Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Blaze and Global Research...

Any possibility that we can drop a million tons of marijuana in that region, light it up, and get everyone to relax? (History of the World, Part 1?)

Anyways. I'd say if Gazans are not safe in Gaza anymore, it's time for them to make a peaceful march into Israel en mass. Will be a real test to see IDF reaction to that. What would they do? Shoot a million migrants/refugees?
 
Last edited:
I suspect they will go lolnope and lock every entry to Israel. Any attempt at breaking through those defences will be as successful as a Viking raiding party against the walls of Constantinople.
 
I suspect they will go lolnope and lock every entry to Israel. Any attempt at breaking through those defences will be as successful as a Viking raiding party against the walls of Constantinople.

Well they have already locked every entry. But if you have a million people, it will be more like "World War Z" zombies climbing the wall.
 
"Colonialist". Last I checked, Israel wasn't in the business of kidnapping Palestinian women and feeding them to dogs while making a livestream of it or imbibing them with whiskey while spreading Smallpox. Nor were they in the business of enslaving natives and hacking off their hands for not meeting work quotas or forcibly addicting them to opium. There's no colonialism like old school colonialism.

No...this is New School Colonialism. Israel drops bombs on children an then claims that they are victims and the entire world is against them. What? The Zionists think they have a God-given right to kill children without the world getting upset? Well...That's Zionism!

Here's what the world feels about Israel...in one Chart:

http://cdn0.vox-cdn.com/assets/4830948/BBC_Israel_polls_2012-2013-2014.png
 
Last edited:
What it means that you can't stop a million people on the move. You can sure try.

The logistics of it alone will render such a move futile, considering how they will have to crush a lot of their own population to even reach halfway the height of those walls, assuming we entertain such a ludicrous scenario.
 
Last edited:
A Brigade is not a culture. Doh!
True. That's why I linked several sources that illustrate the martydom culture in Palestine, not just the one quote from the Al-Qassam Brigade. In your future trolling efforts, you might pretend to read all of the links provided.
 
What it means that you can't stop a million people on the move. You can sure try.

Well, technically you can:

Bundesarchiv_Bild_183-E0406-0022-001,_Russland,_Kesselschlacht_Stalingrad.jpg


But it's got a helluva price tag to do so.
 
The logistics of it alone will render such a move futile, considering how they will have to crush a lot of their own population to even reach halfway the height of those walls, assuming we entertain such a ludicrous scenario.

They can bring stuff to build up a ramp on the wall. Plenty of rubble around Gaza these days.

A simple wall is not going to deter a million folks.
 
They can bring stuff to build up a ramp on the wall. Plenty of rubble around Gaza these days.

A simple wall is not going to deter a million folks.

And you think the Israelis are going to let that happen? Humanity has moved on in terms of Siege Warfare since Laichish (and the wall around Gaza makes Constantinople's -as in we slapped off every siege attempt for over 800 years- look like a garden fence). Besides, what remotely rational objectives could be completed by some folly that requires an extreme disconnect with reality to even contemplate and resources that aren't even there?
 
And you think the Israelis are going to let that happen? Humanity has moved on in terms of Siege Warfare since Laichish (and the wall around Gaza makes Constantinople's -as in we slapped off every siege attempt for over 800 years- look like a garden fence). Besides, what remotely rational objectives could be completed by some folly that requires an extreme disconnect with reality to even contemplate and resources that aren't even there?

How would they stop it? Mass murder? No world would allow the mass slaughtering of a million refugees.
 
How would they stop it? Mass murder? No world would allow the mass slaughtering of a million refugees.

Unless Alien Space Bats brainwash every Gazan into this project, it doesn't stand a hope in hell and even then...

Here's what's more likely to happen. The IDF pays certain Gazans to sabotage the ramp every so often (whether by planting explosives or digging it in ways to cause it to collapse or delay construction) or resorts to sapping or numerous counter-siege tactics that have been tried and tested throughout the millennia. And they have a lot more resources to boot. Eventually, the Gazans are going to give up due to the numerous failed attempts.
 
Unless Alien Space Bats brainwash every Gazan into this project, it doesn't stand a hope in hell and even then...

Here's what's more likely to happen. The IDF pays certain Gazans to sabotage the ramp every so often (whether by planting explosives or digging it in ways to cause it to collapse or delay construction) or resorts to sapping or numerous counter-siege tactics that have been tried and tested throughout the millennia. And they have a lot more resources to boot. Eventually, the Gazans are going to give up due to the numerous failed attempts.

Only thing absurd is your "plans" on how IDF could possibly deter it without massive use of violence.
 
I must drop by to add that I'm really starting more and more to wince every time I hear the latest target that is hit - the power station? And there's only so many times a hamas rocket is going to misfire and hit these sorts of targets.

Either Hamas realises it is done and is going last ditch on the propaganda front to the extent of outright targeting of its own civilians, or the IDF really is getting a bit 'what the hell they are going to accuse of hitting civilians deliberately anyway why make so much effort'

sadly a little bit of both seems fairly plausible at this point
 
Only thing absurd is your "plans" on how IDF could possibly deter it without massive use of violence.

Anyone with an inkling of how siege warfare works knows that your plan relies on Gazans suddenly developing a hivemind, working out how to make that ramp, getting the resources to make it, actual construction, not suffer setbacks by things like weather or temperature, supply the workers on that ramp and protect them from attack, not have members susceptible to betray the plan and not give up regardless of the risks or the costs (willpower can only go so far, and this "plan" would bankrupt gaza 5x over before it reached the 20% mark, and for what?).
 
Last edited:
Anyone with an inkling of how siege warfare works knows that your plan relies on Gazans suddenly developing a hivemind, working out how to make that ramp, getting the resources to make it, actual construction, not suffer setbacks by things like weather or temperature, supply the workers on that ramp and protect them from attack, not have members susceptible to betray the plan and not give up regardless of the risks or the costs (willpower can only go so far, and this "plan" would bankrupt gaza 5x over before it reached the 20% mark, and for what?).

LOL. It's not like they are building an 8-lane highway system here.

The walls are designed to deter small groups of armed people from crossing the border. If you get a lot of people to go to the wall and breach it (and that's all they need to know to do), they'll figure out the rest of the logistics.
 
"breaching the wall" requires resources (hardware, time, patience, viable manpower) that they don't have and Israel doesn't need to kill anybody, just damage their drills and heavy duty demolition equipment (Seriously, they make the walls of Constantinople look tame by comparison in terms of how sturdy they are and by extension the gate is nothing to laugh at) and hamper work efforts. Eventually, the Palestinians will just give up when such a ludicrously insane objective becomes more and more futile.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom