For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

No scientists are suggesting 'we' should 'lie and exaggerate' in the first place.

The fact that lies and exaggerations on AGW are rife in the media, news, and from the likes of Gore, does not mean that "scientists are suggesting we should lie and exaggerate". So your point is....?

RE Science mag, let's break that down. Science writes about the latest IPCC report, summarizing it. Probably summarizing the "Summary for Policymakers" which is the summary of ten or twelve very involved chapters. Each chapter is a review, a summary of science in the area to which that chapter pertains.


yeah, you *break that down* without having read it. That sounds like a great plan, centurion. Let's see how it *breaks down*

You've got in the Science mage, a commentary on a summary of a summary, at the best.


Well, no. Looks like your plan *broke down* already. You really should try reading the actual article, centurion. It's about scientists examining ALL the evidence, not just the summaries.


The latest reports from the nobel Prize-winning Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) were informative enough. Humans are messing with climate and will, sooner or later, get burned if they keep it up. But just how urgent is this global warming business?

IPCC wasn't at all clear on that, at least not in its summary reports. In the absence of forthright guidance from the scientific community, news about melting ice and starving polar bears has stoked the public climate frenzy of the past couple of years. Climate researchers, on the other hand, prefer science to headlines when considering just how imminent the coming climate crunch might be. With a chance to digest the detailed IPCC products that are now available (www.ipcc.ch), many scientists are more convinced than ever that immediate action is required. The time to start "is right now," says climate modeler Gerald Meehl of the National Center for Atmospheric Research in Boulder, Colorado. "We can't wait any longer."

.
.
.
.

Bad things, soon
The disturbing message on the timing of global warming's effects comes in the IPCC chapters and technical summaries quietly posted online months after each of three working groups released a much-publicized Summary for Policymakers (SPM). An overall synthesis of the working group reports was released Saturday at the 27th session of IPCC. Earlier this year, only the SPMs went through the wringer of word-by-word negotiations with governments, which squeezed out a crucial table and part of another (Science, 13 April, p. 188). That information--which was always in the full reports--along with other report material, makes it clear that substantial impacts are likely to arrive sooner rather than later.
 
Last edited:
yeah, you *break that down* without having read it. That sounds like a great plan, centurion. Let's see how it *breaks down*

Well, no. Looks like your plan *broke down* already. You really should try reading the actual article, centurion. It's about scientists examining ALL the evidence, not just the summaries.

On JREF, recently we have had extensive discussion (and in some cases, continuing disagreement) on the following topics in which IPCC was cited heavily -
  1. radiative forcing chart and constituant parts
  2. is water vapor a positive or negative feedback
  3. are clouds correctly accounted for by IPCC
  4. why/is it accurate the 1993 quadrupling of sea level rise cited by IPCC
  5. 20 foot "wall of water", does IPCC science support this if so over what time frame.
Perhaps you were not aware of that?
 
That's rich coming from you,you damnable liar.



You didn't HINT -- you LEFT OUT that fact that the LEADER of the study does NOT consider it to be evidence against AGW, you damnable liar.



this research DOESN'T do that, you damnable liar.



YOU are the one who cited the study as part of a set of ostensibly anti-AGW research, you damnable liar.

btw, has 'Token Conservative' answered the two questions posed in the first post yet?
You haven't answered any question and your point is not done. I posted the very bit you quoted before, showing the controversy on the results.
You still don't get it, don't you? The study was about Melting. It found AGW models in error. Later, the team leader says that it can't be seem as a disproving of the AGW hypothesis, wich is true, and that HE THINKS that AGW still have value BUT THAT IS NOT THE RESULT OF THE STUDY. The study didn't touch the CO2 hypothesis, so the comment has nothing to do with the study. If he have had say "But this don't disprove the great flood, and I think the great flood theory is correct" it would have had the same science backup his real comment did, ie none. Learn to read and how to separate facts from opinion. Or even better, bring to the table studies by this guy supporting the theory that man made CO2 is causing global warming. Commenting that supposed study, he can of course say "Yes, this study probes AGW".
I hope you see the difference. And you still cherrypicked, why don't yoou take the others I posted?
 
I thought I would jump in in this thread. I live in Oregon where our state climatologist, George Taylor, rejects the theory of anthropogenic global warming and as such, has angered our environmentalist governor Ted Kulongoski and he wishes to relieve him of his title. A disgusting example of politics trumping science. What troubles me most in the GW debate is exactly that: the politics. Why can't we stick to science?
When I read things like "every single climatologist" as was stated earlier or comparing AGW denialists to creationists, it makes my skin crawl. Lets be honest here, by a substantial majority most scientists support AGW. There has been countless peer review studies supporting it. On the other hand, in the minority, there are scientists who don't buy it. Smart, qualified scientists and although a minority, I don't think they should be dismissed nor should we completely deny their existence. This minority, we should acknowledge is indeed a minority, but not a "fringe" minority like creationists with Biology PhDs. In other words, we should listen to their expert opinions. And before you dismiss them as in the hands corporate interests, consider how much government funding there is for scientists studying AGW.

An even more difficult question is what should/can we do about AGW? Should we buy Carbon credits that will plant trees in mid latitudes? According to Scientific American, more trees in boreal forests will contribute to global warming:
http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?chanID=sa003&articleID=DCA231BA-E7F2-99DF-3105874539B83ECB&ref=rss

My point is that this subject is so complex it makes my head spin and although I'm very interested in the topic, I don't have the knowledge to have a truly informed opinion to take a stance. You can't even think in terms of cause and effect (CO2 causes more warming) but need to understand things in terms of feedback loops (C02 causes warming and warming causes more CO2), its like studying feedback circuits in electronics which drove me crazy. Consider the question of trees:
1)Trees will remove CO2 from the air (good)
2)Trees will increase evaporation of H2O via transpiration. H2O is a greenhouse gas and will increase global warming but it will also increase clouds increasing Earths albedo decreasing global warming
3)Trees may increase Earths albedo increasing global warming

So are trees good or bad for global warming? I sure don't know. Generally, I think we should take the threat of AGW very seriously indeed but certainly not at the expense of silencing legitimate dissenting scientific opinions or pretending there is no debate whatsoever and that we can simply dismiss the opposing side as loons
He is not the only threatened for that. At least other two state climatologist have been fired because they dare to voice their opinion about...er....the climate.
 
What troubles me most in the GW debate is exactly that: the politics. Why can't we stick to science?

When I read things like "every single climatologist" as was stated earlier or comparing AGW denialists to creationists, it makes my skin crawl. Lets be honest here, by a substantial majority most scientists support AGW. There has been countless peer review studies supporting it.

On the other hand, in the minority, there are scientists who don't buy it. Smart, qualified scientists and although a minority, I don't think they should be dismissed nor should we completely deny their existence. This minority, we should acknowledge is indeed a minority, but not a "fringe" minority like creationists with Biology PhDs. In other words, we should listen to their expert opinions. And before you dismiss them as in the hands corporate interests, consider how much government funding there is for scientists studying AGW.

An even more difficult question is what should/can we do about AGW? Should we buy Carbon credits that will plant trees in mid latitudes? According to Scientific American, more trees in boreal forests will contribute to global warming:
http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?chanID=sa003&articleID=DCA231BA-E7F2-99DF-3105874539B83ECB&ref=rss

My point is that this subject is so complex it makes my head spin and although I'm very interested in the topic, I don't have the knowledge to have a truly informed opinion to take a stance. You can't even think in terms of cause and effect (CO2 causes more warming) but need to understand things in terms of feedback loops (C02 causes warming and warming causes more CO2), its like studying feedback circuits in electronics which drove me crazy. Consider the question of trees:
1)Trees will remove CO2 from the air (good)
2)Trees will increase evaporation of H2O via transpiration. H2O is a greenhouse gas and will increase global warming but it will also increase clouds increasing Earths albedo decreasing global warming
3)Trees may increase Earths albedo increasing global warming

So are trees good or bad for global warming? I sure don't know. Generally, I think we should take the threat of AGW very seriously indeed but certainly not at the expense of silencing legitimate dissenting scientific opinions or pretending there is no debate whatsoever and that we can simply dismiss the opposing side as loons

You covered a LOT briefly there. Make no mistake about it, there is really big money in AGW. Just convince people that carbon trading is needed, then take their money and plant trees.

Ooopsss. Trees maybe don't work?

I've studied this in detail and it bothered me. The reason is that you pay money to get something done, eg., pull carbon dioxide out of the air in certain quantities. But the science keeps flip flopping on whether the trees you bought actually do that. So what you bought was sort of a wish or a guess that some good might be done, not an actual quantifiable "public good service". I could go on about this matter, but it would probably bore most people.

Also note that there is black soot, land use changes, and Asian brown cloud as serious sources of AGW (Skeptics agree with this). Focus on the CO2 greenhouse gas driver, legislate that, and ignore the other factors? There could be a real problem there. Skeptics are pointing to science that shows CO2 may be less important than these other factors.

Meanwhile in public media there is virtually no attention paid to these other factors which Hansen himself has noted ("Alternative Scenario" paper, I think 2000, also Hansen 2007) are equally important as CO2.
 
The problem is that have already found their answer (is man made) and they are trying to make facts fit that answer. That's why I posted a peer reviewed study that links all climatic change in the last century to natural causes.

Their models incorporate many factors, CO2 is only one. They can run the models with no increase in CO2, and then they don't track the climate record.
 
Last edited:
I thought I would jump in in this thread. I live in Oregon where our state climatologist, George Taylor, rejects the theory of anthropogenic global warming and as such, has angered our environmentalist governor Ted Kulongoski and he wishes to relieve him of his title. A disgusting example of politics trumping science. What troubles me most in the GW debate is exactly that: the politics. Why can't we stick to science?

In fact the "state climatologist" scam was an excellent example of politics trumping science. The few deniers in the climatologist camp managed to find a moribund body, the "State Climatologist", and hijack it for their own needs, that is, gaining credbility. Funding for the organisation had been pulled since it was seen as being irrelevant, so most of the positions were not filled. Along came Taylor and a few friends to claim a title that was not being used, and bingo, instant credbility.

When I read things like "every single climatologist" as was stated earlier or comparing AGW denialists to creationists, it makes my skin crawl. Lets be honest here, by a substantial majority most scientists support AGW. There has been countless peer review studies supporting it. On the other hand, in the minority, there are scientists who don't buy it. Smart, qualified scientists and although a minority, I don't think they should be dismissed nor should we completely deny their existence. This minority, we should acknowledge is indeed a minority, but not a "fringe" minority like creationists with Biology PhDs. In other words, we should listen to their expert opinions. And before you dismiss them as in the hands corporate interests, consider how much government funding there is for scientists studying AGW.

I can find a good number of scientists and even biologists who believe in creationism. That will always be the case, scientists are human.
 
I give Shadron the same response you got (it's a 2001 paper) and a link to a study which explains recent findings about the inverse link in temperature in both hemispheres.

There's no recent inverse relation between temperatures in the NH and SH. Global warming is just that - global. I think aup can confirm that for us, he's our man-on-the-spot. Any sign of hemispheric cooling down your way, aup?

You've simply provided another example of taking refuge in the past.

A small increase in Antarctic ice is not evidence of hemispheric cooling. It's not even direct evidence of Antarctic cooling. A lot of the Antarctic ice flows off the continent onto the sea-bed and beyond. The rate of flow can be increased by meltwater (a lubricant) infliltrating to ground-level. The flow can also be accelerated by increased precipitation resulting from Southern Ocean warming.

As a passing note, the "record" Antarctic ice is only a record since 1979. It's still far less ice than in the fifties. The summer ice-melt in the Arctic is an all-time record for the last few centuries of observation and exploration.
 
In fact the "state climatologist" scam was an excellent example of politics trumping science. The few deniers in the climatologist camp managed to find a moribund body, the "State Climatologist", and hijack it for their own needs, that is, gaining credbility. Funding for the organisation had been pulled since it was seen as being irrelevant, so most of the positions were not filled. Along came Taylor and a few friends to claim a title that was not being used, and bingo, instant credbility.

Entryism at its most blatant. "State Climatologist" sounds like a shiny title, but working state climatologists (in those states that have them) are mostly meteorologists and hydrologists advising their State on water resources and management. The AASC was a denialist pulpit that had little or nothing to do with them.
 
There's no recent inverse relation between temperatures in the NH and SH. Global warming is just that - global. I think aup can confirm that for us, he's our man-on-the-spot. Any sign of hemispheric cooling down your way, aup?

You've simply provided another example of taking refuge in the past.

A small increase in Antarctic ice is not evidence of hemispheric cooling. It's not even direct evidence of Antarctic cooling. A lot of the Antarctic ice flows off the continent onto the sea-bed and beyond. The rate of flow can be increased by meltwater (a lubricant) infliltrating to ground-level. The flow can also be accelerated by increased precipitation resulting from Southern Ocean warming.

As a passing note, the "record" Antarctic ice is only a record since 1979. It's still far less ice than in the fifties. The summer ice-melt in the Arctic is an all-time record for the last few centuries of observation and exploration.

Getting hotter, worst drought on record. The Southern Hemisphere is getting hotter slower because there is more ocean down south.

http://www.bom.gov.au/cgi-bin/silo/reg/cli_chg/timeseries.cgi?variable=tmean&region=aus&season=0112
 
Last edited:
AUP, what I find is way different than what you said. Looks completely above board and legitimate.



http://www.stateclimate.org/
The Annual Meeting of the AASC is held each summer.
History of AASC Annual Meetings (PDF: 69.0 kB)
AASC_Meetings.pdf (applicationpdf Object)

State Climatologists

Alabama

Dr. Richard McNider
Department of Atmospheric Sciences
University of Alabama in Huntsville
977 Explorer Drive
Huntsville, AL 35806

T: 205-922-5752
F: 205-922-5755
I: [email protected]

Alaska

Dr. Dwight D. Pollard
Alaska State Climate Center
Environment and Natural Resources Institute
707 A Street
Anchorage, AK 99501

T: 907-257-2741
F: 907-276-6847
I: [email protected]

Arizona

Dr. Anthony J. Brazel
Laboratory of Climatology
Arizona State University
Tempe, AZ 85287-1508

T: 602-965-6265
B: [email protected]
<URL:http://saguaro.la.asu.edu/ooc/general/state/>

Arkansas

Dr. John G. Hehr
Dept of Geography
Ozark Hall 108A
University of Arkansas
Fayetteville, AR 72701

T: 501-575-3159
F: 501-575-2642
I: [email protected]

California

Mr. William A. Mork
CA Dept of Water Resources
Division of Flood Management
P.O. Box 942836
Sacramento, CA 94236-0001

T: 916-653-7237

Colorado

Dr. Thomas McKee
Colorado Climate Center
Dept of Atmospheric Science
Colorado State University
Ft. Collins, CO 80523

T: 303-491-8545
I: [email protected]
(Nolan Doesken, Asst. SC)
<URL:http://ulysses.atmos.colostate.edu/>

Connecticut

Dr. David R. Miller
Dept of Natural Resources-U87
1376 Storrs Road
University of Connecticut
Storrs, CT 06269-4087

T: 203-486-2840
B: dmiller@uconnvm

Delaware

Dr. Daniel J. Leathers
Center for Climatic Research
210 Newark Hall
Dept of Geography
University of Delaware
Newark, DE 19716

T: 302-831-2294
F: 302-831-6654
<URL:http://www.udel.edu/leathers/stclim.html>

Florida

Dr. Kevin Kloesel
Dept of Meteorology
Florida State University
Tallahassee, FL 32306-3034

T: 904-644-1268
I: [email protected]
<URL:http://www.ispa.fsu.edu/climate.html>

on and on and on...
 
I was giving you the history of the organisation. Many of the members more or less appointed themselves, since the seats were vacant and the organisation moribund.

I assume it must rank as an organization to be discredited, since they had some anti-AGW stands. As far as the organization, you can look at my links to all the minutes of the annual meetings and topics discussed. They have useful work they do. Mostly not about AGW. Scanning four or five of the meetings, I didn't see the topic, although obviously it must have been discussed.

So they went anti-AGW. Big deal, so what.
 
I'd appreciate that. Doing otherwise will be cherry picking.

Actually, making hay with your more egregious cites would be cherry-picking. And I may well do that. Up to now I've taken stuff pretty much from the top, missing out some that was really old.

You've not made any response yet to the comments I have posted, so for now I'll leave it as a general demonstration of the inadequacy of your cites to make your case - that the reality of AGW is still a scientifically contentious issue. It isn't.

Regarding cherry-picking, where did you find all those cites?
 
Getting hotter, worst drought on record. The Southern Hemisphere is getting hotter slower because there is more ocean down south.

http://www.bom.gov.au/cgi-bin/silo/reg/cli_chg/timeseries.cgi?variable=tmean&region=aus&season=0112

That confirms what I've been hearing.

I've no problem with there being inverse relationships in the past, they're what you'd expect from a variation in the way heat is distributed around the globe.

What doesn't impress me at all is people bringing up events in historic conditions when it's the peculiar conditions of the modern world that are at issue. 380ppmCO2- most peculiar.

Were we to follow one contrarian argument that springs to mind (there is more ice in Antarctica, ergo it's getting colder in the Southern Hemisphere, ergo there's a hemispheric trade-off going on that's been going on since forever) you'd still find local conditions just as warm.
 
I assume it must rank as an organization to be discredited, since they had some anti-AGW stands. As far as the organization, you can look at my links to all the minutes of the annual meetings and topics discussed. They have useful work they do. Mostly not about AGW. Scanning four or five of the meetings, I didn't see the topic, although obviously it must have been discussed.

So they went anti-AGW. Big deal, so what.

It's like saying a scientific body went creationist.
 
I assume it must rank as an organization to be discredited ...

Hardly. Being discredited militates against such promotion.

... since they had some anti-AGW stands.

Discredited because it was an anti-AGW sock-puppet. It discredited itself, by circular email.

As far as the organization, you can look at my links to all the minutes of the annual meetings and topics discussed. They have useful work they do. Mostly not about AGW. Scanning four or five of the meetings, I didn't see the topic, although obviously it must have been discussed.

So they went anti-AGW. Big deal, so what.

The big deal would be if they didn't right from the start, which they did, and they struggled constantly to maintain that stance as the evidence flooded in. There is useful work that it can do by bringing practical people together to discuss practical issues, but its political stance has ridden piggy-back on that.

In Leninist terms the tactic is known as entryism. Lenin was one heck of a tactician.
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
I assume it must rank as an organization to be discredited ...


​
Hardly. Being discredited militates against such promotion.
Quote:
... since they had some anti-AGW stands.
​
Discredited because it was an anti-AGW sock-puppet. It discredited itself, by circular email.

Circular email discreditature? How does that work?

discredited militates against such promotion.


Chicken and egging a bit?:)

Enough on them. My links include their meeting minutes. Nothing I saw there supports such ire, when it would be focused on them strictly due to their position on this single issue.
 
Entryism at its most blatant. "State Climatologist" sounds like a shiny title, but working state climatologists (in those states that have them) are mostly meteorologists and hydrologists advising their State on water resources and management. The AASC was a denialist pulpit that had little or nothing to do with them.
This is news to me. According to their website, they have been around since 1976. If I understand you correctly, this position became non paying and was "infiltrated" by non AGW's? I was also under the impression that the majority of state climatologists are supporters of AGW so the infiltration was only moderately successful. Nevertheless, there are plenty of qualified AGW dissenters that would hardly fall into such an extreme minority such as the creationists among the biologists.

http://www.stateclimate.org/about/
Founded in 1976, the American Association of State Climatologists is a professional scientific organization composed of state climatologists (one per state), directors of the six Regional Climate Centers and associate members who are persons interested in the goals and activities of the Association. State Climatologists are individuals who have been identified by a state entity as the state's climatologist and who are also recognized by the Director of the National Climatic Data Center (NCDC) of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration as the state climatologist of a particular state.

State Climatologists currently exist in 47 states and Puerto Rico. They are typically either employees of state agencies or are staff members of state-supported universities. Associate members may be assistant state climatologists or other climatologists under the employ of the state climatologist; representatives of federal climate agencies; retired state climatologists; or others interested in climate services. The total membership of the Association is approximately 150.

Members work closely with other climate services partners including NCDC, the NOAA Regional Climate Centers, and the National Weather Service. A strong partnership with these organizations is being nourished. This activity helps provide improved climate services for the nation through greater integration of data quality control, improved communication among the sector, and more coordinated referral of customer inquiries.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom