For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

If you read the thread form the beggining, I was actually asked for scientific evidence from 1993 to date, so my references went from that date to 2007.

I'm hardly going to do that. My attention was drawn by the red bolding in the post on page 2 in response to varwoche, the one that starts with

Just in case you have missed my point, I'll try to clarify some abstracts:

You didn't have to drag up evidence from the 90's just because somebody asked you to. It may - just plausibly - have been a trick question, designed to elicit exactly the response it got.

I'll now get back to that post, having signed off on the section with abstracts. The next secton is new territory, thoroughly laced with links to media reports on what research papers say.
 
I'll now get back to that post, having signed off on the section with abstracts. The next secton is new territory, thoroughly laced with links to media reports on what research papers say.

and that's a BIG problem. i apprecaite that someone is bringing evidence to the table, but scientific research is often misinterpreted by the media. as i've already posted, at least one of these stories seems quite interesting, but the media's reporting may well be somewhat innacurate, to say the least.

lucifuge and mhaze, do either of you have access to a university library where you may be able to actually access some of these journals? i haven't gone through the entire list yet, but at a quick glance, a couple did seem worth tracking down. maybe we should pick out the most interesting and relavant of the research-- for example, the apparent dna found in ice core suggesting the ice survived the last serious warming-- and track down the real articles?

the problem is, whether for or against agw, media reports have a poor track record of accurate reporting of scientific research. we need to see various quotes in context.
 
"1) A 2006 study by Danish researchers from Aarhus University found that “Greenland’s glaciers have been shrinking for the past century, suggesting that the ice melt is not a recent phenomenon caused by global warming.” (LINK) Glaciologist Jacob Clement Yde explained that the study was “the most comprehensive ever conducted on the movements of Greenland’s glaciers, according to an August 21, 2006 article in Agence France-Presse. “Seventy percent of the glaciers have been shrinking regularly since the end of the 1880’s,” Yde explained. [EPW Blog note: 80% of man-made CO2 emissions occurred after 1940. (LINK) ] Niels Tvis Knudsen of Aarhus University co-authored the paper."

So, no link between Greenland glaciers melting and human produced CO2 ie no AGW

Nobody disputes that global temperature has been rising since the 1880's, which saw the last of the great 19thCE eruptions (Krakatoa). That says nothing about the Current Warm Period starting in 1970's, with accelerated glacial retreat during that period. That's where you'd look to find a signal of AGW, given that " 80% of man-made CO2 emissions [have] occurred after 1940", and AGW is a cumulative effect.

Seventy percent of Greenland glaciers have been shrinking regularly since the 1880's; what percentage has been shrinking over the last thirty years? More to the point, what percentage is shrinking now?

There may be no AGW signal revealed in this study, but that's hardly surprising given that for most of the period it covers AGW had a miniscule impact. It only came of age as a real player in the climate game in the 70's.
 
and that's a BIG problem. i apprecaite that someone is bringing evidence to the table, but scientific research is often misinterpreted by the media. as i've already posted, at least one of these stories seems quite interesting, but the media's reporting may well be somewhat innacurate, to say the least.

At the very least a whole new level of interpretation is introduced, and there's a serious disjunction between journalists and scientists. They come from different worlds, and there's very little overlap. You'll have to take me on trust on that; been there, observed that, wasn't at all surprised. C P Snow's Two Cultures still swim in different seas.

Rather than get into this cite-by-cite (which is not say I won't make hay with the more egregious ones), and cutting to the chase, Lucifage Rocifale is having to resort to easily slapped-around references to support the contrarian case. Apparently without realising it. Judgement is called into question.
 
This quote from Christy seems also appropriate:
We are not told here that this assertion is based on computer model output, not direct observation. The simple fact is we don’t have thermometers marked with “this much is human-caused” and “this much is natural”. So, I would have written this conclusion as “Our climate models are incapable of reproducing the last 50 years of surface temperatures without a push from how we think greenhouse gases influence the climate. Other processes may also account for much of this change.”

It does? How so? How is it even remotely relevant to my post? (It was the one about urbanisation and a strongly implied accusation of double-standards.)

Ive looked over your responses to my posts, and there's nothing there. I read your response to shadron before I posted, and there's nothing there either. You brought all this "scientific evidence" up in the first place; do you not have the backbone to stand up and defend any of it?
 
and that's a BIG problem. i apprecaite that someone is bringing evidence to the table, but scientific research is often misinterpreted by the media. as i've already posted, at least one of these stories seems quite interesting, but the media's reporting may well be somewhat innacurate, to say the least.

lucifuge and mhaze, do either of you have access to a university library where you may be able to actually access some of these journals? i haven't gone through the entire list yet, but at a quick glance, a couple did seem worth tracking down. maybe we should pick out the most interesting and relavant of the research-- for example, the apparent dna found in ice core suggesting the ice survived the last serious warming-- and track down the real articles?

the problem is, whether for or against agw, media reports have a poor track record of accurate reporting of scientific research. we need to see various quotes in context.

I can link to a number of them probably tomorrow. Suggest picking just a few for starters.

apparent dna found in ice core suggesting the ice survived the last serious warming

If you dig into the subject of Greenland, it is far more complex and interesting than might be expected at first glance. It seems literally impossible to melt, because higher temps increase snowfall. The part that's without ice is far north, where it's so cold the air has little moisture.
 
I thought I would jump in in this thread. I live in Oregon where our state climatologist, George Taylor, rejects the theory of anthropogenic global warming and as such, has angered our environmentalist governor Ted Kulongoski and he wishes to relieve him of his title. A disgusting example of politics trumping science. What troubles me most in the GW debate is exactly that: the politics. Why can't we stick to science?
When I read things like "every single climatologist" as was stated earlier or comparing AGW denialists to creationists, it makes my skin crawl. Lets be honest here, by a substantial majority most scientists support AGW. There has been countless peer review studies supporting it. On the other hand, in the minority, there are scientists who don't buy it. Smart, qualified scientists and although a minority, I don't think they should be dismissed nor should we completely deny their existence. This minority, we should acknowledge is indeed a minority, but not a "fringe" minority like creationists with Biology PhDs. In other words, we should listen to their expert opinions. And before you dismiss them as in the hands corporate interests, consider how much government funding there is for scientists studying AGW.

An even more difficult question is what should/can we do about AGW? Should we buy Carbon credits that will plant trees in mid latitudes? According to Scientific American, more trees in boreal forests will contribute to global warming:
http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?chanID=sa003&articleID=DCA231BA-E7F2-99DF-3105874539B83ECB&ref=rss

My point is that this subject is so complex it makes my head spin and although I'm very interested in the topic, I don't have the knowledge to have a truly informed opinion to take a stance. You can't even think in terms of cause and effect (CO2 causes more warming) but need to understand things in terms of feedback loops (C02 causes warming and warming causes more CO2), its like studying feedback circuits in electronics which drove me crazy. Consider the question of trees:
1)Trees will remove CO2 from the air (good)
2)Trees will increase evaporation of H2O via transpiration. H2O is a greenhouse gas and will increase global warming but it will also increase clouds increasing Earths albedo decreasing global warming
3)Trees may increase Earths albedo increasing global warming

So are trees good or bad for global warming? I sure don't know. Generally, I think we should take the threat of AGW very seriously indeed but certainly not at the expense of silencing legitimate dissenting scientific opinions or pretending there is no debate whatsoever and that we can simply dismiss the opposing side as loons
 
i'm slowly working through your list, but i wanted to post about this in case it slipped by others. i'll try to track down the actual article sometime this week between classes. if the above summary is accurate, then this could have some very real implications on our current interpretations of AGW. or not. i'll have to read the article first.

but it seems very interesting, regardless. any of you read this yet? what did you think?


Lucifuge is being sneaky with his conclusions from that link he provided (http://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2007/07/06/greenland_ice_yields_hope_on_climate/?page=2). Here's his conclusions:


Denies the predicted income of AGW models, and the reality of the predicted "feedbacks", like albedo.


And here's what the leader of the study said of the work IN THAT VERY LINK:


"If our data is correct, and I believe it is, then this means the southern Greenland ice cap is more stable than previously thought," said Eske Willerslev, research leader and professor of evolutionary biology at the University of Copenhagen. "This may have implications for how the ice sheets respond to global warming. They may withstand rising temperatures."

.
.
.

Researchers from the Danish-led team said the unanticipated findings appear to fly in the face of prevailing scientific views about the likely fate of Greenland's thickly-layered ice, although Willerslev stressed that the findings do not contradict the basic premise that the earth's temperature is rising to worrisome levels, with gases emitted by industry, cars, and other human activity playing a big role. "But it suggests a problem with the [computer] models" that predict melting ice from Greenland could drown cities and destroy civilizations, according to Willerslev.

"We should remain very worried about rising sea levels," he said. "We know that during the last interglacial, sea levels rose by 5 meters or more. But this must have come from sources additional to Greenland, such as Antarctic ice. It does not appear the whole [Greenland] sheet will melt[/QUOTE]


THere's NO denial of GW, or AGW, there, from the leader of the study. Quite the opposite. To claim or imply otherwise is a damnable lie.

Note also that other scientists (like Schmidt) dispute the interpretations of the findings of the research team quoted above re GREENLAND...but both sides are in agreement that AGW is occurring. To imply otherwise is a damnable lie.
 
Last edited:
It does? How so? How is it even remotely relevant to my post? (It was the one about urbanisation and a strongly implied accusation of double-standards.)

Ive looked over your responses to my posts, and there's nothing there. I read your response to shadron before I posted, and there's nothing there either. You brought all this "scientific evidence" up in the first place; do you not have the backbone to stand up and defend any of it?
I give Shadron the same response you got (it's a 2001 paper) and a link to a study which explains recent findings about the inverse link in temperature in both hemispheres.
 
and that's a BIG problem. i apprecaite that someone is bringing evidence to the table, but scientific research is often misinterpreted by the media. as i've already posted, at least one of these stories seems quite interesting, but the media's reporting may well be somewhat innacurate, to say the least.

lucifuge and mhaze, do either of you have access to a university library where you may be able to actually access some of these journals? i haven't gone through the entire list yet, but at a quick glance, a couple did seem worth tracking down. maybe we should pick out the most interesting and relavant of the research-- for example, the apparent dna found in ice core suggesting the ice survived the last serious warming-- and track down the real articles?

the problem is, whether for or against agw, media reports have a poor track record of accurate reporting of scientific research. we need to see various quotes in context.
That's very true and happens a lot in both sides.
I have found the sources from many of the articles, and it's easy to do, just putting the name of the researchers and the paper title. I'll get back to this.
 
At the very least a whole new level of interpretation is introduced, and there's a serious disjunction between journalists and scientists. They come from different worlds, and there's very little overlap. You'll have to take me on trust on that; been there, observed that, wasn't at all surprised. C P Snow's Two Cultures still swim in different seas.

Rather than get into this cite-by-cite (which is not say I won't make hay with the more egregious ones), and cutting to the chase, Lucifage Rocifale is having to resort to easily slapped-around references to support the contrarian case. Apparently without realising it. Judgement is called into question.

I'd appreciate that. Doing otherwise will be cherry picking.
 
Lucifuge is being sneaky with his conclusions from that link he provided (http://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2007/07/06/greenland_ice_yields_hope_on_climate/?page=2). Here's his conclusions:





And here's what the leader of the study said of the work IN THAT VERY LINK:


"If our data is correct, and I believe it is, then this means the southern Greenland ice cap is more stable than previously thought," said Eske Willerslev, research leader and professor of evolutionary biology at the University of Copenhagen. "This may have implications for how the ice sheets respond to global warming. They may withstand rising temperatures."

.
.
.

Researchers from the Danish-led team said the unanticipated findings appear to fly in the face of prevailing scientific views about the likely fate of Greenland's thickly-layered ice, although Willerslev stressed that the findings do not contradict the basic premise that the earth's temperature is rising to worrisome levels, with gases emitted by industry, cars, and other human activity playing a big role. "But it suggests a problem with the [computer] models" that predict melting ice from Greenland could drown cities and destroy civilizations, according to Willerslev.

"We should remain very worried about rising sea levels," he said. "We know that during the last interglacial, sea levels rose by 5 meters or more. But this must have come from sources additional to Greenland, such as Antarctic ice. It does not appear the whole [Greenland] sheet will melt

THere's NO denial of GW, or AGW, there, from the leader of the study. Quite the opposite. To claim or imply otherwise is a damnable lie.

Note also that other scientists (like Schmidt) dispute the interpretations of the findings of the research team quoted above re GREENLAND...but both sides are in agreement that AGW is occurring. To imply otherwise is a damnable lie.
[/quote]

First: Don't cherry pick :)
Second: I already hinted what you quote to the doc. I told him that one of the studies don't disregard AGW but the validity of the models.

Look carefully at your quote:

Researchers from the Danish-led team said the unanticipated findings appear to fly in the face of prevailing scientific views about the likely fate of Greenland's thickly-layered ice, although Willerslev stressed that the findings do not contradict the basic premise that the earth's temperature is rising to worrisome levels, with gases emitted by industry, cars, and other human activity playing a big role. "But it suggests a problem with the [computer] models" that predict melting ice from Greenland could drown cities and destroy civilizations, according to Willerslev.

Now find me and ECM (computer model) that DOESN'T predict the melting of Greenland.

See, if a research imply that all the AGW models are wrong then I have to count it as supporting my point about the lack of reliability of AGW models.

Now look at what is not said in the study. This study was not about AGW was made by man or not, so if the leader of the study says that the AGW hypothesis remains in doubt that's his personal opinion, not result of the cited study. The result of the cited study is that AGW ECMs are wrong and that is what I'm quoting. If you have an study from that same guy, dealing with the man made contribution to Global Warming, please post it.
 
Last edited:
Argument from ignorance. I prefer to hear from those who are trying to find an answer, to those who just throw their hands up in the air and give up.

The problem is that have already found their answer (is man made) and they are trying to make facts fit that answer. That's why I posted a peer reviewed study that links all climatic change in the last century to natural causes.
 
Lucifuge is being sneaky with his conclusions from that link he provided........THere's NO denial of GW, or AGW, there, from the leader of the study. Quite the opposite. To claim or imply otherwise is a damnable lie.

Note also that other scientists (like Schmidt) dispute the interpretations of the findings of the research team quoted above re GREENLAND...but both sides are in agreement that AGW is occurring. To imply otherwise is a damnable lie.

I respectfully disagree, and here is why.

Personally I am quite skeptical about numerous commonly held "AGW beliefs", these include the importance of CO2 as a driver of climate change and Greenland meltdown. However there are other things that most skeptics do agree with, such as black soot effect and Asian brown cloud.

Although I am not in climate research I'd have no problem including a paragraph in a paper written such as "The results do not rule out the possibility of some AGW component overlaid on the natural cycle" or the like. Such boilerplate is very common, sometimes the scientists seem quite sincere and other times (as far as we might read between the lines) it really seems like some standard paragraph was thrown in at the last minute to appease the lions. It is very appropriate for scientists to clearly try to state how the scope of their conclusions is restricted, based on the exact problem they addressed.

And on the contrary, a study that claims to find the "Smoking gun....proof of AGW" based on some flimsey statistical shred (Hansen 1988) should be viewed very, very cautiously.

There are several studies by very pro AGW writers (Tung 2007 comes to mind, this is in LR's list I think) where in spite of their inclination pro AGW, (like it or not), the scientific result is importantly anti AGW. Note the difference: The scientific results versus the opinions of the scientists.

Further, a scientist may ethically feel obliged to expose a clear logical fallacy of AGW ("Greenland will melt down! Coastal towns will flood!) but still be a believer in key concepts of AGW. Here the scientist is saying: "We need to be concerned about AGW, but we should not lie and exaggerate about it".
 
First: Don't cherry pick :)

That's rich coming from you,you damnable liar.

Second: I already hinted what you quote to the doc. I told him that one of the studies don't disregard AGW but the validity of the models.

You didn't HINT -- you LEFT OUT that fact that the LEADER of the study does NOT consider it to be evidence against AGW, you damnable liar.

See, if a research imply that all the AGW models are wrong

this research DOESN'T do that, you damnable liar.

Now look at what is not said in the study. This study was not about AGW was made by man or not, so if the leader of the study says that the AGW hypothesis remains in doubt that's his personal opinion, not result of the cited study. The result of the cited study is that AGW ECMs are wrong and that is what I'm quoting. If you have an study from that same guy, dealing with the man made contribution to Global Warming, please post it.

YOU are the one who cited the study as part of a set of ostensibly anti-AGW research, you damnable liar.

btw, has 'Token Conservative' answered the two questions posed in the first post yet?
 
Last edited:
There are several studies by very pro AGW writers (Tung 2007 comes to mind, this is in LR's list I think) where in spite of their inclination pro AGW, (like it or not), the scientific result is importantly anti AGW. Note the difference: The scientific results versus the opinions of the scientists.

Further, a scientist may ethically feel obliged to expose a clear logical fallacy of AGW ("Greenland will melt down! Coastal towns will flood!) but still be a believer in key concepts of AGW. Here the scientist is saying: "We need to be concerned about AGW, but we should not lie and exaggerate about it".

And that phrasing is just damnable [i/spin[/i] on your part. No scientists are suggesting 'we' should 'lie and exaggerate' in the first place. The dictum of science is to follow the best data...which btw, the IPCC has done. This article is put forth new data as evidence that the modelling of GREENLAND ice is incomplete. It does not indicate that sea levels never rose, or will not rise, as a result of warming. The lead author says that if his model is true then there must be other sources -- such as Antarctic ice -- for the sea level changes we KNOW happened in the past, and for changes that will happen in the future due to AWG.

Btw, that disreputable hack journal Science has a summary news article this week , called GLOBAL WARMING: How Urgent Is Climate Change? It's about the latest IPCC report. You might want to check it out.
 
And that phrasing is just damnable [i/spin[/i] on your part. No scientists are suggesting 'we' should 'lie and exaggerate' in the first place. The dictum of science is to follow the best data...which btw, the IPCC has done.

Btw, that disreputable hack journal Science has a summary news article this week , called GLOBAL WARMING: How Urgent Is Climate Change? It's about the latest IPCC report. You might want to check it out.

No scientists are suggesting 'we' should 'lie and exaggerate' in the first place.

The fact that lies and exaggerations on AGW are rife in the media, news, and from the likes of Gore, does not mean that "scientists are suggesting we should lie and exaggerate". So your point is....?

RE Science mag, let's break that down. Science writes about the latest IPCC report, summarizing it. Probably summarizing the "Summary for Policymakers" which is the summary of ten or twelve very involved chapters. Each chapter is a review, a summary of science in the area to which that chapter pertains.

You've got in the Science mage, a commentary on a summary of a summary, at the best.

While in this thread, we are discussing the actual fundamental scientific articles....

But as the OP noted "Where should we get our information on climate from"? You certainly have made a decent suggestion (depending of course on who wrote that article).
 
And that phrasing is just damnable
That's rich coming from you,you damnable liar.
, you damnable liar.
do that, you damnable liar.
you damnable liar.

Could we get some clever variations in font and maybe some bolds and colors and biggie fonts too?:D

Or do you have some facts and science?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom