Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yup. Hamas use human shields for their military hardware. You support this tactic. We know you do. You have already stated that.

That's stupidities you hear in US media, the truth is that the hamas is waiting for Israelies soldiers to get in gaza, but they don't see them, they just shoot schools and hospitals.
 
Last edited:
Do you have ANY idea of what the nazis did?

Yes, and what we see looks like that, and i don't like it, you do? US is the pet avertion of the world, it is the origin of terrorism and everything that is bad, you should ask your government questions, don't you?
 
Yes, and what we see looks like that, and i don't like it, you do? US is the pet avertion of the world, it is the origin of terrorism and everything that is bad, you should ask your government questions, don't you?

Last I checked, was Israel flaying Palestinians alive to make lampshades, marching palestinians across minefields, randomly executing 10 for every Israeli killed, hanging hamas members with piano wire, rounding them up into concentration camps where disease, starvation and overwork killed them, ripping their fillings out for gold, sending women into forced prostitution, conjoining twins, subjecting them to unit-731 esque experiments etc?

Israel isn't the spawn of all horror in the universe.
 
Last I checked, was Israel flaying Palestinians alive to make lampshades, marching palestinians across minefields, randomly executing 10 for every Israeli killed, hanging hamas members with piano wire, rounding them up into concentration camps where disease, starvation and overwork killed them, ripping their fillings out for gold, sending women into forced prostitution, conjoining twins, subjecting them to unit-731 esque experiments etc?

Israel isn't the spawn of all horror in the universe.

I am not aware of all stupidities you hear in Fox news and others US medias and i won't comment on all these idioties.
 
The tragedy at the school is indeed sending the "Death To Israel" left into a feeding frenzy...and,sad to say, some mainsteam liberal sites seem to have jumped on the bandwagon,the Huffpo becoming a two minute hate.
 
Your own source contradicts your hysterical claims. Look at the picture of the flechettes stuck in the wall. Notice something about that photo? They're stuck in the wall! They don't penetrate! The photo is itself proof that these munitions do exactly the opposite of what you claim: they make it safer for civilians.
Right, a photo is proof of everything. :rolleyes:

The article described them as an "imprecise weapon which is likely to result in civilian injuries." If that is misinformation, then I apologize and will gladly be corrected... as Reheat calmly did. Calling me "hysterical" was completely uncalled for and borders on personal attacks.

If it were "Genocide", Israel would be marching Palestinians across minefields, rounding them up into barns and burning them alive, launching bubonic plague into Gaza and giving food laced with anthrax, forcing sons to rape mothers and fathers to rape daughters, Impaling thousands of Palestinians on the road to Jerusalem and leaving a pyramid of skulls where Gaza once stood.
What... That's probably the stupidest post in the entire thread, and we've seen gems from Jules and CE, so that's saying a lot.

No, Israel isn't committing genocide, but also no, those absurd hypotheticals are not required to fulfill the "genocide" criteria. Christ...
 
Right, a photo is proof of everything. :rolleyes:

It demonstrates quite a lot in this case, if you had been willing to think about what it meant for even a moment.

The article described them as an "imprecise weapon which is likely to result in civilian injuries." If that is misinformation, then I apologize and will gladly be corrected... as Reheat calmly did. Calling me "hysterical" was completely uncalled for and borders on personal attacks.

I called your claims hysterical. Whether or not you were hysterical is a different matter, one I will not touch upon. The evidence in the very link you provided contradicted your claim, not only the photo but even the text. Six tank shells fired, and only one civilian injured. How is it possible that you can look at such numbers and conclude from it that these tank shells pose any greater danger than ordinary munitions? It makes no sense whatsoever. It certainly isn't supported by actual events. How am I to interpret your failure to grasp what should have been obvious, that the use of these shells was clearly of no particular danger to civilians, given that war is intrinsically dangerous? Calling your claim hysterical is, frankly, among the more charitable interpretations.

You ask me to be calm and reasoned in my response, but you displayed none of those qualities yourself when you made the incendiary charge against Israel, a charge far more serious than I have leveled against you, and one which was wholly and obviously unsupported.
 
Right, a photo is proof of everything. :rolleyes:

The article described them as an "imprecise weapon which is likely to result in civilian injuries." If that is misinformation, then I apologize and will gladly be corrected... as Reheat calmly did. Calling me "hysterical" was completely uncalled for and borders on personal attacks.


What... That's probably the stupidest post in the entire thread, and we've seen gems from Jules and CE, so that's saying a lot.

No, Israel isn't committing genocide, but also no, those absurd hypotheticals are not required to fulfill the "genocide" criteria. Christ...

all those "Absud hypotheticals" actually happened in 20th century genocides (whether by the Nazis, imperial Japanese or the Khmer Rouge.)
 
all those "Absud hypotheticals" actually happened in 20th century genocides (whether by the Nazis, imperial Japanese or the Khmer Rouge.)

Well.. When people pull the rope too much (say, Jews in the 1920s) it is logical that the other side gets quite angry
Whatever will happen to the Jews in a few months or years, you can`t say they did all they could to avoid :D
 
What... That's probably the stupidest post in the entire thread, and we've seen gems from Jules and CE, so that's saying a lot.

It isn't even remotely close. not saying you are wrong in what you are criticizing about the post, but seriously if you think that you haven't been reading this thread for the last few pages (or was it just hyperbole like Sentryman's post seemed to me to be)
 
Last edited:
couple of things

1. the nasa photo of the gaza conflict from space - anyone know if this response is correct? http://www.timesofisrael.com/astronauts-tweet-not-gaza-bombing-professor/
I can't find a non-Israeli source supporting this

2. the UNRWA school - there are some reports that Hamas rockets were landing in the area and a couple of reports that at least one hit the school, and the IDF is claiming that UNRWA are misrepresenting some of what happened in the lead-up to the tragedy. Again I struggle to find a non-Israeli source for that. Certainly I'm not going to take either Israeli media or UNRWA themselves as sufficiently unbiased and credible.
 
couple of things

1. the nasa photo of the gaza conflict from space - anyone know if this response is correct? http://www.timesofisrael.com/astronauts-tweet-not-gaza-bombing-professor/
I can't find a non-Israeli source supporting this

There are lots of pictures of earth at night from space. What those pictures mostly show is street lights, which basically map out cities. They all look like that. And you don't need a source to check this, just put the picture up next to Google Maps. It does indeed match the geography as labelled.
 
Here's some interesting discussion on a Radio 4 programme called The Moral Maze where they are discussing war crimes.

Basically, Melanie Philips and a British Army colonel are on Israel's side and Ted Honderich is on Hamas's side (you have to listen to his contribution to at least hear a balls-out support for terrorism).

The rest of the programme features a lot of bickering, naturally, and questions about whether either side is morally justified in its actions.

Mehdi Hasan and Giles Fraser both condemn Hamas, but mostly blame Israel. Some of the others are not so supportive of Israel but mostly blame Hamas.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04b1v8q
 
There are lots of pictures of earth at night from space. What those pictures mostly show is street lights, which basically map out cities. They all look like that. And you don't need a source to check this, just put the picture up next to Google Maps. It does indeed match the geography as labelled.

yes but the tweet from the ISS astronaut was: "My saddest photo yet. From the International Space Station we can actually see explosions and rockets flying over Gaza and Israel.”

which would imply you can see them in the photo he's posting, this article claims it is untrue. The labelling of the geography is from the response not the original tweet. Is it true that they would have been able to see them from space? If you can't see the conflict in the photo, how is it so sad? why not take a picture of the DRC or North Korea at any time ever, it'll be more sad.
 
Here's some interesting discussion on a Radio 4 programme called The Moral Maze where they are discussing war crimes.

Basically, Melanie Philips and a British Army colonel are on Israel's side and Ted Honderich is on Hamas's side (you have to listen to his contribution to at least hear a balls-out support for terrorism).

The rest of the programme features a lot of bickering, naturally, and questions about whether either side is morally justified in its actions.

Mehdi Hasan and Giles Fraser both condemn Hamas, but mostly blame Israel. Some of the others are not so supportive of Israel but mostly blame Hamas.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04b1v8q

but to listen to that you have to listen to both Melanie Philips (shudder) and Mehdi Hasan (urgh). I actually prefer Hasan to that witch.
 
yes but the tweet from the ISS astronaut was: "My saddest photo yet. From the International Space Station we can actually see explosions and rockets flying over Gaza and Israel.”

which would imply you can see them in the photo he's posting, this article claims it is untrue.

Yes, the claim is obviously untrue.

The labelling of the geography is from the response not the original tweet.

I know that. In my previous post, I argued that the labeling of geography was correct, and that you could verify that yourself. Given that geography, individual missiles and explosions would obviously be far too small to actually resolve, let alone identify, in that photograph.

Is it true that they would have been able to see them from space?

It's conceivable that he might have seen more than what showed up in the photo. But I really doubt it.

If you can't see the conflict in the photo, how is it so sad?

It's not. Which is why it's rather baffling that he made such a post. He's either a knave or a villain, and neither answer is encouraging.

why not take a picture of the DRC or North Korea at any time ever, it'll be more sad.

Quite so.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom