels. They knew HAMAS had a few ,but nothing like what they found.

I also think that the Israeli attitude toward International opinion has become
"We are going to get condemned no matter what we do, so we might as well get hung for being wolf rathen then a sheep."
 
If you check Street View in Google Earth, Egypt is indeed building a wall along the Egypt-Gaza border; and yes, as you have noticed, building Apartheid Barriers to keep the population of Gaza from escaping the genocide going on in their open-air prison is... apparently totally fine and dandy when it's Egyptians doing it.

...and this is far from the only example of people condemning Israel for doing something, and turning a blind eye when someone else does exactly the same thing, even if they, too, do it to the Palestinian people.

If I lived in Gaza, I wouldn't be that moved by "solidarity" that was only shown when it was Jews, as opposed to other countries or my own government, that did things to me.
 
But,frankly, expecting the Israelis to stand around doing nother while being attacked is completely unrealistic.

And the tunnels are changing the dynamics. Pretty apparent HAMAS is using those as a response to Iron Dome. The IDF was genuinely shocked by the extent of the tunnels. They knew HAMAS had a few ,but nothing like what they found.

I also think that the Israeli attitude toward International opinion has become
"We are going to get condemned no matter what we do, so we might as well get hung for being wolf rathen then a sheep."

If this results in rocket attacks ceasing then maybe.

However, does any one want to lay any bets on the next time there will be a barrage of rocket attacks from Gaza?

However, I don't really understand the metaphor of hanging a wolf rather than a sheep. I've heard the expression that one might as well be hanged for a sheep as a lamb which is that there's no point in doing something small scale if you are going to be condemned equally for both, but actually that is not the case here. Those who are anti-semitic obviously will condemn Israel no matter what, and those people cannot be reasoned with, but there are plenty of perfectly normal people including sympathizers with Israel for whom the bombing of UN schools and hospitals is too much.
 
I have a question about the "blockade" of Gaza. I have been told that is the justification for Hamas to fire rockets and dig tunnels to grab Israelis. But isn't there a border crossing in Rafah controlled (and currently closed) by Egypt? If so, shouldn't Egypt get some of those rockets and kidnappings? I suspect the answer is that Hamas knows if it started doing those things in Egypt, the Egyptians would show even less restraint than Israel. But I'd be happy to read other explanations.

The tunnels are used primarily to circumvent the illegal blockade and bring in essential supplies.

Your "explanation" is wrong because your question is born of a childishly superficial understanding, based on crude, cartoon propaganda. Hope that helps!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

'Human Shield’ Propaganda Used to Justify State-Sponsored Massacres for Decades

Israel Speaks: "We Purposefully Attack Civilian Targets... Because They Deserve It"
 
Last edited:
The tunnels are used primarily to circumvent the illegal blockade and bring in essential supplies.
Yup.

Your "explanation" is wrong because your question is born of a childishly superficial understanding, based on crude, cartoon propaganda. Hope that helps!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

'Human Shield’ Propaganda Used to Justify State-Sponsored Massacres for Decades

Israel Speaks: "We Purposefully Attack Civilian Targets... Because They Deserve It"
There goes another irony meter:(...
 
The tunnels are used primarily to circumvent the illegal blockade and bring in essential supplies.

Your "explanation" is wrong because your question is born of a childishly superficial understanding, based on crude, cartoon propaganda. Hope that helps!


Even assuming the "essential supplies" are not actually weapons used to attack Israel, how is Israel responsible for a "blockade" which includes a border under Egyptian control?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom