For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

At a loss? Can you not think of any way of identifying the scientific mainstream re. climate science?

Nothing coming to mind at all....?

Anybody?

As for the rest of your post, and what you think I was 'asserting', no. Just... no.

I misunderstood then apparently.

I only seek to apply here same legal theory and standard used in the Bush-Hansen incident improperly spun and publicized as Bush repressing scientific opinion.
 
Right...

If anything, the opposite. Politics could do with being more 'scienceized': basing decisions on the scientific mainstream, not the fringe.

Isn't that a laudable goal?

Indeed it is. Which is not at all to say that science should usurp the role of politics (that way disaster lies) any more than finance, the military, or any industrial sector should. Good government takes a dispassionate view of advice coming from all these fields and acts accordingly.

Of course, I'm of the opinion that science is uniquely valuable because it is explicitly disinterested, and only bad science fails that test. What most riles me about the contrarian argument is that it claims the self-contradictory climate fringe as disinterested science, while the mainstream is politicised. Then they provide links to the Heritage Institute website to prove it.

That's why I keep going at this. I don't expect to make any difference, but when friends of mine are being traduced by such egregious tactics I will not stay quiet.
 
There was a period when the AACS was infiltrated
That is a very underhanded political tactic indeed. Can you provide a few names of these individuals? In the case of Taylor, I don't think he qualifies as part of that campaign. According to the Willamette Week, he's been a vegetarian since the 70's, commutes to work by bike, recycles, likes trees and salmon, etc. He's also held that title since 1991. Instead of keeping someone with his qualifications and experience, perhaps the governorship could find a better spokesperson from Greenpeace or some other organization, qualifications optional for the title of "state climatologist". Kulongoski makes no criticism of Taylors qualifications, nor does he accuse him of entryism or being otherwise compromised by outside interests, he simply disagrees with his politics.
 
I only seek to apply here same legal theory and standard used in the Bush-Hansen incident improperly spun and publicized as Bush repressing scientific opinion.

It was certainly improperly spun if it implied Bush initiating anything. The Bush Administration is a different matter.

Despite your promotion of Hansen to Presidential equivalence, what you're probably referring to concerns political appointees at NASA, not POTUS.
 
Carbon sequestration is science fiction.

Indeed it is. Which is not at all to say that science should usurp the role of politics (that way disaster lies) any more than finance, the military, or any industrial sector should. Good government takes a dispassionate view of advice coming from all these fields and acts accordingly.

Of course, I'm of the opinion that science is uniquely valuable because it is explicitly disinterested, and only bad science fails that test. What most riles me about the contrarian argument is that it claims the self-contradictory climate fringe as disinterested science, while the mainstream is politicised. Then they provide links to the Heritage Institute website to prove it.

That's why I keep going at this. I don't expect to make any difference, but when friends of mine are being traduced by such egregious tactics I will not stay quiet.

No need to quote Heritage, AGW Alarmists abound. Yes, they are politicized. They are not disinterested objective scientists. Here ya go -
Dr. Hansen gave on Oct. 22 before the utilities board of his native state, Iowa. He pressed the case for forbidding the construction of new coal-burning power plants unless and until technologies were developed to capture and store the heat-trapping carbon dioxide emissions. The full text of the testimony is at Dr. Hansen’s Columbia University home page, columbia.edu/~jeh1/.

“Coal will determine whether we continue to increase climate change or slow the human impact....I drove from Denison to Dunlap, where my parents are buried. For most of 20 miles there were trains parked, engine to caboose, half of the cars being filled with coal. If we cannot stop the building of more coal-fired power plants, those coal trains will be death trains – no less gruesome than if they were boxcars headed to crematoria, loaded with uncountable irreplaceable species.”
​
Note 1: Carbon sequestration is science fiction.

Note 2: Hansen never mentions nuclear power.
 
Thanks for the link. From the article:

Doesn't sound like he got the job via an Entryism effort(1991
?) ...

Not the job the shiny title.

Taylor has held the title of "state climatologist" since 1991 when the legislature created a state climate office at OSU The university created the job title, not the state.

A classic example of entryism. From being a guy at OSU to State Climatologist by OSU fiat (OSU being a "state entity") recognised by NOAA because they deliver Oregon's weather data. And thence to Secretary-General of the AACS, much-quoted as a credible contrarian source on the back of the shiny title.

Those who do not understand Leninism are likely to get screwed by it.
 
Not to change the topic, but why is carbon sequestration science fiction? Don't we already pump CO2 into oil fields?

It isn't science fiction. It's being actively researched. To me that makes it at least science.

Not ready for the mainstream yet, sure.
 
Looks like these were state clim. positions going back to 1970s.
Contrary evidence?

The title of Oregon State Climatologist is apparently more recent.

Evidence?

I give you

Founded in 1976, the American Association of State Climatologists is a professional scientific organization composed of state climatologists (one per state), directors of the six Regional Climate Centers and associate members who are persons interested in the goals and activities of the Association.

Said goals and activities being determined by activists who will be well-represented amongst the associate members who apparently are judged (in ill-defined way) on their interest rather than their disinterest.

A classic target for entryism.

Evidence?

Come on, you must have heard that Michaels has given it up?

Conspiracy theory?

Are you drunk?
 
Note 1: Carbon sequestration is science fiction.


Hansen didn't claim that it wasn't. Stop until something happens doesn't imply that it will happen. It does mean Stop.

Note 2: Hansen never mentions nuclear power.

Isn't nuclear generation implicit in stopping coal-fueled generation? From what I can see Hansen was talking about coal.

To my mind he's dead right in re-directing attention from oil to the foundation fossil-fuel that's still widely-available - even more wildly than oil used to be. Peak Coal is on nobody's priority list.
 
"Arctic sea ice thickness remained constant during the 1990s
Winsor P - Geophysical Research Letters 28 (6): 1039-1041 Mar 15 2001

Abstract: The ice cover of the Arctic Ocean is considered to be a sensitive indicator of global climate change. Recent research, using submarine-based observations, suggests that the Arctic ice cover was thinner in the 1990s compared to an earlier period (1958-1979), and that it continued to decrease in thickness in the 1990s. Here I analyze subsurface ice thickness (draft) of Arctic sea ice from six submarine cruises from 1991 to 1997. This extensive data set shows that there was no trend towards a thinning ice cover during the 1990s. Data from the North Pole shows a slight increase in mean ice thickness, whereas the Beaufort Sea shows a small decrease, none of which are significant. Transects between the two areas from 76 degrees N to 90 degrees N also show near constant ice thicknesses, with a general spatial decrease from the Pole towards the Beaufort Sea. Combining the present results with those of an earlier study, I conclude that the mean ice thickness has remained on a near-constant level around the North Pole from 1986 to 1997."

Other contemporary research came to a different conclusion, so I guess the jury was still out on this. One point that intrigues me about the conclusion is the reference to "around the North Pole", rather than "in the Arctic Ocean". Why the distinction? The first answer that springs to mind is that the author's conclusion specifically refers to the most northerly ice, not Arctic ice in toto.

If Arctic ice-cover is a sensitive indicator of climate change, what are we to make of events since 1997? Summer 2005 saw a record low in Arctic ice-extent, and that record was smashed in summer 2007. It's hard to explain this rapid loss of ice without a cumulative thinning over previous decades. I'm bound to wonder just what merit this particular paper retains after another decade of observation.

Ice cover is the area covered by ice. The thing that jumps out in this article is the unsubstantiated claim that ice cover equtes to ice thickness. IDenying climate change based on ice thickness measurements is therefore a classic strawman argument.
 
Not to change the topic, but why is carbon sequestration science fiction? Don't we already pump CO2 into oil fields?

I think what mhaze means - in his over-stated manner - is that financially-viable carbon sequestration on a general scale is speculative.

The science is there, and on a small-scale there's proven technology. What's lacking is a financial incentive.
 
Ice cover is the area covered by ice. The thing that jumps out in this article is the unsubstantiated claim that ice cover equtes to ice thickness. IDenying climate change based on ice thickness measurements is therefore a classic strawman argument.

Thin ice warniing :).

Ice extent, ice cover, ice volume ... that way madness lies.

The abstract does get well into ice-thickness, and concludes it was near-constant over the period of two tacked-together studies.

What jumps out at me is the paucity of data - one randomised submarine cruise between the North Atlantic and the Western Arctic per annum is an extensive dataset? - and the paper's well-deserved obscurity. The fact that it's thrust into the limelight ten years later is evidence of very thin contrarian pickings these days.
 
As a passing note, the "record" Antarctic ice is only a record since 1979. It's still far less ice than in the fifties. The summer ice-melt in the Arctic is an all-time record for the last few centuries of observation and exploration.
You appear to be incorrect.
JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH, VOL. 111, C01001, doi:10.1029/2004JC002851, 2006

Historical variability of sea ice edge position in the Nordic Seas
Dmitry V. Divine and Dr. Chad Dick

Abstract Historical ice observations in the Nordic Seas from April through August are used to construct time series of ice edge position anomalies spanning the period 1750–2002. While analysis showed that interannual variability remained almost constant throughout this period, evidence was found of oscillations in ice cover with periods of about 60 to 80 years and 20 to 30 years, superimposed on a continuous negative trend. The lower frequency oscillations are more prominent in the Greenland Sea, while higher frequency oscillations are dominant in the Barents. The analysis suggests that the recent well-documented retreat of ice cover can partly be attributed to a manifestation of the positive phase of the 60–80 year variability, associated with the warming of the subpolar North Atlantic and the Arctic. The continuous retreat of ice edge position observed since the second half of the 19th century may be a recovery after significant cooling in the study area that occurred as early as the second half of the 18th century.

I am sure your citation does back up your assertion, but I can't figure out how. Care to help?
 
The title of Oregon State Climatologist is apparently more recent.

Said goals and activities being determined by activists who will be well-represented amongst the associate members who apparently are judged (in ill-defined way) on their interest rather than their disinterest.
A classic target for entryism.
Come on, you must have heard that Michaels has given it up?
Are you drunk?

A certain case of entryism would be Greenpeace, as the founder was interviewed by P&T and discussed this. In particular, he noted it got bent from good causes to anti capitalist, anti corporate causes as the result of individuals.

So I can assert entryism (I might be wrong, but at least I can make a case) in the case of Greenpeace. I've cited some shreds of facts which can be looked up and verified.

Neither you or AUP has cited facts or made a case regarding the asserted stealth infiltration and Leninist entryism takeover of AASC by anti-AGW conspirators.
 
Basically they find that the ice retreated similarly to what is seen today in the 1930s. So we don't have an all time record for the last few centuries of observation and exploration.

Popular article, and the arthor interviewed here.

http://thescotsman.scotsman.com/international.cfm?id=258012005

The abstract and the parts you bolded do not seem to back up your assertion.

NASA seem to think 2007 was a year of record loss since they started measuring with satellites.

http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Newsroom/NewImages/images.php3?img_id=17782

Now, their satellite measurements do not extend back as far as the log book derived data from the paper you cited. The abstract of the paper you cited does say though that the cycles they found were superimposed on a continuous negative trend, which could suggest that 2007s ice loss was a record much as Capeldodger stated. I don't know if he was right or not, but you haven't yet convinced me of the truth of your statement either.
 
Last edited:
And they figure that out using a data set that stops in 2002? Here was me thinking I was living in the tail end of 2007. Do you see my difficulty?

The abstract and the parts you bolded do not seem to back up your assertion.

NASA seem to think 2007 was a year of record loss since they started measuring with satellites.

http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Newsroom/NewImages/images.php3?img_id=17782

Now, their satellite measurements do not extend back as far as the log book derived data from the paper you cited. The abstract of the paper you cited does say though that the cycles they found were superimposed on a continuous negative trend, which could suggest that 2007s ice loss was a record much as Capeldodger stated. I don't know if he was right or not, but you haven't yet convinced me of the truth of your statement either.

I've seen no evidence - none - to support the assertion CD made. Have you? Anything? If so please present it.

Why are you referencing satellite data? You're kidding, right? The assertion concerned several centuries, not several decades.
 
I've seen no evidence - none - to support the assertion CD made. Have you? Anything? If so please present it.

Why are you referencing satellite data? You're kidding, right? The assertion concerned several centuries, not several decades.

Why would I be kidding? Please read my post again, although I admit I wasn't exactly on best form when I wrote it (see the big edit for example, very easy to pick apart if you have the inclination :D) so I may not have been very clear.

Anyway...you will notice that I don't say that I am in total agreement with CDs assertion, merely that your rebuttal was rather lacking in substance. I said that CD might be right, but that I don't know if he is or not. I also said that in any case, you didn't provide any information to the contrary.

My real issue with your post was that I think that if people use sources to back up their statements, then the sources should at least be relevent to the statement being made. In the context of this thread, "Where should we get our information from..." I think I made a fair challenge.

I didn't see how your source was relevent. I still don't, at least in the way you presented it. I haven't read the paper so...

I provided the satellite data as it gives us at least one piece of the data required to make a judgement on CDs statement. This past summers ice melt figures for the arctic.

If you want to rebut his point all you have to do is show historical figures that show greater ice melt over the last few centuries. Simple.

CD might have a source he could share perhaps?
 
Last edited:
Why would I be kidding? Please read my post again, although I admit I wasn't exactly on best form when I wrote it (see the big edit for example, very easy to pick apart if you have the inclination :D) so I may not have been very clear.

Anyway...you will notice that I don't say that I am in total agreement with CDs assertion, merely that your rebuttal was rather lacking in substance. I said that CD might be right, but that I don't know if he is or not. I also said that in any case, you didn't provide any information to the contrary.

My real issue with your post was that I think that if people use sources to back up their statements, then the sources should at least be relevent to the statement being made. In the context of this thread, "Where should we get our information from..." I think I made a fair challenge.

I didn't see how your source was relevent. I still don't, at least in the way you presented it. I haven't read the paper so...

I provided the satellite data as it gives us at least one piece of the data required to make a judgement on CDs statement. This past summers ice melt figures for the arctic.

If you want to rebut his point all you have to do is show historical figures that show greater ice melt over the last few centuries. Simple.

CD might have a source he could share perhaps?

Okay, I understand your point of view. Being realistic, any data that we have from the past will be inferential in nature. It will be from ships logs and how those correlate with AMO, PDO and the 70 year climate cycle. So are not going to have any sense of "certainty" about this subject.

However, we can establish that these climate cycles do operate in the Arctic, and that there were periods when for physical reasons the ice went to similar minima. I posted one article on that, there are others. I am not aware of any that support the claim that current melt is unprecedented historically.

So the "extravagant claim" that I think would need to prove itself up here was that current Arctic ice melting is unprecedented in several hundred years of records.

Current melt is at a minima (or was in late August - early Sept) for 30 years of satellite records.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom