This would be necessary under the condition that there are in fact passages in the articles that support LR's "clarifications" but that for some reason he has omitted to quote them and instead for some mysterious reason has quoted, at length, completely different passages which don't support his "clarifications".
It had not crossed my mind that anyone would behave in such a strange way. If he will assure me that he has done so, I shall investigate further.
Yes, indeed you might want to investigate further. I will give a tiny bit of assistance to you. There are no AGW and anti-AGW groups that neatly split up into your definitions. Those are fantasies, or perhaps monsters in your bedroom closet that come out at night.
What there actually are are a group of physical phenomena that may or may not be caused by man's influence.
Possible effects. Variations in Arctic ice, glacier melt, sea level rise or lack of, changes in ocean acidity, variations in global temperature, changes in hurricane frequency or intensity would be four such phenomena.
Possible causes. These include increases in CO2, black soot, Asian brown clouds, land use changes, variations in atmospheric humidity, solar variations, sunspots and cosmic ray influences.
Instead of there being any semblance of your straw man AGW/anti-AGW idiocy, there is widespread agreement between AGW skeptics and AGW believers on many of the linkages between these causes, and effects. There are specific areas of disagreement. They vary quite a bit.
Volatile's original questions are quiet penetrating from a public policy or philosophy of science point of view.
1) If we shouldn't get our information about climate from climatologists, who should we get it from?
2) Where did you learn that global warming wasn't happening and / or wasn't anthropogenic?
Originally Posted by volatile
Knowledge acquisition is what's really at the heart of my two questions - if one is individually unable, through lack of training, resources or anything else, to find out the truth of any particular matter, how should one approach the issue?
Doesn't this question have nontrivial implications regarding how a skeptic "should" function in a democracy? the particular issue, be it global warming or anti-missile missile shields, is irrelevant: does the JREF forum really have nothing to say regarding how one should approach such issues?
Any actual substantial comments? That is, presuming that you do not read the articles and remain in the decisively virginal, blissfully ignorant state?
See how this works now?