Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bull crap.

My position is clear, and has not changed. Israel kills civilians. Israel usually takes reasonable precautions against doing so unnecessarily. Israel causes more civilian deaths than it suffers. As these are absolutes, any attempt to paint these as "anti-Israel" statements is silly, and indicative of someone that is either incapable or unwilling to view such things objectively.
I have never accused you of changing your position. Neither have I accused of your position being 'anti-Israel'. I just simply think your logic is false regardless where these hostilities were to happen. I have never denied that Gaza suffers more civilian deaths due to IDF operations than Israeli civilian deaths due to attacks residing from the various Palestinian terrorist groups from within Gaza.

The death ratio argument, which is decades old in this conflict, has never been a just reason for Israel not respond attacks from Gaza. What does one expect when Hamas does not protect its citizens and routinely (along with other groups) launches attacks from civilian areas?

As for the rest, stop playing the martyr and fabricating attacks against you (in this case from me). That is just plain silly.
 
I have never accused you of changing your position. Neither have I accused of your position being 'anti-Israel'. I just simply think your logic is false regardless where these hostilities were to happen. I have never denied that Gaza suffers more civilian deaths due to IDF operations than Israeli civilian deaths due to attacks residing from the various Palestinian terrorist groups from within Gaza.

The death ratio argument, which is decades old in this conflict, has never been a just reason for Israel not respond attacks from Gaza. What does one expect when Hamas does not protect its citizens and routinely (along with other groups) launches attacks from civilian areas?

As for the rest, stop playing the martyr and fabricating attacks against you (in this case from me). That is just plain silly.

Your post is completely disconnected from the exchanges in this thread. Are you certain you are replying in the correct thread?
 
Your post is completely disconnected from the exchanges in this thread. Are you certain you are replying in the correct thread?
Because I disagree with your choice of diction in one instance and the presentation that somehow firing unguided munitions is routinely done (as into densely populated areas with somewhat reckless disregard)? I understand that you know that the IDF takes precautions when attacking targets within Gaza, but I disagree with you in what targets the IDF/IAF attack and which methods they use. And mostly in the argument that the death ratio argument is a sound one. The presentation of these 'absolutes' does not paint a balanced picture. Mainly that of Hamas and other terrorist organizations in actuality 'routinely' attacking from populated areas knowing that the IDF/IAF [i[might[/i] respond depending on the situation.

My first post was a bit scathing, which I do apologize for. Hopefully we can move past this.
 
Love the Hitch pic!

I recently met a woman here in the states who had lived in Israel 1975 until about 2000. She lived in a kibbutz and said the thing she feared most during her time there was in the early days of her stay there when other Israelis would steal from her collective. She said she did armed guard duty. I myself lived in Israel for 12 years. I worked in industry. Her telling me the story about doing armed guard duty at the kibbutz and fearing other Israelis would steal the collective's produce reminded me what a crazy time that was for myself. I still am confused but less so now. That was the least black and white world that I ever lived in.

Did she tell you about the handsome American sailor she met in Haifa back in 80*mumble* with whom she spent two memorable evenings?

That was me.
 
Sinister Zionist plot to steal Gaza babies!

RAMAT GAN, Israel (AP) -- In his short life, Palestinian toddler Mohammed al-Farra has known just one home: the yellow-painted children's ward in Israel's Tel Hashomer hospital.

Born in Gaza with a rare genetic disease, Mohammed's hands and feet were amputated because of complications from his condition, and the 3 1/2-year-old carts about in a tiny red wheelchair. His parents abandoned him, and the Palestinian government won't pay for his care, so he lives at the hospital with his grandfather.

"There's no care for this child in Gaza, there's no home in Gaza where he can live," said the grandfather, Hamouda al-Farra
 
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/mar/22/israel-apologises-turkey-gaza-flotilla-deaths
The apology to Turkey for the May 2010 incident had been resisted by Israel until now, despite pressure from the international community. Both are close US allies – Turkey is a member of Nato – so the president was well placed to broker the deal.

According to White House officials aboard Air Force One, Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu placed a call to his Turkish counterpart Recep Tayyip Erdogan while closeted with Obama in a trailer on the tarmac at Ben Gurion airport in the last minutes before the president's departure for Jordan. Obama joined the call at one point.

The Israeli prime minister's office said Netanyahu "apologised to the Turkish people for any errors that could have led to the loss of life". Erdogan accepted the apology, White House officials said.
 
Now, if the Zionists would only apologize for taking care of a horribly ill Gazan child whom his parents and Hamas left to die. And that horrible grandfather, bringing this poor infant to the bloody Jews so the can harvest his organs for profit! I'm sure this traitor will soon find himself dragged through the streets of Gaza behind a motorcycle.
 
I can see that this thread is going according to the norm. At least the Israelis using air strikes on the Syrians hasn't offended the Palestinians. Wouldn't be prudent to upset them, would it? :p
 
Stephen Hawking boycotts Israel

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/09/w...awking-joins-boycott-against-israel.html?_r=0

"Stephen W. Hawking, the University of Cambridge physicist and cosmologist, has pulled out of a high-profile conference to be held here in June in order to support an academic boycott of Israel, conference organizers and the university said on Wednesday.



The academic and cultural boycott, organized by international activists to protest Israel’s policies toward the Palestinians, is a heated and contentious issue; having Dr. Hawking join it is likely to help the anti-Israel campaigners significantly.
“Never has a scientist of this stature boycotted Israel,” said Yigal Palmor, the spokesman for Israel’s Foreign Ministry."




That'll show those uppity Jews.:boxedin::boggled:
 
I tend to think the boycott is misguided, but the "defence" given is utter word salad.

I see a few people jumping on "This is his independent decision to respect the boycott, based upon his knowledge of Palestine, and on the unanimous advice of his own academic contacts there" as meaning that he was "pressured by activists".
 
Stephen Hawking claimed that the words from a visit from the ghost of Albert Einstein decided the matter for him:

They asked me to be Prez of Israel, and I said, no, no, no!

...

If invited to this conf'rence in Israel, I won't go, go, go!


:boxedin:
 
I don't think Hawking has a leg to stand on here.

I bet there are some guys right now trying to find the specifications to Hawkings' wheelchair and computer-generated voice technology to find out how many parts were made or invented in Israel and then declaring, "Ah ha! If your boycott is real, you'll stop using your hi-tech wheelchair!"
 
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/09/w...awking-joins-boycott-against-israel.html?_r=0

"Stephen W. Hawking, the University of Cambridge physicist and cosmologist, has pulled out of a high-profile conference to be held here in June in order to support an academic boycott of Israel, conference organizers and the university said on Wednesday.



The academic and cultural boycott, organized by international activists to protest Israel’s policies toward the Palestinians, is a heated and contentious issue; having Dr. Hawking join it is likely to help the anti-Israel campaigners significantly.
“Never has a scientist of this stature boycotted Israel,” said Yigal Palmor, the spokesman for Israel’s Foreign Ministry."




That'll show those uppity Jews Israeli policy makers.:boxedin::boggled:

Fixed that last line for you. Unlike Holocaust Denial, I have seen no evidence that people who criticize Israeli policy, on the whole, are anti-Semites or self-hating Jews (the other favorite description).

I say, "Good for Hawking!"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom