For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

Ad Hoc Committee on Global Climate Issues: Annual report
Gerhard LC, Hanson BM
AAPG Bulletin 84 (4): 466-471 Apr 2000
Deleted because you don't like the conclusions, so you easily blame oil industry.

Putting it back in because, hey, why not?, I'm a crazy ad hoc sorta guy

"Abstract: The AAPG Ad Hoc Committee on Global Climate Issues has studied the supposition of human-induced climate change since the committee’s inception in January 1998. This paper details the progress and findings of the committee through June 1999, At that time there had been essentially no geologic input into the global climate change debate. The following statements reflect the current state of climate knowledge from the geologic perspective as interpreted by the majority of the committee membership. The committee recognizes that new data could change its conclusions, The earth’s climate is constantly changing owing to natural variability in earth processes. Natural climate variability over recent geological time is greater than reasonable estimates of potential human-induced greenhouse gas changes. Because no tool is available to test the supposition of human-induced climate change and the range of natural variability is so great, there is no discernible human influence on global climate at this time."

No tool was available on their say-so in 2000? Is this what the "geologic input into [sic] the global climate change debate" came up with? Not surprising considering that climate science is way out of their field. Geology and climate are at opposite poles of physical science.
 
ok, you all need to stop comparing one another to creationists. seriously.

creationists are not looked down upon because they hold the minority position in a scientific debate; creationists are looked down upon because they invoke the supernatural, and are therefore not scientific. A/GW "skeptics" or "deniers" do not invoke the supernatural.

I quite agree. Creationism is a terrible analogy to use because religion brings so much baggage with it. It really should be left to contrarians to throw the "religion" mud.

A much better analogy would be with a controversy where both sides argue science. Best (in my opinion) not to draw any analogy at all and focus on the subject at hand.
 
"Tropical cyclones and global climate change: A post-IPCC assessment
Henderson-Sellers A, Zhang H, Berz G, Emanuel K, Gray W, Landsea C, Holland G, Lighthill J, Shieh SL, Webster P, McGuffie K
Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society 79 (1): 19-38 Jan 1998"

A paper confirming, back in '98, that climate models are not good with such detail as cyclonic activity. Something which is of great significance on a human scale but not so much on a climate scale. There are models dedicated to cyclonic activity which are pretty good, and do predict more activity when a warmer climate is fed in as the base-line.

Notice that we're now back to '98, and we work back to '93 before Lucifage Rocifale signs off his cut-and-paste job with

Science is no settled

That's the end of the abstracts.
 
6) A July 6, 2007 study published in the journal Science about Greenland by an international team of scientists found DNA “evidence that suggests the frozen shield covering the immense island survived the Earth’s last period of global warming,” according to a Boston Globe article. (6-6-07) (LINK) According to the article, the study indicates “Greenland’s ice may be less susceptible to the massive meltdown predicted by computer models of climate change, the main author (Eske Willerslev, professor of evolutionary biology at University of Copenhagen) said in an interview. “This may have implications for how the ice sheets respond to global warming. They may withstand rising temperatures,” Willerslev said. The article explained, “The discovery of organic matter in ice dating from half –a-million years ago offers evidence that the Greenland ice sheet remained frozen even during the Earth’s last ‘interglacial period’ – some 120,000 years ago – when average temperatures were 9 degrees Fahrenheit warmer than they are now.” Willerslev addressed scary computer model predictions of a massive Greenland melt. “[The study] suggests a problem with [computer] models” that predict melting ice from Greenland could drown cities and destroy civilizations, Willerslev said. The study found “Greenland really was green, before Ice Age glaciers enshrouded vast swaths of the Northern Hemisphere…somewhere between 450,000 and 800,000 years ago,” according to the article.

Denies the predicted income of AGW models, and the reality of the predicted "feedbacks", like albedo.



i'm slowly working through your list, but i wanted to post about this in case it slipped by others. i'll try to track down the actual article sometime this week between classes. if the above summary is accurate, then this could have some very real implications on our current interpretations of AGW. or not. i'll have to read the article first.

but it seems very interesting, regardless. any of you read this yet? what did you think?
 
i'm slowly working through your list, but i wanted to post about this in case it slipped by others. i'll try to track down the actual article sometime this week between classes. if the above summary is accurate, then this could have some very real implications on our current interpretations of AGW. or not. i'll have to read the article first.

but it seems very interesting, regardless. any of you read this yet? what did you think?

I've been trying to figure out a way to melt Greenland.

So far no luck. Lower temps cause more snow and it gets thicker in the center. IPCC has a page in Ch. 10 where they claim it could melt in a thousand years or so. Hansen has some wild idea that a lot of it could melt by 2050, but this does not seem to be substantiated.

Interesting issue.
 
A paper confirming, back in '98, that climate models are not good with such detail as cyclonic activity. Something which is of great significance on a human scale but not so much on a climate scale. There are models dedicated to cyclonic activity which are pretty good, and do predict more activity when a warmer climate is fed in as the base-line.

This abstract indicates only what time has proven out, that the frequency of hurricanes is not related to more or less of the supposed GW (whether or not there is an "A" in front of it). Since then the predominant AGW position has shifted to not "more hurricanes" but "fewer more powerful hurricanes" if I have correctly kept track of the shifting sands of cause and effect in the AGW hypothesis.

I think the latter theory, "fewer more powerful hurricanes" has also not been borne out by the last decade. But can one go backwards from these concepts and make a statement such as the following?
There were more (or fewer, but more powerful) hurricanes and thus AGW has another strong underpinning, because the models predict this, so this proves AGW. I neither hold this position or the reverse (that this not being true would somehow disprove AGW).
​
AGW and hurricanes, not related.

As far as Real science (Gore science is a whole 'nuther thing):)
 
Putting it back in because, hey, why not?, I'm a crazy ad hoc sorta guy

No tool was available on their say-so in 2000? Is this what the "geologic input into [sic] the global climate change debate" came up with? Not surprising considering that climate science is way out of their field. Geology and climate are at opposite poles of physical science.

GRL is a leading publisher of, in my opinion, some of the best climate articles that we have seen. The difference appears to be that AAGP is energy oriented? Might they know a bit about stuff like CO2 and fossil fuels?
 
Other contemporary research came to a different conclusion, so I guess the jury was still out on this. One point that intrigues me about the conclusion is the reference to "around the North Pole", rather than "in the Arctic Ocean". Why the distinction? The first answer that springs to mind is that the author's conclusion specifically refers to the most northerly ice, not Arctic ice in toto.

If Arctic ice-cover is a sensitive indicator of climate change, what are we to make of events since 1997? Summer 2005 saw a record low in Arctic ice-extent, and that record was smashed in summer 2007. It's hard to explain this rapid loss of ice without a cumulative thinning over previous decades. I'm bound to wonder just what merit this particular paper retains after another decade of observation.

Whether or not Arctic ice went up or down is a measure of global warming, not man made global warming. Other studies have shown Arctic ice declines in the 1930-1940s similar to that of today, and I believe also in the prior cycle around 1880.

So I do not see how this article has anything to do with refuting AGW.
 
The unbolded part of the final sentence says "the crime-scene was so compromised" just before the "no useful evidence could be gathered from it". All the paper concludes is that this is not a good way to extract a climate-change signal from surrounding noise. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, m'kay?

Given that contrarians so often cite urbanisation as a reason not to trust weather-station series I find it amusing this is still on their forwarding list. The list never seems to get pruned - this is another paper from 2001.

Well, sheeessh. Asia? Someone would hope to fingerprint (or not) an AGW component in Asia? Okay, well, we could chalk part up to black soot, part to the "asian brown cloud", and somehow after that have some effect left to fingerprint as a CO2 effect? Absolutely impossible.

Don't get me talking about Asia.....I'm agreeing with CD here.
 
What I find interesting about TC's comments is how implicitly self-contradictory they are, yet he fails entirely to see it.

He cites in his own response numerous examples of where humans have had a very serious, deleterious effect on the environment ("Aswan Dam, the Aral sea, rabbits and cats in Australia, kudzu and nutria in the American south, the lower Colorado River in the American Southwest, the missing cedar forests in Central Mexico, the missing well...everything on Easter Island, etc.,").

And he then states that it is ludicrous of humans to think that we can change or have a significant impact on that same environment.

Had humans on Easter Island practiced moderation and sustainable environmental practices, they would have avoided the results. The results were not unavoidable, and it was fully within human power to make choices that would have drastically different effects on the environment.

Today, we are pumping huge amounts of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere; and pretty much every climatologist on the planet agrees that it is having an impact (although they disagree somewhat as to the degree of that impact).

Are we, as humans, able to stop or control natural, cyclical processes of climate change? Of course not.

Are we, as humans, able to choose to moderate behaviors that are proven to have a deleterious effect on our climate and our environment? Most certainly.

Going back to the example of Easter Island, TC would be the guy who, when the entire island's ecology was collapsing around them, would be saying, "Hey, ecology is a cyclical thing, there's nothing we can do to change it", while ignoring the blatant evidence that, in fact, much of the damage was a direct result of human actions. and that altering those human actions would also alter the impact on the ecology around them.
 
No, you withdrew the one that wasn't peer-reviewed and was sponsored by an oil company.

We have to leave the climate stuff up to climatologists, really ... we don't have the satellites or the great big computers they have. If you can't trust scientists to do science, who can you trust?

Yes, I left that stuff to the real scientists, that's why I'm just posting stuff from them.
 
LUCIFUGE,

i appreciate the fact that you've taken the time to actually post abstracts and cites that you interpret as supporting your conclusion. i've read through a great number of A/GW material in various threads here, at realclamate.org and even climateaudit.org, and i've not seen many of these abstracts previously.

our current understanding of paleoclimate correlates beautifully to milankovitch cycles. these data seem to confirm that milankovitch cycles drive the earth's major warming and cooling periods. the degree of difference in distance between the earth and sun caused by milankovitch cycles is very small, however the degree of temperature difference between these cycles is quite large. this is very good evidence that positive and negative feedback loops exist to elevate warming periods and dampen cooling periods.

we know that in the lab CO2 is a greenhouse gas, so it is very likely that atmospheric CO2 behaves in a similar manner. we also have quite a nice set of paleoclimate data from various ice cores. these data show a very definite correlation between atmospheric CO2 and temperature. given that CO2 is a greenhouse gas in the lab, and that CO2 correlates so well with temperature, it seems more than likely that CO2 creates positive feedback.

given that we know positive feedback holds a great deal of control over the degree of warming that the earth experiences, and given that we have good reason to suspect that CO2 creates positive feedback, we have good reason to expect that increased atmospheric CO2 should increase the warming that the earth experiences. the question that i think is still not answered is, well, how much?

from all i've read, and my current understanding, further data could very well still place atmospheric carbon as a major contributer to the total positive feedback that drives the major increases in temperature. further data could very well place atmospheric carbon as a minor contributer that simply "breaks the camel's back", unleashing a number of other positive feedback loops (methane from the permafrost, for example), that lead to a greater degree of warming than previously expected. further data could very well place atmospheric carbon as a minor contributer whose affects on temperature and climate are simply negligible. all these conclusions are possible.

regardless, i think that we've enough confidence of our basic understanding of the importance of positive feedback loops to do our best to leave the carbon cycle alone if at all possible. while we may not have the data, yet, to accurately predict the total amount of increased warming that the increased atmospheric carbon will cause, there's no reason to risk anything, if alternatives exist, and to a large extent, they do.

currently, i believe that increased CO2 will cause a measurable, noticable increase in global warming, but i don't think it will be catastrophic, but my conclusions can only get more accurate with increased data, so i appreciate the fact that you've brought some evidence to the table. those that do not appreciate your evidence have either already been made aware of the evidence, or do not care as much about accurate conclusions as they do about defending their positions.

i will read through your abstracts as time warrents, and comment when possible.

thanks,
anthony.

My understating of the issue is that the CO2 driver hypothesis is seriously compromised, and that model outcomes are been probed not so robust.
 
Other contemporary research came to a different conclusion, so I guess the jury was still out on this. One point that intrigues me about the conclusion is the reference to "around the North Pole", rather than "in the Arctic Ocean". Why the distinction? The first answer that springs to mind is that the author's conclusion specifically refers to the most northerly ice, not Arctic ice in toto.

If Arctic ice-cover is a sensitive indicator of climate change, what are we to make of events since 1997? Summer 2005 saw a record low in Arctic ice-extent, and that record was smashed in summer 2007. It's hard to explain this rapid loss of ice without a cumulative thinning over previous decades. I'm bound to wonder just what merit this particular paper retains after another decade of observation.


Look at my response to Shadron.
 
The unbolded part of the final sentence says "the crime-scene was so compromised" just before the "no useful evidence could be gathered from it". All the paper concludes is that this is not a good way to extract a climate-change signal from surrounding noise. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, m'kay?

Given that contrarians so often cite urbanisation as a reason not to trust weather-station series I find it amusing this is still on their forwarding list. The list never seems to get pruned - this is another paper from 2001.

This quote from Christy seems also appropriate:

We are not told here that this assertion is based on computer model output, not direct observation. The simple fact is we don’t have thermometers marked with “this much is human-caused” and “this much is natural”. So, I would have written this conclusion as “Our climate models are incapable of reproducing the last 50 years of surface temperatures without a push from how we think greenhouse gases influence the climate. Other processes may also account for much of this change.”
 
Putting it back in because, hey, why not?, I'm a crazy ad hoc sorta guy



No tool was available on their say-so in 2000? Is this what the "geologic input into [sic] the global climate change debate" came up with? Not surprising considering that climate science is way out of their field. Geology and climate are at opposite poles of physical science.

If you read the thread form the beggining, I was actually asked for scientific evidence from 1993 to date, so my references went from that date to 2007.
 
A paper confirming, back in '98, that climate models are not good with such detail as cyclonic activity. Something which is of great significance on a human scale but not so much on a climate scale. There are models dedicated to cyclonic activity which are pretty good, and do predict more activity when a warmer climate is fed in as the base-line.

Notice that we're now back to '98, and we work back to '93 before Lucifage Rocifale signs off his cut-and-paste job with



That's the end of the abstracts.

Remember, I was aasked for sources from 1993 to date. And that's not the end of the abstracts, there is a shortlist made fro the doctor which contains the papers I find most interesting among all the ones I quoted.
 
i'm slowly working through your list, but i wanted to post about this in case it slipped by others. i'll try to track down the actual article sometime this week between classes. if the above summary is accurate, then this could have some very real implications on our current interpretations of AGW. or not. i'll have to read the article first.

but it seems very interesting, regardless. any of you read this yet? what did you think?


Here you have both sides of the issue:

Researchers from the Danish-led team said the unanticipated findings appear to fly in the face of prevailing scientific views about the likely fate of Greenland's thickly-layered ice, although Willerslev stressed that the findings do not contradict the basic premise that the earth's temperature is rising to worrisome levels, with gases emitted by industry, cars, and other human activity playing a big role.


"But it suggests a problem with the [computer] models" that predict melting ice from Greenland could drown cities and destroy civilizations, according to Willerslev.
"We should remain very worried about rising sea levels," he said. "We know that during the last interglacial, sea levels rose by 5 meters or more. But this must have come from sources additional to Greenland, such as Antarctic ice. It does not appear the whole [Greenland] sheet will melt."
Computer models suggest that Greenland and Antarctica will be the main contributors to rising sea levels as the climate warms. (The Arctic won't affect sea level, because its ice already floats in the ocean.)
Some scientists not involved in the study drew a conclusion very different from that of the Danish-led team .
"The raw results of this study are very impressive -- southern Greenland was unglaciated sometime during the last million years or so," said Gavin Schmidt, a climatologist with National Aeronautics and Space Administration 's Goddard Institute for Space Studies. "I would argue that this implies a more unstable ice sheet, not the opposite."
Schmidt said that during the more recent warming period, most but not all of the ice might have disappeared from southern Greenland, leaving a thin layer that would have been sufficient to preserve the DNA.

Gavin Schmidt is a frequent contributor to realclimate and he is really involved in the pro AGW camp. Reading his conclusion I'd say that he entered to denial-mode.
 
Are we, as humans, able to stop or control natural, cyclical processes of climate change? Of course not.

We're almost in a position to try that - we could fine-tune atmospheric CO2-load, for instance - but I wouldn't recommend it, given the unbending Law of Unintended Consequences.

Are we, as humans, able to choose to moderate behaviors that are proven to have a deleterious effect on our climate and our environment? Most certainly.

Are we as a global society able to do this? I really don't think so. I expect the Bali Conference to be explanation enough of why I've reached that conclusion.

Going back to the example of Easter Island, TC would be the guy who, when the entire island's ecology was collapsing around them, would be saying, "Hey, ecology is a cyclical thing, there's nothing we can do to change it", while ignoring the blatant evidence that, in fact, much of the damage was a direct result of human actions. and that altering those human actions would also alter the impact on the ecology around them.

I can picture two schools of thought in play as the last few trees are inexorably felled. One school contends that trees come from other trees - evidence being that they grow near other trees, people come from people, pigs come from pigs - so without any trees there'll be no more trees ever. The other school contends that trees come from the soil (everybody's seen it), trees have never been observed mating, the current shortage of trees is cyclical and so nothing new, and anyone saying different is promoting alarm in the hope of Overthrowing The Social Order :eek:.

After the last trees were felled and the last saplings were fed to the last pigs and then there were no more pigs or trees, I can't help thinking it was the "alarmists" that got the blame. After all, they disturbed the social order, and look what it led to.
 
GRL is a leading publisher of, in my opinion, some of the best climate articles that we have seen. The difference appears to be that AAGP is energy oriented? Might they know a bit about stuff like CO2 and fossil fuels?

They'll certainly know about fossil fuels : finding and extracting them. Why would they know or care about CO2 or its effect on climate? Even in the fossil-fuel industry as a whole CO2 is something that goes away up a chimney or out of an exhaust. The only reason the AAGP has for taking an interest in climate is that at the further end of the fossil-fuel industry - where the chimneys and exhausts and serious money are - there seems to be a PR problem. It seems the CO2 doesn't just go away, and it does have an effect on climate.

Taking this into account, and that the AAGP was estabished in 1998 some time after AGW was a sufficient concern to have spawned the IPCC and Kyoto Accord, the conclusion in a report from an Ad Hoc Committee two years later that there's no certainty in it is of no import.

Where it does have an impact is when people deliberately bring it up as supportive of their case. It raises all sorts of questions about their judgement.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom