LUCIFUGE,
i appreciate the fact that you've taken the time to actually post abstracts and cites that you interpret as supporting your conclusion. i've read through a great number of A/GW material in various threads here, at realclamate.org and even climateaudit.org, and i've not seen many of these abstracts previously.
our current understanding of paleoclimate correlates beautifully to milankovitch cycles. these data seem to confirm that milankovitch cycles drive the earth's major warming and cooling periods. the degree of difference in distance between the earth and sun caused by milankovitch cycles is very small, however the degree of temperature difference between these cycles is quite large. this is very good evidence that positive and negative feedback loops exist to elevate warming periods and dampen cooling periods.
we know that in the lab CO2 is a greenhouse gas, so it is very likely that atmospheric CO2 behaves in a similar manner. we also have quite a nice set of paleoclimate data from various ice cores. these data show a very definite correlation between atmospheric CO2 and temperature. given that CO2 is a greenhouse gas in the lab, and that CO2 correlates so well with temperature, it seems more than likely that CO2 creates positive feedback.
given that we know positive feedback holds a great deal of control over the degree of warming that the earth experiences, and given that we have good reason to suspect that CO2 creates positive feedback, we have good reason to expect that increased atmospheric CO2 should increase the warming that the earth experiences. the question that i think is still not answered is, well, how much?
from all i've read, and my current understanding, further data could very well still place atmospheric carbon as a major contributer to the total positive feedback that drives the major increases in temperature. further data could very well place atmospheric carbon as a minor contributer that simply "breaks the camel's back", unleashing a number of other positive feedback loops (methane from the permafrost, for example), that lead to a greater degree of warming than previously expected. further data could very well place atmospheric carbon as a minor contributer whose affects on temperature and climate are simply negligible. all these conclusions are possible.
regardless, i think that we've enough confidence of our basic understanding of the importance of positive feedback loops to do our best to leave the carbon cycle alone if at all possible. while we may not have the data, yet, to accurately predict the total amount of increased warming that the increased atmospheric carbon will cause, there's no reason to risk anything, if alternatives exist, and to a large extent, they do.
currently, i believe that increased CO2 will cause a measurable, noticable increase in global warming, but i don't think it will be catastrophic, but my conclusions can only get more accurate with increased data, so i appreciate the fact that you've brought some evidence to the table. those that do not appreciate your evidence have either already been made aware of the evidence, or do not care as much about accurate conclusions as they do about defending their positions.
i will read through your abstracts as time warrents, and comment when possible.
thanks,
anthony.