Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't think anyone here supports everything the IDF or Israel does, I know for sure I don't. The stereotypical Israel cheerleader who handwaves every bad thing Israel does because it's Israel is a myth.
 
That made no sense but I'll let it pass since it must be some english language play on words I didn't get. On the bright side, you got 1 point to your post count.

When you don't understand a phrase, e.g., "word salad," you can highlight it and "right click" which will search for the phrase on google or another search engine. I find this tool very handy.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Word_salad
 
International law 'is a joke' because there is no independent force to carry out that law. If the US breaks what is considered an international law which force will instill the law? It is not the laws itself but the means by which it is carried out. There is no point to having laws that can't be instilled equally with no exception.
 
Scroll back and recheck his words and my response, slowly.

I read both. I made no comment on the content of either post. You appeared unfamiliar with the phrase "word salad," seemingly indicating that English was not your first language. I told you about an easy way to check such a phrase. You are welcome.
 
I read both. I made no comment on the content of either post. You appeared unfamiliar with the phrase "word salad," seemingly indicating that English was not your first language. I told you about an easy way to check such a phrase. You are welcome.

If you read both, you'd notice that 'word salad' wasn't stated and maybe caught on the rebuttal. That's why I suggested you scrolled back and check it slowly.

...seeing that you wanted a thanks or something, sure thing. We can go back on topic.
 
So there is internal stuggle in Israel on the mission. Do they just keep targeting the tunnels, or are they going to try to take out Hamas leadership? Currently the former is still the mission, but it might escalate to the latter, which would mean even worse number of civilian casualties.
 
Don't be fooled. "The most moral army in the world" has been wiping out entire neighborhoods. The tunnels thing is just cynical PR.


2638953daad05b675b.jpg
 
A Big pile of smoke =/= entire neighbourhoods being wiped out. I'm pretty sure Tamerlane, the Conquistadors and numerous other conquerors would call Israel Amateurs in terms of wiping out an enemy.
 
An illegal occupation:

Debunking Israel's 'self-defense' argument

Israel claims that it is acting in self-defense in Gaza, thereby portraying itself as the victim in the present conflict. ... But is it an accurate assessment?

Gaza is not an independent state like Lebanon or Jordan. Israel accepts this but instead sees Gaza as a “hostile entity,” a concept unknown to international law and one that Israel has not sought to explain.

But the status of Gaza is clear. It is an occupied territory — part of the occupied Palestinian territory. In 2005 Israel withdrew its settlers and the Israel Defense Forces from Gaza, but it continues to retain control of it, not only through intermittent incursions into and regular shelling of the territory but also by effectively controlling the land crossings into Gaza, its airspace and territorial waters and its population registry, which determines who may leave and enter.

Effective control is the test for occupation. The International Court of Justice recently confirmed this in a dispute between the Democratic Republic of the Congo and Uganda. The physical presence of Israel in Gaza is not necessary provided it retains effective control and authority over the territory by other means. Modern technology now permits effective control from outside the occupied territory, and this is what Israel has established.

That Gaza remains occupied is accepted by the United Nations and all states except, possibly, Israel.

An illegal occupation

Military or belligerent occupation is a status recognized by international law. According to the terms of the Fourth Geneva Convention of 1949 — to which Israel is a party — a state is allowed to occupy a territory acquired in armed conflict pending a peace settlement. But the occupation must be temporary, and the occupying power is obliged to balance its security needs with the welfare of the occupied people. Collective punishment is strictly prohibited.

The occupation of Gaza is now in its 47th year, and Israel is largely responsible for the failure to reach an agreement on a peaceful settlement. Moreover, Israel is in breach of many of the humanitarian provisions contained in the Fourth Geneva Convention as a result of the siege it has imposed on Gaza since 2007. In short, Gaza is not only an occupied territory; it is also an illegally occupied territory.

by John Dugard - Emeritus professor of international law at the University of Leiden in the Netherlands and former U.N. special rapporteur on human rights in the occupied Palestinian territory.
 
Last edited:
72 hour truce. Ground troops stay in place.
IMHO the only reason both sides agreed to this is they were both running low at ammo and need to resupply.......
 
I'd say Israel is going to have quite a bit to answer for after this fight is over and done with.

That doesn't change the fact that Israel's cause is the defense of its civilians.
 
I looked up "Cognitive Dissonance Assuaging Casuistry" on Google and got two hits, both to threads here on JREF.
Love it when people make up terms like this :D . "Disagree with me? You have ACBGSGHRDHJRFD!!! You fail!".


"Woe is me", your "Daniel come to judgement" performance is a "countenance more in sorrow than in anger". Your ignorance of the "Queen's English" "beggars all description".

I'd hate to be the one to bedew your beetling ardor but someone ought to before you turn asphyctic. I suggest that you might be a little addled. There's "a method in my madness" which you might have fathomed had you been a little more erudite.

I'll try to explain for the sake of your pedagogy, so "once more unto the breach, dear friends, once more":

If you have noticed in my above farcical introduction, I have stitched together a few phrases that have been made up by Shakespeare (I hope you know who that is... all the quoted italicized phrases are his).

I have not coined the phrase "Cognitive Dissonance Assuaging Casuistry" (CDAC) just right out of the luminiferous ether.

Using English words one can make up catchy phrases.

Usually the individual meaning of the words combined composes the overall meaning of the phrase.

Sometimes, as in the case of Shakespeare, the phrase acquires a synergy where the meaning conveyed is more than just the sum of the meanings of the individual words.

While I am no Shakespeare, I nevertheless am utilizing something called Neologism about which it might behoove you to educate yourself.


My term “Cognitive Dissonance Assuaging Casuistry” (CDAC) is an apothegmatic Neologism.

Had you had the acumen to actually look up each word in a dictionary (instead of just looking up the entire phrase on the internet) you would have perhaps managed to comprehend the meaning of the term.

Furthermore, in the medical field it is a very common practice to make up medical terms/words/phrases (see here http://www.staff.fcps.net/pburke/Med term/Medical Terminology Word Building.pdf) to describe a medical or clinical condition especially in the field of Psychology.

As much as I'd love to lay claim to the term "Cognitive Dissonance" I cannot. Had you been a little more assiduous in search engines usage you may have actually found that out and not have gone on a "wild goose chase".

However, I did add the words "assuage" and "casuistry" which are "Queen's English" that you could have looked up in any dictionary.​

Accordingly, this is "the short and the long of it":
Cognitive Dissonance Assuaging Casuistry (CDAC) means the use of tortured illogic and mental gymnastics to malign and dismiss the sources and bearers of information as well as the information itself that belies one’s long cherished ideals and ideologies so as to alleviate the mental shock of realizing that one has been bamboozled and hoodwinked. It is also a medical condition that implies that one hates to change one’s mind and would rather “keep one’s head in the sand” and refuse to “open one’s eyes” to reality and facts and science and humanity and dignity and ethics.​

In other words as Mark Twain said
"It is easier to fool people than to convince them that they have been fooled" - Mark Twain​
And most people manage to “add insult to injury” by actually fooling themselves to boot.

I am sure, of course, that all this sounds like
ACBGSGHRDHJRFD!!!

To you, but that however is your shortcoming not mine and I only can say to you
You fail!".
 
I'd say Israel is going to have quite a bit to answer for after this fight is over and done with.

That doesn't change the fact that Israel's cause is the defense of its civilians.

Yeah, it really is looking pretty bad. I know the goal is the destruction of the tunnels, which certainly seems like a legitimate objective, but still... It's heavy-handed.

I suppose the reason for the heavy-handedness is minimizing the risk of Israeli casualties, yet the cost is pretty high.
 
"Cdac" is the sort of.ad hominem no planers, illuminati nuts and moon hoaxers would say, up there with "you r sources are lies , only conspiracy sites tell the truth".



So let's see there who is doing the denying of official sources

... to the extent they'd believe blatantly fabricated reports of atrocities hook line and sinker.


Plus who is using ad hominems

.... no planers, illuminati nuts and moon hoaxers would say, up there with ....

Why do people, especially on the left, .....


So, I guess by your own critrion you are

....no planers, illuminati nuts and moon hoaxers ....


CDAC much???
 
Yeah, it really is looking pretty bad. I know the goal is the destruction of the tunnels, which certainly seems like a legitimate objective, but still... It's heavy-handed.

I suppose the reason for the heavy-handedness is minimizing the risk of Israeli casualties, yet the cost is pretty high.



Ok, I might not be a military expert or anything like that. But I do know that if the tunnel constitutes any danger to Israel then it must have an exit somewhere in Israel and that is in fact what they are claiming.

If the aim is destroying the tunnels and also minimizing Israeli casualties wouldn't it have been a lot more prudent to mount a load of explosives on some robotic device like they use in Oil Pipes or in Metro undergrounds etc. and then drive it into the tunnel utilizing the exit on the Israeli side and then detonate it?

No???

I do know that Israel is one of the most advanced countries in technology. I do know that robotics and drones are utilized in the air and on the ground and under the sea.

Another fact that I do know is that there are numerous civil engineers in Israel that would be able to tell the army that bombing the surface of a neighborhood might collapse the tunnels and it might not depending on the tunnel structure and the ordinances' power.

If the aim is destroying the tunnels then the least effective and most inhumane way by any engineering and logical measures would be to level the buildings and infrastructure above the tunnels.

It is extremely more effective, and less injurious to all concerned to just locate the tunnel exits into Israel and then send drones to destroy the structure.


No???

If the aim is to minimize casualties on the Israeli side without any humane concern for the Palestinian civilians and infrastructure then the best way would have been to not even send one tank, but rather to bomb from the air and deploy surface to surface missiles and rockets.

If the aim is to destroy the tunnels then bombing the surface and buildings is the LEAST effective way and in fact may not even guarantee the destructions of the tunnels.

No???

If one is to argue that the tunnels may not have an exit into Israel and thus they would be hard to locate, then might I point out that we nowadays have satellites that can locate underground rivers and so forth. Why couldn't Israel utilize these satellites to locate the tunnels and then tunnel under to intercept the tunnels and proceed as described above?

However, the claim is that these tunnels do have exits in Israel and have been utilized to kidnap children etc. So which is the truth? Even if some do have exists and the majority do not then the above will still be valid.

I am smelling a fishy tale here somewhere!!!
 
Last edited:
I'd say Israel is going to have quite a bit to answer for after this fight is over and done with.

That doesn't change the fact that Israel's cause is the defense of its civilians.


So what, the USA will just use its veto power and nothing will happen, just like the umpteen times before where Israel or the USA broke international law with no consequences other than hot air from IMPOTENT ants called the rest of the world.

MIGHT IS RIGHT and people who open their mouths in protest will have something shoved in them real tight.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom