Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Drat, should have hit the specific: it may or may not be a massacre - but, even if it is, it is not a war crimes because the rules of warfare allow military operations in otherwise protected civilian areas - even hospitals and schools and religious buildings and regular houses/apartment houses/businesses - even if civilians are present in them IF military (like hamass) are also in them and/or if military materiel of any kind (though especially provisions and weapons) are or may legitimately be suspected of being stored in them. Real law, World Court kind of law. No war crimes on Israel's part. hamasses though..... Why do they hate their civilians so much (oh, good news I got on NPR while driving home earlier - Palestinians are beginning to talk to reporters about wanting hamass out of their locations and lives as they apparently begin to realize Israel is not going away and is not going to take having it's citizen's murdered by war criminals (or common criminals - covers hamass either way)???

That stupidities you hear in US medias, first of all hamas members are not in schools, this is propaganda use by Israel to kill innocent people, these 1000 people from now dead there are not 5 members of hamas, they are all waiting for Israel soldiers to get in gaza to protect their country and their people, the terrosist are Obama of american administration and israel administration.
 
Nay!
It is the American people who are mostly ignorant, hypocrite and on a psichiatric power trip

That would be "Psychotic".

As the Neocons are fond of saying: "Absolute Power Corrupts Absolutely...but it also Rocks Absolutely!"

As a result, we are in big trouble here.
 
No. They are not attacking the US. Neither is Iran, Neither is the Hezbollah. Neither is Syria. Neither is the Muslim Brotherhood.

They got a Boner for Israel. So leave the US out of it. It is not the USA's war.


You've missed my point. To posters like KumarS and JihadJane, the Palestinian people and their suffering are just a tool to attack, and they use that tool to attack the US, among other things. I didn't say that the Palestinians are attacking the US.


They are human people even if they are treated as animals by the US-supported Zionists
And they do have choices,: accept the status quo and live as slaves or fight the US-supported Zionist criminals and strive for their dignity
They have chosen the latter even at risk of their lives


No, they are not. They are treated as people who have choices and those choices are in their power to decide. To say that Israel is responsible for the choices of Hamas or the Palestinians in electing Hamas is to remove all power even for internal choices from the Palestinians. Because you cannot, must not, see them as anything other than 'victims' you can't attribute any mistakes or crimes they commit to them. That would be giving them power, and giving them power means they have responsibilities. As soon as you do that the entire narrative you rely on to hate falls apart.

So you wont.

Your choices are a false dichotomy in addition to one of them being patently untrue.
 
You've missed my point. To posters like KumarS and JihadJane, the Palestinian people and their suffering are just a tool to attack, and they use that tool to attack the US, among other things. I didn't say that the Palestinians are attacking the US.





No, they are not. They are treated as people who have choices and those choices are in their power to decide. To say that Israel is responsible for the choices of Hamas or the Palestinians in electing Hamas is to remove all power even for internal choices from the Palestinians. Because you cannot, must not, see them as anything other than 'victims' you can't attribute any mistakes or crimes they commit to them. That would be giving them power, and giving them power means they have responsibilities. As soon as you do that the entire narrative you rely on to hate falls apart.

So you wont.

Your choices are a false dichotomy in addition to one of them being patently untrue.

I might be wrong, but I think this line of reasoning is a bit over KumarS's head.
 
No, they are not. They are treated as people who have choices and those choices are in their power to decide. To say that Israel is responsible for the choices of Hamas or the Palestinians in electing Hamas is to remove all power even for internal choices from the Palestinians.

It is you who, very hypocritally, are talking about Hamas and do nt see that the same point applies to Israeli as well
While Hamas does have responsibilities..

To say that Hamas is responsible for the murderous choices of Israel or the Jews in electing Nethanyahu is to remove all power even for internal choices from the Jews.

Israel could have agreed on the two state solution based on 1967 borders.
They did not
They are guilty of this refusal, Hamas is not
People who refuse to condemn this are also guilty of the deaths of 1000+ civilians
 
Last edited:
It is you who, very hypocritally, are talking about Hamas and do nt see that the same point applies to Israeli as well
While Hamas does have responsibilities..

To say that Hamas is responsible for the murderous choices of Israel or the Jews in electing Nethanyahu is to remove all power even for internal choices from the Jews.

Israel could have agreed on the two state solution based on 1967 borders.
They did not
They are guilty of this refusal, Hamas is not
People who refuse to condemn this are also guilty of the deaths of 1000+ civilians

Like I said.
 
That would be "Psychotic".

As the Neocons are fond of saying: "Absolute Power Corrupts Absolutely...but it also Rocks Absolutely!"

As a result, we are in big trouble here.

Nothing new here ..
It has been like this since the beginning of humankind
 
I keep checking this thread but it has massively degenerated (not that it was ever great) thanks to people like CE, JG and KS who frankly should be embarrassed by their level of debate (and the other side including me have their share of blame for not simply using the ignore function on what is basically trolling)

There is a spectrum of crazy, and its easy to imagine many people on the far end are just faking it for the reactions. Some probably are, but others really are that crazy.

This is the problem I have with this debate, I'm sure Israel does its share of bad and questionable **** like any other nation made up of human beings, but those on the anti-Israel side tend to be so ridiculous in their argumentation and wilful in their ignorance of the history and context (and I consider my knowledge shallow at best) that it just makes me disgusted with their side and more pro-Israeli. Maybe some of the less extreme pro-Israeli's in this thread could, for my benefit sum up the things they thing are most 'wrong' done by Israel and what changes to its current policy Israel should make

I think that's a very hard question. I can name a number of things I believe Israel is doing wrong, but suggesting alternatives? That assumes I have an idea of how to end the conflict, and I really don't.

I've often thought I could run a much better anti-Israel campaign than the Israel haters could. Right now it follows a pattern; someone squawks some outrageous hyperbole about some incident that "proves" how awful Israel is, and that's followed by other people adding context, correcting facts and generally proving the first group are idiots, before degenerating into a shouting match. Over time, reasonable people see how unreasonable the Israel haters are, and dismiss them. Often they will end up dismissing the pro-Israelis as well.

also while scouring the internet following this debate I hadn't come across this quote before but I love it:

http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/m/martinluth101536.html

A few days ago I heard George Takei being interviewed by Jon Stewart on the Daily Show and the topic went to Japanese internment during WWII, which George Takei remembered being taken to the camps in his childhood when he was about 5 years old. In later years, in discussing it with his father, his father told him (and this is from memory, so the quote won't be verbatum), "America is a democracy of it's people, and can be as great as it's people, and as terrible as it's people."

I think that sums it up for the United States, Israel, and every other democracy around the world. Sometimes we get it very right, but sometimes we get it very wrong. Hopefully, the long term trend is to get it more right than wrong.
 
Wow...turns out that Hamas was not complicit in kidnapping the three (3) Irsraeli teens. But...that never stopped Israel from using the kidnapping as an excuse for invading Palestine and killing Arabs!

http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2014/07/hamas-didnt-kidnap-the-israeli-teens-after-all.html

1) Nobody has invaded "Palestine". That nation doesn't exist.

2) Nobody is invading anybody because somebody kidnapped three Israeli teens. Israel is entering Gaza because Hamas is shooting rockets at Israel.
 
1) Nobody has invaded "Palestine". That nation doesn't exist.

2) Nobody is invading anybody because somebody kidnapped three Israeli teens. Israel is entering Gaza because Hamas is shooting rockets at Israel.

Yeah it is. First thing Netanyahu did was blame Hamas and then sent his Thugs to Palestine to crack Arab heads.

And then Israel wonders why the Palestinians got all upset? Puhlease!

Israel thought they could "Flog the Wog" as a sort of Cathartic Military Mission of Vengeance...but it didn't work out so well for them. Now, the whole world knows that Israel started the violence and on a false pretext.
 
Last edited:
Shujayea: Massacre at Dawn

A powerful film with exclusive footage from the day of the Israeli assault on the densely populated district of Shujayea in Gaza City. A film by Amjad Almalki and Ahmed Ashour.

Published on Jul 26, 2014

WARNING: Contains graphic images of casualties.

 
Yeah it is. First thing Netanyahu did was blame Hamas and then sent his Thugs to Palestine to crack Arab heads.

And then Israel wonders why the Palestinians got all upset? Puhlease!

Israel thought they could "Flog the Wog" as a sort of Cathartic Military Mission of Vengeance...but it didn't work out so well for them. Now, the whole world knows that Israel started the violence and on a false pretext.

I said this before, but I'll try again:

You're trying way too hard. You need to dial it back a notch.

Or you could say something racist again.
 
Shujayea: Massacre at Dawn

A powerful film with exclusive footage from the day of the Israeli assault on the densely populated district of Shujayea in Gaza City. A film by Amjad Almalki and Ahmed Ashour.

Published on Jul 26, 2014

WARNING: Contains graphic images of casualties.


I'm sure they are blaming Hamas for hiding among civilians in that film, right?
 
It is you who, very hypocritally, are talking about Hamas and do nt see that the same point applies to Israeli as well
While Hamas does have responsibilities..

To say that Hamas is responsible for the murderous choices of Israel or the Jews in electing Nethanyahu is to remove all power even for internal choices from the Jews.


I have not argued that Hamas is responsible for the election of Netanyahu. I have not argued that Hamas is responsible for the 'murderous choices' of Israel. In fact I've argued that the hard liners in Israel having as much say as they do is a mistake and something to criticize Israel for.

I've also not argued that Israel's choices don't effect the people in Gaza's choices or vice versa. Of course what the other side in a war does (like not cease fire) will effect others choices. But electing Hamas? The blame for that is on the voters. That was their responsibility. External factors might effect it, but when it comes down to it they have ownership of that, not Israel.


Israel could have agreed on the two state solution based on 1967 borders.
They did not
They are guilty of this refusal, Hamas is not
People who refuse to condemn this are also guilty of the deaths of 1000+ civilians


:rolleyes:

I used to not bother arguing on this subject because of how obviously wrong a lot of the things said are, and normally I wouldn't bother refuting you. I've seen this line of reasoning growing with others who aren't simply anti-west fanatics and for the lurkers I must object. Don't worry, because I'm under no illusion that you're even attempting to honestly understand what I'm arguing so I'm not holding it against you when you don't.
 
Or you could say something racist again.

But...but...but....Hitler!

You got to feel sorry for us Jews because of Hitler.

We suffered...and our suffering is Special!

Therefore, we have a right to bomb innocent men, women and children...because Hitler made us Suffer.

We have a right to Palestinian Land because the World is against us...the Whole World hates the Jews (even people who say they love the Jews - and even aliens from other planets).

Everybody hates us because we are so good...so smart...so decent...so generous...so kind...so productive.

They hate us because we are good...they Hate the Good for being Good. They hate the Productive for being Productive.

And anyone who disagrees is a racist, anti-semite, jew-hating, bigot - and they definetly are not fans of Ayn Rand or Amy Winehouse!
 
Last edited:
Nay!
It is the American people who are mostly ignorant, hypocrite and on a psichiatric power trip

I will agree that "some" are mostly ignorant, hypocritical, and maybe even on a power trip. Your comments have been directed at the US as a whole, however, which is, frankly, just as reasonable as calling Muslims in general terrorists. "Some" Muslims are indisputably terrorists, after all. That doesn't make it reasonable to say that they all are.


Only to keep them forced into submission

Which is why they've been helping to train and equip Palestinian security forces since the Oslo accords. Yup, training people to be more effective in taking others down is the perfect route to keep people forced into submission.
 
The whole of Gaza is a civilian area. No one is forcing Israeli war makers to kill civilians - 100% innocent men, women and children, who have done nothing to turn "civilian areas into military targets". The Zionist regime chooses to do so because it calculates that it can get away with it. It calculates that Palestinian lives are very cheap, compared to Israeli lives.

Wow. Talk about spin and ignoring relevant facts. You may be a master of it. If you think that this is in any way a valid counter to the points I made, however, you are utterly wrong.


The current round of blood-letting was provoked, over many months of killings and violent incursions, by Israel.

Feel free to put forth the necessary evidence required to supports these claims. Certainly, Israel does bear responsibility for things like Operation Brother's Keeper, but even then, the raw number of arrests and people killed don't even remotely tell the whole story. If a Palestinian throws a grenade at the IDF and gets shot and killed as a result, for example, that's not considered in such numbers. On the other hand, number of buildings destroyed isn't reflected in such numbers.

Why shouldn't Palestinians defend themselves?

That depends. Are they actually defending themselves? Or are they simply attacking? Targeting civilian areas with no military targets, for example, isn't a defensive action under any reasonable definition.

So leave the US out of it. It is not the USA's war.

Indeed. It's really not. Which is a major reason why the USA has stayed out of it, other than repeated attempts to help both sides reach a ceasefire and actual peace.

They are human people even if they are treated as animals by the US-supported Zionists
And they do have choices,: accept the status quo and live as slaves or fight the US-supported Zionist criminals and strive for their dignity

As noted before, the highly flawed mindsets and arguments that you espouse are likely quite damaging to any efforts to reach a viable peace.

It is you who, very hypocritally, are talking about Hamas and do nt see that the same point applies to Israeli as well
While Hamas does have responsibilities..

To say that Hamas is responsible for the murderous choices of Israel or the Jews in electing Nethanyahu is to remove all power even for internal choices from the Jews.

Israel could have agreed on the two state solution based on 1967 borders.
They did not
They are guilty of this refusal, Hamas is not
People who refuse to condemn this are also guilty of the deaths of 1000+ civilians

Well, given how worthless this repeatedly addressed set of points are on somewhat objective inspection, I'm going to have to agree that a fair bit is going over your head.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom