No it's not. So right there you lose all credibility. Being Jewish is not at all the same as being Christian.
I always have to explain this in my classes and I'll say "A Jew is like a Sioux"
Jews are descendants from the 12 tribes of Israel. That's why there are so many different types of Jews around the world. Lineage is matrilineal and so if a Jewish man marries a non Jew conversion is required to raise the children Jewish.
It's not a choice any more than being a Cherokee is a choice.
Your analogy does not make sense on any level of scientific epistemology! Your remarks display ignorance of
real history, biology, sociology, anthropology and most surprisingly, even theology.
The Sioux/Cherokee were tribes who lived for Generation as one tribe living in the one geographical area on one continent. The Cherokee are not Sioux and vice versa. Each was a distinct
homogeneous autochthonous group of people.
Jews are neither isolated geographically nor culturally except by RELIGIOUS CULTURE and are varied genetically from blonds to blacks.
If the Sioux spread out over Europe and Africa and Asia and intermarried with all sorts of peoples for over 3000 years, would we then still call them an AUTOCHTHONOUS group of people distinct from their fellow citizens in whatever country they are living in?
What distinguishes Jews is JUDAISM not genetics, just like the
Bahai people (the
Zoroatrians too) are still Persians despite their persecution in Iran and their distinct religious adherence. And if a Sioux converts to Bahaism he does not become Persian any more than if a Persian converts to Judaism does he become a descendent of the mythical 12 brothers.
Jews are descendants from the 12 tribes of Israel. That's why there are so many different types of Jews around the world. Lineage is matrilineal and so if a Jewish man marries a non Jew conversion is required to raise the children Jewish.
Are there black Jews? Are there Blonde Jews? Are there Indian Jews? Are there Chinese Jews?
You do know that the supposed 12 tribes are supposed to be descended from 12
brothers? You do know that Abraham is a myth and so were Isaac and Jacob? They were no more reality than
Remus or Romulus. Or do you believe that all Italians today come from these two brothers?
Do you believe that the world is 5774 years old and that it all started with Adam and Eve too?
In what classes are you teaching that Jews are like the Cherokee and are still allowed to teach...it must be in a religious institution.
By no sane definition can one consider any people who lived on 3 continents thousands of years and have
phenotypes varying from blond-blue-eyed whites to blacks as a
homogeneous autochthonous race descended from
12 brothers from 4 mothers, two of whom were sisters who in turn were first cousins to the father?
In fact it is actually even more preposterous because 10 of the tribes are supposed to have vanished and ALL Jews
Sephardim /Ashkenazim / Falasha / Mizrahim etc. are supposed to be descended only from the two tribes of Judah and Benjamin (with a few Levites maybe).
Are there any black Sioux? What about Blue-Eyed Blond-Haired Cherokee?
Unfortunately for your class they are not reading
this tidbit of information
A 2013 study of Ashkenazi mitochondrial DNA by a team led by Martin B. Richards of the University of Huddersfield in England tested the full 16,600 DNA units composing mitochondrial DNA in all their subjects. The study found that the four main female Ashkenazi founders had descent lines that were established in Europe 10,000 to 20,000 years in the past[21] whilst most of the remaining minor founders also have a deep European ancestry. The study states that the great majority of Ashkenazi maternal lineages were not brought from the Levant, nor recruited in the Caucasus, but were assimilated within Europe. The study estimated that 80 percent of Ashkenazi maternal ancestry comes from women indigenous to Europe, 8 percent from the Near East, and the remainder undetermined.[21] According to the study these findings 'point to a significant role for the conversion of women in the formation of Ashkenazi communities.'[22][23][24][25][26][27]
No it's not. So right there you lose all credibility. Being Jewish is not at all the same as being Christian.
Read this bit again
The study estimated that 80 percent of Ashkenazi maternal ancestry comes from women indigenous to Europe, 8 percent from the Near East, and the remainder undetermined.[21] According to the study these findings 'point to a significant role for the conversion of women in the formation of Ashkenazi communities.'
So how does that make Judaism any different from any other religion. People from all around the world intermarried and
CONVERTED to Judaism and are now Jews.... how is that different from Christianity?
Can one CONVERT to Cherokeeism? Can one convert to Christianity? In fact most early Christians became so because their mothers or wives converted.
Can one convert to Judaism? Your answer is
“ if a Jewish man marries a non Jew conversion is required to raise the children Jewish”…. So how is that different from any other religion?
If the Sioux intermarry with Europeans for generation are they still Sioux.... I have met many people here in the US who keep claiming that they are One-Umpteenth Apache etc. Maybe I should advise them to attend your class in order to learn how to claim that they are FULL Cherokee or whatever and maybe claim the right to shares in that Casino they have.