Good points all around.
I am not really sure how to take the above statement
Is it a cynical snide? Is it an honest agreement?
I am confused....especially in the light of this
If a JEW intermarries they are STILL A JEW.![]()
I know you posted this post before this above one but then you posted this one afterwards.
So I am really confused
When you say
If a JEW intermarries they are STILL A JEW.![]()
Are you sarcastically asserting that it is true or are you saying you are not sure???
Well, in fact the statement as it stands
If a JEW intermarries they are STILL A JEW
Is actually true..... if X marries anything he is still X.
The question is if a Persian marries a French then their children are what?
And if these Children marry English, what are the grandchildren and if the grandchildren marry African then what are the great-grand-children, and if the great great great great great grand children all intermarry numerous and different ethnicities, what do they become????
But a more analogous situation to the Ashkenazim especially but many other Jews is the question:
If a Persian Muslim marries a French who also converts to Islam and they live in France and then their children marry French who convert to Islam and go on to live in France and their great grand children marry French and so on for 50 generations and all brought up as Muslim living in France…. Are the g-g-g-g-Children Muslim? Are they Persians?
I am sure you can see that the answer to the former question is:
It depends on what religion they confess (or lack of).
I hope you can also see that the answer to the latter question is:
NO they are French!!! Unless you are an extreme racist and human rights abuser, that is.
If you are a non practicing Jew you are still a Jew. If you are a non practicing Christian you are not a Christian. How about some education on this before blathering on nonsense.
I hope that you can now see that this is only because of RACISM and ANTI-Judaism which is not different from the current Anti-Islam.
Are you saying that an apostate Muslim is still a Muslim just because he continues to eat Hummus and Shish Kebabs Instead of Pork Chops on Sundays?
I am sure your answer is yes if you are basing it on RACIST considerations, but it should be no, if you are considering it on theological considerations, just as you just did above in the case of a Christian.
The same applies to a Jewish person…. I hope you can see that, especially if you were not just sarcastically agreeing that this post has "Good points all around".
Last edited: