Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I will leave you with your impervious barrier. Please do spend your free time attempting to secure tactics keep it from getting preached.
 

Attachments

  • GazaBarrier.jpg
    GazaBarrier.jpg
    71.8 KB · Views: 9
UAVs tracking movements allowing the IDF to pinpoint attempted breaches and neutralise such equipment. It's also telling that there have been no attempts to breach the wall.
 
Been away for a while, and not too eager to play catch-up right now, so I suppose I'll just hop on here and try to rejoin the discussion.
 
"breaching the wall" requires resources (hardware, time, patience, viable manpower) that they don't have and Israel doesn't need to kill anybody, just damage their drills and heavy duty demolition equipment (Seriously, they make the walls of Constantinople look tame by comparison in terms of how sturdy they are and by extension the gate is nothing to laugh at) and hamper work efforts. Eventually, the Palestinians will just give up when such a ludicrously insane objective becomes more and more futile.
This actually made me picture HAMAS terrorists with a trebuchet:D.

More seriously, though, the HAMAS workaround is simple digging. They have taken the concrete that was meant to be used for reconstruction, civilian blast shelters, etc. and built sturdy bunkers and tunnels into Israeli territory for their operatives. I've been told (on the IDF Facebook page, I believe it was) that HAMAS was planning to send thousands of terrorists through the tunnels to attack Israeli targets. If true, thank heavens it was foiled. Sounds like just the kind of "Day Z" scenario I see up to several of the usual suspects here dreaming about.
 
Open letter from doctors and scientists on what Israel is doing to Gaza
The Lancet 30 July 2014:

Israel's behaviour has insulted our humanity, intelligence, and dignity as well as our professionalethics and efforts. Even those of us who want to go and help are unable to reach Gaza due to the blockade.



Something I see is utterly and totally evading many people posting the Casuistic Dissonance Assuaging Casuistry (CDAC) in this thread.

Of course they will tell you that the doctors and scientists who wrote that letter are bleeding-heart liberals or something as equally devoid of the stuff that is highlighted above.

It is a lot easier to demonize and dehumanize people than to face the REAL REALITY of having been totally and utterly bamboozled and hoodwinked for one’s entire life along with one's entire culture and country for generations. It is a lot easier to DENY REALITY than to face one’s own Cognitive Dissonance Agonies and to wake up from the Wishful Thinking Stupors.
 
Don't worry, they were all human shields. Hamas is evil and, anyway, they started it. They wanted to die telegenically because they have a martyrdom culture and it's good for demonizing Israel.

UN: 'world stands disgraced' as shelter for Gaza children is shelled by Israel


Pierre Krahenbuhl, commissioner-general of the UN agency for Palestinian refugees, UNRWA, condemned “in in the strongest possible terms this serious violation of international law by Israeli forces”.

He said in a statement: “Last night, children were killed as they slept next to their parents on the floor of a classroom in a UN-designated shelter in Gaza. Children killed in their sleep; this is an affront to all of us, a source of universal shame. Today the world stands disgraced.

“We have visited the site and gathered evidence. We have analysed fragments, examined craters and other damage. Our initial assessment is that it was Israeli artillery that hit our school, in which 3,300 people had sought refuge. We believe there were at least three impacts.

“It is too early to give a confirmed official death toll. But we know that there were multiple civilian deaths and injuries including of women and children and the UNRWA guard who was trying to protect the site. These are people who were instructed to leave their homes by the Israeli army.”

It was the sixth time that UNRWA schools had been struck, he added. “Our staff, the very people leading the humanitarian response are being killed. Our shelters are overflowing. Tens of thousands may soon be stranded in the streets of Gaza, without food, water and shelter if attacks on these areas continue.”



UN Official Chris Gunness Breaks Down On Air After School Bombing


Don't worry, Chris. It was Hamas' fault.

 
Last edited:
Something I see is utterly and totally evading many people posting the Casuistic Dissonance Assuaging Casuistry (CDAC) in this thread.

Of course they will tell you that the doctors and scientists who wrote that letter are bleeding-heart liberals or something as equally devoid of the stuff that is highlighted above.

It is a lot easier to demonize and dehumanize people than to face the REAL REALITY of having been totally and utterly bamboozled and hoodwinked for one’s entire life along with one's entire culture and country for generations. It is a lot easier to DENY REALITY than to face one’s own Cognitive Dissonance Agonies and to wake up from the Wishful Thinking Stupors.

That's very insightful and very well put. Are you referring to the authors of the open letter in The Lancet?
 
You mistakenly and ignorantly equated Gaza with the Palestinian homeland,

A Palestinian homeland which didn't exist in the first place? Either way, I did no such thing. I did, in fact, respond to your claims of the Palestinians wanting to end the "destruction of their homeland" with regards to what seemed like the only viable choice for what "destruction" you could be talking about, though.

ignoring the fact that Palestinians have been forced to live densely packed into such a small area like sardines because of Israel's colonialist aggression and ethnic cleansing campaigns.

Hardly the whole story and a change of subject.

Entire neighborhoods have been flattened in the current hyperviolent assault.

I'm pretty sure that your sensitivities would be truly overwhelmed by the "hyperviolence" that Israel could very, very easily be doing instead of what they've largely been doing.

Entire civilian neighborhoods do not constitute "military targets".

Maybe, maybe not. When military targets are being hidden in civilian areas, however, things become much, much more grey. Keep the military targets out of the civilian neighborhoods and, amazingly, that greyness disappears.

They are being cleared to create a "buffer zone", stealing yet more living space from Palestinian people.

Maybe, maybe not.

No one is forcing Israel to kill civilians. They are choosing to do so.

No one forced Hamas to fire rockets and openly endorse killing Israeli civilians, knowing that it would definitely provoke a response, either.


That's a lot of wandering words saying nothing of any substance.

Forgive me if I don't consider your opinion on such matters to have much weight. After actually looking at the link, it looks like you and your link greatly exaggerate the number of valid claims.


Cynically orchestrated lies and propaganda, much of which is regurgitated as truth on these very pages.

An opinion which isn't supported by your links. Nor particularly well by "these very pages." Accurate criticism will tend to get you much further than inaccurate criticism with a bunch of emotional appeals and unsubstantiated claims.


The occupation started in 1948 and has never stopped. The recent "outbreak of hostilities" was orchestrated by a deliberate campaign of lies cynically exploiting the murder of three young Israeli from an illegal settlement (i.e. stolen land).

Ignoring the rest, I'm pretty sure that this has been addressed in this thread, regardless, with the consensus being fairly strongly against Israel's overall course of actions with regards to Operation Brother's Keeper. Yet, the consensus also seems to be that that does not excuse Hamas launching rockets at civilian areas with no military targets. Had they been launching their rockets at military targets, especially relevant ones, they'd have more to stand upon.


Israel's occupation and blockade is illegal under international law. There is no reason why Hamas should accept it.

Which, again, is trying to change the subject away from the points made. The "myth," itself, was remarkably dumb on even casual inspection and trying to debunk it with the point that Hama would accept a ceasefire if it got everything it demands is, frankly, both pointing out the obvious and portraying Hamas as extortionists.


It's not a "low casualty count".

Compared to what it could be, just given the weapons used so far, it's incredibly low. Compared to ISIS and the way things have been going on in Syria, both of which have received far less condemnation at last check, it's incredibly low. Compared to the actual population in Gaza, it's really low. It is much, much higher than is desirable, certainly, but even one civilian death is higher than desirable.

Rest assured that it wouldn't be considered low if the casualties were Israelis, many murdered in their own homes - innocent men, women and children.

Were all relevant conditions reversed, in particular, the military targets in civilians areas one? I, at least, would be rather unlikely to be much different.

Journalists in Gaza have found no evidence that Hamas has asked civilians to put themselves in the line of fire.

Journalists who, at last check, were easily within reach of Hamas' frequently violent displeasure? Either way, is this video being translated quite incorrectly, as just one example?

Entire neighborhoods have been flattened by Israel's so'called "precision bombing".

A point which is well worth remembering.



Seriously?


There is no "culture of martyrdom" amongst the innocent civilians who have been slaughtered. They all wanted to live as much as you and I do.

Of course there isn't.

The use of "human shields" depends on the unwillingness of the aggressor to kill non-combatants.

No, it doesn't. For it to be a successful tactic, sure. If it's allowed to be a successful tactic, it will simply be used more often in the future, though, which again, leaves things in a grey area regarding those who seek to discourage its use.

There is evidence from the past of Palestinians being used as humans shields by Israeli soldiers, however.

Feel free to present it. I'm not likely to be surprised either way, though.

Open letter from doctors and scientists on what Israel is doing to Gaza
The Lancet 30 July 2014:

As I noted before, I do quite think that Israel should make amends for any and all war crimes that they commit. Of course, I'd prefer if the war crimes didn't happen in the first place, certainly, but that ship sailed a while ago, likely.
 
Last edited:
"Colonialist". Last I checked, Israel wasn't in the business of kidnapping Palestinian women and feeding them to dogs while making a livestream of it or imbibing them with whiskey while spreading Smallpox. Nor were they in the business of enslaving natives and hacking off their hands for not meeting work quotas or forcibly addicting them to opium. There's no colonialism like old school colonialism.

"Ethnic Cleansing". I don't see any accordion players magically removing kebab from the premises. In fact, he is probably disappointed about how slow Israel is going with their casualty rates.
I see a lot of this from pro-Palestine posters for some reason. "Holocaust", "ethnic cleansing", and other words that mean something completely different from what people want them to. This, coupled with strange arguments I don't see in any other debate (for example, excusing HAMAS' atrocities by saying they're a democratically elected parties:confused:), adds up to a very strange debate environment.
 
For me, when someone says the words "Apartheid", "Genocide" or "Ethnic Cleansing" when discussing Israel is de facto admitting they know nothing, the same way screaming "sunspots" when discussing climate change is admitting ignorance.
 
I see a lot of this from pro-Palestine posters for some reason. "Holocaust", "ethnic cleansing", and other words that mean something completely different from what people want them to. This, coupled with strange arguments I don't see in any other debate (for example, excusing HAMAS' atrocities by saying they're a democratically elected parties:confused:), adds up to a very strange debate environment.

Yeah, it's odd.

I mean, a vicious expansionist party wings an election. Refuses to hold further elections or step down. Blames the Jews for their misfortunes. Has territorial designs on their neighbors who they then attack. And we are supposed to let it slide because Hitler, sorry, because Hamas won an election that time?

Respecting democracy does not mean that you have to respect someone invading Poland.
 
And the precedents were set (ironically enough) in Britain's blockade of Germany during WW1 (as long as you can enforce it AFAIK)
 
Don't worry, they were all human shields. Hamas is evil and, anyway, they started it. They wanted to die telegenically because they have a martyrdom culture and it's good for demonizing Israel.
That's very insightful and very well put. Are you referring to the authors of the open letter in The Lancet?


Yes I was referring to the Lancet letter.


We are doctors and scientists, who spend our lives developing means to care and protect health and lives. We are also informed people; we teach the ethics of our professions, together with the knowledge and practice of it. We all have worked in and known the situation of Gaza for years.
On the basis of our ethics and practice, we are denouncing what we witness in the aggression of Gaza by Israel.

We ask our colleagues, old and young professionals, to denounce this Israeli aggression. We challenge the perversity of a propaganda that justifies the creation of an emergency to masquerade a massacre, a so-called “defensive aggression”. In reality it is a ruthless assault of unlimited duration, extent, and intensity. We wish to report the facts as we see them and their implications on the lives of the people.
We are appalled by the military onslaught on civilians in Gaza under the guise of punishing terrorists. This is the third large scale military assault on Gaza since 2008. Each time the death toll is borne mainly by innocent people in Gaza, especially women and children under the unacceptable pretext of Israel eradicating political parties and resistance to the occupation and siege they impose.

This action also terrifies those who are not directly hit, and wounds the soul, mind, and resilience of the young generation. Our condemnation and disgust are further compounded by the denial and prohibition for Gaza to receive external help and supplies to alleviate the dire circumstances.
[snip]

We denounce the myth propagated by Israel that the aggression is done caring about saving civilian lives and children's wellbeing.

Israel's behaviour has insulted our humanity, intelligence, and dignity as well as our professional ethics and efforts. Even those of us who want to go and help are unable to reach Gaza due to the blockade.
[snip]

We register with dismay that only 5% of our Israeli academic colleagues signed an appeal to their government to stop the military operation against Gaza. We are tempted to conclude that with the exception of this 5%, the rest of the Israeli academics are complicit in the massacre and destruction of Gaza. We also see the complicity of our countries in Europe and North America in this massacre and the impotence once again of the international institutions and organisations to stop this massacre.



I was also trying to highlight the more general situation of Christians who rally to the defense of Israel unquestioningly and unconditionally as demonstrated in this article and many posts here.

Jesus in Matthew 15:21-28 (see verses below) humiliated and insulted a poor woman and told her that she is not even fit to receive his "salvation" because he was sent only for the salvation of the Lost Sheep of Israel.

He told the woman that as a dog she is not worthy of salvation because it is not right to throw the meat to the dogs when the children are hungry.

Only after the woman groveled sufficiently and accepted becoming Israel's DOG which therefore can lick and slurp up some of the crumbs that fall off of the tables of the MASTERS, did Jesus deign to talk to her and help her.

This is why I think most Christians in America are panting and barking to prove to the MASTERS that they are real good GUARD DOGS for Israel..... I guess if Jesus said it, it must be true..... and to hell with humanity, intelligence, dignity and ethics.... these are pointless of course in comparison to salvation even at the price of being reduced to the status of dogs.

That is why they viciously and relentlessly maul (and will continue to do so) anyone who tries to point out to them the war crimes and human rights abuses of Israel.

They do not want to admit the hard realities of life because otherwise their wishful thinking will be exposed for the delusion it is and their Cognitive Dissonance Agonies will become excruciatingly unbearable when they realize that their whole life and culture and country has been hoodwinked and bamboozled for generations.

That is why their Cognitive Dissonance Assuaging Casuistry (CDAC) does not limit itself to just barking, rather it becomes deadly political, economic and military rallying to gnash apart anyone and anything that threatens to lift the pall off their benighted eyes and brains, because they believe wholeheartedly that if they do anything less they will be instead gnashing their teeth in a burning lake of sulfur and brimstone.

Matthew 15:21-28

15:21 Then Jesus went thence, and departed into the coasts of Tyre and Sidon.
15:22 And, behold, a woman of Canaan came out of the same coasts, and cried unto him, saying, Have mercy on me, O Lord, thou son of David; my daughter is grievously vexed with a devil.
15:23 But he answered her not a word. And his disciples came and besought him, saying, Send her away; for she crieth after us.
15:24 But he answered and said, I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of Israel.15:25 Then came she and worshipped him, saying, Lord, help me.
15:26 But he answered and said, It is not meet to take the children's bread, and to cast it to dogs.
15:27 And she said, Truth, Lord: yet the dogs eat of the crumbs which fall from their masters' table.15:28 Then Jesus answered and said unto her, O woman, great is thy faith: be it unto thee even as thou wilt. And her daughter was made whole from that very hour.


By the way... compare how Jesus obeyed with subservient obeisance and truckling servility his Roman Superiors in Matthew 8:5-11 when he ran on the double to the Centurion's house upon his command to heal his slave. The centurion had to educate Jesus on how gods can heal at a distance without having to scamper and dogtrot to their superiors' houses to subserviently heal their slaves with nary a hint or admonition on how slavery is bad and that maybe as a condition the centurion should give up being a blood drenched centurion and free his slaves. Not a single whimper from Jesus on how he cannot heal the centurion's slave because he does not deserve any bread. He did not dare call him a dog for not being Jewish.
 
Last edited:
Where do you think they lived, then?

What do you think the requirements for being dubbed a "Palestinian" were? That answers that question quite well enough. Either way, as a political entity, there was no such land or nation and there have been numerous governing authorities of the area.
 
What do you think the requirements for being dubbed a "Palestinian" were? That answers that question quite well enough. Either way, as a political entity, there was no such land or nation and there have been numerous governing authorities of the area.


You know something, ignorance of history is one thing but deliberately falsifying history is a MORAL CRIME because it falsifies human heritage and denies humans the true reality of their past and thus the TRUTH about things from which they can verify TRUTHFUL REALITY.

Just to show you how uninformed your Cognitive Dissonance Assuaging Casuistry (CDAC) is, have a look at REAL history if you are able to withstand the C.D. Agony for a few seconds

Have a look at the Balfour Declaration
His Majesty's government view with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people, and will use their best endeavours to facilitate the achievement of this object, it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine, or the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country.[1]​

Palestine is mentioned in more historical documents B.C.E. than the word Israel. Even Jewish scholars called it Palestine in their writings that were not related to religious writing.
The first clear use of the term Palestine to refer to the entire area between Phoenicia and Egypt was in 5th century BC Ancient Greece.[8] Herodotus wrote of a 'district of Syria, called Palaistinê in The Histories, the first historical work clearly defining the region, which included the Judaean Mountains and the Jordan Rift Valley.[9][10][11][12] and formed part of the 5th Persian satrapy (νομός).[13] Approximately a century later, Aristotle used a similar definition in Meteorology, writing "Again if, as is fabled, there is a lake (λίμνη) in Palestine, such that if you bind a man or beast and throw it in it floats and does not sink, this would bear out what we have said. They say that this lake is so bitter and salt that no fish live in it and that if you soak clothes in it and shake them it cleans them," understood by scholars to be a reference to the Dead Sea.[14] Later writers such as Polemon, and Pausanias also used the term to refer to the same region. This usage was followed by Roman writers such as Ovid, Tibullus, Pomponius Mela, Pliny the Elder,[15] Statius, as well as Roman-era Greek writers such as Plutarch, Dio Chrysostom and Roman-era Judean writers such as Philo of Alexandria[16] and Josephus.[17] Other writers, such as Strabo, a prominent Roman-era Greek geographer, referred to the region as Coele-Syria around 10–20 CE,[18][19] and the Gospel of Matthew's description of the Flight into Egypt refers to the region as "the land of Israel" [εἰς γῆν Ἰσραήλ], the only time in the New Testament such a reference is made.[20] The term was first used to denote an official province of the Roman Empire in c. 135 CE, when the Roman authorities, following the suppression of the Bar Kokhba revolt, combined Iudaea Province with Galilee and other surrounding cities such as Ashkelon to form Syria Palaestina. There is circumstantial evidence linking Hadrian with the name change,[21] although the precise date is not certain,[21] and the interpretation of some scholars that the name change may have been intended "to complete the dissociation with Judaea"[22][23] is disputed.[24]​

Even the Bible also calls it Palestina 3 times and Philistia 3 times and the land of the Philistines 293 times
Exodus 15:14
The people shall hear, and be afraid: sorrow shall take hold on the inhabitants of Palestina.​
Isaiah
14:29 Rejoice not thou, whole Palestina, because the rod of him that smote thee is broken: for out of the serpent’s root shall come forth a cockatrice, and his fruit shall be a fiery flying serpent.

14:31 Howl, O gate; cry, O city; thou, whole Palestina, art dissolved: for there shall come from the north a smoke, and none shall be alone in his appointed times.​

Psalms
60:8 Moab is my washpot; over Edom will I cast out my shoe: Philistia, triumph thou because of me.
87:4 I will make mention of Rahab and Babylon to them that know me: behold Philistia, and Tyre, with Ethiopia; this man was born there.
108:9 Moab [is] my washpot; over Edom will I cast out my shoe; over
Philistia will I triumph.
​

Genesis
21:32 Thus they made a covenant at Beersheba: then Abimelech rose up, and Phichol the chief captain of his host, and they returned into the land of the Philistines.
21:34 And Abraham sojourned in the Philistines' land many days.
​


Have a look at this Palestinian Coin and Palestinian PASSPORT from during the British Mandate over Palestine.




 
Last edited:
Why do people, especially on the left, single out Israel as a Genghis/Timur/Cortez/Hitler level horror (seriously, even the USA in Abu Ghraib didn't get anywhere near as much scrutiny as the recent Gaza campaign) to the extent they'd believe blatantly fabricated reports of atrocities hook line and sinker.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom