For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

No I haven't, which is why I have never said any such thing.
Now I'm confused. Based in what you say, you think that there are peer reviewed science and legitimate climate scientists who disagree with IPCC?
If so, what's the reason of the foolish portrait of AGW skeptics as creationists? I have never seem a peer reviewed creationist paper and I don't think there is such thing as a legitimate creationist biologist.
 
Now I'm confused. Based in what you say, you think that there are peer reviewed science and legitimate climate scientists who disagree with IPCC?
Yes, of course. Which is why I never said otherwise.

If so, what's the reason of the foolish portrait of AGW skeptics as creationists?
'Cos that's what they behave like. I'm not talking about "scientists who disagree with IPCC". I'm talking about the people who lie, distort, think up paranoid conspiracy theories about how global warming is a plot to destroy the American economy, explain how it's impossible to trap heat 'cos of the Second Law of Thermodynamics, indulge in half-a-dozen logical fallacies before breakfast ... heck, you've seen what I object to.

And each such rant slightly increases my confidence that there is global warming, and that it's anthropogenic, because people who are right don't need to adopt the rhetorical techniques of people who are utterly wrong.

I have never seem a peer reviewed creationist paper and I don't think there is such thing as a legitimate creationist biologist.
Kurt Wise is a creationist paleontologist. He's quite nice actually.
 
Last edited:
Ping Pong?

'Cos that's what they behave like. I'm not talking about "scientists who disagree with IPCC". I'm talking about the people who lie, distort, think up paranoid conspiracy theories about how global warming is a plot to destroy the American economy, explain how it's impossible to trap heat 'cos of the Second Law of Thermodynamics, indulge in half-a-dozen logical fallacies before breakfast ... heck, you've seen what I object to.

And each such rant slightly increases my confidence that there is global warming, and that it's anthropogenic, because people who are right don't need to adopt the rhetorical techniques of people who are utterly wrong.
​
Replacing key phrases and you've got...
'Cos that's what they behave like. I'm not talking about "scientists who agree with IPCC". I'm talking about people who lie, distort, think up paranoid conspiracy theories about how Exxon and anti global warming deniers is a plot to destroy the progressive far left agenda, with it's cherished group of central, anti nuclear power treehuggers, explain how it's impossible to not trap heat 'cos of the Second Law of Thermodynamics, indulge in half-a-dozen logical fallacies before breakfast ... heck, you've seen what I object to.
​
Replacing more key phrases and you've got...
heck, you've seen what I object to.

And each such rant slightly increases my confidence that there isn't a significant global warming that is anthropogenic, because people who are right don't need to adopt the rhetorical techniques of people who are utterly wrong.
​
I've provided published, peer reviewed examples of this attitude, additionally, I've provided examples in public media. I'm sure you can point to some entries on blogs to prove your assertion. I personally have no interest in a couple of blog entries as proof of an assertion about a significant scientific opinion on a major subject.

Simple searching of Google can show where the most abuse of the truth is. Want to try 20 foot wall of water? Greenland melting? Species extinction? Hockey stick? Planet in imminent peril?
 
Replacing key phrases and you've got...

Replacing more key phrases and you've got ...
Yes, replacing truth with falsehood will produce false statements.

However, what you need to sustain your end of the debate would be truth, not stupid insane lies about statements that your opponents have never made.

I'm sure you can point to some entries on blogs to prove your assertion.
And also to the crazy halfwitted puke of half-digested lies that you vomit up in your posts.

If you want people to take anti-AGW arguments seriously, you should try to conceal the fact that you've gone off your head.

---

I notice that you still haven't told me what my "definitions" are. I guess the vaguer you keep your lies, the harder they are to refute, yes?
 
Last edited:
[snip]
no, troothers do not invoke the supernatural, so they are more similar to AGW deniers than are creationists. but at least AGW deniers are defending a minority position in the scientific community that was previously widely held within the scientific community, for which a minority of evidence exists.
[another snip]


Excuse me? One does not have to be an "AGW denier" to scoff at the silly so-called "solutions" proposed to mitigate global warming.
 
Stave off runaway, catastrophic global warming!!! ?

So, you have no scientific opinions, matters, or issues to debate, and would like to slant the discussion into personal innuendo and such. Some sort of vague unsubstantiated allegories to some religious sect beliefs and some other bunch I've never heard of and don't care to.

Nothing new there, I must say.

Or am I mistaken?

By the way. Here are tree hugger action groupies at Environmental Defense with their latest "science". Are these reflective of your concept of real science as espoused by climatologists? (bold is mine).

Or to put it in the words of the OP,

Is this who you get your climate science from?


What's At Stake? Operation Climate Vote - Take Action


Why Must We Act Now?

We have launched Operation Climate Vote to ramp up public pressure on Congress to tackle global warming this year. That's because when it comes to fighting global warming, we are running out of time.
Scientists tell us that even if we cut global warming emissions to zero tomorrow, there is enough carbon dioxide pollution already accumulated in the atmosphere to increase global temperatures for decades to come. Every additional ton of carbon we emit accelerates this warming trend.
To stave off runaway, catastrophic global warming, scientists tell us that we must stabilize the concentration of carbon dioxide pollution in the earth's atmosphere at 450 parts per million. To reach this target, America needs to cut its CO2 pollution by 80% by 2050.
That's an average of 2% reductions per year if we start now.
However, even after Congress passes a global warming cap and the president signs it into law, it will take another couple years to develop and implement procedures to effectively administer the law.


So, it will be 2010 at the earliest before we begin achieving real emissions cuts. And, if we don't pass law this year, the politics of passing legislation next year during a presidential campaign is dicey. It could be 2009 or later before we have another realistic chance to pass a bill.
The longer we delay, the deeper we have to cut to hit our 80% reduction target by 2050.
 
I notice that you still haven't told me what my "definitions" are. I guess the vaguer you keep your lies, the harder they are to refute, yes?

Let me jump in and add my definition..

There are two types of people:

o Those that had read the papers and then passed judgement.
o Those that had passed judgement before reading the papers.

You have admitted that you are in the later group. Your opinion of those papers is an admittedly ignorant one, yet you still saw no problem sharing that opinion in a thread that asks where TokenConservative should be getting his information.

Apparently he should be getting it from someone as ignorant as he is.
 
And each such rant slightly increases my confidence that there is global warming, and that it's anthropogenic, because people who are right don't need to adopt the rhetorical techniques of people who are utterly wrong.

I object that. I have seem the same from both groups. But if the debating technique is what has formed your opinion instead of the actual science, then you are wrong no matter that, if by chance, your opinion result correct.
 
So, you have no scientific opinions, matters, or issues to debate ...
Well, not in your posts, anyway. Just a lot of hysterical gibble about "the far left agenda" and stupid lies about thermodynamics.

Do let us know when your going to present some "scientific opinions, matters, or issues" for me to debate, rather than halfwitted lies about your opponents.

---

I notice that you still haven't told me what my "definitions" are.
 
Last edited:
Well, not in your posts, anyway. Just a lot of hysterical gibble about "the far left agenda" and stupid lies about thermodynamics.

Do let us know when your going to present some "scientific opinions, matters, or issues" for me to debate, rather than halfwitted lies about your opponents.

Tu quoque ? You and in this thread?
:D
 
Tu quoque ? You and in this thread?
:D
In English, if you will?

---

I quoted a real person on one side of the debate talking rubbish about the second law of thermodynamics, as creationists do. Mhaze pretended that people on the other side of the debate had done the same thing. This is a lame attempt at a tu quoque, and also a lie.
 
Last edited:
In English, if you will?

I quoted a real person on one side of the debate talking rubbish about the second law of thermodynamics, as creationists do. Mhaze pretended that people on the other side of the debate had done the same thing. This is a lame attempt at a tu quoque, and also a lie.

Gosh, my lame attempts all include references and citations.

You have made an effort to bait and draw people into some sort of little catfight, me thinks. Now, you may get some takers on that. A childish little game, though, isn't it?

You have lost every argument you conclude by asserting your opponent is a liar, in case you did not know.

is quisnam clamo liar est liar
 
Maybe the issue I don't get completely (on the political side of the debate) is the great separation you have in your country between liberals (mostly democrats) and right wing. The liberal side is associated with separation of church and state, correct science teaching in schools (evolution), civil liberties, more taxes and so on. Right wing, OTOH, is linked to capitalism, religion in schools, pro-lifers, and in this case AGW skepticism. So a linkage to creationism and AGW skepticism is viewed as "natural".

That's not healthy. There is a POV which is compatible with right wing economical thinking and left wing social liberal thinking, reflected, per example, in Capitalism Magazine (http://capmag.com). Long time fighters against creationism and other forms of bad science, abortion supporters, AGW skeptics, pro-free market and so on. I guess that combination sound strange to most americans, and just now I realize that it can lead to moronic comparatives about completely unrelated fields.
Why you haven't developed a political force who respect economic liberties, social liberties and good science is a question that escapes to my historic knowledge.

End of thread derail :)
 
Gosh, my lame attempts all include references and citations.
Apart from the bits where you lie and lie and lie with no references or citations whatsoever.

You have made an effort to bait and draw people into some sort of little catfight, me thinks. Now, you may get some takers on that. A childish little game, though, isn't it?

You have lost every argument you conclude by asserting your opponent is a liar, in case you did not know.

is quisnam clamo liar est liar
So, instead of trying to justify your gibble-gabble, you just declare that I've "lost the argument". I guess that must be a great comfort to you. It will hardly be convincing to others.

By the way, you still haven't told me what my "definitions" are.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom