Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Interesting article

The End of Israel

In his speech to the nation Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu acknowledged yesterday that the war on Gaza is a battle for the existence of the Jewish State. Netanyahu is correct. And Israel cannot win this battle; it cannot even define what a victory might entail.
[..]
For ten days Netanyahu did all he could to prevent an IDF ground operation. He was facing the reality that Israel lacks a military answer to Palestinian resistance. Netanyahu knew that a defeat on the ground would eradicate the little that remains of IDF’s power of deterrence.
[..]
But that has changed rapidly since Israel launched its ground operation. Israel is now, once again, involved in colossal war crimes against a civilian population and worse, at least strategically, its elite infantry commandos are being eradicated in a face-to-face street battle in Gaza. In spite of clear Israeli technological superiority and firepower, the Palestinian militants are winning the battle on the ground and they have even managed to move the battle to Israeli territory. In addition, the barrage of rockets on Tel Aviv doesn’t seem to stop.
[..]
Israeli military superiority belongs to the past. There is no future for the Jews-only-State in Palestine; they may have to try somewhere else.
http://www.thepeoplesvoice.org/TPV3/Voices.php/2014/07/23/the-end-of-israel
 
Interesting article

The End of Israel

In his speech to the nation Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu acknowledged yesterday that the war on Gaza is a battle for the existence of the Jewish State. Netanyahu is correct. And Israel cannot win this battle; it cannot even define what a victory might entail.
[..]
For ten days Netanyahu did all he could to prevent an IDF ground operation. He was facing the reality that Israel lacks a military answer to Palestinian resistance. Netanyahu knew that a defeat on the ground would eradicate the little that remains of IDF’s power of deterrence.
[..]
But that has changed rapidly since Israel launched its ground operation. Israel is now, once again, involved in colossal war crimes against a civilian population and worse, at least strategically, its elite infantry commandos are being eradicated in a face-to-face street battle in Gaza. In spite of clear Israeli technological superiority and firepower, the Palestinian militants are winning the battle on the ground and they have even managed to move the battle to Israeli territory. In addition, the barrage of rockets on Tel Aviv doesn’t seem to stop.
[..]
Israeli military superiority belongs to the past. There is no future for the Jews-only-State in Palestine; they may have to try somewhere else.
http://www.thepeoplesvoice.org/TPV3/Voices.php/2014/07/23/the-end-of-israel

You surely must be a clone of "Bagdad Bob", are you?
 
It's one thing to be critical of their use of the territories but on the other hand I have to wonder how most critics would view their incursion into Palestinian territory given the current circumstances. I know if I were a resident of there having missiles routinely launched over my head and the possibility that I might be hit, I'd probably support some form of action to abate it. As bad one might think of Israel I would find Hamas an order of magnitude worse for the fact that they specifically place their equipment in civilian locations to maximize collateral when Israel has to go in and decommission that equipment.

Hell... I can't even imagine what the Palestinians are dealing with given Hamas's habit of placing their missile launchers in the middle of freakin' civilian populations.

It's nothing short of a tragedy...


Blah...Blah...Blah. If Israel quit stealing land and gave back the land they stole, then things would start to get better immediatly. Also, Israel has got to stop treating the West bank and Gaza like Prison Camps. Now..Israel can start doing this unilaterally - they do not need the approval of Hamas. In fact, doing the right thing can always be done unilaterally and that's all people are asking Israel to do. And - we have a Special Right to ask Israel to do this.

Israel is the recipient of Billions of Dollars of Welfare per year in Arms and Money. And as long as Israel is "under out roof" so-to-speak, we have the right to insist that it do the right thing because its actions represent the countries that give it welfare. Thus, when Israel does bad things, it reflects poorly on America and other countries that lavish it with cash.
 
It's one thing to be critical of their use of the territories but on the other hand I have to wonder how most critics would view their incursion into Palestinian territory given the current circumstances. I know if I were a resident of there having missiles routinely launched over my head and the possibility that I might be hit, I'd probably support some form of action to abate it. As bad one might think of Israel I would find Hamas an order of magnitude worse for the fact that they specifically place their equipment in civilian locations to maximize collateral when Israel has to go in and decommission that equipment.

Hell... I can't even imagine what the Palestinians are dealing with given Hamas's habit of placing their missile launchers in the middle of freakin' civilian populations.

It's nothing short of a tragedy...

Where do you suggest Hamas launch their missiles from? Please be precise. Thank you
 
So you admit that Israel is a Land Thief!

I'm not addressing that point. Others already have, and it's not necessary for my purposes. Even if we accept your position about the land being stolen, the fact of the matter is that giving it back doesn't help. We know this for certain, because it's already happened. You can't argue otherwise, so you're trying to change the subject away from your own indefensible claim.
 
Blah...Blah...Blah. If Israel quit stealing land and gave back the land they stole, then things would start to get better immediatly. Also, Israel has got to stop treating the West bank and Gaza like Prison Camps. Now..Israel can start doing this u doing the right thing can always be done unilaterally and that's all people are asking Israel to do. And - we have a Special Right to ask Israel to do this.

You desire Israeli concessions not with the objective of peace, but in order to portray Jews as weak and cowardly. Racists such as yourself have no "special right" to anything, with the possible exception of tar and feathers.
 
Last edited:
You desire Israeli concessions not with the objective of peace, but in order to portray Jews as weak and cowardly. Racists such as yourself have no "special right" to anything, with the possible exception of tar and feathers.

I never said the Jews were weak...just Cowardly. And Jews aren't a "Race", either - so quit your pathetic whining and whimpering.

But...I will say this about Israel...they are Pitiful - just like any bunch of Sociopaths that hurt the defenseless at will and then seek pity when they get called out for their destruction.

When you see people hurting other people and then trying to elicit pity, then you are certainly looking at a bunch of Sociopaths. When you see people trying to re-write history (i.e., Gaslighting) then you are certainly dealing with Sociopaths. And when you see a people with as much "Entitlement" as Israel - then you are certainly looking at Sociopaths.

Yeah...Israelis are masters at playing up the "whole world against the Jewish State" narrative. It's sickening.


Here's Israel's common Refrain:

I steal Land...Pity Me!

I kill Children...Pity Me!

The World has been cruel to me in the past...Pity Me.

The world is against ME....Pity Me!

Pity Me...or you are a Hateful person...because I am Special!
 
Last edited:
I never said the Jews were weak...just Cowardly. And Jews aren't a "Race", either - so quit your pathetic whining and whimpering.

Well, since accurately describing you as a detestable racist isn't pathetic wining or whimpering, there's nothing for me to quit.

As for your claim that Jews are cowardly... that would be dead wrong.
 
When you see people trying to re-write history (i.e., Gaslighting)

Your knowledge of cinema is as bad as your knowledge of history. "Gaslighting" does not refer to rewriting history ("1984" offers the canonical artistic representation of that), it refers to trying to make someone think that they are crazy by screwing with their sensory perceptions.

And you denied history yourself. You claimed that things would improve immediately if Israel gave back land. But it already gave back land, and that only made things worse. By your own metric, you are a sociopath.

Here's Israel's common Refrain:

You keep trying to make excuses for your hatefulness, but nobody actually buys it. KumarS is the only company you keep. How pathetic.
 
...the average age in Gaza is 17...

I feel guilty in leaving, and for the first time in my reporting life, scarred, deeply scarred by what I have seen, some of it too terrible to put on the screen....

Leaving Israel and beleaguered Gaza far below me, I lay back in my BA seat headed for London. I donned my headphones and listened to Bach’s heavenly violin concerto in E major, and wept, as I rarely have as an adult.


http://blogs.channel4.com/snowblog/bring-israelis-palestinians/24316

Judgement

Israel has proved one bitter truth. There is no such thing as a forensic or even a surgical attack. In this densely packed slither of land, fenced off from the rest of the world, it has proved impossible to ‘kill a militant’, without taking out a child, twenty children, or a grandmother, aunt, cousin, cousin’s cousin.

Gazan society is a construct of huge families interwoven across the territory. It is hard to pin-prick one man – kill him, and leave. You can obliterate his house, and he most probably he wont be there, but his seventeen relatives will be, and at the end of the attack they will be beyond life.

Finally, I have been stranded in Gaza City these three days. It was too dangerous to move far. Yet some of the worst of the carnage has been south of here, where no journalist has yet ventured.

But blessed Youtube, combined with short bursts of phone and electricity supply have enabled locals’ pictures to reach the outside world and we journalists to verify and then weave them into our reports.

The world is witnessing what is happening in Gaza. There is bound to be judgement.



Gaza’s ‘Birthplace of saints and death-yard of angels’
 
Last edited:
It's one thing to be critical of their use of the territories but on the other hand I have to wonder how most critics would view their incursion into Palestinian territory given the current circumstances. I know if I were a resident of there having missiles routinely launched over my head and the possibility that I might be hit, I'd probably support some form of action to abate it. As bad one might think of Israel I would find Hamas an order of magnitude worse for the fact that they specifically place their equipment in civilian locations to maximize collateral when Israel has to go in and decommission that equipment.

Hell... I can't even imagine what the Palestinians are dealing with given Hamas's habit of placing their missile launchers in the middle of freakin' civilian populations.

It's nothing short of a tragedy...

Further to my question about where Hamas should best launch their rockets from:

What do you think would be the best way for the Palestinians to decommission Israel's equipment?
 



From the bottom of the second article
The world is witnessing what is happening in Gaza. There is bound to be judgement.



Oh there will be lots of judgment .... however, there will not be any sentencing or penalties.

This has happened NUMEROUS times before and in fact almost on monthly basis for decades. All have elicited lots of judgment. But so far no consequences other than a lot of hot air. So why would this time be any different.

Have a look at this video and tell me why is this time any different from all the other times before it.... if nothing got done those times, then the very same reasons will also be why nothing will be done this time either.

It is called MIGHT IS RIGHT and objectors who open their mouths will have something shoved in them real tight.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom