For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

...So. Where's TokenConservative?
And has he answered his claim about the age of consent in the Netherlands? I forgot.
 
I wanted to add a link where George Taylor defends himself:
http://www.ocs.orst.edu/page_links/publications/taylor_response.html
Here is a taste:
Actually, I get most of my information from peer-reviewed journals, including Journal of Climate, Journal of Geophysical Research, and Climate Research. The articles I write (including, for example, the Arctic article) are based on journal articles and contain full bibliographies. Admittedly, I seldom give“both sides” of the argument, because the “other side” (the one that suggests that human activities exert a dominant role in the climate system) is well-represented in journals and the media. My goal is to be a voice saying “wait, maybe there’s another side to this. Take a look at THIS data and see what you think. Then let’s talk about it.” Unfortunately, this issue has become such a divisive and angry one that ad hominem attacks have replaced dialogue..

Sounds pretty reasonable to me. A minority opinion for sure, but not one that should be silenced in my opinion.
He has an MS in Meteorology and manages the Oregon Climate service, the state repository for weather and climate information with a staff of 10. Hardly a bogus responsibility of a worthless organization.
 
I thought I would jump in in this thread. I live in Oregon where our state climatologist, George Taylor, rejects the theory of anthropogenic global warming and as such, has angered our environmentalist governor Ted Kulongoski and he wishes to relieve him of his title. A disgusting example of politics trumping science. What troubles me most in the GW debate is exactly that: the politics. Why can't we stick to science?

Kulongoski wants to take the “State” out of Taylor’s “State Climatologist” title. As governor Kulongoski said, “He is Oregon State University's climatologist. He is not the state of Oregon's climatologist.” The title had been awarded by the university, not the state.

http://www.kgw.com/news-local/stories/kgw_020607_news_taylor_title.59f5d04a.html

So it’s not so much the suppression of scientific thought, a la Galileo, as it is a governor perhaps wanting to maintain the credibility of the state of Oregon. Reading a little further in that article, Sen. Avakian wanted to bring a bill to have a climatologist appointed as consultant to the governor, and governor Kulongoski wanted the state to have “a consistent message on reducing greenhouse gases to combat climate change: "I just think there has to be somebody that says, 'this is the state position on this.'" A position which Taylor was not putting forth.

At the state governor level, of course there be politics. If a governor wants to appoint someone to an advisory position who can advise from the scientific mainstream, what’s the problem? Taylor is no Galileo; all he stands to lose is a title that a University gave to him. If he wants to spout scientifically unsupportable nonsense, best he not do that in the name of your fine state. Taking the 'State' from his title won't silence him. I note that he has no problem getting himself heard.

So where should a state governor get his information on climate? From someone that will "seldom give 'both sides' of the argument, because the 'other side' (the one that suggests that human activities exert a dominant role in the climate system) is well-represented in journals and the media"?

Isn't it better instead that he get that information from someone that will represent the mainstream scientific opinion?
 
I wanted to add a link where George Taylor defends himself:
http://www.ocs.orst.edu/page_links/publications/taylor_response.html
Here is a taste:


Sounds pretty reasonable to me. A minority opinion for sure, but not one that should be silenced in my opinion.
He has an MS in Meteorology and manages the Oregon Climate service, the state repository for weather and climate information with a staff of 10. Hardly a bogus responsibility of a worthless organization.

Sounds exactly like a reasonable creationist, and there are scientists who are also creationists.

What research has he done into the issue, and published?
 
So where should a state governor get his information on climate? From someone that will "seldom give 'both sides' of the argument, because the 'other side' (the one that suggests that human activities exert a dominant role in the climate system) is well-represented in journals and the media"?

Isn't it better instead that he get that information from someone that will represent the mainstream scientific opinion?
Thanks for the link. From the article:
Taylor has held the title of "state climatologist" since 1991 when the legislature created a state climate office at OSU The university created the job title, not the state.
Doesn't sound like he got the job via an Entryism effort(1991
?) nor does the Oregon Climate Service qualify as a moribund institution as others have suggested but you make a very good point: As an advisor to the governor, he is a very poor choice indeed but I think the title of "state climatologist" belongs to the most qualified and experienced individual, regardless if this jives with the agenda of the governor or not. Sounds to me that he obtained his title via fair play, and not some concerted entryism campaign or has been otherwise compromised by outside interests. If that state title is indeed at the pleasure of the governor, then he should be summarily relieved of his title as Kulongoski is a dedicated AGW proponent.
 
Sounds exactly like a reasonable creationist, and there are scientists who are also creationists.

What research has he done into the issue, and published?
I don't believe he has published anything on the subject, as far as his own research, his primary responsibility, if I understand correctly, is record keeping of climate data of the state and providing that data to the public. That's a worthy endeavor in its own right. Outside of those responsibilities he has stated his own personal opinion and interpretation of existing data on climate. I don't think creationists would qualify as reasonable and there are scientists who are creationists, I just don't think its fair or correct to characterize AGW dissenters as marginal as creationist scientists most certainly are.
 
I don't believe he has published anything on the subject, as far as his own research, his primary responsibility, if I understand correctly, is record keeping of climate data of the state and providing that data to the public. That's a worthy endeavor in its own right. Outside of those responsibilities he has stated his own personal opinion and interpretation of existing data on climate. I don't think creationists would qualify as reasonable and there are scientists who are creationists, I just don't think its fair or correct to characterize AGW dissenters as marginal as creationist scientists most certainly are.

I am sure he does a worthy job of recording temperatures, he's not a research scientist.

But this has me worried.
http://www.ocs.orst.edu/enso.html

http://www.ocs.orst.edu/enso.html

interesting link doesn't work.

goto the home page reports->climate reports-> El nino.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the link. From the article:

Doesn't sound like he got the job via an Entryism effort(1991
?) nor does the Oregon Climate Service qualify as a moribund institution as others have suggested but you make a very good point: As an advisor to the governor, he is a very poor choice indeed but I think the title of "state climatologist" belongs to the most qualified and experienced individual, regardless if this jives with the agenda of the governor or not. Sounds to me that he obtained his title via fair play, and not some concerted entryism campaign or has been otherwise compromised by outside interests. If that state title is indeed at the pleasure of the governor, then he should be summarily relieved of his title as Kulongoski is a dedicated AGW proponent.

I didn't say the OCS was moribund, I said the AASC was, before it was hijacked for political reasons.

He is the self proclaimed state climatologist, a title the state did not confer on him.
 
Last edited:
You haven't answered any question and your point is not done. I posted the very bit you quoted before, showing the controversy on the results.
You still don't get it, don't you? The study was about Melting. It found AGW models in error. Later, the team leader says that it can't be seem as a disproving of the AGW hypothesis, wich is true, and that HE THINKS that AGW still have value BUT THAT IS NOT THE RESULT OF THE STUDY.


Or maybe because he knows that the mass of AGW evidence doesn't stand or fall solely on his team's modelling of GREENLAND ICE, you damnable liar.
 
Last edited:
I am sure he does a worthy job of recording temperatures, he's not a research scientist.

But this has me worried.
http://www.ocs.orst.edu/enso.html

http://www.ocs.orst.edu/enso.html

interesting link doesn't work.

goto the home page reports->climate reports-> El nino.


Looks like this State Climatologist (who should not be listened to because he is not a research scientist:)) agrees with LR's reference #1 -

Tsonis - recent climate variability can be explained by natural causation.

1) New peer-reviewed study finds global warming over last century linked to natural causes: Published in Geophysical Research Letters: Excerpt: “Tsonis et al. investigate the collective behavior of known climate cycles such as the Pacific Decadal Oscillation, the North Atlantic Oscillation, the El Nino/Southern Oscillation, and the North Pacific Oscillation. By studying the last 100 years of these cycles' patterns, they find that the systems synchronized several times. Further, in cases where the synchronous state was followed by an increase in the coupling strength among the cycles, the synchronous state was destroyed. Then a new climate state emerged, associated with global temperature changes and El Nino/Southern Oscillation variability. The authors show that this mechanism explains all global temperature tendency changes and El Nino variability in the 20th century. Authors: Anastasios A. Tsonis, Kyle Swanson, and Sergey Kravtsov: Atmospheric Sciences Group, Department of Mathematical Sciences, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, U.S.A. See August 2, 2007 Science Daily – “Synchronized Chaos: Mechanisms For Major Climate Shifts” (LINK)
 
At the state governor level, of course there be politics. If a governor wants to appoint someone to an advisory position who can advise from the scientific mainstream, what’s the problem? Taylor is no Galileo; all he stands to lose is a title that a University gave to him. If he wants to spout scientifically unsupportable nonsense, best he not do that in the name of your fine state. Taking the 'State' from his title won't silence him. I note that he has no problem getting himself heard.

So where should a state governor get his information on climate? From someone that will "seldom give 'both sides' of the argument, because the 'other side' (the one that suggests that human activities exert a dominant role in the climate system) is well-represented in journals and the media"?

Isn't it better instead that he get that information from someone that will represent the mainstream scientific opinion?

Science should be politicized?

Thanks for clarifying your opinion on that.
 
As a passing note, the "record" Antarctic ice is only a record since 1979. It's still far less ice than in the fifties. The summer ice-melt in the Arctic is an all-time record for the last few centuries of observation and exploration.

You appear to be incorrect.
JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH, VOL. 111, C01001, doi:10.1029/2004JC002851, 2006

Historical variability of sea ice edge position in the Nordic Seas
Dmitry V. Divine and Dr. Chad Dick

Abstract Historical ice observations in the Nordic Seas from April through August are used to construct time series of ice edge position anomalies spanning the period 1750–2002. While analysis showed that interannual variability remained almost constant throughout this period, evidence was found of oscillations in ice cover with periods of about 60 to 80 years and 20 to 30 years, superimposed on a continuous negative trend. The lower frequency oscillations are more prominent in the Greenland Sea, while higher frequency oscillations are dominant in the Barents. The analysis suggests that the recent well-documented retreat of ice cover can partly be attributed to a manifestation of the positive phase of the 60–80 year variability, associated with the warming of the subpolar North Atlantic and the Arctic. The continuous retreat of ice edge position observed since the second half of the 19th century may be a recovery after significant cooling in the study area that occurred as early as the second half of the 18th century.
 
Or maybe because he knows that the mass of AGW evidence doesn't stand or fall solely on his team's modelling of GREENLAND ICE, you damnable liar.

Modeling is an extremely important part of AGW. Sea level rise is one of the few direct signals of GW. Greenland is viewed by scientists as more meltable than Antarctica for reasons I doubt you would comprehend.

LR's comment is on tract.
 
Science should be politicized?

Thanks for clarifying your opinion on that.

Right...

If anything, the opposite. Politics could do with being more 'scienceized': basing decisions on the scientific mainstream, not the fringe.

Isn't that a laudable goal?
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
Science should be politicized?
Thanks for clarifying your opinion on that.

​
Right...
If anything, the opposite. Politics could do with being more 'scienceized': basing decisions on the scientific mainstream, not the fringe.
Isn't that a laudable goal?

Considering massive - truly massive - funding and pushing by the likes of Greenpeace and Environmental Defense League to influence legislation and public opinion, I'm at a loss to establish how at any moment in time, in a highly politicized environment, one might be able to step aside and say "Here is the scientific mainstream - OBEY AND FOLLOW".

You are asserting that the individual is not capable of certain decisions, should not be allowed certain opinions, that run counter to the cultural milieu we find ourselves in. Or that if he has such opinions, he should keept quiet about them. Your attitude on this seems very dangerous politically, and counter to Western concepts of the value of individual contribution and thinking.

In my opinion, this is a simple matter of free speech. We happen to have in the USA, a thing called a Bill of Rights.
 
Considering massive - truly massive - funding and pushing by the likes of Greenpeace and Environmental Defense League to influence legislation and public opinion, I'm at a loss to establish how at any moment in time, in a highly politicized environment, one might be able to step aside and say "Here is the scientific mainstream - OBEY AND FOLLOW".

You are asserting that the individual is not capable of certain decisions, should not be allowed certain opinions, that run counter to the cultural milieu we find ourselves in. Or that if he has such opinions, he should keept quiet about them. Your attitude on this seems very dangerous politically, and counter to Western concepts of the value of individual contribution and thinking.

In my opinion, this is a simple matter of free speech. We happen to have in the USA, a thing called a Bill of Rights.

He can say anything he wants. He can't say it as the representative of his state as State Climatologist if his state doesn't think he is entitled to that title. It's like I proclaim myself State Climatologist here in Australia, and start making pronouncements.
 
I'm at a loss to establish how at any moment in time, in a highly politicized environment, one might be able to step aside and say "Here is the scientific mainstream - OBEY AND FOLLOW".


At a loss? Can you not think of any way of identifying the scientific mainstream re. climate science?

Nothing coming to mind at all....?

Anybody?

As for the rest of your post, and what you think I was 'asserting', no. Just... no.
 
This is news to me. According to their website, they have been around since 1976. If I understand you correctly, this position became non paying and was "infiltrated" by non AGW's? I was also under the impression that the majority of state climatologists are supporters of AGW so the infiltration was only moderately successful. Nevertheless, there are plenty of qualified AGW dissenters that would hardly fall into such an extreme minority such as the creationists among the biologists.

http://www.stateclimate.org/about/

State climatologists, where they exist, are payed by their State; where funding is mentioned it refers to funding for the AACS - an association.

There was a period when the AACS was infiltrated, and when you consider the definition of State Climatologist

"State Climatologists are individuals who have been identified by a state entity as the state's climatologist and who are also recognized by the Director of the National Climatic Data Center (NCDC) of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration as the state climatologist of a particular state."

it's hazy enough to allow such infiltration, paticularly via states that did not previously recognise such a position. Following the Leninist handbook (no sloppy creationist analogies from me :)) such entryists were activists, willing to commit time and expense to office-holding through which they presented a political face to the outside world.

It worked for a while (the period that its referenced from by the likes of mhaze) but as you point out the ordinary members are normal scientists who can spot an elephant in a room. That's why it only worked for a while. Even Pat Michaels has given up on it.

Michaels has a point in that there are great demands on his time, there being so few qualified AGW dissenters available to provide the media with the balance it so often demands.
 
State climatologists, where they exist, are payed by their State; where funding is mentioned it refers to funding for the AACS - an association.

There was a period when the AACS was infiltrated, and when you consider the definition of State Climatologist

Looks like these were state clim. positions going back to 1970s.
Contrary evidence?

it's hazy enough to allow such infiltration, paticularly via states that did not previously recognise such a position. Following the Leninist handbook (no sloppy creationist analogies from me :)) such entryists were activists, willing to commit time and expense to office-holding through which they presented a political face to the outside world.
Evidence?

It worked for a while (the period that its referenced from by the likes of mhaze) but as you point out the ordinary members are normal scientists who can spot an elephant in a room. That's why it only worked for a while. Even Pat Michaels has given up on it.
Evidence?

Michaels has a point in that there are great demands on his time, there being so few qualified AGW dissenters available to provide the media with the balance it so often demands.
Conspiracy theory?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom