For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

Maybe the issue I don't get completely (on the political side of the debate) is the great separation you have in your country between liberals (mostly democrats) and right wing. The liberal side is associated with separation of church and state, correct science teaching in schools (evolution), civil liberties, more taxes and so on. Right wing, OTOH, is linked to capitalism, religion in schools, pro-lifers, and in this case AGW skepticism. So a linkage to creationism and AGW skepticism is viewed as "natural".

That's not healthy. There is a POV which is compatible with right wing economical thinking and left wing social liberal thinking, reflected, per example, in Capitalism Magazine (http://capmag.com). Long time fighters against creationism and other forms of bad science, abortion supporters, AGW skeptics, pro-free market and so on. I guess that combination sound strange to most americans, and just now I realize that it can lead to moronic comparatives about completely unrelated fields.
Why you haven't developed a political force who respect economic liberties, social liberties and good science is a question that escapes to my historic knowledge.

End of thread derail :)
Very true, but there is a wide middle ground in both parties and an even wider bunch of independents between the parties. The independents can go either way and usually are the deciding factor.

The Democrats have to at least act like they respect their radical left wing environmental faction, which is anti-nuclear energy. That's increasingly a big problem for them. AGW is a big problem, too. There has been an effort to politicize AGW here, which has backfired in many interesting ways.

We seem to be heading toward a Demo-AGW-anti nuclear power and Repub-AGW-pro nuclear power set of platforms. In general though, if there is not a discussion on the science or the economics of AGW/GW, I'm not a participant.

is quisnam clamo liar est liar:D
 
I think, however, that your specific thread derail might only apply to Americans.
And for foreigners that are confused (like me) about the strong connection you people have between AGW skepticism and creationism. I'm browsing google right now and noticing how often both are promoted in the same american political web sites.
 
Last edited:
And for foreigners that are confused (like me) about the strong connection you people have between AGW skepticism and creationism. I'm browsing google right now and noticing how often both are promoted in the same american political web sites.
Earth to Lucifuge Rofocale ...

I am not American. I've never even visited the continent.
 
Last edited:
In general though, if there is not a discussion on the science or the economics of AGW/GW, I'm not a participant.
Which is sensible, given how stupid you look when you do stick your oar in.

is quisnam clamo liar est liar:D
Do you realise that that isn't a Latin tag, isn't Latin, and means bugger-all in that Classical tongue?
 
Last edited:
First : Its LUCIFUGE.
Second : In that case, you are a foreigner that is NOT confused by the connection :)
Third: Why don't you go back to page 2 and try to read the articles I posted? I even made a special short list specifically directed at you, eliminating various papers that don't have , at first sight, strong connection to my comments? Maybe you overlooked that list.


Earth to Lucifage Rofocale ...

I am not American. I've never even visited the continent.
 
First : Its LUCIFUGE.
You will notice that I corrected that before you mentioned it. Call me ... Dr Accurate.

Third: Why don't you go back to page 2 and try to read the articles I posted? I even made a special short list specifically directed at you, eliminating various papers that don't have , at first sight, strong connection to my comments?
As I've pointed out, I am already aware of this stuff; and I have already read your precis of the papers plus the quotations from them that you find telling; but if it makes you happy, I'll read the papers on your shortlist.

Though it would be more convenient if you could just quote or precis the bits that you think I should read. Otherwise it's like a Twoofer or a creationist urging me to watch a 90 minute video --- is it really going to contain anything I haven't seen already? If you have more points to make, couldn't you just make them?
 
First : Its LUCIFUGE.
Second : In that case, you are a foreigner that is NOT confused by the connection :)
Third: Why don't you go back to page 2 and try to read the articles I posted? I even made a special short list specifically directed at you, eliminating various papers that don't have , at first sight, strong connection to my comments? Maybe you overlooked that list.
BTW, that was your post #666. Couldn't you have made it a bit more ... fiendish?
 
Last edited:
Dr Adequate;3181467As I've pointed out said:
your[/I] precis of the papers plus the quotations from them that you find telling; but if it makes you happy, I'll read the papers on your shortlist.

You'll find contrarians very demanding in that regard.

Though it would be more convenient if you could just quote or precis the bits that you think I should read.

That you won't find so much.
 
You will notice that I corrected that before you mentioned it. Call me ... Dr Accurate.

As I've pointed out, I am already aware of this stuff; and I have already read your precis of the papers plus the quotations from them that you find telling; but if it makes you happy, I'll read the papers on your shortlist.

Though it would be more convenient if you could just quote or precis the bits that you think I should read. Otherwise it's like a Twoofer or a creationist urging me to watch a 90 minute video --- is it really going to contain anything I haven't seen already? If you have more points to make, couldn't you just make them?

Don't worry, if you want read just the conclusions . Hint: One of them even says that AGW could change the conclusions of it when more data becomes available.

But first one thing:

Do you question the sources? do you think that I'm using biased sources or invalid researchers?
. If you'll claim so , then, why bother? I have refrained to post references from Lindzen or other that have been attempted to discredit by AGWr's, so that shouldn't be a concern, but who knows?
 
Last edited:
Do you question the sources? do you think that I'm using biased sources or invalid researchers?
No, you withdrew the one that wasn't peer-reviewed and was sponsored by an oil company.

We have to leave the climate stuff up to climatologists, really ... we don't have the satellites or the great big computers they have. If you can't trust scientists to do science, who can you trust?
 
LUCIFUGE,

i appreciate the fact that you've taken the time to actually post abstracts and cites that you interpret as supporting your conclusion. i've read through a great number of A/GW material in various threads here, at realclamate.org and even climateaudit.org, and i've not seen many of these abstracts previously.

our current understanding of paleoclimate correlates beautifully to milankovitch cycles. these data seem to confirm that milankovitch cycles drive the earth's major warming and cooling periods. the degree of difference in distance between the earth and sun caused by milankovitch cycles is very small, however the degree of temperature difference between these cycles is quite large. this is very good evidence that positive and negative feedback loops exist to elevate warming periods and dampen cooling periods.

we know that in the lab CO2 is a greenhouse gas, so it is very likely that atmospheric CO2 behaves in a similar manner. we also have quite a nice set of paleoclimate data from various ice cores. these data show a very definite correlation between atmospheric CO2 and temperature. given that CO2 is a greenhouse gas in the lab, and that CO2 correlates so well with temperature, it seems more than likely that CO2 creates positive feedback.

given that we know positive feedback holds a great deal of control over the degree of warming that the earth experiences, and given that we have good reason to suspect that CO2 creates positive feedback, we have good reason to expect that increased atmospheric CO2 should increase the warming that the earth experiences. the question that i think is still not answered is, well, how much?

from all i've read, and my current understanding, further data could very well still place atmospheric carbon as a major contributer to the total positive feedback that drives the major increases in temperature. further data could very well place atmospheric carbon as a minor contributer that simply "breaks the camel's back", unleashing a number of other positive feedback loops (methane from the permafrost, for example), that lead to a greater degree of warming than previously expected. further data could very well place atmospheric carbon as a minor contributer whose affects on temperature and climate are simply negligible. all these conclusions are possible.

regardless, i think that we've enough confidence of our basic understanding of the importance of positive feedback loops to do our best to leave the carbon cycle alone if at all possible. while we may not have the data, yet, to accurately predict the total amount of increased warming that the increased atmospheric carbon will cause, there's no reason to risk anything, if alternatives exist, and to a large extent, they do.

currently, i believe that increased CO2 will cause a measurable, noticable increase in global warming, but i don't think it will be catastrophic, but my conclusions can only get more accurate with increased data, so i appreciate the fact that you've brought some evidence to the table. those that do not appreciate your evidence have either already been made aware of the evidence, or do not care as much about accurate conclusions as they do about defending their positions.

i will read through your abstracts as time warrents, and comment when possible.

thanks,
anthony.
 
Last edited:
currently, i believe that increased CO2 will cause a measurable, noticable increase in global warming, but i don't think it will be catastrophic, but my conclusions can only get more accurate with increased data, so i appreciate the fact that you've brought some evidence to the table. those that do not appreciate your evidence have either already been made aware of the evidence, or do not care as much about accurate conclusions as they do about defending their positions.

i will read through your abstracts as time warrents, and comment when possible.

thanks,
anthony.
August 9, 2007 in the Geophysical Research Letters finds that climate models fail test against real clouds. "To give an idea of how strong this enhanced cooling mechanism is, if it was operating on global warming, it would reduce estimates of future warming by over 75 percent," Dr. Roy Spencer said. "At least 80 percent of the Earth's natural greenhouse effect is due to water vapor and clouds, and those are largely under the control of precipitation systems. Until we understand how precipitation systems change with warming, I don't believe we can know how much of our current warming is manmade. Without that knowledge, we can't predict future climate change with any degree of certainty," Spencer added. The paper was co-authored by University of Alabama Huntsville's Dr. John R. Christy and Dr. W. Danny Braswell, and Dr. Justin Hnilo of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA. (LINK)

STUDY # 3:
New Study: Global warming over last century linked to natural causes

(Below excerpt clarifies study’s conclusion)

Excerpts: It is interesting to speculate on the climate shift after the 1970s event. The standard explanation for the post 1970s warming is that the radiative effect of greenhouse gases overcame shortwave reflection effects due to aerosols [Mann and Emanuel, 2006]. However, comparison of the 2035 event in the 21st century simulation and the 1910s event Figure 3. Same as Figure 1 but for a control run of GFDL CM2.1 model with 1860 pre-industrial conditions. See text for discussion.L13705 TSONIS ET AL.: MECHANISM FOR MAJOR CLIMATE SHIFTS L13705 4 of 5 in the observations with this event, suggests an alternative hypothesis, namely that the climate shifted after the 1970s event to a different state of a warmer climate, which may be superimposed on an anthropogenic warming trend.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/08/070801175711.htm


Harvard Physicist Lubos Motl reacts to new climate change study linking temps to natural causes (Study # 3 above)

Excerpt: If you are interested in their predictions, a 0.2 Celsius cooling between 2005 and 2020 should be followed by a 0.3 Celsius warming until 2045 or so and by cooling in the rest of the 21st century. 2100 is seen as more than 0.1 Celsius cooler than 2005. While they admit the possibility that their curves should be superimposed with contributions such as the enhanced greenhouse effect, they have a very different explanation for the climate shift in the late 1970s that has nothing to do with aerosols or greenhouse gases.

http://motls.blogspot.com/2007/08/mechanism-for-major-climate-shifts.html
 
Scepticism, a hallmark of science, is frowned upon.

while we may not have the data, yet, to accurately predict the total amount of increased warming that the increased atmospheric carbon will cause, there's no reason to risk anything, if alternatives exist, and to a large extent, they do.

currently, i believe that increased CO2 will cause a measurable, noticable increase in global warming, but i don't think it will be catastrophic, but my conclusions can only get more accurate with increased data

One more. Christy, by the way, agrees with AGW, but his research shows that land use changes is far more important than CO2. Thus he views the current AGW political agenda to restrict CO2 as largely futile.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/7081331.stm
John R Christy is Professor and Director of the Earth System Science Center at the University of Alabama, Huntsville, US
He has contributed to all four major IPCC assessments, including acting as a Lead Author in 2001 and a Contributing Author in 2007
Scepticism, a hallmark of science, is frowned upon. (I suspect the IPCC bureaucracy cringes whenever I’m identified as an IPCC Lead Author.)

The signature statement of the 2007 IPCC report may be paraphrased as this: “We are 90% confident that most of the warming in the past 50 years is due to humans.”

We are not told here that this assertion is based on computer model output, not direct observation. The simple fact is we don’t have thermometers marked with “this much is human-caused” and “this much is natural”. So, I would have written this conclusion as “Our climate models are incapable of reproducing the last 50 years of surface temperatures without a push from how we think greenhouse gases influence the climate. Other processes may also account for much of this change.”
​
 
This is the Science and tech forum...

HEEEEELLLOOOO?
In several posts, in response to non-scientific content, you have reminded members that this is a Science forum.

Well, bravo I say. I take it then that you have rethought your practice of citing non-scientific propaganda. (In fairness, many but not all these goofy cites are courtesy of mhaze.)
 
How does one square this with the fact that the US and Canada are in talks about the legal and trade ramifications of the imminent opening of the Northwest passage?

Check out the publication date : March 2001. The situation has changed a lot since then, and there's been quite a flurry of flag-planting in the (not so) Frozen North recently.

It'll all end in tears, mark my words.
 
"Arctic sea ice thickness remained constant during the 1990s
Winsor P
Geophysical Research Letters 28 (6): 1039-1041 Mar 15 2001
Abstract: The ice cover of the Arctic Ocean is considered to be a sensitive indicator of global climate change. Recent research, using submarine-based observations, suggests that the Arctic ice cover was thinner in the 1990s compared to an earlier period (1958-1979), and that it continued to decrease in thickness in the 1990s. Here I analyze subsurface ice thickness (draft) of Arctic sea ice from six submarine cruises from 1991 to 1997. This extensive data set shows that there was no trend towards a thinning ice cover during the 1990s. Data from the North Pole shows a slight increase in mean ice thickness, whereas the Beaufort Sea shows a small decrease, none of which are significant. Transects between the two areas from 76 degrees N to 90 degrees N also show near constant ice thicknesses, with a general spatial decrease from the Pole towards the Beaufort Sea. Combining the present results with those of an earlier study, I conclude that the mean ice thickness has remained on a near-constant level around the North Pole from 1986 to 1997."

Other contemporary research came to a different conclusion, so I guess the jury was still out on this. One point that intrigues me about the conclusion is the reference to "around the North Pole", rather than "in the Arctic Ocean". Why the distinction? The first answer that springs to mind is that the author's conclusion specifically refers to the most northerly ice, not Arctic ice in toto.

If Arctic ice-cover is a sensitive indicator of climate change, what are we to make of events since 1997? Summer 2005 saw a record low in Arctic ice-extent, and that record was smashed in summer 2007. It's hard to explain this rapid loss of ice without a cumulative thinning over previous decades. I'm bound to wonder just what merit this particular paper retains after another decade of observation.
 
"Climate change and trend detection in selected rivers within the Asia-Pacific region
Cluis D, Laberge C
Water International 26 (3): 411-424 SEP 2001
Abstract: Global climate change is currently an issue of great concern. This phenomenon was studied using the runoff of large rivers, which can be considered a regional integrator of the local precipitation occurring in their basins. The long-term stationarity and the possibility of trends in streamflow records stored in the databank of the Global Runoff Data Center (GRDC) at the Federal Institute of Hydrology in Koblenz (Germany) were studied. Runoff records originating from. 78 rivers with long monthly runoff series that are geographically distributed throughout the whole Asia-Pacific region were selected for study. For each of the selected rivers, three time series were constructed and analyzed: the mean yearly, and the maximum and minimum monthly discharges. These series were submitted to a two-tier analysis. First, a segmentation procedure developed by Hubert was applied to assess their stationarity. Then the segmented series were submitted to a specialized trend detection software. The results show that about two-thirds of the series have remained stationary and that the monthly minimum runoff exhibited more changing levels (37/78) than the mean (26/78) and maximum (18/78) runoff. Most of the detected changes occurred during the 1960s and 1970s, a period of rapid demographic expansion and urbanization in Asia, when irrigation and other water uses were developed, especially in tropical areas. During the same period and within the area studied, a number of large dams and reservoirs were completed. Since these anthropic interventions could be at the origin of the changes in runoff, there is no regionally consistent evidence supporting global climate change."

The unbolded part of the final sentence says "the crime-scene was so compromised" just before the "no useful evidence could be gathered from it". All the paper concludes is that this is not a good way to extract a climate-change signal from surrounding noise. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, m'kay?

Given that contrarians so often cite urbanisation as a reason not to trust weather-station series I find it amusing this is still on their forwarding list. The list never seems to get pruned - this is another paper from 2001.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom