For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

Originally Posted by Dr AdequateI don't know how you "noticed" that, but my method of assessing his veracity was to compare what the abstracts said with what he said they said. The contrast is really quite striking.​
Do you think that people on this forum are not be familiar with most of these references?

Hint:
Read the actual articles and get back to us when you are up to speed.
Science and Tech, right?
 
Do you think that people on this forum are not be familiar with most of these references?
Since you ask, I think that some of them are be, that some of them are not be, and that I am not be sure what the point of your question is be.
 
Last edited:
creationists are not looked down upon because they hold the minority position in a scientific debate; creationists are looked down upon because they invoke the supernatural, and are therefore not scientific.
The reason I look down on creationists is 'cos their arguments are rubbish. If they had any good ones, I should embrace the supernatural.

A/GW "skeptics" or "deniers" do not invoke the supernatural.
Nor do Twoofers, but the resemblance is striking.
 
Read the actual articles and get back to us when you are up to speed.
This would be necessary under the condition that there are in fact passages in the articles that support LR's "clarifications" but that for some reason he has omitted to quote them and instead for some mysterious reason has quoted, at length, completely different passages which don't support his "clarifications".

It had not crossed my mind that anyone would behave in such a strange way. If he will assure me that he has done so, I shall investigate further.
 
Last edited:
ok, you all need to stop comparing one another to creationists. seriously.

creationists are not looked down upon because they hold the minority position in a scientific debate; creationists are looked down upon because they invoke the supernatural, and are therefore not scientific. A/GW "skeptics" or "deniers" do not invoke the supernatural.

Yet, as I described, the behavior is identical. The deception and dishonesty, the ridiculous conspiracy beliefs, the rejection of reality in favor of ignorance in support of a partially unrelated agenda... they behave in the same way, whether their delusions are about homeopathic non-medicine, 9-11 conspiracies, or the anti-GW nonsense.
 
Arctic sea ice thickness remained constant during the 1990s
Winsor P
Geophysical Research Letters 28 (6): 1039-1041 Mar 15 2001
Abstract: The ice cover of the Arctic Ocean is considered to be a sensitive indicator of global climate change. Recent research, using submarine-based observations, suggests that the Arctic ice cover was thinner in the 1990s compared to an earlier period (1958-1979), and that it continued to decrease in thickness in the 1990s. Here I analyze subsurface ice thickness (draft) of Arctic sea ice from six submarine cruises from 1991 to 1997. This extensive data set shows that there was no trend towards a thinning ice cover during the 1990s. Data from the North Pole shows a slight increase in mean ice thickness, whereas the Beaufort Sea shows a small decrease, none of which are significant. Transects between the two areas from 76 degrees N to 90 degrees N also show near constant ice thicknesses, with a general spatial decrease from the Pole towards the Beaufort Sea. Combining the present results with those of an earlier study, I conclude that the mean ice thickness has remained on a near-constant level around the North Pole from 1986 to 1997.


This study says that there is no evidence of even a warming, so if there isn't a warming there isn't AGW also


How does one square this with the fact that the US and Canada are in talks about the legal and trade ramifications of the imminent opening of the Northwest passage?
 
This would be necessary under the condition that there are in fact passages in the articles that support LR's "clarifications" but that for some reason he has omitted to quote them and instead for some mysterious reason has quoted, at length, completely different passages which don't support his "clarifications".

It had not crossed my mind that anyone would behave in such a strange way. If he will assure me that he has done so, I shall investigate further.

Yes, indeed you might want to investigate further. I will give a tiny bit of assistance to you. There are no AGW and anti-AGW groups that neatly split up into your definitions. Those are fantasies, or perhaps monsters in your bedroom closet that come out at night.

What there actually are are a group of physical phenomena that may or may not be caused by man's influence.

Possible effects. Variations in Arctic ice, glacier melt, sea level rise or lack of, changes in ocean acidity, variations in global temperature, changes in hurricane frequency or intensity would be four such phenomena.

Possible causes. These include increases in CO2, black soot, Asian brown clouds, land use changes, variations in atmospheric humidity, solar variations, sunspots and cosmic ray influences.

Instead of there being any semblance of your straw man AGW/anti-AGW idiocy, there is widespread agreement between AGW skeptics and AGW believers on many of the linkages between these causes, and effects. There are specific areas of disagreement. They vary quite a bit.

Volatile's original questions are quiet penetrating from a public policy or philosophy of science point of view.

1) If we shouldn't get our information about climate from climatologists, who should we get it from?

2) Where did you learn that global warming wasn't happening and / or wasn't anthropogenic?
Originally Posted by volatile

Knowledge acquisition is what's really at the heart of my two questions - if one is individually unable, through lack of training, resources or anything else, to find out the truth of any particular matter, how should one approach the issue?
Doesn't this question have nontrivial implications regarding how a skeptic "should" function in a democracy? the particular issue, be it global warming or anti-missile missile shields, is irrelevant: does the JREF forum really have nothing to say regarding how one should approach such issues?
​
Any actual substantial comments? That is, presuming that you do not read the articles and remain in the decisively virginal, blissfully ignorant state?

See how this works now?
 
Hello Shadron:

1.- This paper is dated 2001.
2.- There are more recent papers that state the following:
17) Update - September 11, 2007: Antarctic ice GROWS to record levels. Excerpt: While the news focus has been on the lowest ice extent since satellite monitoring began in 1979 for the Arctic, the Southern Hemisphere (Antarctica) has quietly set a new record for most ice extent since 1979. This can be seen on this graphic from this University of Illinois site The Cryosphere Today, which updated snow and ice extent for both hemispheres daily. The Southern Hemispheric areal coverage is the highest in the satellite record, just beating out 1995, 2001, 2005 and 2006. Since 1979, the trend has been up for the total Antarctic ice extent. < > This winter has been an especially harsh one in the Southern Hemisphere with cold and snow records set in Australia, South America and Africa. (LINK) & (LINK) A February 2007 study reveals Antarctica is not following predicted global warming models. Excerpt: “A new report on climate over the world's southernmost continent shows that temperatures during the late 20th century did not climb as had been predicted by many global climate models." The research was led by David Bromwich, professor of professor of atmospheric sciences in the Department of Geography, and researcher with the Byrd Polar Research Center at Ohio State University. [See: Antarctic temperatures disagree with climate model predictions - (LINK) ]

How could this be? See, there is a study that could clarify that:
11) An April 2007 study revealed the Earth’s climate “seesawing” during the last 10,000 years, according to Swedish researchers Svante Björck, Karl Ljung and Dan Hammarlund of Lund University. Excerpt: During the last 10,000 years climate has been seesawing between the North and South Atlantic Oceans. As revealed by findings presented by Quaternary scientists at Lund University, Sweden, cold periods in the north have corresponded to warmth in the south and vice verse. These results imply that Europe may face a slightly cooler future than predicted by IPCC, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. < > We can identify a persistent "seesaw" pattern. When the South Atlantic was warm it was cold in the North Atlantic and vice versa. This is most certainly related to large-scale ocean circulation in the Atlantic Ocean. The main current system - "the Great Ocean Conveyor" - is driven by sinking of dense, relatively cold and salty water in the northern North Atlantic. This results in southward-flowing deep-water that is replaced by warm surface water brought to high northern latitudes from the tropics and ultimately from the South Atlantic, says Svante Björck. < > Our results from Nightingale Island in the Tristan da Cunha island group, between South Africa and Argentina, for the first time give evidence of warming of the South Atlantic associated with cooling in the north. This is a major breakthrough in palaeoclimate research. (LINK)
Which also refutes AGW models replacing CO2 with ocean circulation as climate driver, denying AGW

The AGW "explanation" is that GW is not "uniform". The much more informed (they don't use models, they use real data) Björck,Ljung and Hammarlund conclusion is that ocean circulation drives those changes, instead of CO2.

How does one square this with the fact that the US and Canada are in talks about the legal and trade ramifications of the imminent opening of the Northwest passage?
 
For gods sake, no-one has ever claimed it did.
[/b][/size][/font]

Funny you comment only one study. For this one, you should reasonably assume that if CO2 is a so powerful GHG then it could stop a ice age, when it was MUCH MORE at that time than now and than predicted.

But my real point is that you haven't choose to comment any of the recent peer reviewed studies that explicitly deny AGW.

And also.....god doesn't exist :)
 
Last edited:
This would be necessary under the condition that there are in fact passages in the articles that support LR's "clarifications" but that for some reason he has omitted to quote them and instead for some mysterious reason has quoted, at length, completely different passages which don't support his "clarifications".

It had not crossed my mind that anyone would behave in such a strange way. If he will assure me that he has done so, I shall investigate further.

I would say that some of the papers are too old or that the resemblance to my point is not entirely obvious, so I could reduce the list to this ones who contribute to my point hands down (note: The others do so, but I think you need a reduced, more explicit list) :


A 2006 study by a team of scientists led by Petr Chylek of Los Alamos National Laboratory, Space and Remote Sensing Sciences found the rate of warming in 1920-1930 was about 50% higher than that in 1995-2005, suggesting carbon dioxide ‘could not be the cause’ of warming. (LINK)
“We find that the current Greenland warming is not unprecedented in recent Greenland history. Temperature increases in the two warming periods (1920-1930 and 1995-2005) are of similar magnitude, however the rate of warming in 1920-1930 was about 50% higher than that in 1995-2005,” the abstract of the study read.
The peer-reviewed study, which was published in the June 13, 2006 Geophysical Research Letters, found that after a warm 2003 on the southeastern coast of Greenland, “the years 2004 and 2005 were closer to normal being well below temperatures reached in the 1930’s and 1940’s.” The study further continued, “Almost all post-1955 temperature averages at Greenland stations are lower (colder climate) than the (1881-1955) temperature average.”
In addition, the Chylek led study explained, “Although there has been a considerable temperature increase during the last decade (1995 to 2005) a similar increase and at a faster rate occurred during the early part of the 20th century (1920 to 1930) when carbon dioxide or other greenhouse gases could not be a cause. The Greenland warming of 1920-1930 demonstrates that a high concentration of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases is not a necessary condition for a period of warming to arise. The observed 1995-2005 temperature increase seems to be within natural variability of Greenland climate. A general increase in solar activity [Scafetta and West, 2006] since 1990’s can be a contributing factor as well as the sea surface temperature changes of tropical ocean [Hoerling et al., 2001].”
“To summarize, we find no direct evidence to support the claims that the Greenland ice sheet is melting due to increased temperature caused by increased atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide.” The co-authors of the study were M.K. Dubey of Los Alamos National Laboratory and G. Lesins, Dalhousie University in Canada.

Explicitly denies AGW. See, if CO2 doesn't drive climate then NO model is correct.

Another problem for predictions of catastrophic sea level rise due to polar ice melt is Antarctica is not cooperating with the man-made catastrophic global warming models. “A new report on climate over the world's southernmost continent shows that temperatures during the late 20th century did not climb as had been predicted by many global climate models,” reads the February 15, 2007 press release announcing the findings of David Bromwich, professor of professor of atmospheric sciences in the Department of Geography, and researcher with the Byrd Polar Research Center at Ohio State University. (See: Antarctic temperatures disagree with climate model predictions LINK)
"It's hard to see a global warming signal from the mainland of Antarctica right now,” Bromwich explained. The release explains that Bromwich’s research team found “no increase in precipitation over Antarctica in the last 50 years. Most models predict that both precipitation and temperature will increase over Antarctica with a warming of the planet.”

Self explanatory. Models says that AGW is HAPPENING right now. Also gave some predictions that failed.


1) New peer-reviewed study finds global warming over last century linked to natural causes: Published in Geophysical Research Letters: Excerpt: “Tsonis et al. investigate the collective behavior of known climate cycles such as the Pacific Decadal Oscillation, the North Atlantic Oscillation, the El Nino/Southern Oscillation, and the North Pacific Oscillation. By studying the last 100 years of these cycles' patterns, they find that the systems synchronized several times. Further, in cases where the synchronous state was followed by an increase in the coupling strength among the cycles, the synchronous state was destroyed. Then a new climate state emerged, associated with global temperature changes and El Nino/Southern Oscillation variability. The authors show that this mechanism explains all global temperature tendency changes and El Nino variability in the 20th century. Authors: Anastasios A. Tsonis, Kyle Swanson, and Sergey Kravtsov: Atmospheric Sciences Group, Department of Mathematical Sciences, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, U.S.A. See August 2, 2007 Science Daily – “Synchronized Chaos: Mechanisms For Major Climate Shifts” (LINK)

EXPLICITLY DENIES AGW. This peer reviewed study shows that the recent climate changes have no man made components.

2) Belgian weather institute’s (RMI) August 2007 study dismisses decisive role of CO2 in warming: Excerpt: "Brussels: CO2 is not the big bogeyman of climate change and global warming. This is the conclusion of a comprehensive scientific study done by the Royal Meteorological Institute, which will be published this summer. The study does not state that CO2 plays no role in warming the earth. "But it can never play the decisive role that is currently attributed to it", climate scientist Luc Debontridder said. "Not CO2, but water vapor is the most important greenhouse gas. It is responsible for at least 75 % of the greenhouse effect. This is a simple scientific fact, but Al Gore's movie has hyped CO2 so much that nobody seems to take note of it." said Debontridder. "Every change in weather conditions is blamed on CO2. But the warm winters of the last few years (in Belgium) are simply due to the 'North-Atlantic Oscillation'. And this has absolutely nothing to do with CO2," he added. (LINK)
EXPLICITLY DENIES AGW. If CO2 plays no role warming earth, then all AGW models will fail predicting global trends, which is the case (see all the other studies who falsify model outcomes and predictions)



4) New peer-reviewed study finds clouds may greatly reduce global warming: Excerpt: This study published on August 9, 2007 in the Geophysical Research Letters finds that climate models fail test against real clouds. "To give an idea of how strong this enhanced cooling mechanism is, if it was operating on global warming, it would reduce estimates of future warming by over 75 percent," Dr. Roy Spencer said. "At least 80 percent of the Earth's natural greenhouse effect is due to water vapor and clouds, and those are largely under the control of precipitation systems. Until we understand how precipitation systems change with warming, I don't believe we can know how much of our current warming is manmade. Without that knowledge, we can't predict future climate change with any degree of certainty," Spencer added. The paper was co-authored by University of Alabama Huntsville's Dr. John R. Christy and Dr. W. Danny Braswell, and Dr. Justin Hnilo of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA. (LINK)
EXPLICITLY DENIES validity of agw models. See, if cloud effects are omitted, then the models would have fails and won't predict anything.


5) New peer-reviewed study finds that the solar system regulates the earth’s climate - The paper, authored by Richard Mackey, was published August 17, 2007 in the Journal of Coastal Research - Excerpt: “According to the findings reviewed in this paper, the variable output of the sun, the sun’s gravitational relationship between the earth (and the moon) and earth’s variable orbital relationship with the sun, regulate the earth’s climate. The processes by which the sun affects the earth show periodicities on many time scales; each process is stochastic and immensely complex. (LINK) & (LINK)

EXPLICITLY DENIES AGW. This peer reviewed paper finds causes other than man made CO2 emissions.
8) Chinese scientists Lin Zhen-Shan, and Sun Xian’s 2007 study, published in the peer-reviewed Meteorology and Atmospheric Physics, noted that CO2’s impact on warming may be “excessively exaggerated.” Excerpt: “The global climate warming is not solely affected by the CO2 greenhouse effect. The best example is temperature obviously cooling however atmospheric CO2 concentration is ascending from 1940s to 1970s. Although the CO2 greenhouse effect on global climate change is unsuspicious, it could have been excessively exaggerated. It is high time to reconsider the trend of global climate change,” the two scientists concluded. (LINK) & (LINK)

EXPLICITLY DENIES AGW (read the pdf, they predict a cooling). If there is a cooling in the next years, as those guys predict in this peer rebviewed study, then by definition there is no AGW.

10) A June 29, 2007 critique by Gerd Burger of Berlin’s Institute of Meteorology in the peer-reviewed Science Magazine challenged a previously touted study claiming the 20th century had been unusually warm. Excerpt: “Burger argues that [the 2006 temperature analysis by] Osborn and Briffa did not apply the appropriate statistical tests that link the proxy records to observational data, and as such, Osborn and Briffa did not properly quantify the statistical uncertainties in their analyses. Burger repeated all analyses with the appropriate adjustments and concluded “As a result, the ‘highly significant’ occurrences of positive anomalies during the 20th century disappear.” (LINK) Burger's technical comments in Science Magazine state: “Osborn and Briffa (Reports, 10 February 2006, p. 841) identified anomalous periods of warmth or cold in the Northern Hemisphere that were synchronous across 14 temperature-sensitive proxies. However, their finding that the spatial extent of 20th-century warming is exceptional ignores the effect of proxy screening on the corresponding significance levels. After appropriate correction, the significance of the 20th-century warming anomaly disappears.” (LINK)

There is not even a warming anomaly, so no AGW. See, if there are no 20 century anomalies then all models are wrong (again, that's why I posted so many papers that say that the models haven't passed reality check)

11) An April 2007 study revealed the Earth’s climate “seesawing” during the last 10,000 years, according to Swedish researchers Svante Björck, Karl Ljung and Dan Hammarlund of Lund University. Excerpt: During the last 10,000 years climate has been seesawing between the North and South Atlantic Oceans. As revealed by findings presented by Quaternary scientists at Lund University, Sweden, cold periods in the north have corresponded to warmth in the south and vice verse. These results imply that Europe may face a slightly cooler future than predicted by IPCC, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. < > We can identify a persistent "seesaw" pattern. When the South Atlantic was warm it was cold in the North Atlantic and vice versa. This is most certainly related to large-scale ocean circulation in the Atlantic Ocean. The main current system - "the Great Ocean Conveyor" - is driven by sinking of dense, relatively cold and salty water in the northern North Atlantic. This results in southward-flowing deep-water that is replaced by warm surface water brought to high northern latitudes from the tropics and ultimately from the South Atlantic, says Svante Björck. < > Our results from Nightingale Island in the Tristan da Cunha island group, between South Africa and Argentina, for the first time give evidence of warming of the South Atlantic associated with cooling in the north. This is a major breakthrough in palaeoclimate research. (LINK)
Which also refutes AGW models replacing CO2 with ocean circulation as climate driver, denying AGW. Look at AGW predictions and come to this paper and their predictions and past outcome. IPCC and this paper are in contradiction. Guess which one has the correct and observed results.

A July 2007 analysis of peer-reviewed literature thoroughly debunks fears of Greenland and the Arctic melting and predictions of a frightening sea level rise. Excerpt: "Research in 2006 found that Greenland has been warming since the 1880’s, but since 1955, temperature averages at Greenland stations have been colder than the period between 1881-1955. A 2006 study found Greenland has cooled since the 1930's and 1940's, with 1941 being the warmest year on record. Another 2006 study concluded Greenland was as warm or warmer in the 1930’s and 40’s and the rate of warming from 1920-1930 was about 50% higher than the warming from 1995-2005. One 2005 study found Greenland gaining ice in the interior higher elevations and thinning ice at the lower elevations. In addition, the often media promoted fears of Greenland’s ice completely melting and a subsequent catastrophic sea level rise are directly at odds with the latest scientific studies." [See July 30, 2007 Report - Latest Scientific Studies Refute Fears of Greenland Melt – (LINK) ]

Reality check for IPCC model NOT PASSED. Is consistent with the paper above and not with IPCC.

Update - September 11, 2007: Antarctic ice GROWS to record levels. Excerpt: While the news focus has been on the lowest ice extent since satellite monitoring began in 1979 for the Arctic, the Southern Hemisphere (Antarctica) has quietly set a new record for most ice extent since 1979. This can be seen on this graphic from this University of Illinois site The Cryosphere Today, which updated snow and ice extent for both hemispheres daily. The Southern Hemispheric areal coverage is the highest in the satellite record, just beating out 1995, 2001, 2005 and 2006. Since 1979, the trend has been up for the total Antarctic ice extent. < > This winter has been an especially harsh one in the Southern Hemisphere with cold and snow records set in Australia, South America and Africa. (LINK) & (LINK) A February 2007 study reveals Antarctica is not following predicted global warming models. Excerpt: “A new report on climate over the world's southernmost continent shows that temperatures during the late 20th century did not climb as had been predicted by many global climate models." The research was led by David Bromwich, professor of professor of atmospheric sciences in the Department of Geography, and researcher with the Byrd Polar Research Center at Ohio State University. [See: Antarctic temperatures disagree with climate model predictions - (LINK) ]

Reality check for IPCC model NOT PASSED. See above.


 
Do you think that people on this forum are not be familiar with most of these references?
The good doctor (who I really respect, he has an informed opinion in all themes I have seem he post) bought the AGW notion that there are not peer reviewed science and not climate scientists who disagree with IPCC. I understand his fury, remember a while ago when I came here to ask for sources who contradict a Chrichton article I found outrageous. Since then, and reading the sources I mentioned, I changed my mind about the subject.
 
Hansen
thick ice sheets provide not only a positive feedback... potential for cataclysmic collapse.....projected warmings under BAU would initiate albdeo-flip changes...

possible to save the Arctic from complete loss of ice...if absolute reduction of air pollutant forcings is achieved along with a reduction of CO2 growth...most rapid feasible slowdown of CO2 emissions, coupled with a forced reductions of other forcings, may just have a chance of avoiding disastrous climate change.....albedo feedback whipped the planet to hellish hothouse conditions...whipsaw between cold and warm.........imminent peril is initiation of dynamical and thermodynamical processess on the West Antartic and Greenland ice sheets....devastating sea-level rise will inevitably occur....activate the albedo-flip trigger....BAU GHG scenarios would cause large sea-level rise this century......best chance for averting ice sheet disintegration seems to be intense simultaneous efforts to reduce both co2 emissions and non-co2 climate forcings...
​
Climate Change and Trace Gases Hansen et al 2007
doi:10.1098/rsta.2007.2052
​

This Hansen quote is in direct contradiction with the science and climate scientists I posted before:

A February 8, 2007 peer-reviewed paper published in Science found the melt rate of two of Greenland’s largest glaciers has “suddenly slowed, bringing the rate of melting last year down to near the previous rate,” according to the New York Times blog
(2-8-07). (LINK)
The report found that the Kangerdlugssuaq glacier’s “average thinning over the glacier during the summer of 2006 declined to near zero, with some apparent thickening in areas on the main trunk.” (LINK) University of Washington’s Applied Physics Laboratory researcher Ian Howat, the lead author of the report, explained “Greenland was about as warm or warmer in the 1930’s and 40’s, and many of the glaciers were smaller than they are now.” “However, it does suggest that large variations in ice sheet dynamics can occur from natural climate variability,” Howat, also a researcher with the University of Colorado’s National Snow and Ice Data Center, explained. “Special care must be taken in how these and other mass-loss estimates are evaluated, particularly when extrapolating into the future because short-term spikes could yield erroneous long term trends,” Howat cautioned.
No link between increase of CO2 and climate, and this result contradicts directly the models.

A July 6, 2007 study published in the journal Science about Greenland by an international team of scientists found DNA “evidence that suggests the frozen shield covering the immense island survived the Earth’s last period of global warming,” according to a Boston Globe article. (6-6-07) (LINK) According to the article, the study indicates “Greenland’s ice may be less susceptible to the massive meltdown predicted by computer models of climate change, the main author (Eske Willerslev, professor of evolutionary biology at University of Copenhagen) said in an interview. “This may have implications for how the ice sheets respond to global warming. They may withstand rising temperatures,” Willerslev said. The article explained, “The discovery of organic matter in ice dating from half –a-million years ago offers evidence that the Greenland ice sheet remained frozen even during the Earth’s last ‘interglacial period’ – some 120,000 years ago – when average temperatures were 9 degrees Fahrenheit warmer than they are now.” Willerslev addressed scary computer model predictions of a massive Greenland melt. “[The study] suggests a problem with [computer] models” that predict melting ice from Greenland could drown cities and destroy civilizations, Willerslev said. The study found “Greenland really was green, before Ice Age glaciers enshrouded vast swaths of the Northern Hemisphere…somewhere between 450,000 and 800,000 years ago,” according to the article.

Denies the predicted income of AGW models, and the reality of the predicted "feedbacks", like albedo.


Climatologist Dr. Patrick Michaels of University of Virginia and the Virginia State climatologist wrote the scenario promoted by former Vice President Al Gore and others showing Greenland’s ice melting and raising sea levels by 20 feet is not supported anywhere in scientific literature, not even by the United Nations. “Where is the support for this claim? Certainly not in the recent [Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC)] Policymakers Summary from the United Nations. Under the [IPCC’s] medium-range emission scenario for greenhouse gases, a rise in sea level of between 8 and 17 inches is predicted by 2100. Gore’s film exaggerates the rise by about 2,000 percent,” Michaels wrote in a February 23, 2007 article. (LINK) “According to satellite data published in [the journal] Science in November 2005,” Michaels wrote, “Greenland was shedding ice at 0.4 percent per century.” “Nowhere in the traditionally [peer-reviewed] refereed scientific literature do we find any support for Gore’s [Greenland melt] hypothesis,” Michaels concluded.

But many here will say that Gore is "Technically" correct


Geologist Morten Hald, an Arctic expert at of the University of Tromso in Norway has also questioned the reliability of computer models predicting a melting Arctic. "The main problem is that these models are often based on relatively new climate data. The thermometer has only been in existence for 150 years and information on temperature which is 150 years old does not capture the large natural changes,” Hald, who is participating with a Norwegian national team in Arctic climate research, said in a May 18, 2007 article. (LINK) The article continued, “Professor Hald believes the models which are utilized to make prognoses about the future climate changes consider paleoclimate only to a minor degree.” “Studies of warm periods in the past, like during the Stone Ages can provide valuable knowledge to understand and tackle the warmer climate in the future,” Hald explained. Models are not reliable, for god reasons

Polar expert Ivan Frolov, the head of Russia’s Science and Research Institute of Arctic and Antarctic Regions, said atmospheric temperature would have to much higher to make continental glaciers melt. “Many hundred years or 20-30 degree temperature rise would have made glaciers melt,” Frolov said in a December 14, 2006 Russian news article. (LINK) Frolov noted that currently Greenland’s and Antarctic glaciers have the tendency to grow. The article explained, “Frolov says cooling and warming periods are common for our planet – temperature fluctuations amounted to 10-12 degrees. However, such fluctuations haven’t caused glaciers to melt. Thus, we shouldn’t be afraid they melt today.”
ie the predicted IPCC outcome is not reliable


10) Physicist Dr. Syun-Ichi Akasofu, the former director of both University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute and International Arctic Research Center who has twice been named one of the "1000 Most Cited Scientists," told a Congressional hearing in 2006 that highly publicized climate models showing a disappearing Arctic were nothing more than “science fiction.” "All the papers since (the advent of satellites) show warming. That's what I call 'instant climatology.' I'm trying to tell young scientists, 'You can't study climatology unless you look at a much longer time period.'” (LINK)

Ditto


11) Ivy League geologist Dr. Robert Giegengack of the University of Pennsylvania rejected fears of a catastrophic 20 foot sea level rise. "Sea level is rising," Giegengack said, but it's been rising ever since warming set in 18,000 years ago, he explained according to a February 2007 article in Philadelphia Magazine. But the Earth's global ocean level is only going up 1.8 millimeters per year -- less than the thickness of one nickel, Giegengack further explained. “At the present rate of sea-level rise it’s going to take 3,500 years to get up there (to a rise of 20 feet) So if for some reason this warming process that melts ice is cutting loose and accelerating, sea level doesn’t know it. And sea level, we think, is the best indicator of global warming," he said. (LINK) Giegengack also noted that the history of the last one billion years on the planet reveals "only about 5% of that time has been characterized by conditions on Earth that were so cold that the poles could support masses of permanent ice." (LINK)

Ditto, and also says that the link between increased CO2 and sea level rise don't exists, as proposed by AGW models


12) Prominent scientist Professor Nils-Axel Morner, declared "the rapid rise in sea levels predicted by computer models simply cannot happen." Morner, a leading world authority on sea levels and coastal erosion who headed the Department of Paleogeophysics & Geodynamics at Stockholm University, noted on August 6, 2007: "When we were coming out of the last ice age, huge ice sheets were melting rapidly and the sea level rose at an average of one meter per century. If the Greenland ice sheet stated to melt at the same rate - which is unlikely - sea level would rise by less than 100 mm - 4 inches per century." Morner, who was president of the INQUA Commission on Sea Level Changes and Coastal Evolution from 1999 to 2003, has published a new booklet entitled "The Greatest Lie Ever Told," to refute claims of catastrophic sea level rise. (LINK)

See above
Another problem for predictions of catastrophic sea level rise due to polar ice melt is Antarctica is not cooperating with the man-made catastrophic global warming models. “A new report on climate over the world's southernmost continent shows that temperatures during the late 20th century did not climb as had been predicted by many global climate models,” reads the February 15, 2007 press release announcing the findings of David Bromwich, professor of professor of atmospheric sciences in the Department of Geography, and researcher with the Byrd Polar Research Center at Ohio State University. (See: Antarctic temperatures disagree with climate model predictions LINK)
"It's hard to see a global warming signal from the mainland of Antarctica right now,” Bromwich explained. The release explains that Bromwich’s research team found “no increase in precipitation over Antarctica in the last 50 years. Most models predict that both precipitation and temperature will increase over Antarctica with a warming of the planet.”

Self explanatory
 
The good doctor (who I really respect, he has an informed opinion in all themes I have seem he post) bought the AGW notion that there are not peer reviewed science and not climate scientists who disagree with IPCC. I understand his fury, remember a while ago when I came here to ask for sources who contradict a Chrichton article I found outrageous. Since then, and reading the sources I mentioned, I changed my mind about the subject.

Good points. That is why I have attempted to show something of the diversity of the subject and the inability to credibly reduce it to moronic level parallels with religious belief patterns.

Going back to the OP, here is one suggestion. Repeating the assertions of the OP -
Knowledge acquisition is what's really at the heart of my two questions - if one is individually unable, through lack of training, resources or anything else, to find out the truth of any particular matter, how should one approach the issue?
Doesn't this question have nontrivial implications regarding how a skeptic "should" function in a democracy? the particular issue, be it global warming or anti-missile missile shields, is irrelevant: does the JREF forum really have nothing to say regarding how one should approach such issues?
​
An average person or a skeptic functioning in a democracy should be educated in the methods of detecting propaganda and be able to recognize it. Perhaps such a person should be more skeptical when the issue being promulgated is from a national government or international government source?

Here as one example is a document for British guidance on AGW.

Talking points for the British Ministry of EverTruthy Climate Propaganda says to always say the science is settled.
Warm Words
a spin doctor’s manual for convincing the public that they face a climate catastrophe


​

​
 
Exercise in Climate Change Propaganda. Remember - Always assert the science is settled. (bold is mine)


Washington Post on Greenland


Journeys -- and their ends -- come easily to mind as you sit in the sun at midnight on the porch of the Hotel Arctic in Ilulissat, Greenland, sipping a Chilean wine and watching giant icebergs float by below on their own incredible trip.
You have come to see the beginning of their end, hastened on the journey from ice to water by global warming.


In few places can you watch the metamorphoses brought by climate change so intimately as you can here, where the fastest glacier in the world delivers spectacular icebergs right to your camera lens.
 
Actually, IPCC has softened their predictions. Media is just following the massive last year's trend. I guess the next IPCC report will soften their predictions again, according to the latest research........I really hope so.
 
Once national governments have "Climate Change" or "Greenhouse Gas" agencies, ministries, and the like, then the issue becomes propagation and enlargement of the agency.
 
The reason I look down on creationists is 'cos their arguments are rubbish. If they had any good ones, I should embrace the supernatural

with all due respect, the reasons for which you personally look down upon creationists are completely irrelavant. whether you personally acknowledge the fact that creationists insist on intruding science with their inherently non-scientific, supernatural myths doesn't change the fact that, in the world of science, creationism is rejected outwright because it invokes the supernatural, and therefore cannot be science. there is a world of difference between holding the minority position in a scientific debate, and attemping to force a non scientific position into science. comparing AGW deniers to creationists elevates creationism from non science to bad science.

Nor do Twoofers, but the resemblance is striking.

no, troothers do not invoke the supernatural, so they are more similar to AGW deniers than are creationists. but at least AGW deniers are defending a minority position in the scientific community that was previously widely held within the scientific community, for which a minority of evidence exists. troothers are defending a position that has never been held by even the minority of the scientific community, for which zero valid evidence exists.
 
Last edited:
The good doctor (who I really respect, he has an informed opinion in all themes I have seem he post) bought the AGW notion that there are not peer reviewed science and not climate scientists who disagree with IPCC.
No I haven't, which is why I have never said any such thing.
 
Last edited:
Yes, indeed you might want to investigate further. I will give a tiny bit of assistance to you. There are no AGW and anti-AGW groups that neatly split up into your definitions.
Which definitions would those be?

If, as I suspect, they exist only in your head, then as I'm not a mind-reader, you'll have to tell me what my "definitions" are.

Those are fantasies ...
Yeah, that's what I was thinking.

What there actually are are a group of physical phenomena that may or may not be caused by man's influence.

Possible effects. Variations in Arctic ice, glacier melt, sea level rise or lack of, changes in ocean acidity, variations in global temperature, changes in hurricane frequency or intensity would be four such phenomena.

Possible causes. These include increases in CO2, black soot, Asian brown clouds, land use changes, variations in atmospheric humidity, solar variations, sunspots and cosmic ray influences.
Perhaps now you could tell me something I don't know, like what my "definitions" are.

Instead of there being any semblance of your straw man AGW/anti-AGW idiocy ...
You're saying that this is my straw man?

That's amusing.

Please try to bear in mind that you are lying to me about what I think, rather than vice versa.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom