Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, the claim is obviously untrue.

I know that. In my previous post, I argued that the labeling of geography was correct, and that you could verify that yourself. Given that geography, individual missiles and explosions would obviously be far too small to actually resolve, let alone identify, in that photograph.

It's conceivable that he might have seen more than what showed up in the photo. But I really doubt it.

...snipped...

Quite so.

I completely misinterpreted your original response. but I think you pinned down what was bothering me about something relatively trivial like this (aside from the whole photograph from an orbiting space station, that's never trivial)

It's not. Which is why it's rather baffling that he made such a post. He's either a knave or a villain, and neither answer is encouraging.

but dude, he's an astronaut!
 
Seeing those more than 800 people death and a lot more wounded, we can say that it is a massacre and war crimes, so these pro-active supporters of israel, Obama and Kerry, should be treated as war criminals and taken before the international court as their support back up Israel to continue their crimes.
 
but dude, he's an astronaut!

Indeed. One would expect better, but competence or even great expertise in one field can still be accompanied by monumental stupidity in others. But it's never comforting to find such examples.
 
This is not racist. There is no "Jewish" gene. There is no Jewish Race.

Being a Jew is a choice - just like being a Christian, Muslim, Hindu, Tea Partier, Republican or Liberace Fanboy.

Judaism does not deserve my respect...or anyone else's. It is just an old and bloody cult that convinces it's victims that they are both Supermen (i.e., God's Chosen people) and Victims - a very dangerous ideology.

What's even worse is the death-cult of Christian Millennialism which has aided the Zionists so much. that's a real tragedy, too.

No it's not. So right there you lose all credibility. Being Jewish is not at all the same as being Christian.

I always have to explain this in my classes and I'll say "A Jew is like a Sioux"

Jews are descendants from the 12 tribes of Israel. That's why there are so many different types of Jews around the world. Lineage is matrilineal and so if a Jewish man marries a non Jew conversion is required to raise the children Jewish.

It's not a choice any more than being a Cherokee is a choice.
 
No it's not. So right there you lose all credibility. Being Jewish is not at all the same as being Christian.

I always have to explain this in my classes and I'll say "A Jew is like a Sioux"

Jews are descendants from the 12 tribes of Israel. That's why there are so many different types of Jews around the world. Lineage is matrilineal and so if a Jewish man marries a non Jew conversion is required to raise the children Jewish.

It's not a choice any more than being a Cherokee is a choice.

Baloney. Being a Jew is a choice just like being a Christian....ans there is nothing special about being a Jew. Jews are not special little Snowflakes: they are just another group of deluded people who believe in a Sky Daddy. Nothing special here.

There is no Jewish Gene. So...our special little Jewey Snowflakes must reconcile that they are only human after all. Just like everyone else.
 
Being a Jew is a choice just like being a Christian....There is no Jewish Gene
Pure ignorance. Did you choose who your mother was?


wiki said:
Judaism shares some of the characteristics of a nation, an ethnicity,[16] a religion, and a culture, making the definition of who is a Jew vary slightly depending on whether a religious or national approach to identity is used.[61][62] Generally, in modern secular usage Jews include three groups: people who were born to a Jewish family regardless of whether or not they follow the religion, those who have some Jewish ancestral background or lineage (sometimes including those who do not have strictly matrilineal descent), and people without any Jewish ancestral background or lineage who have formally converted to Judaism and therefore are followers of the religion.[63]
 
That's stupidities you hear in US media, the truth is that the hamas is waiting for Israelies soldiers to get in gaza, but they don't see them, they just shoot schools and hospitals.
Actually, we do not hear it enough (barely at all) - and apparently not at all in Europe. And if you actually think the hamass cowards are rushing out, manning up and looking for a straight on fight with Israeli units, your thought processes are even lower than I have assumed they are. Also, I am going to guess that you are unaware that hamass is violating most, if not all of the Geneva Conventions (the whole set, not just 1949) as well as others agreed to by the major developed nations. Essentially, not one single hamass member is not a war criminal based on one or more acts against the aforementioned rules. Beginning with requirements that they must have a distinct uniform making them clearly distinguishable from civilians and they must have rank insignia on the uniforms (that is less important, but, yes, it is part of the rules.) and that they must not (my word here) endanger civilians by being among them during military operations and may not force or ask civilians to cover for them when they start urinating and defecating in their clothes as deserved death comes for them. Cowards and slime=hamass..
 
Last edited:
Seeing those more than 800 people death and a lot more wounded, we can say that it is a massacre and war crimes, so these pro-active supporters of israel, Obama and Kerry, should be treated as war criminals and taken before the international court as their support back up Israel to continue their crimes.
You really, really need to carefully read the Geneva Conventions and the other appropriate rules of warfare. I would send it to you (Geneva plus the specific ones as given and trained on to US personnel re: civilians and what is allowed and when) but you clearly would just keep on playing as if there were no such rules and as if anyone other than hamass was violating them.. Israel is perfectly in step with it - hamass is not even on the same planet with it.
 
One thing I've noticed I'd that Jews and Arabs don't fight outside of the nasty, dried out, resource-poor "holy land." I was in a martial arts class with guys who would have been mortal enemies in their respective homelands but were best buddies.

I blame the heat. I watched my National Guard unit fall to pieces several times when they needed to cool down and drink water. One weekend the Chaplain (!) dropped a couple soldiers for 20 push-ups because they were about to come to blows over the proper way to coil up a power cable.

I say we truck the entire Middle East somewhere else more comfortable.
 
Seeing those more than 800 people death and a lot more wounded, we can say that it is a massacre and war crimes, so these pro-active supporters of israel, Obama and Kerry, should be treated as war criminals and taken before the international court as their support back up Israel to continue their crimes.

Drat, should have hit the specific: it may or may not be a massacre - but, even if it is, it is not a war crimes because the rules of warfare allow military operations in otherwise protected civilian areas - even hospitals and schools and religious buildings and regular houses/apartment houses/businesses - even if civilians are present in them IF military (like hamass) are also in them and/or if military materiel of any kind (though especially provisions and weapons) are or may legitimately be suspected of being stored in them. Real law, World Court kind of law. No war crimes on Israel's part. hamasses though..... Why do they hate their civilians so much (oh, good news I got on NPR while driving home earlier - Palestinians are beginning to talk to reporters about wanting hamass out of their locations and lives as they apparently begin to realize Israel is not going away and is not going to take having it's citizen's murdered by war criminals (or common criminals - covers hamass either way)???
 
One thing I've noticed I'd that Jews and Arabs don't fight outside of the nasty, dried out, resource-poor "holy land." I was in a martial arts class with guys who would have been mortal enemies in their respective homelands but were best buddies.

Would that this were true everywhere. I don't doubt your story, but there are also counter-examples.
 
One thing I've noticed I'd that Jews and Arabs don't fight outside of the nasty, dried out, resource-poor "holy land." I was in a martial arts class with guys who would have been mortal enemies in their respective homelands but were best buddies.

I blame the heat. I watched my National Guard unit fall to pieces several times when they needed to cool down and drink water. One weekend the Chaplain (!) dropped a couple soldiers for 20 push-ups because they were about to come to blows over the proper way to coil up a power cable.

I say we truck the entire Middle East somewhere else more comfortable.

I was an Israeli resident for a significant minority of my life, and I have to disagree that it's the heat.
 
Would that this were true everywhere. I don't doubt your story, but there are also counter-examples.

I'm sure you're right at some small level but I've never heard of open war breaking out in subdivisions anywhere but the Mideast. They're fighting over some of the crappiest land on earth. Get 'em outa there and they don't fight about it.
 
I'm sure you're right at some small level but I've never heard of open war breaking out in subdivisions anywhere but the Mideast.

Well, there was that nasty little business called World War II, and before that the Pogroms.

They're fighting over some of the crappiest land on earth. Get 'em outa there and they don't fight about it.

The land isn't the problem. The culture is. If you simply transplant Arabs from the middle east to somewhere else without doing anything to their culture, they'll still attack Jews. That's essentially what happened in France. I strongly suspect that your Jew-friendly Arab has been assimilated into Western culture. That doesn't mean removing all traces of Arab culture, but it does mean some pretty big changes.
 
One thing I've noticed I'd that Jews and Arabs don't fight outside of the nasty, dried out, resource-poor "holy land." I was in a martial arts class with guys who would have been mortal enemies in their respective homelands but were best buddies.

I blame the heat. I watched my National Guard unit fall to pieces several times when they needed to cool down and drink water. One weekend the Chaplain (!) dropped a couple soldiers for 20 push-ups because they were about to come to blows over the proper way to coil up a power cable.

I say we truck the entire Middle East somewhere else more comfortable.


Strange you should say that.

Currently working in Spain where yesterday it reached 42 degrees C, according to the signs on the streets. My behaviour does change. I love doing chess exercises and sodukus, in this weather, I cannot do any of them.

People around me are also different trying to cope with the heat, many are locals so they should be used to it. Have been here since February and aggression is definitively much higher than 6 months ago. Never experienced that before.

You may have a point.
 
Last edited:
on another forum I just came across another propaganda video that begins 'israel dropped over 400 tons of bombs killing over 130 palestinians'

according to wikipedia and some rough calculations they are going to need 5.6 million tons of bombs to wipe out the population of gaza at this rate. guess they are going to have to nuke it

do these people even listen to themselves?
 
Ahhh...the 'Ole "Your either with us, or you're a Jew Hater" routine coupled with "They've already given back some of that Land they stole...what, you want them to give back everything they stole?"

So...let's get this straight. If someone objects to the Israelis stealing land, then they are a Anti-semitic? That is one hell of an argument!
It's one thing to be critical of their use of the territories but on the other hand I have to wonder how most critics would view their incursion into Palestinian territory given the current circumstances. I know if I were a resident of there having missiles routinely launched over my head and the possibility that I might be hit, I'd probably support some form of action to abate it. As bad one might think of Israel I would find Hamas an order of magnitude worse for the fact that they specifically place their equipment in civilian locations to maximize collateral when Israel has to go in and decommission that equipment.

Hell... I can't even imagine what the Palestinians are dealing with given Hamas's habit of placing their missile launchers in the middle of freakin' civilian populations.

It's nothing short of a tragedy...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom