For TokenConservative - Where should we get our information on climate from?

The GW denialists will say that the climate scientists know for a fact that there is no basis for their claims ... The creationists will say that the biologists know for a fact that there is no basis for their claims ...
And will also claim that GW/evolution are "religions" supported by passionate "faith".
 
You know... that "creationist" comparison is a very important one. The similarities are unmistakable, and more telling than any single bit of information that the cultists in either group might present.

For instance, the GW denialists will say "the scientists want to destroy our oil-based economy and our way of life" as though that claim as any bearing on the accuracy of the science. The creationists will say "the scientists want to destroy our religious-based morality and our way of life" as though that claim as any bearing on the accuracy of the science.

The GW denialists will quote economists, lawyers, oil-company executives, scientists in unrelated fields, and political operatives as more reliable scientific sources than actual climate scientists. The creationists will quote economists, lawyers, religious leaders, scientists in unrelated fields, and political operatives as more reliable scientific sources than actual biologists.

The GW denialists will point to a handful of (often discredited)climate scientists, and claim that there is a large and growing movement against the mainstream scientific consensus. The creationists will point to a handful of (often discredited)biologists, and claim that there is a large and growing movement against the mainstream scientific consensus.

The GW denialists will lie, misquote, and twist evidence to fit their viewpoint, while falsely accusing real scientists of doing the same. The creationists will lie, misquote, and twist evidence to fit their viewpoint, while falsely accusing real scientists of doing the same.

The GW denialists will say that the climate scientists know for a fact that there is no basis for their claims, implying that there is a giant worldwide conspiracy supporting Global Warming and working against them, often for sinister purposes. The creationists will say that the biologists know for a fact that there is no basis for their claims, implying that there is a giant worldwide conspiracy supporting "Darwinism" and working against them, often for sinister purposes.

So, really, because the pattern is identical, because the basis in both cases is about something other than science... in a way, you can ignore any specific claims that either group makes. Not because they might not be right about one detail or another, but because they are engaged in a fundamentally dishonest enterprise, that doesn't actually value facts at all. So, it may actually be fundamentally impossible to discuss facts with them at all. When they are occasionally correct on some minor detail, they count it as a major victory. When they are wrong on just about everything else, they STILL count it as a victory, because clearly they have stood up bravely to the evil conspiracy.:rolleyes:
You forgot to mention the Twoofers.

For instance, the Twoofers will say "the scientists are all neo-conservatives" as though that claim as any bearing on the accuracy of the science.

The Twoofers will quote NeoNazis, theologians, scientists in unrelated fields, and Alex Jones as more reliable scientific sources than actual engineers.

The Twoofers will point to a handful of (often discredited) physical scientists, and claim that there is a large and growing movement against the mainstream scientific consensus.

The Twoofers will lie, misquote, and twist evidence to fit their viewpoint, while falsely accusing real scientists of doing the same.

The Twoofer will say that the scientists know for a fact that there is no basis for their claims, implying that there is a giant worldwide conspiracy covering up Da Twoof and working against them, invariably for sinister purposes.

---

And one more thing. The creationists, the anti-GW loons, and the Twoofers all lie about the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

A 9/11 denier: "The idea that the WTC buildings fell straight down from asymmetric airplane crashes and subsequent random fires blatantly violates the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics."

A GW denier:

Most of these articles take as their starting point the most recent report of the IPCC, and thus, most of these articles quote some version of this statement: "The greenhouse effect occurs because carbon dioxide traps heat." This is a classic bald assertion, and this is why- NOTHING traps heat. Heat cannot be trapped. Carbon dioxide does not trap heat, and neither does anything else. I can't stress this enough- heat cannot be trapped. As soon as I realized this, the whole stupid debate was over for me- and apparently, only me.

Wouldn't we live in a very different universe if heat could be trapped? It would be so nice if if I could save summer heat in a box and release it into my house in November, just to keep me warm all winter. Do you know those "portable ovens" that Domino's uses to keep your pizza warm? I guess they could just leave that on your countertop and your pizza will never cool off. In fact, I am just a step away from perfecting my new "carbon dioxide oven." Imagine the energy savings! All you need to do is turn it on once, let it heat up to five hundred degrees, and you can cook as many pizzas as you want without ever having to heat it up again!

Sound ridiculous? You bet it does. And yet, this false idea is now in the heads of an entire generation, and it was put there by supposed scientists that should know better. Even skeptics apparently believe that we have stumbled across the one substance in the universe that violates the second law of thermodynamics.

The evolution denier stuff I'm guessing you've seen.
 
I didn't forget to mention the Twoofers. They actually don't fit into this discussion, because I forgot to add this to my list:

The GW deniers pretend to be independent and impartial critics, while actually being the public face of a larger propaganda campaign, created by extremist right-wing organizations to advance a powerful political and financial agenda. The creationists pretend to be independent and impartial critics, while actually being the public face of a larger propaganda campaign, created by extremist right-wing organizations to advance a powerful political and religious agenda.

The Twoofers don't, to my knowledge, have that sort of backing.
 
Perhaps I should explain to you that everything that you know about the climate is known to climatologists.

Quite so. We have this delicate natural balance ... and we pump greenhouse gasses into it. Crazy, huh? Maybe we should stop mucking about with this process.

Maybe the Chinese, who have already surpassed the USA in GHG output, don't care one squat about your ideas. Maybe they've already publicly stated that they will not abide by any post - Kyoto agreement which says that they must limit their GHG outputs. Maybe they love agreements like Kyoto which help shift profitable industry to their country.

Maybe attempts to limit GHG in one place can increase it in another.

Maybe "carbon sequestration" is pure, unadulterated science fiction.

Maybe some prominent climatologists have gone way too far in predicting alarming, scientifically unsound short term climate catastrophes, thus rightly provoking the wrath of reasonable people.

Gosh. But these directions of thinking get into issues of business, public policy and economics. Which your esteemed climatologists really are not competent at, are they?
Sidenote: Apparently this thread was moved due to basically some Anti-AGW poster flame baiting and trolling incessently. Totally unproductive and uncalled for in my opinion.​
 
Maybe the Chinese, who have already surpassed the USA in GHG output, don't care one squat about your ideas. Maybe they've already publicly stated that they will not abide by any post - Kyoto agreement which says that they must limit their GHG outputs. Maybe they love agreements like Kyoto which help shift profitable industry to their country.

Maybe attempts to limit GHG in one place can increase it in another.

Maybe "carbon sequestration" is pure, unadulterated science fiction.

Maybe some prominent climatologists have gone way too far in predicting alarming, scientifically unsound short term climate catastrophes, thus rightly provoking the wrath of reasonable people.

Gosh. But these directions of thinking get into issues of business, public policy and economics. Which your esteemed climatologists really are not competent at, are they?
Sidenote: Apparently this thread was moved due to basically some Anti-AGW poster flame baiting and trolling incessently. Totally unproductive and uncalled for in my opinion.​

So, to link this to the OP, if we do not get our information from climatologists, where should we get information from? The 'reasonable people' you mention?
 
Maybe the Chinese, who have already surpassed the USA in GHG output, don't care one squat about your ideas. Maybe they've already publicly stated that they will not abide by any post - Kyoto agreement which says that they must limit their GHG outputs. Maybe they love agreements like Kyoto which help shift profitable industry to their country.

Maybe attempts to limit GHG in one place can increase it in another.

Maybe "carbon sequestration" is pure, unadulterated science fiction.

Maybe some prominent climatologists have gone way too far in predicting alarming, scientifically unsound short term climate catastrophes, thus rightly provoking the wrath of reasonable people.

Gosh. But these directions of thinking get into issues of business, public policy and economics. Which your esteemed climatologists really are not competent at, are they?
Sidenote: Apparently this thread was moved due to basically some Anti-AGW poster flame baiting and trolling incessently. Totally unproductive and uncalled for in my opinion.​


Maybe your post has absolutely nothing at all to do with what the good Dr said.
 
Last edited:
The GW deniers pretend to be independent and impartial critics, while actually being the public face of a larger propaganda campaign, created by extremist right-wing organizations to advance a powerful political and financial agenda. The creationists pretend to be independent and impartial critics, while actually being the public face of a larger propaganda campaign, created by extremist right-wing organizations to advance a powerful political and religious agenda.
No, you'd have to substitute "impotent" for "powerful" and "anti-Semitic" for "religious".

But in any case, the causes of denialism are not its identifying features. The common preoperties are too obvious to ignore.

More Twoofer/creationism comparisons here.

Oh, another resemblance --- they all think that the things that they vaguely remember learning in high-school science classes can overturn established science without it ever occurring to them that anything they know about science that's actually true must also be known to scientists.
 
Last edited:
Gosh. But these directions of thinking get into issues of business, public policy and economics. Which your esteemed climatologists really are not competent at, are they?
Which is why I don't rely on the judgement of climatologists on issues of business, public policy and economics.

I do however think that climatologists might know about the climate.

Do you see how this works now?
 
Last edited:
For the OP:

My sources include the IPCC, Climateaudit, realclimate, many peer reviewed articles (specially one of a couple of chinese climate scientist that are in the correct path as time is proving they correct), this forum, climatesceptic, how to deal with a GW sceptic, and gerlish paper.

(sorry I don't have the links for some of those, my markers has been erased yesterday).

For the Dr. and some people. As a long time debater against creationists, IDr's and religious nuts, my POV is that the ones using the strategies of creationist are most AGW'rs. The strategies include ad-homs, conspiracy theories (it's funny that the ones complaining about skeptics claims of vested interests from some climatologists could say something like "The GW deniers pretend to be independent and impartial critics, while actually being the public face of a larger propaganda campaign, created by extremist right-wing organizations to advance a powerful political and financial agenda."), threats and menaces to dissenting scientists, firing of dissenting scientists, unproved assumptions (2.5 C for doubling of CO2 and 20 ft of sea level rise are just a couple), name calling (Deniers = Darwinists....?), unlimited trust in non-verified models, blatant lies ( "not trust the opinions of every single climatologist on the planet?" , a very popular lie spread by AGWr's , that there are not legitimate climate scientists that disagrees with AGW ) and so on.
I don't give a damn about the consequences of the policies they have are also wrong. Almost all of the AGW skeptics here agree that nuclear plants are the way to go, even if AGW is not real (which mean that the powerful and evil oil corporations will have MORE losses than using Kyoto strategies). The skeptics have better plans in case AGW were true, like nuclear plants and the recently developed "Artificial trees" capable of absorb lot's of CO2 and expel oxygen, and so on.
 
Last edited:
Oh, another resemblance --- they all think that the things that they vaguely remember learning in high-school science classes can overturn established science without it ever occurring to them that anything they know about science that's actually true must also be known to scientists.

Indeed. TC is a case in point - he knows that the climate warms and cools in cycles, and thus concludes that all global warming must be cyclical. It simply doesn't occur to him that lots of people worked this out a long time ago and have provided careful and considered answers to the very question he's posing.

It's like only reading half a book.

I'm giving up hope that he'll actually post here, though. I do hope the mods will move any future ranting of his on this topic that appears in an unrelated thread here, but I doubt even that will persuade him to explain himself, or actually learn anything about the issue at all.
 
Last edited:
As a long time debater against creationists, IDr's and religious nuts, my POV is that the ones using the strategies of creationist are most AGW'rs. The strategies include ad-homs, conspiracy theories (it's funny that the ones complaining about skeptics claims of vested interests from some climatologists could say something like "The GW deniers pretend to be independent and impartial critics, while actually being the public face of a larger propaganda campaign, created by extremist right-wing organizations to advance a powerful political and financial agenda."), threats and menaces to dissenting scientists, firing of dissenting scientists, unproved assumptions (2.5 C for doubling of CO2 and 20 ft of sea level rise are just a couple), name calling (Deniers = Darwinists....?), unlimited trust in non-verified models, blatant lies ( "not trust the opinions of every single climatologist on the planet?" , a very popular lie spread by AGWr's , that there are not legitimate climate scientists that disagrees with AGW ) and so on.
You sound just like a creationist, right down to the lame tu quoque.

You should stop debating them and join their cause, you'd fit in nicely.
 
Last edited:
For the OP:

My sources include the IPCC
,

...who say

"Warming of the climate system is unequivocal." and "Most of the observed increase in globally averaged temperatures since the mid-20th century is very likely due to the observed increase in anthropogenic (human) greenhouse gas concentrations."


many peer reviewed articles [...]
(sorry I don't have the links for some of those, my markers has been erased yesterday).
How convenient.

Give us one citation from a paper published in a peer-reviewed journal since 1993 that concludes that AGW isn't happening. Just one of the "many" would suffice.

that there are not legitimate climate scientists that disagrees with AGW ) and so on.
Name one, and link to a peer-reviewed article he or she has published. Just one.

Funny how you, Tokie and the creationists all claim there is "masses", "loads", "lots" of evidence to support your claim, but are all singularly unable to ever produce any. Ever.
 
Last edited:
You sound just like a creationist, right down to the lame tu quoque.

You should stop debating them and join their cause, you'd fit in nicely.

It is the same mindset, manifesting in the same way, following the same worn-out path. It almost seems as though there is a certain "type", that is just waiting for someone to come along and provide them with a conspiracy to attach their pre-existing mentality to. There are people who are natural athletes, who will excel at any sport, and share traits with athletes in all sports. There are people who are natural scholars, who enjoy the pursuit of knowledge no matter which field they choose to focus on.

Then there are the CT/Creationist/GW denial folks... they choose different paths of expression, but what they are expressing is the same in all cases.
 
You sound just like a creationist, right down to the lame tu quoque.
Reread what I wrote , the tu quoqe is not my argument, I don't buy the Right wing conspiracy argument, so there is no tu quoque.

You should stop debating them and join their cause, you'd fit in nicely.
Let's suppose I "sound" like a creationist. Is that your argument? Name the fallacy.
 
Reread what I wrote , the tu quoqe is not my argument, I don't buy the Right wing conspiracy argument, so there is no tu quoque.
You responded to a post pointing out the resemblances between GW deniers and creationists by writing: "the ones using the strategies of creationist are most AGW'rs"

This, y'see, would be a lame attempt at a tu quoque.

Why didn't you just recite: "I am rubber, you are glue ..."?

Let's suppose I "sound" like a creationist. Is that your argument? Name the fallacy.
I presume that you had a point, and I am mildly curious to know what it is.
 
Last edited:
Lucifer Rofocale's Creationist Twin said:
As a long time debater against Twoofers, my POV is that the ones using the strategies of Twoofers are most evolutionists. The strategies include ad-homs, conspiracy theories (it's funny that the ones complaining about skeptics claims of vested interests from some Darwinists could say something like "The creationists pretend to be independent and impartial critics, while actually being the public face of a larger propaganda campaign, created by extremist right-wing organizations to advance a powerful political and religious agenda."), threats and menaces to dissenting scientists, firing of dissenting scientists, unproved assumptions (radiometric dating and "millions and millions of years" are just a couple), name calling (Fundies = Duhbunkers....?), unlimited trust in non-verified models, blatant lies ( "not trust the opinions of every single paleontologist on the planet?" , a very popular lie spread by evolutionists , that there are not legitimate scientists that disagrees with evolution ) and so on.
..
 
To paraphrase someone else ...

Climate is an extremely complex, chaotic, coupled, non-linear, time-dependent system with massive, external, naturally-occurring inputs and wide variability in measurable states.

To suggest that we can accurately predict the climate 100 years from now is scientifically laughable.

To suggest that we can successfully predict the result that altering the gas-mileage of SUV's will have on the climate is ludicrous in the extreme.
 
To paraphrase someone else ...

Climate is an extremely complex, chaotic, coupled, non-linear, time-dependent system with massive, external, naturally-occurring inputs and wide variability in measurable states.

To suggest that we can accurately predict the climate 100 years from now is scientifically laughable.

To suggest that we can successfully predict the result that altering the gas-mileage of SUV's will have on the climate is ludicrous in the extreme.

Is that someone a climate scientist?
 
To paraphrase someone else ...

Climate is an extremely complex, chaotic, coupled, non-linear, time-dependent system with massive, external, naturally-occurring inputs and wide variability in measurable states.
Well in that case, Goddidit ... oh, wait ... wrong argument.

To suggest that we can accurately predict the climate 100 years from now is scientifically laughable.

To suggest that we can successfully predict the result that altering the gas-mileage of SUV's will have on the climate is ludicrous in the extreme.
Oh, hooray, it's the Argument from Personal Incredulity!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom