Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Don't be fooled. "The most moral army in the world" has been wiping out entire neighborhoods.

I'm mildly curious about who here claims that Israel's army is "the most moral army in the world?"

72 hour truce. Ground troops stay in place.
IMHO the only reason both sides agreed to this is they were both running low at ammo and need to resupply.......

I... rather doubt that Israeli forces are low on ammo. I wouldn't be all that surprised if the Palestinians were, though.
 
While this may be true, the truth of what actually happened here was nothing even remotely as nefarious as you're trying to claim. I was quite tired when I typed that and made a couple fairly simple mistakes regarding terms, of two types. For the first, I accidentally misremembered "Palestinian refugees" as "Palestinians" in the part of this wikipedia entry -



For the second, well... that's better addressed below.



The horror! It burns!

More seriously, I'm well aware that that land area has been known as Palestine for a long, long time and, in my tiredness, was sloppy regarding the terms I used in response to JihadJane's attempt to counter the point that I made. At no point did I intend to deny history and I do retract the wording that I used. With that said, by the definition that JihadJane actually was using to try to dispute the point, which is what I was I responding to, there, refugee camps where Palestinians refugees live can be called their homeland just as well. Palestine, as a distinct Arab country that Israel "stole land from" in the course of Israel coming to exist or after it came to be, never actually existed, however close it came to existing. This is a separate matter from a number of the very nasty things that the Jews did to the Arabs and the Arabs tried to do or did do to the Jews during whichever relevant time period.

:th:

In regards to the highlighted bit... When the UN partitioned Palestine in1947 to create Israel they also took it that Palestine was to be what remains of Palestine after some of it is carved away to create Israel.... that was why it was called a PARTITION plan. The Israelis carried out ethnic cleansing raids during the clashes that ensued with the objecting Palestinian populations in the bits allotted to Israel and when the war with Arab countries in1948 finished, Israel ended up with more land from Palestine than allotted by the UN. Egypt took over Gaza and Jordan took over the West Bank and no one ever bothered to REestablish Palestine as was intended all along.

In 1967 Israel took the rest along with the Golan and Sinai after the 6 days war.

Other than giving back Sinai after the 1973 war the rest of Palestine remains occupied by Israel, even though they now only talk about Gaza and some of the WB being even considered if ever as a Palestine.....however the 1947 partition provided for a much larger land area than the bits left over now and Palestine which preceded Israel as a state, albeit under the mandate of Britain, was to REMAIN still as Palestine albeit with lesser territory, after the establishment of Israel.

Have a look at the maps sequence in this page.


I personally think that a two state solution is impossible now....watch this video

 
Last edited:
In regards to the highlighted bit... When the UN partitioned Palestine in1947 to create Israel they also took it that Palestine was to be what remains. The Israelis carried out ethnic cleansing raids during the clashes that ensued and when the war with Arab countries in1948 ended Israel ended up with more land from Palestine than alloted by the UN and Egypt took over Gaza and Jordan took over the West Bank and no one ever bothered to establish Palestine as was intended all along.

I'm aware. Hence the "however close it came to existing" right after what you highlighted.

Other than giving back Sinai after the 1973 war the rest of Palestine remains occupied by Israel, even though they now only talk about Gaza and some of the WB being even considered if ever as a Palestine.....however the 1947 partition provided for a much larger land area than the bits left over now.

They don't talk about it because the Sinai Peninsula wasn't part of Palestine in the first place. And yes, I'm well aware that the originally planned size of Arab controlled Palestine was significantly larger... and it would have been nice if the Jews and Arabs would have played nicely. They didn't, obviously, though, which, in large part, has led to the current state of affairs.


I personally think that a two state solution is impossible now....watch this video

Maybe. It's likely pretty close to that for the moment, given the choices made on both sides.
 
Last edited:
I'm aware. Hence the "however close it came to existing" right after what you highlighted.


Do not forget that it was ALREADY a state albeit under the British mandate after they (and the French) took over the territories of the Ottoman Empire and established all sorts of states like Lebanon, Jordan, Syria and Iraq etc. etc. It had its central bank and money minting and passports and currency etc. etc.

So in fact Palestine was a state long before Israel was.... you really need to read this web page intently.... also this page.

That is why the U.N. PARTITIONED Palestine... it was Palestine before it was partitioned and the bits taken away became Israel and what remained was and would have still been Palestine had it not been for the Arabs making wars against Israel and annexing the Palestinian territories to theirs and never bothering to REestablish Palestine after Britain washed their hands from the whole mess they created in the first place.

So in fact we can say that the Arabs are the ones who knocked down Palestine and Israel just kept its foot over it after it was already down.


Maybe. It's likely pretty close to that for the moment, given the choices made on both sides.


I do not think that the Zionists ever intended to relinquish JUDAH. They will never do so NOW whether they ever intended or not.

Have a look at what the Israeli guy says in this debate minutes 01:23:00 to 01:25:00.... you will see what the facts are.

 
Last edited:
So let's see there who is doing the denying of official sources

And I am sure there were official sources on Saddam's WMDs or North Korea's prosperity.


Plus who is using ad hominems

That's an interesting way of responding to having fallacious logic called out.

So, I guess by your own critrion you are

I was asking as to why so many people thought Israel was a horror on the level of Nazi Germany, Tamerlane, Imperial Spain and Genghis Khan.

CDAC much???

CDAC is a codeword for "I cannot substantiate my claims so I will call anyone I disagree with Legally insane*"

*suffering an extreme disconnect from reality


So what, the USA will just use its veto power and nothing will happen, just like the umpteen times before where Israel or the USA broke international law with no consequences other than hot air from IMPOTENT ants called the rest of the world.

MIGHT IS RIGHT and people who open their mouths in protest will have something shoved in them real tight.

Everyone breaks International Law when It's convenient for them, but why is Israel singled out as though it were Nazi Germany post Wannsee?
 
Do not forget

I did not. My actual statement stands.

So in fact we can say that the Arabs are the ones who knocked down Palestine and Israel just kept its foot over it after it was already down.

We could. It would be inaccurate, though. A far better way to put it would be to note that Palestine would have existed as a distinct Arab country, had the Arabs of the area and of the surrounding countries not tried to gang up on the newly formed Israel to take it all at that point, but that the Jews bear responsibility for Israel forming in the first place in the area. They worked hard to make that happen, though their hard work frequently was to the exclusive benefit of the Jews and their methods were sometimes well worth condemning. That the Arabs did not help the Palestinians make their own country after that is indeed telling, though. That Jordan actually tried to annex the West Bank is telling, as well, even going so far as to issue citizenship to the residents of the West Bank. Furthermore, the Arabs bear quite a bit of responsibility for again trying to gang up on Israel in 1967, which again resulted in them losing control of quite a bit of land.



I do not think that the Zionists ever intended to relinquish JUDAH. They will never do so NOW whether they ever intended or not.

Maybe, maybe not. They are quite unlikely to completely give it up at this point, certainly, yes, but they would be more likely to be willing to give up land elsewhere in exchange, as has been proposed before in negotiations with the Palestinians.
 
Last edited:
I'm mildly curious about who here claims that Israel's army is "the most moral army in the world?"

Google it.

I... rather doubt that Israeli forces are low on ammo. I wouldn't be all that surprised if the Palestinians were, though.


Google it.

e.g. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/...spite-global-concern/articleshow/39359145.cms
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


A 'self-hating' Jew's guide to answering Zionist talking points

A growing number of Jews in Israel and around the world are standing with the Palestinians in their struggle for justice in the Gaza conflict.
 
"Woe is me", your "Daniel [and so on]
Your pedantry and strawmen aside, everything I say stands. The problem isn't that I don't understand what you're trying to say. I do. The issue is that you basically invent psychological terms, or "psychological conditions" out of thin air, perhpas in an attempt to poison the well. In other words, "you disagree with me? You're just another poor sufferer of x. Get well soon".

Either way, I would like to add that when posting on message boards such as this one, relying on terms not in everyday language is as much a shortcoming as it is a skill. I've written my share of college papers, where we students would often throw around social work terms and whatnot, and often it just made the papers hard to read. This is a forum where people from all backgrounds come to post and read. As our professors said, "the way you speak is more than good enough".
 
Here's a debate between Max Blumenthal and the president of the Zionist Organization of America. Somehow I suspect it's intentional to put someone with Tourette syndrome at the top of that organization so that if people laugh at the dreck that's coming out of his mouth (beside the noises), they can be charged with political incorrectness. On the other hand, they don't need that as they always can use the old anti-semite or in this case self-hating jew (he almost says it) canard, can't they? What a vile person.

 
by John Dugard - Emeritus professor of international law at the University of Leiden in the Netherlands and former U.N. special rapporteur on human rights in the occupied Palestinian territory.

Google it.


Google it.

Not to worry, I always google your biased sources.

wikipedia said:
UN Watch criticized Dugard in 2006, protesting his appointment to lead a “fact-finding mission...on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories.” Dugard's reports, complained UN Watch, “stand out, even by UN standards, for their virulently anti-Israel prejudice. Not only does Dugard systematically ignore Palestinian acts of terror and their victims, but he has gone so far as to laud Palestinian 'militarized groups armed with rifles, mortars, and Kassam-2 rockets [who] confront the [Israeli army] with new determination, daring, and success.'” Also, while “many UN figures...like to lambaste Israel,” Dugard is “the only appointee of the UN who regularly rails against the UN-sponsored Quartet and its Road Map for Middle East Peace.” Citing Dugard's statement about the recent capture by Hamas of Israeli Corporal Gilad Shalit, in which Dugard expressed sympathy “for all Israel's young soldiers compelled to serve in the army of an occupying power,” UN Watch commented that “Dugard could not bring himself to express sympathy for the captured soldier without wrapping it in a sharp stab, drenched with cynicism, at Israel's morality. We've seen nothing to suggest Corporal Shalit has felt anything other than patriotic about his service.”

Dugard also wants to consider, oh, the elimination of Israel as a Jewish state. Not that he's biased or anything.
John Dugard said:
“Interlocutors within both Israel and the West Bank warned the special rapporteur that with the two-state solution becoming increasingly difficult, if not impossible, consideration should be given to the establishment of a binational Palestinian state. The demography of the region increasingly points to such an outcome.”

link
 
Hate to break it to you but wanting to maintain an apartheid state is anything but unbiased, carlitos. It's racist.

I don't think Israel is an "Apartheid state". It is more like the result of a minority that was kicked around Europe and North America since the 100s culminating in the first and only attempt at industrial scale extinction of a culture. As a result of millennia of persecution, the European Jews decided that any country where they were a minority wasn't a safe place (who can blame them? Even after said industrial scale extinction attempt, they were subject to pogroms and were often housed in displaced persons camps). Thus they turned to Israel, a land they were promised by the British (who happened to promise the land to the Arabs as well, which was going to go down fine, and during the Nazi regime, Jewish emigrants to Palestine were turned round). Come Israel's foundation in 1948, the local Arab powers decided to try and finish the job Hitler started, but got their clocks cleaned, and lost quite a bit of clay. Come 1967, they went for round 2 and lost even more clay. >> to today and this is the result. Israel is seeing Palestinians the same way it saw the Arab world in 1967, the rest of the Arab world is going to hell in a handbasket with their very own Khmer Rouge rising up.

For many Israelis today, the One State Solution is inviting Extinction, and who can blame them?
 
Yeah, it really is looking pretty bad. I know the goal is the destruction of the tunnels, which certainly seems like a legitimate objective, but still... It's heavy-handed.

I suppose the reason for the heavy-handedness is minimizing the risk of Israeli casualties, yet the cost is pretty high.

I imagine that a lot of German cities looked pretty bad in 1945, yet one doesn't tend to hear too much hand wringing over Allied heavy handedness.

When a population votes in a bunch of authoritarian, genocidal, expansionist scumbags who then start shooting at their more powerful neighbors... well, it's not pretty but maybe the neighbors are justified in their response.
 
Someone on Finnish TV is telling us that at least one missile was launched from Shiva Hospital in Gaza. Make sure you hit the "CC" button when you view this, to see the captions.

 
To the more knowledgeable here: if the IDF goes "all the way" and crushes HAMAS and occupies Gaza, how do you think this will go for them? I wouldn't mind seeing HAMAS go, but I worry Gaza would turn into another "NATO in Iraq/Afghanistan" scenario.
 
To the more knowledgeable here: if the IDF goes "all the way" and crushes HAMAS and occupies Gaza, how do you think this will go for them? I wouldn't mind seeing HAMAS go, but I worry Gaza would turn into another "NATO in Iraq/Afghanistan" scenario.

I'm hoping more in the line of UN in Cyprus.
 
Originally Posted by Safe-Keeper

To the more knowledgeable here: if the IDF goes "all the way" and crushes HAMAS and occupies Gaza, how do you think this will go for them? I wouldn't mind seeing HAMAS go, but I worry Gaza would turn into another "NATO in Iraq/Afghanistan" scenario.

If Hamas goes something more extreme will replace them. Ruthless oppression leads to ruthless resistance.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom