Why would I be kidding? Please read my post again, although I admit I wasn't exactly on best form when I wrote it (see the big edit for example, very easy to pick apart if you have the inclination

) so I may not have been very clear.
Anyway...you will notice that I don't say that I am in total agreement with CDs assertion, merely that your rebuttal was rather lacking in substance. I said that CD might be right, but that I don't know if he is or not. I also said that in any case, you didn't provide any information to the contrary.
My real issue with your post was that I think that if people use sources to back up their statements, then the sources should at least be relevent to the statement being made. In the context of this thread, "Where should we get our information from..." I think I made a fair challenge.
I didn't see how your source was relevent. I still don't, at least in the way you presented it. I haven't read the paper so...
I provided the satellite data as it gives us at least one piece of the data required to make a judgement on CDs statement. This past summers ice melt figures for the arctic.
If you want to rebut his point all you have to do is show historical figures that show greater ice melt over the last few centuries. Simple.
CD might have a source he could share perhaps?