Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Good points all around.


I am not really sure how to take the above statement :confused:.

Is it a cynical snide? Is it an honest agreement?

I am confused....especially in the light of this

If a JEW intermarries they are STILL A JEW. :confused::confused:


I know you posted this post before this above one but then you posted this one afterwards.

So I am really confused :confused::confused:.


When you say
If a JEW intermarries they are STILL A JEW. :confused::confused:

Are you sarcastically asserting that it is true or are you saying you are not sure???


Well, in fact the statement as it stands
If a JEW intermarries they are STILL A JEW​

Is actually true..... if X marries anything he is still X.

The question is if a Persian marries a French then their children are what?

And if these Children marry English, what are the grandchildren and if the grandchildren marry African then what are the great-grand-children, and if the great great great great great grand children all intermarry numerous and different ethnicities, what do they become????

But a more analogous situation to the Ashkenazim especially but many other Jews is the question:
If a Persian Muslim marries a French who also converts to Islam and they live in France and then their children marry French who convert to Islam and go on to live in France and their great grand children marry French and so on for 50 generations and all brought up as Muslim living in France…. Are the g-g-g-g-Children Muslim? Are they Persians?​

I am sure you can see that the answer to the former question is:
It depends on what religion they confess (or lack of).​

I hope you can also see that the answer to the latter question is:
NO they are French!!! Unless you are an extreme racist and human rights abuser, that is.​



If you are a non practicing Jew you are still a Jew. If you are a non practicing Christian you are not a Christian. How about some education on this before blathering on nonsense.


I hope that you can now see that this is only because of RACISM and ANTI-Judaism which is not different from the current Anti-Islam.

Are you saying that an apostate Muslim is still a Muslim just because he continues to eat Hummus and Shish Kebabs Instead of Pork Chops on Sundays?

I am sure your answer is yes if you are basing it on RACIST considerations, but it should be no, if you are considering it on theological considerations, just as you just did above in the case of a Christian.

The same applies to a Jewish person…. I hope you can see that, especially if you were not just sarcastically agreeing that this post has "Good points all around".
 
Last edited:
For me, when someone says the words "Apartheid", "Genocide" or "Ethnic Cleansing" when discussing Israel is de facto admitting they know nothing, the same way screaming "sunspots" when discussing climate change is admitting ignorance.


I am sure you think American President Jimmy Carter knows nothing, after all he was a Democrat. Also see this video.

I am sure you think American Senator and Secretary Of State John Kerry is a moron liberal Democrat who thinks that poor people have rights.

I am sure that you think the person who wrote this editorial is a loon too who values such crazy lefty stuff as humanity and human rights.

I am sure you think all the people who wrote all these books are anti-Semite morons who also think that global warming is a fact.

I am also sure that you think all these "scholars" and "international lawyers" and "United Nations commissioners" mentioned in this Wikipedia page are leftists and communists and godless gays perhaps.


Oh well, I'm glad there are still knowledgeable people like you left to point out the errors of all those misguided scholars and international lawyers…. CDAC much????

The analogy has been used by scholars, United Nations investigators, human rights groups and critics of Israeli policy, some of which have also accused Israel of committing the crime of apartheid.[2][3] Critics of Israeli policy say that "a system of control" in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, including Jewish-only settlements, the ID system, separate roads for Israeli and Palestinian citizens, military checkpoints, discriminatory marriage law, the West Bank barrier, use of Palestinians as cheap labour, Palestinian West Bank enclaves, inequities in infrastructure, legal rights, and access to land and resources between Palestinians and Israeli residents in the Israeli-occupied territories resembles some aspects of the South African apartheid regime, and that elements of Israel's occupation constitute forms of colonialism and of apartheid, which are contrary to international law.[4] Some commentators extend the analogy, or accusation, to include Arab citizens of Israel, describing their citizenship status as second-class.[12]

....

In a 2007 report, United Nations Special Rapporteur for Palestine John Dugard stated, "elements of the Israeli occupation constitute forms of colonialism and of apartheid, which are contrary to international law" and suggested that the "legal consequences of a prolonged occupation with features of colonialism and apartheid" be put to the International Court of Justice.[44] In 2009 South Africa's statutory research agency the Human Sciences Research Council (HSRC) published a report stating, "the State of Israel exercises control in the [Occupied Palestinian Territories] with the purpose of maintaining a system of domination by Jews over Palestinians and that this system constitutes a breach of the prohibition of apartheid."[45] The report was written by a team of international law experts and scholars and does not represent an official position of the HSRC.[46] In 2010 United Nations Special Rapporteur for Palestine Richard A. Falk reported that criminal apartheid features of the Israeli occupation had been entrenched in the three years since the report of his predecessor, John Dugard.[47] In March 2011, Falk said, "The continued pattern of settlement expansion in East Jerusalem combined with the forcible eviction of long-residing Palestinians is creating an intolerable situation ... [and] can only be described in its cumulative impact as a form of ethnic cleansing."[48]

 
Last edited:
Why do people, especially on the left, single out Israel as a Genghis/Timur/Cortez/Hitler level horror (seriously, even the USA in Abu Ghraib didn't get anywhere near as much scrutiny as the recent Gaza campaign) to the extent they'd believe blatantly fabricated reports of atrocities hook line and sinker.


CDAC much?


Something I see is utterly and totally evading many people posting the Cognitive Dissonance Assuaging Casuistry (CDAC) in this thread.

Of course they will tell you that the doctors and scientists who wrote that letter are bleeding-heart liberals or something as equally devoid of the stuff that is highlighted above.

It is a lot easier to demonize and dehumanize people than to face the REAL REALITY of having been totally and utterly bamboozled and hoodwinked for one’s entire life along with one's entire culture and country for generations. It is a lot easier to DENY REALITY than to face one’s own Cognitive Dissonance Agonies and to wake up from the Wishful Thinking Stupors.
 
You know something, ignorance of history is one thing but deliberately falsifying history is a MORAL CRIME because it falsifies human heritage and denies humans the true reality of their past and thus the TRUTH about things from which they can verify TRUTHFUL REALITY.

While this may be true, the truth of what actually happened here was nothing even remotely as nefarious as you're trying to claim. I was quite tired when I typed that and made a couple fairly simple mistakes regarding terms, of two types. For the first, I accidentally misremembered "Palestinian refugees" as "Palestinians" in the part of this wikipedia entry -

On 11 December 1948, 12 months prior to UNRWA's establishment, United Nations General Assembly Resolution 194 was adopted. The resolution accepted the definition of Palestinian refugees as "persons of Arab origin who, after 29 November 1947, left territory at present under the control of the Israel authorities and who were Palestinian citizens at that date" and; "Persons of Arab origin who left the said territory after 6 August 1924 and before 29 November 1947 and who at that latter date were Palestinian citizens; 2. Persons of Arab origin who left the territory in question before 6 August 1924 and who, having opted for Palestinian citizenship, retained that citizenship up to 29 November 1947"[92]

For the second, well... that's better addressed below.

Just to show you how uninformed your Cognitive Dissonance Assuaging Casuistry (CDAC) is, have a look at REAL history if you are able to withstand the C.D. Agony for a few seconds

The horror! It burns!

More seriously, I'm well aware that that land area has been known as Palestine for a long, long time and, in my tiredness, was sloppy regarding the terms I used in response to JihadJane's attempt to counter the point that I made. At no point did I intend to deny history and I do retract the wording that I used. With that said, by the definition that JihadJane actually was using to try to dispute the point, which is what I was I responding to, there, refugee camps where Palestinians refugees live can be called their homeland just as well. Palestine, as a distinct Arab country that Israel "stole land from" in the course of Israel coming to exist or after it came to be, never actually existed, however close it came to existing. This is a separate matter from a number of the very nasty things that the Jews did to the Arabs and the Arabs tried to do or did do to the Jews during whichever relevant time period.
 
Last edited:
I looked up "Cognitive Dissonance Assuaging Casuistry" on Google and got two hits, both to threads here on JREF.
Love it when people make up terms like this :D . "Disagree with me? You have ACBGSGHRDHJRFD!!! You fail!".
 
I looked up "Cognitive Dissonance Assuaging Casuistry" on Google and got two hits, both to threads here on JREF.
Love it when people make up terms like this :D . "Disagree with me? You have ACBGSGHRDHJRFD!!! You fail!".

I'm reminded of "check your privilege", and wonder why the Palestinians aren't expected to show such introspection.
 
Why do people, especially on the left, single out Israel as a Genghis/Timur/Cortez/Hitler level horror (seriously, even the USA in Abu Ghraib didn't get anywhere near as much scrutiny as the recent Gaza campaign) to the extent they'd believe blatantly fabricated reports of atrocities hook line and sinker.
Because it's trendy. You'll notice stopping Kony was all of a sudden super-important once someone made it a brand of merchandise, and then not that important at all once the fad fizzled out.
 
Because it's trendy. You'll notice stopping Kony was all of a sudden super-important once someone made it a brand of merchandise, and then not that important at all once the fad fizzled out.

I'm not just talking SO EDGY YouTube anarchists. It's a lot of mainstream "boycott genocide" campaigns that make any Israeli campaign to be tamerlane sacking Baghdad and leaving a pyramid of skulls.
 
International law has been a joke since at least the cold war (nobody pays anything more than lip service to it considering how the nations are supposed to enforce it only do so selectively) and just because someone makes a statement doesn't mean they are automatically right due to their authority (otherwise creationism is right because some politician said it was so)
 
This is an eerie thing to watch and observe. The infallibility of a government, a group, whose actions can be stripped and excused by itself and its most attentive followers.
Gives me that same feeling when an alleged gang member's mother comes on the television stating her son was a good boy. Strange isn't it... the mind just clings to that idea and ignores/dismisses everything else. Fully convinces itself.
Crazy world.
 
richardfalk.wordpress.com/2014/07/28/joint-declaration-by-international-law-experts-on-israels-gaza-offensive/"]Joint Declaration by International Law Experts on Israel’s Gaza Offensive[/URL]

Here's some of Falk's greatest hits.

Ayatollah Khomeini in 1979[edit]
In early 1979, when Falk was a professor of International Law at Princeton, he visited Iranian Revolution leader Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini at his home in exile in France.[76] In a February 1979 New York Times op-ed, after Khomeini had returned to Iran, Falk wrote, "The depiction of him as fanatical, reactionary and the bearer of crude prejudices seems certainly and happily false."[37] Falk wrote that Khomeini's "entourage was uniformly composed of moderate, progressive individuals,"[77] and that "having created a new model of popular revolution based, for the most part, on nonviolent tactics, Iran may yet provide us with a desperately-needed model of humane governance for a third-world country."[78] By the end of 1979 Khomeini had become Supreme Leader of Iran and began removing moderates from his circles, arresting and even killing political opponents, and supporting students who took over the U.S. embassy in Tehran, holding American hostages for 444 days. Falk was criticized for having supported Khomeini.[77][79] Falk later changed his opinion of Khomeini's regime, calling it "the most terroristic since Hitler."[77]

...

In 2004, Falk wrote the preface to David Ray Griffin's book The New Pearl Harbor: Disturbing Questions About the Bush Administration and 9/11 which maintains that the George W. Bush administration was complicit in the September 11 attacks.[80] In that preface he argued: "There have been questions raised here and there and allegations of official complicity made almost from the day of the attacks, especially in Europe, but no one until Griffin has had the patience, the fortitude, the courage, and the intelligence to put the pieces together in a single coherent account."[37] Falk also wrote a chapter for Griffin's 2006 book, 9/11 and American Empire: Intellectuals Speak Out.[81]
He also said reprehensible things about the Boston Marathon bombings, and once posted a cartoon right out of Der Sturmer. So, "international law experts," when posted here by JihadJane, means pretty much who you'd expect.
 
This is an eerie thing to watch and observe. The infallibility of a government, a group, whose actions can be stripped and excused by itself and its most attentive followers.
Gives me that same feeling when an alleged gang member's mother comes on the television stating her son was a good boy. Strange isn't it... the mind just clings to that idea and ignores/dismisses everything else. Fully convinces itself.
Crazy world.

No one has said Israel is infallible. Noone.
 
This is an eerie thing to watch and observe. The infallibility of a government, a group, whose actions can be stripped and excused by itself and its most attentive followers.
Gives me that same feeling when an alleged gang member's mother comes on the television stating her son was a good boy. Strange isn't it... the mind just clings to that idea and ignores/dismisses everything else. Fully convinces itself.
Crazy world.

Nice serving of World Salad.
 
International law has been a joke since at least the cold war (nobody pays anything more than lip service to it considering how the nations are supposed to enforce it only do so selectively) and just because someone makes a statement doesn't mean they are automatically right due to their authority (otherwise creationism is right because some politician said it was so)
Now you just sound like Kumar :p .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom